We present a combined experimental and theoretical study of electronic and optical properties of dihydro-tetraaza-acenes (DHTAn). Using solvent-free condensation, we are able to synthesize not only DHTA5 but also the longer DHTA6 and DHTA7 molecules. We then investigate their gas-phase electronic structures by means of ab initio density functional calculations employing an optimally tuned range-separated hybrid functional. By comparing with the parent linear oligoacenes (nA) and based on computed ionization potentials and electron affinities, we predict DHTAn molecules to be more stable than acenes of the same length, where we expect DHTAn molecules to be persistent at least up to n = 7 rings. We further exploit the analogy with nA by analyzing the entire intramolecular π-band structure of the DHTAn molecules. This clearly reveals that the additional two electrons donated by the dihydropyrazine group are delocalized over the entire molecule and contribute to its π-electron system. As a consequence, the symmetry of the frontier orbitals of DHTAn differs from that of the parent nA molecule. This also affects the UV-vis absorption spectra which have been measured for DHTA5, 6, and 7 dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide and analyzed by means of excited state calculations within a time-dependent density functional theory framework.
We present a combined experimental and theoretical study of electronic and optical properties of dihydro-tetraaza-acenes (DHTAn). Using solvent-free condensation, we are able to synthesize not only DHTA5 but also the longer DHTA6 and DHTA7 molecules. We then investigate their gas-phase electronic structures by means of ab initio density functional calculations employing an optimally tuned range-separated hybrid functional. By comparing with the parent linear oligoacenes (nA) and based on computed ionization potentials and electron affinities, we predict DHTAn molecules to be more stable than acenes of the same length, where we expect DHTAn molecules to be persistent at least up to n = 7 rings. We further exploit the analogy with nA by analyzing the entire intramolecular π-band structure of the DHTAn molecules. This clearly reveals that the additional two electrons donated by the dihydropyrazine group are delocalized over the entire molecule and contribute to its π-electron system. As a consequence, the symmetry of the frontier orbitals of DHTAn differs from that of the parent nA molecule. This also affects the UV-vis absorption spectra which have been measured for DHTA5, 6, and 7 dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide and analyzed by means of excited state calculations within a time-dependent density functional theory framework.
In the field of organic electronics, pentacene
(5A) is presumably
one of the most investigated organic molecules covered by a vast literature
ranging from device physics[1,2] over to fundamental
studies on electronic[3−7] and optical properties.[8−11] However, pentacene suffers from long-term stability
issues because of its photo-oxidation and low thermal stability.[12] To overcome these limitations and to provide
alternative molecules with improved film morphology and stability,
nitrogen-containing derivatives of pentacene, N-heteroacenes, have
been shown to be promising.[13−19] The synthesis of larger heteroacenes and the investigation of their
properties have already a long-standing history.[16] As early as in 1901, Hinsberg[20] has presented a comprehensive investigation of such multiunit nitrogeneous
ring systems, thereby discovering interesting properties regarding
their chemical stability or fluorescence properties. In the 1960s,
Kummer and Zimmermann have systematically studied the electronic properties
of linear diaza- and tetra-azaacenes compared with that of the parent
oligoacenes.[21] More recently, Nuckolls
and co-workers have demonstrated the fabrication of a thin-film transistor
based on a hydrogenated diaza-pentacene,[14] whereas Winkler and Houk have discussed the usage of nitrogen-rich
oligoacenes as n-channel transistors based on density functional calculations.[15]We decided to focus on 5-14-dihydro-5,7,12,14-tetraazapentacene
derivatives (DHTAn) depicted in Scheme because of two fundamental
features inherent to their chemical structure which offer a number
of opportunities to manipulate and control the electronic properties,
the stability, and the supramolecular arrangement in the solid.[22] First, these N-heteroacenes can be viewed as
constituted of dihydropyrazine units which add two more electrons
to the π system and thereby stabilize the molecule.[23] Second, the presence of H-donor (dihydropyrazine,
N–H) and H-acceptor sites (pyrazine, N) leads to well-organized
intermolecular H-bonding networks, forming a stable arrangement in
the solid state.[24] The first documented
molecule of that sort, 5-14-dihydro-5,7,12,14-tetraazapentacene (DHTA5),
has in fact been synthesized as early as 1890[25] and also been investigated in the seminal work by Hinsberg who called
this molecule homofluorindin.[20] Its structural
and electrochemical properties have already been reported,[26,27] and its electronic band structure has been revealed by ultraviolet
photoemission spectroscopy.[28] Driven by
new efficient synthesis routes,[22] its fundamental
properties and its potential for organic devices have been assessed.[17,18,23,29−31] However, extended DHTAn for n > 5 have not been reported so far where the presence
of
extra phenyl rings should affect the stability of their oxidized and/or
reduced forms. Also, a systematic study on the electronic structure
of the whole DHTAn family of molecules using a state-of-the-art
and predictive ab initio electronic structure method is still lacking.
Scheme 1
Chemical Structures of the Investigated Molecules
The left column shows representatives
of the oligoacene series denoted as nA, while the
right column depicts dihydro-tetraaza-acenes (DHTAn) with n = 5, 6, 7 rings.
Chemical Structures of the Investigated Molecules
The left column shows representatives
of the oligoacene series denoted as nA, while the
right column depicts dihydro-tetraaza-acenes (DHTAn) with n = 5, 6, 7 rings.In this work, extended DHTAn have been synthesized
(n = 6, 7) and fully characterized. Using a combined
experimental and theoretical approach, we investigate their electronic
and optical properties. Theoretically, we perform density functional
theory (DFT) calculations for the gas-phase oligoacene (nA) and dihydro-tetraaza-acene (DHTAn) molecules.
In addition to a standard exchange–correlation functional,
a generalized gradient approximation (GGA) as parameterized by Perdew,
Burke, and Ernzerhof (PBE),[32] we employ
a range-separated hybrid (RSH) density functional, with an asymptotically
exact and short-range fractional Fock exchange, where the parameters
are tuned nonempirically, per system, on the basis of exact physical
constraints, also known as optimally tuned RSH (OT-RSH).[33−36] This method leads to highly reliable values for the ionization potentials
(IPs) and the electron affinities (EAs) for DHTAn which we compare to the parent nA series. Moreover,
we also present a comparison of the π bands of DHTAn with those of nA with an emphasis on the changes
induced by the pyrazine and dihydropyrazine groups. We envision that
the insights gained by our study will be not only important for further
exploiting DHTAn molecules for various applications
but also useful for designing other novel N-heteroacenes.
Experimental
Section
Synthesis and Characterization of DHTA6
A well-mixed
solid of phenazine-2,3-diol (m = 800 mg, 3.72 mmol,
1 equiv), 2,3-diaminonaphthalene (m = 626 mg, 3.96
mmol, 1.05 equiv), and benzoic acid (m = 4.9 g, 40.0
mmol, 10 equiv) was heated to 400 °C for 10 min. Then, EtOH was
added to the hot mixture. This dark-colored suspension in EtOH (v = 50 mL) was sonicated (at 60 °C, 1 h), filtrated,
and washed with dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and acetone. The desired
product was afforded after 3 times sublimations under vacuum (8 mbar,
450 °C, 15 min) as a dark violet powder (m =
712 mg, 2.31 mmol, 58% yield). 1H NMR (400 MHz, DMSO-d6): δ (ppm) = 10.17 (br s, 2H), 7.78–7.76
(m, 2H), 7.53–7.48 (m, 4H), 7.14–7.12 (m, 2H), 6.86
(s, 2H), 6.63 (s, 2H). Solid 13C NMR (100 MHz): δ
(ppm) = 145.3, 144.1, 138.8, 130.7, 128.6, 123.0, 108.2, 100.8, 100.0.
HRMS (MALDI-TOF) m/z: [M + H]+ for C22H15N4+ calcd, 335.1291; found, 335.1290; error < 1 ppm.
Synthesis and
Characterization of DHTA7
A well-mixed
solid of 2,5-dihydroxy-1,4-benzoquinone (m = 445
mg, 3.18 mmol, 1 equiv), 2,3-diaminonaphthalene (m = 1020 mg, 6.45 mmol, 2.03 equiv), and benzoic acid (m = 7.2 g, 59.0 mmol, 18 equiv) was heated to 360 °C for 15 min.
Then, EtOH was added to the hot mixture. This dark-colored suspension
in EtOH (v = 50 mL) was sonicated (at 60 °C,
1 h) and filtrated thrice. The desired product was afforded after
3 times sublimations under vacuum (8 mbar, 450 °C, 15 min) as
a dark violet powder (m = 745 mg, 1.94 mmol, 61%
yield). 1H NMR (400 MHz, DMSO-d6): δ (ppm) = 10.55 (br s, 2H), 8.37 (s, 2H), 8.03–8.00
(m, 2H), 7.57–7.55 (m, 2H), 7.43–7.41 (m, 2H), 7.19–7.17
(m, 2H), 7.00 (s, 2H), 6.66 (s, 2H). Solid 13C NMR (100
MHz): δ (ppm) = 146.0, 138.3, 132.2, 126.1, 123.1, 108.2, 99.1.
HRMS (MALDI-TOF) m/z: [M + H]+ for C26H17N4+ calcd, 385.1447; found, 385.1447; error < 2 ppm.
Computational
Details
Within the generalized Kohn–Sham
formalism,[35,37] RSH functionals consist of a
partition of the Coulomb interaction as[38−40]Here, r is the interelectron
coordinate, erf is the error function, and α, β, and γ
are parameters, which in principle may be freely chosen or determined
empirically.[38] The first term in eq is treated within Hartree–Fock
(HF) theory, while the second one is treated within a standard semilocal
(sl) approximation.[41] The range-separation
parameter γ controls which of the two terms dominate at a given
distance. It has been repeatedly shown that γ can be strongly
system- and size-dependent;[33,35,42−44] thus, one uniform value for γ is not sufficient.
Therefore, we prefer to determine it separately for each system by
enforcing a nonempirical condition: we make use of the IP theorem[45−48] and choose γ such that the difference between the energy of
the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) level and the IP is
minimized. Specifically, this is accomplished by minimizing the following
target function[42]Here,
the εγ,α are the HOMOs of the (N + i) electron
molecular systems and i is an integer number. The
IPγ,α(N + i) are the corresponding
IPs, which are calculated
from the total energy difference between the (N + i) electron and the N + i – 1 electron system. In eq , when i = 0, the HOMO of the neutral
system is adjusted with the IP, whereas when i =
1, the IP of the anionic system, that is, the EA of the neutral system,
is considered, such that its difference from the lowest unoccupied
molecular orbital (LUMO) eigenvalue is minimized.[35] Note that γ has to be tuned for each choice of α
separately.As can be seen from eq , the parameters α and β control the behavior
of the Fock term for r → 0 and r → ∞, leading to and , respectively. The asymptotic behavior
of the xc functional for r →
∞ has been shown to be crucial for obtaining accurate HOMO–LUMO
gaps and thereby introduces another constraint on the parameters.
For a gas-phase molecule, enforcing α + β = 1 leads to
the correct asymptotic
behavior.[49] As a consequence, the semilocal
contribution in the long
range vanishes and α controls the amount of nonlocal Fock exchange
in the short range. This can be seen in the expression for the exchange–correlation
energy of the RSH functional, obtained with this constraint[34]where sl,x and sl,c denote semilocal exchange and correlation,
respectively,
and HF,x denotes nonlocal Fock exchange.We
have also simulated the optical absorption spectrum of molecules
in solution. To this end, we have taken into account the dielectric
constant of the solvent, DMSO, for which we take an experimental literature
value of ε = 2.18. Enforcing the correct asymptotic behavior
of the exchange potential in the solvent, , requires to
choose . Thus, the
exchange–correlation
energy is generalized to[36]Note that eq reduces to eq in the gas-phase case where ε
= 1. Using the functional
form of eq , we have
computed the spin-restricted vertical excitation energies within the
framework of time-dependent DFT (TD-DFT) using the Casida formalism.[50]All electronic structure calculations
have been performed using
the ab initio computational chemistry software package NWChem.[51] The Gaussian-based DFT module has been used
with a cc-PVTZ basis set. For the computations, we have utilized the
standard PBE exchange–correlation functional[32] as well as the long-range-corrected RSH functional (LC-wPBE).
Note that the preceding geometry relaxations have been performed using
the PBE functional and all molecular geometries are found to be planar.
Results
Synthesis
DHTA5 was prepared according to the procedure
reported in the literature[24] using solvent-free
condensation between the commercially available 2,5-dihydroxy-p-benzoquinone 1 and o-diaminobenzene 2 (2 equiv) (Scheme ). This reaction occurs at high temperature in the presence
of excess PhCO2H as the catalyst to afford the target pentacycle
that could be easily isolated by filtration in 80% yield. DHTA6 could
be isolated as a violet solid in 58% yield by reacting similarly the
commercially available 2,3-diaminonaphthalene 4 and 2,3-dihydroxyphenazine 3, which could be obtained in a previous work from 1 and 2 (1 equiv).[22] The same
procedure using precursors 1 and 4 (2 equiv)
leads to the formation of DHTA7 in 61% yield (see the Experimental Section).
Scheme 2
Synthesis of DHTA5,[24] DHTA6, and DHTA7
Influence of Short-Range Exchange
For our gas-phase
DFT calculations, we have tuned the range-separation parameter γ
by minimizing the target function defined in eq by taking into account, both, the neutral
molecule (i = 0) and the anion (i = 1). To judge the influence of α, the fraction of short-range
HF exchange, on the orbital energies, we have varied α from
0 to 0.5 and optimally tuned γ for each value of α. The
results for DHTA5 are plotted in Figure . First, we notice that compared to the GGA-PBE
result of 1.77 eV, the HOMO–LUMO gap is considerably widened
to 5.60 eV in a symmetric manner. The OT-RSH value of the gap, in
fact also the absolute HOMO and the LUMO position, is quite insensitive
to the value of α. This is because the IP and the EA are mainly
governed by the asymptotic behavior of the respective orbital that
depends on the long-range behavior of the exchange–correlation
potential which is independent of α. As expected, the optimal
range-separation parameter γopt reduces with increasing
α. Such a behavior can be rationalized because the range 1/γopt at which full Fock exchange sets in can be extended to
larger distances if the amount of the Fock exchange at short range,
governed by α, is increased.[34,36]
Figure 1
(a) Orbital
energies of DHTA5 computed within PBE-GGA and the OT-RSH
functional for α-values between 0 and 0.5; the corresponding
optimal γ-values are also shown (right axis). (b) Kohn–Sham
orbitals resulting from the OT-RSH calculations for α = 0.25;
the labels are explained in the text.
(a) Orbital
energies of DHTA5 computed within PBE-GGA and the OT-RSH
functional for α-values between 0 and 0.5; the corresponding
optimal γ-values are also shown (right axis). (b) Kohn–Sham
orbitals resulting from the OT-RSH calculations for α = 0.25;
the labels are explained in the text.We have color-coded the orbital energies according to the
symmetry
of the respective orbitals that are depicted in panel (b) of Figure . All π orbitals
with no node in the x,z-plane, denoted
as π, and the respective orbital
energies are plotted in red, while π orbitals with a node in
the x,z-plane, denoted as π, are plotted in orange. Here, m counts the nodes along the long molecular axis (x-axis). Orbitals of σ symmetry are shown in green,
specifically two states denoted as σa and σb which are centered around the pyrazine groups of the molecule.
In contrast to the π states, these orbitals exhibit a pronounced
dependence on the amount of short-range HF exchange. This is the typical
behavior for comparably localized states resulting from the growing
compensation of the self-interaction error with increasing α.[36] Note that for the remaining part of the paper,
we have set α = 0.25 because this value has been shown to yield
the best agreement with quasiparticle calculations for other pentacene
derivatives[36] as well as for the organic
pigment PTCDA.[34]It is worth mentioning
that the two types of π orbitals introduced
in Figure , namely,
π and π, are sometimes also termed linking and apex π bands,
respectively, referring to the position of the carbon atoms with the
strongest contribution.[52] For instance,
the HOMO of DHTA5, denoted as π6,0, has six nodes
along the long molecular axis and it belongs to the linking band.
Interestingly, the HOMO of DHTA5 has the same nodal structure as the
LUMO of pentacene.[53] This is because DHTA5
has two π electrons more compared to pentacene owing to the
two N–H groups which each contribute one more π electron.
Thus, overall DHTA5 exhibits 24 π electrons which lead to 12
occupied states, 5 of which are in the apex band (π0,1, π1,1, ..., π4,1) and 7 in the
linking band (π0,0, π1,0, ..., π6,0).
Frontier Orbitals
Naively, one may
conclude that 24
π electrons for DHTA5, as compared to 22 π electrons for
5A, may destabilize DHTA5 relative to 5A following the so-called 4n Hückel rule.[23] This
is, however, not the case as can be seen from a comparison of the
frontier orbitals, that is, the HOMO and LUMO energies, between DHTAn and the parent nA molecules which is
the focus of this subsection.In Figure , we have depicted the IP and the EA, computed
from the OT-RSH functional with α = 0.25, for oligoacenes from
naphthalene (n = 2) up to heptacene (n = 7) as black triangles and for the DHTAn for n = 5, 6, 7, 9, 11 as red circles. For the oligoacenes up
to pentacene, we have also included experimental data (blue plus signs)
for the IP[54] and the EA.[55] Both, experiment and calculation, nicely show the reduction
of the IP and the increase in EA, respectively, in the series from
naphthalene (n = 2), anthracene (n = 3), tetracene (n = 4), and pentacene (n = 5). The OT-RSH results slightly underestimate IP with
a maximum deviation of 0.3 eV compared to the experiment, while the
EA values all agree within ±0.15 eV. The further decrease in
IP (increase in EA) computed for hexacene (n = 6)
and heptacene (n = 7) is in fact the reason for the
well-known chemical instability of linear acenes longer than pentacene.
Figure 2
(a) IPs
and EAs for nA and DHTAn vs number
of rings n on a reciprocal axis. Experimental
IP and EA values for nA (blue plus signs) are from
refs (54) and (55). The OT-RSH-computed values
for nA and DHTAn are shown as black
triangles and red circles, respectively. (b) Optimal range-separation
parameter γopt corresponding to the computational
results of panel (a).
(a) IPs
and EAs for nA and DHTAn vs number
of rings n on a reciprocal axis. Experimental
IP and EA values for nA (blue plus signs) are from
refs (54) and (55). The OT-RSH-computed values
for nA and DHTAn are shown as black
triangles and red circles, respectively. (b) Optimal range-separation
parameter γopt corresponding to the computational
results of panel (a).We now turn to the OT-RSH results for the DHTAn molecules represented as red circles in Figure a. When comparing nA with
DHTAn of the same length, we clearly observe a stabilization
of, both, the IP and the EA. For instance for n =
5, the IP increases by 0.3 eV and the EA reduces by almost 0.5 eV
because of the introduction of the pyrazine and dihydropyrazine groups.
We predict that this trend is continued for the longer molecules such
that one can expect chemically stable dihydro-tetraaza-acenes up to
7 rings. While our computed EA for DHTAn has the
expected trend as a function of n, we observe a peculiar
behavior of the IP for which the OT-RSH results predict an almost
constant value of 6.6 eV between n = 5 and n = 7 before it considerably reduces for n = 9 and n = 11. We believe that this is related
to the underlying structure of the π bands of linear oligoacenes
which will be the focus of the next subsection.Before we close
this section, we briefly point out that, as depicted
in panel (b) of Figure , the optimal range-separation parameter γopt also
follows a clear trend as a function of the molecular length n, where almost the same values for nA
and DHTAn have been computed. The longer the molecule,
the smaller γopt has to be chosen; in other words,
the larger the distance dividing the short from the long range, 1/γopt has to be chosen. Interestingly, we find a linear trend
as a function of the inverse length n with a saturation
value of γopt = 0.07 bohr for a hypothetical infinitely
long acene chain.
π Bands
For pentacene, it
has been shown that
the orbital energies of the 11 occupied π orbitals can be interpreted
as intramolecular band structure grouped into the linking band containing
six and the apex band containing five orbitals, respectively. This
intramolecular band structure could also be measured by means of angle-resolved
photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES).[52] Here,
we show that the π orbitals of dihydro-tetraaza-acenes strongly
resemble those of the parent oligoacenes and can be equally represented
as the intramolecular band structure.Clearly, to establish
an intramolecular energy dispersion relation, orbital energy E versus momentum k, a momentum value k needs to be assigned to a given orbital. Now, for a molecule
of finite length, the momentum k is not a good quantum
number. For molecules with a quasiperiodicity such as nA and DHTAn, we can nevertheless define a quasimomentum
value by computing the Fourier transform of the orbital and assigning
the k-value to the maximum intensity in Fourier space.
Such theoretical momentum maps are depicted in Figure a for the LUMO + 1, LUMO, and HOMO of 5A
(top to bottom) and in Figure b for the LUMO, HOMO, and HOMO – 1 of DHTA5, respectively,
where the k-values corresponding to the maximum intensity
in momentum space are indicated by the vertical dashed lines. It should
be noted that the theoretical momentum maps for 5A have already been
experimentally confirmed by analyzing the photoelectron angular distribution
within ARPES experiments.[52,53,56−58] Using the technique of photoemission tomography,[59] such measurements are being planned also for
DHTAn in future.
Figure 3
(a) Theoretical momentum maps of the LUMO
+ 1 (π7,0), LUMO (π6,0), and HOMO
(π4,1)
of 5A with the k-value
at maximum intensity indicated as vertical dashed lines. (b) Same
as (a) for the LUMO (π7,0), HOMO (π6,0), and HOMO – 1 (π4,1) of DHTA5. (c) Orbital
energies of nA and DHTAn molecules
plotted vs the respective k-value defined in panel (a). Filled and open symbols correspond
to the linking and apex π bands denoted as π and π, respectively.
The solid and dashed black lines correspond to the π-band structure
of a hypothetical infinite polyacene chain, where empty bands (dashed
lines) have been rigidly shifted to match the empty orbitals of the
acenes.
(a) Theoretical momentum maps of the LUMO
+ 1 (π7,0), LUMO (π6,0), and HOMO
(π4,1)
of 5A with the k-value
at maximum intensity indicated as vertical dashed lines. (b) Same
as (a) for the LUMO (π7,0), HOMO (π6,0), and HOMO – 1 (π4,1) of DHTA5. (c) Orbital
energies of nA and DHTAn molecules
plotted vs the respective k-value defined in panel (a). Filled and open symbols correspond
to the linking and apex π bands denoted as π and π, respectively.
The solid and dashed black lines correspond to the π-band structure
of a hypothetical infinite polyacene chain, where empty bands (dashed
lines) have been rigidly shifted to match the empty orbitals of the
acenes.As already mentioned earlier,
the LUMO and HOMO belong to the linking
band with seven and six nodes perpendicular to the long axis, respectively,
and no nodal plane parallel to the long molecular axis. Roughly speaking,
given the length of DHTA5, L ≈ 12.1 Å,
the k-values are simply determined by , where m is the number
of nodes. This leads to 1.55 and 1.82 Å–1 for
the HOMO (π6,0) and LUMO (π7,0),
respectively, while the more precise values determined from the momentum
maps, from which also the momentum spread Δk is apparent, are 1.51 and 1.70 Å–1. Similarly,
the HOMO – 1 (π4,1) would be assigned a k-value of 1.04 Å–1 from simple node
counting arguments, while the momentum map yields 1.18 Å–1.When plotting the computed orbital energies
against the momentum
values k determined
from the momentum maps, the quasiband structure, or equivalently,
the intramolecular band structure can be determined.[52,60] Several interesting observations can be made when comparing the
intramolecular band structures of nAs with those
from the DHTAn molecules as depicted in Figure c. First, all π
orbitals of the oligoacenes are nicely threaded on the energy bands
of a hypothetical, infinitely long polyacene chain shown as solid
and dashed lines. Note that polyacene actually turns out to be gapless
with valence and conduction bands crossing slightly before the Brillouin
zone boundary (indicated by a vertical line), but for the sake of
comparison, we have shifted the conduction bands of polyacene (dashed
lines) such that they match the empty states of the oligoacenes in
energy. Second, we observe that all orbital energies of DHTAn are, on average, shifted by ≈1 eV to higher binding
energies and are slightly more scattered. We also notice a systematic
increase in the k-values from nA
to DHTAn as indicated by the brown lines connecting
black and red circles for n = 5. We attribute these
effects to the presence of the pyrazine and dihydropyrazine groups
that are responsible for the dipole moment of the molecule for which
we obtain 3.49, 3.84, and 3.21 debye for n = 5, 6,
and 7, respectively. As a result of the dipole moment, the electrostatic
potential exhibits a step along the long molecular axis, leading to
an asymmetric orbital structure and a concomitant deviation from the
simple particle-in-a-boxlike band dispersion. The potential step is
also responsible for a stronger spatial confinement of the orbital
and thereby explains the increased k-values. A third
observation has already been mentioned earlier but can be well-confirmed
by plotting the band structure, namely, that the symmetry of the frontier
orbitals changes when going from nA to DHTAn. While the HOMOs of nA belong to the
apex band, π, the HOMOs of DHTAn, for n = 5, 6, 7, are rather part of
the linking band π. This results
from the presence of two N–H groups that add two more electrons
to the π system which fill up one more π orbital. Similarly,
the LUMOs of DHTAn have in fact the analogous orbital
structure as the LUMO + 1’s of the oligoacenes. Last but not
the least, the analysis of the π-band structure of DHTAn allows us also to explain the aforementioned peculiar
behavior of the IP (the HOMO orbital energy), which remains at an
almost constant value of 6.6 eV for n = 5, 6, 7 but
reduces significantly for the 9- and 11-ring molecules. The reason
is that in the case of DHTA9 and DHTA11, the topmost orbital of the
apex band, π, is predicted to
become the HOMO rather than the highest orbital of the linking band
as is the case for n = 5, 6, 7.
UV–Vis
Absorption Spectra
We have also measured
UV–vis absorption spectra of DHTA5,[22] DHTA6, and DHTA7 which are depicted as solid lines in Figure . All three molecules show
two main absorption bands, one in the UV near 300 nm and another in
the visible range between 450 and 650 nm. Note that the results for
DHTA6 and DHTA7 are thus similar to those already observed earlier
for the parent system DHTA5.[22] With increasing
molecular length, we observe an overall red shift of the absorption
features, a phenomenon that is already well-known for oligoacenes
and for other aza-acenes.[21] This can be
clearly seen for the peak in the UV, but also the onset of the first
excitation shifts to lower energies, which is in line with a reduction
of the HOMO–LUMO gap.
Figure 4
Solid lines show the experimental UV–vis
absorption of compounds
DHTAn dissolved in DMSO, whereas the dashed lines
show the corresponding calculated TD-DFT spectra.
Solid lines show the experimental UV–vis
absorption of compounds
DHTAn dissolved in DMSO, whereas the dashed lines
show the corresponding calculated TD-DFT spectra.To analyze the experimental observations, we have simulated
the
vertical excitations energies of DHTAn within the
framework of TD-DFT.[50] To account for the
solvent, we have considered its dielectric constant, ε = 2.18,
in the expression for the exchange correlation energy given by eq . Compared to the gas-phase
calculations with ε = 1, the dielectric screening in the environment
of the solvent leads to a reduction of the single-particle HOMO–LUMO
gap from the gas-phase values of 5.60, 5.19, and 5.11 eV for DHTA5,
6, and 7, respectively (see Figure ), to 3.80, 3.54, and 3.49 eV in the solvent. Focusing
on the lowest energy transition, the excitations energies resulting
from the TD-DFT calculation turn out to be slightly smaller than those
of the HOMO–LUMO gaps, namely, 2.81, 2.61, and 2.62 eV for
DHTA5, 6, and 7, respectively. Within our TD-DFT approach and using
an OT-RSH functional, this difference between the HOMO–LUMO
gap and the optical excitation energy may indeed be interpreted as
exciton binding energies with an accuracy comparable to GW-BSE calculations.[61] Thus, we predict exciton binding energies to
range between 0.9 and 1.0 eV, which are typical values to be expected
for such molecules in a solvent. Note that a reduction of the exciton
binding energy is expected for the molecules in the solid state.[8,9,62,63]Figure 4 shows the lowest 10 excitations of DHTA5 with their
corresponding
oscillator strengths and a Gaussian broadening of 0.1 eV, which are
represented by a black dashed line. Apart from an overall shift of
approximately 0.5 eV to higher energies, the simulated spectrum compares
quite favorably to the experimental result. With the help of TD-DFT,
we can thereby identify the two major absorption bands separated by
about 2 eV to arise primarily from the HOMO–LUMO transition
and the HOMO – 1/LUMO + 1 transition, respectively. Owing to
the symmetry and nodal structure of the involved orbitals (HOMO–LUMO
= π6,0/π7,0 and HOMO – 1/LUMO
+ 1 = π4,1/π5,1), both excitations
exhibit a transition dipole parallel to the long molecular axis with
calculated oscillator strengths of 0.62 and 2.03 whose ratio fits
excellently to the experimental spectrum. It is important to note
that the optical absorption of DHTA5 therefore distinctly differs
from pentacene for which the lowest-lying transition is polarized
perpendicular to the molecule.Finally, also for DHTA6 and DHTA7,
the calculations predict the
lowest energy transition to be polarized parallel to the long molecular
axis. Moreover, also the second major absorption bands of DHTA6 and
DHTA7 around 4.34 and 4.26 eV, respectively, mainly arise from the
HOMO–LUMO + 2 transition polarized parallel to the long axis.
Compared to the experiment, a similar shift of about 0.5 eV for both
absorption bands is observed. One reason for this discrepancy could
be the fact that the effect of the solvent is taken into account only
by its dielectric constant, while for a more accurate description
of the spectra a more realistic description of the molecule–solvent
interactions may be necessary. Also note that the fine structure apparent
in the lowest energy absorption band in the experiment is likely due
to a vibrational progression which is not taken into account in the
theoretical spectra.
Conclusions and Outlook
Building
on the already reported synthesis root for DHTA5, in this
work, we have succeeded to synthesize and isolate the longer DHTA6
and DHTA7 molecules which we have characterized, both, experimentally
and by means of density functional calculations with a nonempirically
tuned RSH functional. We have computed the gas-phase electronic structure
of linear oligoacene (nA) derivatives in which the
benzene rings left and right to the central ring are replaced by rings
containing a pyrazine and a dihydropyrazine group, respectively. Despite
the fact that such dihydro-tetraaza-acenes (DHTAn, compare Scheme ) contain 4n π electrons and are thus nominally
expected to be unstable, our computed IPs and EAs reveal the opposite,
namely, an increase in IP and a decrease in EA when going from nA to DHTAn for a given number of rings n. This conclusion supports previous works based on the
resonance energies, extra cyclic resonance energy, and nucleus independent
chemical shift data of 4n π electron dihydro-aza-pentacenes
which are stabilized by aromaticity and conjugations of the dihydropyrazine
moieties.[23] We further predict that all
π orbitals of DHTAn strongly resemble the one
of the parent nA molecules; however, the symmetry
of the frontier orbitals changes owing to the addition of two electrons
to the π system.We have also computed photoemission momentum
maps for DHTAn which, in future studies, should be
tested against experimental
observations and could confirm the orbital energies and spatial structure
of the frontier orbitals. As a first step toward this direction, we
have measured the UV–vis absorption spectra of DHTA5, 6, and
7 in solution and compared them to TD-DFT results. This allows us
to identify the origin and polarization of the main optical transitions
which are distinctly different from the parent oligoacene series.
Moreover, preliminary investigations on the intermolecular packing
of DHTAn have emphasized the pronounced role of the
molecule’s dipole moment and the importance of hydrogen bonding
for these DHTAn molecules. In view of applications
in organic electronics, the intramolecular electronic structure together
with the expected intermolecular bonding forces makes DHTAn molecules an interesting class of molecules that certainly
deserve further investigations regarding thin-film morphologies and
bulk electronic structure.
Authors: Daniel Lüftner; Thomas Ules; Eva Maria Reinisch; Georg Koller; Serguei Soubatch; F Stefan Tautz; Michael G Ramsey; Peter Puschnig Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2013-12-16 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Anthony Thomas; Thomas Leoni; Olivier Siri; Conrad Becker; Martin Unzog; Christian Kern; Peter Puschnig; Peter Zeppenfeld Journal: Phys Chem Chem Phys Date: 2022-04-20 Impact factor: 3.945