Literature DB >> 29672709

Surveillance of travel-associated diseases at two referral centres in Marseille, France: a 12-year survey.

Karolina M Griffiths1, Hélène Savini2, Philippe Brouqui1, Fabrice Simon2, Philippe Parola1, Philippe Gautret1.   

Abstract

Background: With increasing international travel and historically high numbers of residents visiting friends and relatives overseas, travel-associated illnesses are frequent in Marseille, France. We report the changing epidemiology of travel-related illnesses over a 12-year period.
Methods: A single site GeoSentinel surveillance analysis was undertaken for 3460 ill returned travellers presenting to two public hospitals in Marseille, France from March 2003 to October 2015, with travel-related illnesses. Demographic characteristics, travel history, presenting symptoms and information on pre-travel consultations were collected.
Results: There was a predominance of travel to sub-Saharan Africa, in particular to Comoros archipelago. Tourism was the main reason for travel (1591/3460, 46%), followed by visiting friends or relatives (VFR) (895/3460, 26%), with a mean duration of 29 days; 35% (1212/3460) of travellers reported a pre-travel health consultation. The most common syndromic diagnoses were febrile systemic illness (1343, 39%), dermatologic (716, 21%), gastrointestinal (340, 10%) and respiratory/ear-nose-throat (331, ENT) (10%). Hospitalization rates were highest amongst travellers from sub-Saharan Africa (858/ 1632, 53%), and VFR (573/ 895, 64%, P < 0.001). Frequent diagnoses included malaria (797, 23%), dengue (96, 2.77%) and chikungunya (75, 2.17%), reflecting global trends. Comparison of two periods (2003-10 to 2011-15) demonstrated an increase in chikungunya and decrease in malaria and influenza-like illness. We report an increase in ill travellers from the Caribbean, Middle East and South-East Asia.
Conclusion: Surveillance of travellers provides relevant sentinel information on the changing epidemiology of infectious diseases across the globe, most notably for malaria, dengue and chikungunya. We demonstrate the use of travel surveillance in improving pre-travel consultation needs and to address autochthonous vector-borne viral risks.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2018        PMID: 29672709      PMCID: PMC7107586          DOI: 10.1093/jtm/tay007

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Travel Med        ISSN: 1195-1982            Impact factor:   8.490


Background

International travel is increasing, with more than 23 million visits overseas by French tourists in 2015, compared to over 84 million international tourists arriving in France over the same period.[1] Marseille, the main town in Mediterranean France, includes an urban and peri-urban population of over 1.5 million inhabitants. The economy of Marseille and its region is still partly linked to its commercial port and has always been one of the main gateways into France.[2] Migrants, originating notably from North Africa, Senegal and Comoros, have settled in Marseille over several decades.[2,3] Considering this context, travel-associated diseases are frequent in the local population. We aim to report surveillance data to document the spectrum of infections in patients admitted for travel-related illness over a 12-year period to two referral centres in Marseille, in order to compare with other international data on ill returning travellers and to inform public health surveillance and local prevention practices.

Material and Method

Study design and procedures

The GeoSentinel Surveillance Network is a global clinic based surveillance system to track travel-related illnesses within 66 clinics in 29 countries.[4] Physicians in travel/tropical medicine electronically submit demographic, clinical and diagnostic information on patients seeking medical care for a travel-related illness having crossed an international border within the past 10 years.[5] Every patient has at least one confirmed or probable diagnostic code, and may be assigned several. Diagnoses are based on recognition of a syndrome and/or a specific pathogen. Other data includes travel characteristics, in/outpatient status, and whether a pre-travel consultation took place. We report all patients recorded on the GeoSentinel database in Marseille over a 12-year period. Eligible patients had been referred to two hospitals in Marseille, ‘Assistance Publique—Hôpitaux de Marseille’ from March 2003 to October 2015 and ‘Hôpital d’Instruction des Armées Laveran’ from May 2007 to October 2015.

Statistical analysis

Two time periods of interest were compared, 2003–10 and 2011–15. All summary descriptive statistics were carried out using Microsoft Access and R statistical software program. Continuous variables were described with mean and SD or median and IQR as appropriate. Categorical variables were described with numbers and percent. Unpaired t-tests or Wilcoxon signed rank test was used to compare continuous quantitative variables, depending on the distribution. Non-parametric Fisher tests were used to compare qualitative variables. Due to multiple tests being performed a conservative two-sided significance level of P < 0.01 was chosen. Time series analysis of malaria cases (the most frequent diagnosis) was performed and multiplicative decomposition of monthly data was used to examine the trend, after removing seasonality and random error.

Results

A total of 3460 patients were included during the 12-year study period with a M/F sex ratio of 1.2 and a median age of 38 years (range: 1–86 years) (Table 1). Tourism was the main reason for travel (1591/3460, 46%), followed by visiting friends or relatives (VFR) (895, 26%). The mean travel duration was 29 days and 35% (1212) of all travellers reported a pre-travel health consultation. Among 1931 travellers (56%) to Africa, 557 (16%) travelled to the Comoros archipelago alone, 1632 to sub-Saharan Africa, and 299 (9%) to North Africa. Only 634 (18%) travelled to Asia, 407 (12%) to Latin America and 136 (4%) to Europe (Figure 1). The majority of patients were seen after travel (3264, 94%) and 38% (1326) were hospitalized (Table 1). No deaths were recorded. The percentage of hospitalized patients was highest amongst travellers to sub-Saharan Africa (858/ 1632, 53%), with similar rates seen in the Middle East (41/75, 55%, P = 0.8) and North America (42/66, 64%, P = 0.1), but much lower rates when compared to travellers from Asia (122/ 634, P < 0.001), Central America (46/ 202, P < 0.001) and Europe (35/ 136, P < 0.001). Higher proportions of patients visiting friends and family (573/ 895, 64%) were hospitalized, in comparison to tourists (409/ 1591, 26%, P < 0.001) or business travellers (163/488, 33%, P <0.001). The majority of VFRs had visited sub-Saharan Africa (689/895, 77%) and did not report any pre-travel consultation (561/895, 63%).
Table 1.

Overall patient demographics and travel characteristics (n = 3460), and comparisons between two periods (2003–10 and 2011–15)

N (%)2003–10, n = 21442011–15, n = 1316
Gender
 Male1852 (53.53)1158 (54.01)694 (52.74)
 Female1598 (46.18)977 (45.57)621 (47.19)
 Not documented10 (0.29)9 (0.42)1 (0.08)
Median age in years (IQR)38 (27–52)39 (27–51)*40 (28–54)*
Country of birth
 France2324 (67.17%)1369 (63.85)955 (72.57)
Reason for travel
 Tourism1591 (45.98)958 (44.68)633 (48.10)
 Visiting friends and relatives895 (25.87)599 (27.94)*296 (22.49)*
 Business488 (14.1)286 (13.34)202 (15.35)
 Missionary/volunteer/researcher/aid work197 (5.69)128 (5.97)69 (5.24)
 Military122 (3.53)67 (3.12)55 (4.18)
 Immigration68 (2.91)34 (1.59)17 (1.29)
 Student60 (1.74)48 (2.24)*12 (0.91)*
 Medical tourism34 (0.98)19 (0.89)13 (0.99)
 Not documented5 (0.14)5 (0.23)0
Travel duration (median, IQR)29 (15–61)29 (15–61)27 (15–60)
Pre-travel encounter
 Yes1212 (35.03)782 (36.47)430 (32.67)
 No1672 (48.32)999 (46.6)673 (51.14)
 Don’t know576 (16.65)327 (15.25)213 (16.19)
Clinical setting
 Immigration travel only68 (1.96)34 (1.59)17 (1.29)
 Seen during travel126 (3.64)86 (4.01)40 (3.04)
 Seen after travel3264 (94.34)2022 (94.31)1242 (94.38)
 Not documented2 (0.06)2 (0.09)0
Patient type
 Inpatient1326 (38.32)908 (42.35)*418 (31.76)*
 Outpatient2124 (61.39)1226 (57.18)*898 (68.24)*
 Not documented10 (0.29)10 (0.47)0
Region of exposure
 Australia/New Zealand6 (0.17)6 (0.28)0 (0)
 Caribbean146 (4.22)71 (3.31)*75 (5.7)*
 Central America56 (1.62)35 (1.63)21 (1.6)
 Eastern Europe40 (1.16)21 (0.98)19 (1.44)
 Middle East75 (2.17)26 (1.21)*49 (3.72)*
 North Africa299 (8.64)168 (7.84)131 (9.95)
 North America66 (1.91)56 (2.61)*10 (0.76)*
 North East Asia43 (1.24)31 (1.45)12 (0.91)
 Oceania35 (1.01)15 (0.7)20 (1.52)
 South America205 (5.92)123 (5.74)82 (6.23)
 South Central Asia164 (4.74)102 (4.76)62 (4.71)
 South East Asia427 (12.34)204 (9.51)*223 (16.95)*
 Sub-Saharan Africa1632 (47.17)1129 (52.66)*503 (38.22)*
 Western Europe96 (2.77)69 (3.22)27 (2.05)
 Not ascertainable170 (4.91)88 (4.1)*82 (6.23)*
Presenting syndromes
 Fever1343 (38.82)903 (42.12)440 (33.43)*
 Respiratory/ENT331 (9.57)202 (9.42)129 (9.80)
 Gastrointestinal (except acute diarrhoea)340 (9.83)173 (8.07)167 (12.69)*
 Acute diarrhoea267 (7.72)203 (9.47)64 (4.86)*
 Dermatological716 (20.69)447 (20.85)269 (20.44)
Etiological conditions
 Malaria797 (23.03)607 (28.31)*190 (14.44)*
 Dengue96 (2.77)58 (2.71)38 (2.89)
 Chikungunya75 (2.17)29 (1.35)*46 (3.50)*
 ILI148 (4.28)109 (5.08)*39 (2.96)*
 Giardia49 (1.42)33 (1.54)16 (1.22)

*Significant difference, at the alpha 0.01 level.

Figure 1.

(A) Main rates of presenting syndromes by year 2003–2015 in travellers returning to Marseille. (B) Main rates of etiological diagnosis for Malaria, Dengue, Chikungunya, Influenza-like illness and Giardia by years 2003–15 in travellers returning to Marseille.

Overall patient demographics and travel characteristics (n = 3460), and comparisons between two periods (2003–10 and 2011–15) *Significant difference, at the alpha 0.01 level. (A) Main rates of presenting syndromes by year 2003–2015 in travellers returning to Marseille. (B) Main rates of etiological diagnosis for Malaria, Dengue, Chikungunya, Influenza-like illness and Giardia by years 2003–15 in travellers returning to Marseille. Comparing patient characteristics between the two periods (2003–10 and 2011–15), there was a significant difference in the age of travellers, with an increase in the median age from 37 to 40. There was a significant decline in VFR as the reason for travel (599/2144, 27.94% to 296/1316, 22.49%). There was a decrease in hospitalization rates between the two periods (908/2144, 42.35% to 418/1316, 31.76%). Travel trends between the two periods differed, with increasing travel to the Caribbean (71/2144, 3.31% to 75/1316, 5.7%), the Middle East (26/2144, 1.21% to 49/1316, 3.72%), South East Asia (204/2144, 9.51% to 223/1316, 16.95%). Declining rates of travellers were seen from North America and sub-Saharan Africa (Table 1). The most common syndromic diagnoses were febrile systemic illness (1343/3460, 39%), dermatologic (716, 21%), gastrointestinal (340, 10%) and respiratory/ear–nose–throat (331, ENT) (10%) (Figure 2A). A large number of respiratory infections (148/331, 44.7%) and acute diarrhoeal cases were undocumented (105 / 267, 39.3%). In comparison, the proportion of fever cases without an etiological cause was lower (209/1356, 15.6%). Unspecified skin infections and arthropod bites accounted respectively for 17.2% (n = 125) and 7.4% (n = 54) of dermatological presentations. Influenza-like illness (ILI), pneumonia, bronchitis and unspecified pharyngitis accounted respectively for 44.7% (n = 148), 29.6% (n = 98), 8.2% (n = 27) and 5.1% (n = 17) of respiratory and ENT presentations. Confirmed influenza cases included 28 influenza A, 12 H1N1 and eight influenza B. Overall, 49 patients with acute diarrhoea had confirmed[25] or suspected[24] Giardia infection.
Figure 2.

(A) Top 10 syndromic diagnoses (n = 3369 of 3794 diagnoses). (B) Top 20 diagnosis with etiological agent identified (n = 1465). Further information: Dengue (uncomplicated, 94, severe 2), Influenza (28 confirmed cases of influenza A, 12 H1N1 and eight influenza B), intestinal helminthic infections (Ascaris, 2; Pinworm, 1; Heterophyes, 1; hookworm, 12; tapeworm, 4; whipworm, 2; unspecified, 23), schistosomiasis (S. haematobium; 9, S. mansoni, 15, species unknown, 11), filariasis (Bancroft, 1; loiasis, 26, other, 1; species unknown, 4), viral hepatitis (hepatitis A acute, 13; hepatitis B carrier, 1; hepatitis B acute, 2; hepatitis B chronic, 2, hepatitis C chronic, 3, hepatitis E, 7), Salmonella infections (S. paratyphi, 8; S. typhi, 8, other, 13), tuberculosis (pulmonary, 13; extrapulmonary, 3; MDR or XDR, 5), rickettsial infection (Rickettsia orientia, 1; tickborne spotted fever, 12; murine typhus, 2, other, 4), other intestinal protozoal infections (amoebas other than Entamoeba histolytica, 7; Blastocystis, 5; Dientamoeba, 2; Isospora, 1; other (no further precision), 5).

(A) Top 10 syndromic diagnoses (n = 3369 of 3794 diagnoses). (B) Top 20 diagnosis with etiological agent identified (n = 1465). Further information: Dengue (uncomplicated, 94, severe 2), Influenza (28 confirmed cases of influenza A, 12 H1N1 and eight influenza B), intestinal helminthic infections (Ascaris, 2; Pinworm, 1; Heterophyes, 1; hookworm, 12; tapeworm, 4; whipworm, 2; unspecified, 23), schistosomiasis (S. haematobium; 9, S. mansoni, 15, species unknown, 11), filariasis (Bancroft, 1; loiasis, 26, other, 1; species unknown, 4), viral hepatitis (hepatitis A acute, 13; hepatitis B carrier, 1; hepatitis B acute, 2; hepatitis B chronic, 2, hepatitis C chronic, 3, hepatitis E, 7), Salmonella infections (S. paratyphi, 8; S. typhi, 8, other, 13), tuberculosis (pulmonary, 13; extrapulmonary, 3; MDR or XDR, 5), rickettsial infection (Rickettsia orientia, 1; tickborne spotted fever, 12; murine typhus, 2, other, 4), other intestinal protozoal infections (amoebas other than Entamoeba histolytica, 7; Blastocystis, 5; Dientamoeba, 2; Isospora, 1; other (no further precision), 5). The top 20 etiological diagnoses are presented in Figure 2B. Parasitic infections were largely predominant and disproportionately dominated by malaria cases followed distantly by intestinal protozoal and helminthic infections, skin parasitic infections (cutaneous larva migrans, filariasis, myasis, leishmaniasis and scabies) and schistosomiasis. Arthropod-borne viral infections including dengue and chikungunya were also frequent. Influenza virus was the most frequently identified pathogen responsible for respiratory tract infections, followed by tuberculosis. Viral hepatitis, salmonella and cytomegalovirus infections were also among the most common diagnoses. In total, 19 rickettsial infections were identified (Figure 3).
Figure 3.

Number of monthly malaria cases by region of exposure. Black dotted line: monthly number of total malaria cases reported; red line: overall trend after multiplicative decomposition in Comoros; green line: overall trend after multiplicative decomposition in regions of exposure other than the Comoros.

Number of monthly malaria cases by region of exposure. Black dotted line: monthly number of total malaria cases reported; red line: overall trend after multiplicative decomposition in Comoros; green line: overall trend after multiplicative decomposition in regions of exposure other than the Comoros. Less frequent etiological diagnoses included bacterial infections (n = 60), parasitic and fungal infections (n = 32) and viral infections (n = 26) (Table 2).
Table 3.

Characteristics of the five main etiological diagnoses

Malaria (N = 797)Dengue (N = 96)Chikungunya (N = 75)Influenza-like illness (N = 148)Giardia (N = 49)
Male (%)522 (65.5)49 (51.04)35 (46.67)71 (47.97)24 (48.98)
Median age (IQR)26 (17–36)19 (13–29.5)23 (12.25–31.75)32 (1–62)11 (5–27)
French born254 (31.87%)79 (82.29)67 (89.33)102 (68.92)46 (93.88)
Top 3 reason for travel, N (%)Visiting Friends andTourism 60 (62.5)Tourism 45 (60.00)Tourism 108 (72.97)Tourism 21 (42.86)
Relatives 474 (59.47)Visiting Friends andBusiness 15 (20)Visiting Friends andBusiness 11 (22.45)
Business 109 (13.67)Relatives 16 (16.67)Visiting Friends andRelatives 19 (12.84)Student = 7 (14.29)
Military 68 (8.53)Business 13 (13.54)Relatives 8 (10.67)Business 17 (11.49)Missionary/volunteer/research/aid work = 7 (14.29)
Top 3 regions of exposure, N (%)Sub-Saharan Africa 729 (91.47)Asia 34 (35.42)Caribbean 33 (44)North America 36 (24.32)Sub-Saharan Africa 16 (32.65)
South America 51 (6.4)Caribbean 24 (25)Sub-Saharan Africa 29 (38.67)Western Europe 25 (16.89)Asia 15 (30.61)
Asia 6 (0.75)Sub-Saharan Africa 21 (21.88)Asia 10 (13.33)Sub-Saharan Africa 22 (14.86)South America 6 (12.24)
Top 5 countries of exposure, N (%)Comoros 411 (51.57)Guadeloupe 15 (15.62)Martinique 17 (22.67)United States 35 (23.65)India 10 (20.41)
Côte d’Ivoire 66 (8.28)Indonesia 11 (11.46)Reunion 17 (22.67)Saudi Arabia 21 (14.19)Madagascar 5 (10.20)
French Guana 44 (5.52)Thailand 11 (11.46)Guadeloupe 11 (14.67)Spain 14 (9.46)Benin 3 (6.12)
Cameroon 35 (4.39)Comoros 9 (9.38)Madagascar 4 (5.33)Comoros 11 (7.43)Burkina Faso 3 (6.12)
Burkina Faso 33 (4.14)Martinique 8 (8.33)India/Indonesia/Mauritius/Saint Martin = 3 (4)United Kingdom 9 (6.08)China 3 (6.12)
Indonesia 3 (6.12)
Senegal 3 (6.12)
Pre-travel encounterNo 409 (51.32)No 51 (53.12)No 53 (70.67)No 59 (39.86)No 12 (24.49)
Yes 305 (38.27)Yes 29 (30.21)Yes 16 (21.33)Yes 57 (38.51)Yes 23 (46.94)
Don’t know (9.54)Don’t know 16 (16.67)Don’t know 6 (8)Don’t know 32 (21.62)Don’t know (26.53)
Less frequent infections acquired by travellers, according to main presenting complaints and type of pathogen Legionnaire disease (4) Pertussis (2) Streptococcus pharyngitis (2) Shigella (6) Campylobacter infection (2) Helicobacter pylori infection (2) Clostridium difficile infection (1) Echinococcosis (5) Lyme disease (7) Tungasis (1) Herpes simplex infection (7) Chikenpox (4) Herpes zoster (2) Measles (2) Mumps (1) Zika virus infection (1) Syphilis (3) Chlamydiae trachomatis genital infection (2) Gonorrhoea (2) Acute HIV infection (4) AIDS (1) Meningocccal meningitis and sepsis (2) Pneumococcal meningitis (1) Neurocysticercosis (4) African trypanosomiasis (1) Japanese encephalitis (1) Leptospirosis (9) Q fever (8) Melioidosis (1) Toxocara infection (7) Toxoplasmosis (1) Trichinellosis (1) Epstein-Barr virus infection (3) The most common etiological diagnoses in patients presenting with a systemic febrile illness (n = 1343) were malaria (797, 59.3%), dengue (96, 7.1%), chikungunya (75, 5.5%) and cytomegalovirus (24, 1.8%). Among 797 diagnoses of malaria, Plasmodium falciparum accounted for 603 (76%) cases, P. vivax for 82 (10%), P. ovale for 50 (6%) and P. malariae for 24 (3%), while 38 were unspecified. Severe malaria affected 33 of these patients. Most malaria cases were in migrant VFRs (474/797, 59.5%) and were acquired in sub-Saharan Africa (729, 91.5%), notably in the Comoros archipelago (411, 51.6%) (Table 3). Figure 3 compares the overall trends after multiplicative decomposition of monthly malaria cases in the Comoros archipelago and in other exposure regions. Characteristics of the five main etiological diagnoses A total of 96 dengue cases, including two severe cases, and 75 chikungunya cases were recorded. Most cases were in French-born tourists returning from Asia, the French Caribbean islands and Africa (Table 3). Most patients with malaria, dengue and chikungunya infections did not seek pre-travel advice (409, 51.32%; 51, 53.12% and 53, 70.67%, respectively). Regarding the presenting syndromes and diagnoses between the two periods (2003–10 and 2011–15), there was a significant increase in the number of patients with gastrointestinal symptoms, apart from acute diarrhoea, (173/2144, 8.07% to 167/1316, 12.69%) with a decrease in fever (903/2144, 42.12% to 440/1316, 33.43%), and acute diarrhoeal presentations (203/2144, 9.47% to 64/1316, 4.86%) (Table 1). There was a significant decrease in patients with malaria (607/2144, 28.31% to 190/1316, 14.44%) and ILI (109/2144, 5.08% to 39/1316, 2.96%) between the two periods with a significant increase in the rates of chikungunya (29/2144, 1.25% to 46/1316, 3.50%).

Discussion

Many demographic characteristics reported here are comparable to global GeoSentinel surveillance studies amongst returning travellers from the developing world and in travellers returning to the USA. Similar rates in terms of sex, median age, travel duration and predominance for tourism as the reason of travel are reported.[6,7] However, our results are characterized by the predominance of travellers returning from Africa, in comparison to Asia in a previous global GeoSentinel study.[4] This can be explained by the local demographics in Marseille, particularly related to the migrant African population. Marseille is historically associated with Comoros migrants, with a large Comoros-originated population estimated at 50 000–70 000 in early 2000s, although more recent figures are unknown.[3] This results in differences of traveller characteristics in comparison to other GeoSentinel sites, notably higher rates of VFRs, more frequent hospitalizations and low levels of pre-travel consultations. We report a disproportionately high rate of hospitalizations in patients from sub-Saharan Africa and amongst VFRs. This highlights the need to target our travel health prevention messages towards VFRs, a sub-group with known barriers to accessing pre-travel health advice.[8,9] The African migrant population in Marseille may have specific barriers to pre-travel consultations, including financial constraints for malaria prophylaxis and lack of information. Potential strategies include primary care physicians routinely questioning immigrant patients about future travel plans.[8] Sentinel surveillance amongst travellers can be used to collect important epidemiological and virological information to alert international authorities to the changing epidemiology of infections, especially in countries with limited active public health surveillance.[10,11] This is demonstrated by the decline of malaria in the Comoros. We confirm that P. falciparum malaria remains the most frequent cause of febrile illness in international travellers returning to Marseille, particularly from sub-Saharan Africa. This is similar to both global studies[4] and previous local studies in Marseille from 1999 to 2003.[12] An overall decreasing trend in the number of monthly malaria cases can be noted from 2007 to 2015 (Figure 3). This is consistent with a global general decreasing trend since 2000.[4] However, in our study, the sudden drop in 2011 is most likely due to a decrease in the numbers of cases acquired in the Comoros archipelago (Figure 3); decomposition of monthly non-Comoros malaria cases demonstrated a gradual decreasing trend in comparison to the sudden drop of cases in Comoros travellers from 2011. This is in line with local malaria surveillance data demonstrating a major decline in malaria morbidity and mortality in the Union of Comoros between 2010 and 2014, which is attributed to malaria prevention and control interventions.[13] This is an example of a local single site analysis in Marseille providing accurate sentinel surveillance information for malaria epidemiology in Comoros. Alongside sentinel analysis for diagnosis, important information on rates of malarial drug resistance can also be collected from travellers.[14] Our results highlight VFRs as disproportionately at risk for malaria, which corroborates recent French national data and from a London tropical hospital.[15,16] Other at risk groups in our series were business travellers and military personnel, as previously observed.[17-19] Other examples of the use of travellers as sentinels for public health surveillance includes the identification of dengue outbreaks in Luanda and Dar es Salaam[11] and for the Indian Ocean and West Africa.[20,21] Due to a large number of our patients returning from Africa, travellers returning to Marseille may be useful sentinels for future arboviral African outbreaks. Rapid testing for dengue is essential in patients presenting with a fever from Africa. Similarly, the geographical profile and number of travellers presenting with chikungunya in Marseille (Table 3 and Figure 1B) is a reflection of increasing global expansion, providing further examples of vital sentinel surveillance in travellers.[22,23] As our survey ended in October 2015, we only report one case of Zika virus; however, this is now an important differential amongst febrile travellers.[24] Marseille may be a vital sentinel site to document possible Zika epidemics on the African continent.[25] Public health surveillance of these arboviral infections are of particular interest in the Mediterranean region, due to the local emergence of arthropod-borne diseases given the presence of the Aedes albopictus vector in the Mediterranean region and risk of autochthonous transmission, particularly around hospitals.[26] Arthropod-borne diseases accounted for 68% of the top 20 diagnoses. Dengue was the second most common diagnosis during our study period, with 35% of patients from Asia, consistently with global data.[4,7] Furthermore, we report a significant increase in chikungunya cases between the two periods. This high rate of imported arboviral diseases is likely to increase, given the trend of increasing numbers of unwell travellers returning from the Caribbean and South East Asia. This indicates the need for improved prevention strategies, both before travel, by reinforcing pre-travel advice toward prevention of insect bites and malaria chemoprophylaxis, and after, with improved epidemiological surveillance and healthcare professional training. Pre- and post-travel advice should also include advice on reducing respiratory transmission (such as local emergence of multi-resistant tuberculosis or Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS) coronavirus), and improved hygiene practices to reduce nosocomial transmission of multi-resistant bacteria. Furthermore, improved diagnostic tools after travel, such as multiplex PCR, may help increase the number of etiological diagnoses amongst syndromic diarrhoeal and respiratory illnesses. Another specificity of Marseille are the large numbers of Muslim Hajj pilgrims each year returning from Mecca.[27] We demonstrate the increasing trend of travellers returning from the Middle East, demonstrating the importance of Marseille as a sentinel surveillance site to the Middle East. Over the last few years, the vast majority of travellers with respiratory symptoms after returning from the Middle East consulted because of a fear of contracting MERS.[28] Due to a protocolized management procedure, patients returning from the Middle East (n = 75) were disproportionately hospitalized (41, 55%), resulting in a hospitalization bias. Finally, the characteristics of sentinel surveillance in Marseille are also related to the specifics of the medical community. We house the national reference centre for rickettsioses, and so provide an opportunity to document high risk geographic areas for these emerging, underestimated infections.[29] Similarly, the centre for rabies vaccination is situated in Marseille, providing sentinel surveillance on patients seeking rabies post-exposure prophylaxis. We highlight the potential for rabid animal exposure in travellers, notably in Asia and the need to reinforce pre-exposure prophylaxis.[30] Previous studies local to Marseille have used a prospective cohort design, providing a denominator, amongst Hajj pilgrims[31] and travellers to Senegal.[32] This approach allows an estimation of risk of travel-associated diseases, including mild self-limiting conditions but is biased by traveller selection. Here, we use a different approach that describes the spectrum of diseases in patients returning from any foreign destinations and being referred to a specialized structure. Limitations include an important recruitment bias, with an underestimate of self-limiting conditions, a lack of denominator and disease prevalence estimates. However, it captures more severe and uncommon travel-related illnesses and provides vital sentinel information on the changing epidemiology of infectious diseases across the globe, most notably for dengue and chikungunya, as well as identifying less common infectious disease outbreaks in the tropics where laboratory facilities may be limited.[33] In conclusion, we demonstrate the need to understand the local population and corresponding travel risks, particular amongst those visiting friends and relatives who have higher hospitalization rates post-travel. Sentinel surveillance amongst travellers in Marseille provides essential information to guide both local practices, especially pre-travel consultation needs and addressing autochthone vector-borne risks, and informing institutional partners worldwide regarding the spread of arboviral epidemics and other arthropod borne infections.
Table 2.

Less frequent infections acquired by travellers, according to main presenting complaints and type of pathogen

Presenting complaintsBacterial infectionsParasitic and fungal infectionsViral infections
Respiratory/URTI

Legionnaire disease (4)

Pertussis (2)

Streptococcus pharyngitis (2)

Gastrointestinal

Shigella (6)

Campylobacter infection (2)

Helicobacter pylori infection (2)

Clostridium difficile infection (1)

Echinococcosis (5)

Dermatological

Lyme disease (7)

Tungasis (1)

Herpes simplex infection (7)

Chikenpox (4)

Herpes zoster (2)

Measles (2)

Mumps (1)

Zika virus infection (1)

STI

Syphilis (3)

Chlamydiae trachomatis genital infection (2)

Gonorrhoea (2)

Acute HIV infection (4)

AIDS (1)

Neurological

Meningocccal meningitis and sepsis (2)

Pneumococcal meningitis (1)

Neurocysticercosis (4)

African trypanosomiasis (1)

Japanese encephalitis (1)

Wide range of symptoms

Leptospirosis (9)

Q fever (8)

Melioidosis (1)

Toxocara infection (7)

Toxoplasmosis (1)

Trichinellosis (1)

Epstein-Barr virus infection (3)

  28 in total

1.  Illness in French travelers to Senegal: prospective cohort follow-up and sentinel surveillance data.

Authors:  Aïssata Dia; Philippe Gautret; Eric Adheossi; Albane Bienaimé; Catherine Gaillard; Fabrice Simon; Philippe Parola; Philippe Brouqui
Journal:  J Travel Med       Date:  2010 Sep-Oct       Impact factor: 8.490

2.  Innovative community-based initiatives to engage VFR travelers.

Authors:  K Leder; S Lau; P Leggat
Journal:  Travel Med Infect Dis       Date:  2011-10-02       Impact factor: 6.211

3.  2012 outbreak of acute haemorrhagic conjunctivitis in Indian Ocean Islands: identification of Coxsackievirus A24 in a returned traveller.

Authors:  C Aubry; P Gautret; A Nougairede; A S Dussouil; E Botelho-Nevers; C Zandotti; X De Lamballerie; P Brouqui; P Parola
Journal:  Euro Surveill       Date:  2012-05-31

4.  Infectious diseases related aeromedical evacuation of French soldiers in a level 4 military treatment facility: a ten year retrospective analysis.

Authors:  C Rapp; O Aoun; C Ficko; D Andriamanantena; C Flateau
Journal:  Travel Med Infect Dis       Date:  2014-03-19       Impact factor: 6.211

5.  Surveillance for travel-related disease--GeoSentinel Surveillance System, United States, 1997-2011.

Authors:  Kira Harvey; Douglas H Esposito; Pauline Han; Phyllis Kozarsky; David O Freedman; D Adam Plier; Mark J Sotir
Journal:  MMWR Surveill Summ       Date:  2013-07-19

6.  Sentinel surveillance of imported dengue via travellers to Europe 2012 to 2014: TropNet data from the DengueTools Research Initiative.

Authors:  Andreas Neumayr; Jose Muñoz; Mirjam Schunk; Emmanuel Bottieau; Jakob Cramer; Guido Calleri; Rogelio López-Vélez; Andrea Angheben; Thomas Zoller; Leo Visser; Núria Serre-Delcor; Blaise Genton; Francesco Castelli; Marjan Van Esbroeck; Alberto Matteelli; Laurence Rochat; Elena Sulleiro; Florian Kurth; Federico Gobbi; Francesca Norman; Ilaria Torta; Jan Clerinx; David Poluda; Miguel Martinez; Antonia Calvo-Cano; Maria Paz Sanchez-Seco; Annelies Wilder-Smith; Christoph Hatz; Leticia Franco
Journal:  Euro Surveill       Date:  2017-01-05

7.  Longitudinal study assessing the return of chloroquine susceptibility of Plasmodium falciparum in isolates from travellers returning from West and Central Africa, 2000-2011.

Authors:  Myriam Gharbi; Jennifer A Flegg; Véronique Hubert; Eric Kendjo; Jessica E Metcalf; Lionel Bertaux; Philippe J Guérin; Jacques Le Bras; Ahmed Aboubaca; Patrice Agnamey; Adela Angoulvant; Patricia Barbut; Didier Basset; Ghania Belkadi; Anne Pauline Bellanger; Dieudonné Bemba; Françoise Benoit-Vica; Antoine Berry; Marie-Laure Bigel; Julie Bonhomme; Françoise Botterel; Olivier Bouchaud; Marie-Elisabeth Bougnoux; Patrice Bourée; Nathalie Bourgeois; Catherine Branger; Laurent Bret; Bernadette Buret; Enrique Casalino; Sylviane Chevrier; Frédérique Conquere de Monbrison; Bernadette Cuisenier; Martin Danis; Marie-Laure Darde; Ludovic De Gentile; Jean-Marie Delarbre; Pascal Delaunay; Anne Delaval; Guillaume Desoubeaux; Michel Develoux; Jean Dunand; Rémy Durand; Odile Eloy; Nathalie Fauchet; Bernard Faugere; Alber Faye; Odile Fenneteau; Pierre Flori; Madeleine Fontrouge; Chantal Garabedian; Françoise Gayandrieu; Nadine Godineau; Pascal Houzé; Sandrine Houzé; Jean-Pierre Hurst; Houria Ichou; Laurence Lachaud; Agathe Lebuisson; Magalie Lefevre; Anne-Sophie LeGuern; Gwenaë Le Moal; Daniel Lusina; Marie-Claude Machouart; Denis Malvy; Sophie Matheron; Danièle Maubon; Denis Mechali; Bruno Megarbane; Guillaume Menard; Laurence Millon; Muriel Mimoun Aiach; Philippe Minodier; Christelle Morelle; Gilles Nevez; Philippe Parola; Daniel Parzy; Olivier Patey; Pierre Patoz; Pascale Penn; Alice Perignon; Stéphane Picot; Jean-Etienne Pilo; Isabelle Poilane; Denis Pons; Marie Poupart; Bruno Pradines; Didier Raffenot; Christophe Rapp; Marie-Catherine Receveur; Claudine Sarfati; Yaye Senghor; Fabrice Simon; Jean-Yves Siriez; Nicolas Taudon; Marc Thellier; Maxime Thouvenin; Dominique Toubas
Journal:  Malar J       Date:  2013-01-25       Impact factor: 2.979

8.  Travel-associated diseases, Indian Ocean Islands, 1997-2010.

Authors:  Hélène Savini; Philippe Gautret; Jean Gaudart; Vanessa Field; Francesco Castelli; Rogelio López-Vélez; Poh Lian Lim; Marc Shaw; Frank von Sonnenburg; Louis Loutan; Fabrice Simon
Journal:  Emerg Infect Dis       Date:  2013-08       Impact factor: 6.883

9.  Infections in symptomatic travelers returning from the Arabian peninsula to France: A retrospective cross-sectional study.

Authors:  Karolina Griffiths; Remi Charrel; Jean-Christophe Lagier; Antoine Nougairede; Fabrice Simon; Philippe Parola; Philippe Brouqui; Philippe Gautret
Journal:  Travel Med Infect Dis       Date:  2016-05-14       Impact factor: 6.211

10.  Travel-associated illness trends and clusters, 2000-2010.

Authors:  Karin Leder; Joseph Torresi; John S Brownstein; Mary E Wilson; Jay S Keystone; Elizabeth Barnett; Eli Schwartz; Patricia Schlagenhauf; Annelies Wilder-Smith; Francesco Castelli; Frank von Sonnenburg; David O Freedman; Allen C Cheng
Journal:  Emerg Infect Dis       Date:  2013-07       Impact factor: 6.883

View more
  6 in total

1.  A Prospective Study on the Impact and Out-of-Pocket Costs of Dengue Illness in International Travelers.

Authors:  Yesim Tozan; Tyler Y Headley; Maquines Odhiambo Sewe; Eli Schwartz; Tamar Shemesh; Jakob P Cramer; Kirsten A Eberhardt; Michael Ramharter; Nicole Harrison; Karin Leder; Andrea Angheben; Christoph Hatz; Andreas Neumayr; Lin Hwei Chen; Cornelis A De Pijper; Martin P Grobusch; Annelies Wilder-Smith
Journal:  Am J Trop Med Hyg       Date:  2019-06       Impact factor: 2.345

2.  Chikungunya resurgence in the Maldives and risk for importation via tourists to Europe in 2019-2020: A GeoSentinel case series.

Authors:  Pierre Dudouet; Philippe Gautret; Carsten Schade Larsen; Marta Díaz-Menéndez; Elena Trigo; Frank von Sonnenburg; Federico Gobbi; Martin P Grobusch; Denis Malvy; Vanessa Field; Hilmir Asgeirsson; Inés Oliveira Souto; Davidson H Hamer; Philippe Parola; Emilie Javelle
Journal:  Travel Med Infect Dis       Date:  2020-06-30       Impact factor: 6.211

3.  Novel tools for the surveillance and control of dengue: findings by the DengueTools research consortium.

Authors:  Annelies Wilder-Smith; Hasitha Tissera; Sazaly AbuBakar; Pattamaporn Kittayapong; James Logan; Andreas Neumayr; Joacim Rocklöv; Peter Byass; Valérie R Louis; Yesim Tozan; Eduardo Massad; Raman Preet
Journal:  Glob Health Action       Date:  2018       Impact factor: 2.640

Review 4.  What Is the Impact of Lockdowns on Dengue?

Authors:  Oliver Brady; Annelies Wilder-Smith
Journal:  Curr Infect Dis Rep       Date:  2021-01-21       Impact factor: 3.663

5.  Introduction of the SARS-CoV-2 Beta variant from Comoros into the Marseille geographical area.

Authors:  Van Thuan Hoang; Loutfia Assoumani; Jérémy Delerce; Linda Houhamdi; Marielle Bedotto; Jean-Christophe Lagier; Matthieu Million; Anthony Levasseur; Pierre-Edouard Fournier; Bernard La Scola; Didier Raoult; Philippe Gautret; Philippe Colson
Journal:  Travel Med Infect Dis       Date:  2022-02-12       Impact factor: 6.211

Review 6.  A Review of Guidelines/Guidance from Various Countries Around the World for the Prevention and Management of Travellers' Diarrhoea: A Pharmacist's Perspective.

Authors:  Geeta Hitch
Journal:  Pharmacy (Basel)       Date:  2019-08-04
  6 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.