Alexis Desrichard1,2, Fengshen Kuo1, Diego Chowell1,2, Ken-Wing Lee1,2, Nadeem Riaz1,3, Richard J Wong4, Timothy A Chan1,2,3, Luc G T Morris1,2,4. 1. Immunogenomics and Precision Oncology Platform, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY. 2. Human Oncology and Pathogenesis Program, Memorial, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY. 3. Department of Radiation Oncology, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY. 4. Department of Surgery, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY.
Abstract
Background: Tobacco smoking creates DNA damage, inducing mutations and potentially altering the tumor immune microenvironment. These types of genetic and immune microenvironment alterations are critical factors known to affect tumor response to immunotherapy. Here we analyze the association between the mutational signature of tobacco smoking, tumor mutational load, and metrics of immune activity in squamous cell carcinomas arising in the head and neck and lung. Methods: Using RNA and DNA sequencing data from The Cancer Genome Atlas head and neck (HNSC; n = 287) and lung (LUSC; n = 130) squamous cell carcinoma data sets and two independent gene expression data sets (HNSC, n = 136; LUSC, n = 75), we examined associations between the mutational smoking signature, mutation count, immune cell infiltration, cytolytic activity, and interferon-γ signaling. Results: An increasing mutational smoking signature was associated with statistically significantly increased overall mutational load in both HNSC (ρ = .33, P = 1.01 × 10-7) and LUSC (ρ = .49, P = 2.80 × 10-9). In HNSC, a higher mutational smoking signature was associated with lower levels of immune infiltration (ρ = -.37, P = 1.29 × 10-10), cytolytic activity (ρ = -.28, P = 4.07 × 10-6), and interferon-γ pathway signaling (ρ = .39, P = 3.20 × 10-11). In LUSC, these associations were reversed (ρ = .19, P = .03; ρ = .20, P = .02; and ρ = .18, P = .047, respectively). Differentially expressed genes between smoking-high and smoking-low tumors revealed broad tobacco-induced immunosuppression in HNSC, in contrast to a tumor-inflamed microenvironment in smokers with LUSC. Conclusions: In squamous cell carcinomas, the genetic smoking signature is associated with higher mutational load, but variable effects on tumor immunity can occur, depending on anatomic site. In HNSC, smoking is predominantly immunosuppressive; in LUSC, more pro-inflammatory. Both tumor mutation load and immune microenvironment affect clinical response to immunotherapy. Thus, the mutational smoking signature is likely to have relevance for immunotherapeutic investigation in smoking-associated cancers.
Background: Tobacco smoking creates DNA damage, inducing mutations and potentially altering the tumor immune microenvironment. These types of genetic and immune microenvironment alterations are critical factors known to affect tumor response to immunotherapy. Here we analyze the association between the mutational signature of tobacco smoking, tumor mutational load, and metrics of immune activity in squamous cell carcinomas arising in the head and neck and lung. Methods: Using RNA and DNA sequencing data from The Cancer Genome Atlas head and neck (HNSC; n = 287) and lung (LUSC; n = 130) squamous cell carcinoma data sets and two independent gene expression data sets (HNSC, n = 136; LUSC, n = 75), we examined associations between the mutational smoking signature, mutation count, immune cell infiltration, cytolytic activity, and interferon-γ signaling. Results: An increasing mutational smoking signature was associated with statistically significantly increased overall mutational load in both HNSC (ρ = .33, P = 1.01 × 10-7) and LUSC (ρ = .49, P = 2.80 × 10-9). In HNSC, a higher mutational smoking signature was associated with lower levels of immune infiltration (ρ = -.37, P = 1.29 × 10-10), cytolytic activity (ρ = -.28, P = 4.07 × 10-6), and interferon-γ pathway signaling (ρ = .39, P = 3.20 × 10-11). In LUSC, these associations were reversed (ρ = .19, P = .03; ρ = .20, P = .02; and ρ = .18, P = .047, respectively). Differentially expressed genes between smoking-high and smoking-low tumors revealed broad tobacco-induced immunosuppression in HNSC, in contrast to a tumor-inflamed microenvironment in smokers with LUSC. Conclusions: In squamous cell carcinomas, the genetic smoking signature is associated with higher mutational load, but variable effects on tumor immunity can occur, depending on anatomic site. In HNSC, smoking is predominantly immunosuppressive; in LUSC, more pro-inflammatory. Both tumor mutation load and immune microenvironment affect clinical response to immunotherapy. Thus, the mutational smoking signature is likely to have relevance for immunotherapeutic investigation in smoking-associated cancers.
Authors: David P Carbone; Martin Reck; Luis Paz-Ares; Benjamin Creelan; Leora Horn; Martin Steins; Enriqueta Felip; Michel M van den Heuvel; Tudor-Eliade Ciuleanu; Firas Badin; Neal Ready; T Jeroen N Hiltermann; Suresh Nair; Rosalyn Juergens; Solange Peters; Elisa Minenza; John M Wrangle; Delvys Rodriguez-Abreu; Hossein Borghaei; George R Blumenschein; Liza C Villaruz; Libor Havel; Jana Krejci; Jesus Corral Jaime; Han Chang; William J Geese; Prabhu Bhagavatheeswaran; Allen C Chen; Mark A Socinski Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2017-06-22 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: M Choi; H Kadara; J Zhang; E R Parra; J Rodriguez-Canales; S G Gaffney; Z Zhao; C Behrens; J Fujimoto; C Chow; K Kim; N Kalhor; C Moran; D Rimm; S Swisher; D L Gibbons; J Heymach; E Kaftan; J P Townsend; T J Lynch; J Schlessinger; J Lee; R P Lifton; R S Herbst; I I Wistuba Journal: Ann Oncol Date: 2017-01-01 Impact factor: 32.976
Authors: Naiyer A Rizvi; Matthew D Hellmann; Alexandra Snyder; Pia Kvistborg; Vladimir Makarov; Jonathan J Havel; William Lee; Jianda Yuan; Phillip Wong; Teresa S Ho; Martin L Miller; Natasha Rekhtman; Andre L Moreira; Fawzia Ibrahim; Cameron Bruggeman; Billel Gasmi; Roberta Zappasodi; Yuka Maeda; Chris Sander; Edward B Garon; Taha Merghoub; Jedd D Wolchok; Ton N Schumacher; Timothy A Chan Journal: Science Date: 2015-03-12 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Lisa M McShane; Douglas G Altman; Willi Sauerbrei; Sheila E Taube; Massimo Gion; Gary M Clark Journal: J Natl Cancer Inst Date: 2005-08-17 Impact factor: 13.506
Authors: Claudia P Hernandez; Kevin Morrow; Cruz Velasco; Dorota D Wyczechowska; Amarjit S Naura; Paulo C Rodriguez Journal: Cell Immunol Date: 2013-04-22 Impact factor: 4.868
Authors: Robert L Ferris; George Blumenschein; Jerome Fayette; Joel Guigay; A Dimitrios Colevas; Lisa Licitra; Kevin Harrington; Stefan Kasper; Everett E Vokes; Caroline Even; Francis Worden; Nabil F Saba; Lara C Iglesias Docampo; Robert Haddad; Tamara Rordorf; Naomi Kiyota; Makoto Tahara; Manish Monga; Mark Lynch; William J Geese; Justin Kopit; James W Shaw; Maura L Gillison Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2016-10-08 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Paul C Tumeh; Christina L Harview; Jennifer H Yearley; I Peter Shintaku; Emma J M Taylor; Lidia Robert; Bartosz Chmielowski; Marko Spasic; Gina Henry; Voicu Ciobanu; Alisha N West; Manuel Carmona; Christine Kivork; Elizabeth Seja; Grace Cherry; Antonio J Gutierrez; Tristan R Grogan; Christine Mateus; Gorana Tomasic; John A Glaspy; Ryan O Emerson; Harlan Robins; Robert H Pierce; David A Elashoff; Caroline Robert; Antoni Ribas Journal: Nature Date: 2014-11-27 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Vonn Walter; Xiaoying Yin; Matthew D Wilkerson; Christopher R Cabanski; Ni Zhao; Ying Du; Mei Kim Ang; Michele C Hayward; Ashley H Salazar; Katherine A Hoadley; Karen Fritchie; Charles J Sailey; Charles G Sailey; Mark C Weissler; William W Shockley; Adam M Zanation; Trevor Hackman; Leigh B Thorne; William D Funkhouser; Kenneth L Muldrew; Andrew F Olshan; Scott H Randell; Fred A Wright; Carol G Shores; D Neil Hayes Journal: PLoS One Date: 2013-02-22 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Ludmil B Alexandrov; Serena Nik-Zainal; David C Wedge; Samuel A J R Aparicio; Sam Behjati; Andrew V Biankin; Graham R Bignell; Niccolò Bolli; Ake Borg; Anne-Lise Børresen-Dale; Sandrine Boyault; Birgit Burkhardt; Adam P Butler; Carlos Caldas; Helen R Davies; Christine Desmedt; Roland Eils; Jórunn Erla Eyfjörd; John A Foekens; Mel Greaves; Fumie Hosoda; Barbara Hutter; Tomislav Ilicic; Sandrine Imbeaud; Marcin Imielinski; Marcin Imielinsk; Natalie Jäger; David T W Jones; David Jones; Stian Knappskog; Marcel Kool; Sunil R Lakhani; Carlos López-Otín; Sancha Martin; Nikhil C Munshi; Hiromi Nakamura; Paul A Northcott; Marina Pajic; Elli Papaemmanuil; Angelo Paradiso; John V Pearson; Xose S Puente; Keiran Raine; Manasa Ramakrishna; Andrea L Richardson; Julia Richter; Philip Rosenstiel; Matthias Schlesner; Ton N Schumacher; Paul N Span; Jon W Teague; Yasushi Totoki; Andrew N J Tutt; Rafael Valdés-Mas; Marit M van Buuren; Laura van 't Veer; Anne Vincent-Salomon; Nicola Waddell; Lucy R Yates; Jessica Zucman-Rossi; P Andrew Futreal; Ultan McDermott; Peter Lichter; Matthew Meyerson; Sean M Grimmond; Reiner Siebert; Elías Campo; Tatsuhiro Shibata; Stefan M Pfister; Peter J Campbell; Michael R Stratton Journal: Nature Date: 2013-08-14 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Janis V de la Iglesia; Robbert J C Slebos; Laura Martin-Gomez; Xuefeng Wang; Jamie K Teer; Aik Choon Tan; Travis A Gerke; Garrick Aden-Buie; Tessa van Veen; Jude Masannat; Ritu Chaudhary; Feifei Song; Michelle Fournier; Erin M Siegel; Matthew B Schabath; J Trad Wadsworth; Jimmy Caudell; Louis Harrison; Bruce M Wenig; Jose Conejo-Garcia; Juan C Hernandez-Prera; Christine H Chung Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2019-12-17 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Babatunde Y Alli; Robert D Burk; Mahnaz Fatahzadeh; Julie Kazimiroff; Robert M Grossberg; Richard V Smith; Thomas J Ow; Mauricio Wiltz; Jacqueline Polanco; Marie-Claude Rousseau; Belinda Nicolau; Nicolas F Schlecht Journal: J Infect Dis Date: 2020-07-23 Impact factor: 5.226
Authors: Mei Jiang; Aline F Fares; Daniel Shepshelovich; Ping Yang; David Christiani; Jie Zhang; Kouya Shiraishi; Brid M Ryan; Chu Chen; Ann G Schwartz; Adonina Tardon; Sanjay Shete; Matthew B Schabath; M Dawn Teare; Loic Le Marchand; Zuo-Feng Zhang; John K Field; Hermann Brenner; Nancy Diao; Juntao Xie; Takashi Kohno; Curtis C Harris; Angela S Wenzlaff; Guillermo Fernandez-Tardon; Yuanqing Ye; Fiona Taylor; Lynne R Wilkens; Michael Davies; Yi Liu; Matt J Barnett; Gary E Goodman; Hal Morgenstern; Bernd Holleczek; Sera Thomas; M Catherine Brown; Rayjean J Hung; Wei Xu; Geoffrey Liu Journal: Lung Cancer Date: 2020-12-04 Impact factor: 5.705
Authors: Nicole D Facompre; Pavithra Rajagopalan; Varun Sahu; Alexander T Pearson; Kathleen T Montone; Claire D James; Frederico O Gleber-Netto; Gregory S Weinstein; Jalal Jalaly; Alexander Lin; Anil K Rustgi; Hiroshi Nakagawa; Joseph A Califano; Curtis R Pickering; Elizabeth A White; Bradford E Windle; Iain M Morgan; Roger B Cohen; Phyllis A Gimotty; Devraj Basu Journal: Int J Cancer Date: 2020-07-06 Impact factor: 7.396