| Literature DB >> 29572203 |
Mirjana Subotic-Kerry1, Catherine King1,2, Kathleen O'Moore1, Melinda Achilles1, Bridianne O'Dea1,2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Anxiety disorders and depression are prevalent among youth. General practitioners (GPs) are often the first point of professional contact for treating health problems in young people. A Web-based mental health service delivered in partnership with schools may facilitate increased access to psychological care among adolescents. However, for such a model to be implemented successfully, GPs' views need to be measured.Entities:
Keywords: adolescent; anxiety; depression; general practitioners; internet
Year: 2018 PMID: 29572203 PMCID: PMC5889492 DOI: 10.2196/humanfactors.8913
Source DB: PubMed Journal: JMIR Hum Factors ISSN: 2292-9495
Themes contributing to the acceptability of the proposed service model (N=13).
| Theme | Definition | n (%) | Example |
| Early intervention and prevention | The belief that the service provides an opportunity to detect youth with subthreshold symptoms who may remain undetected or receive little attention by traditional services, thus providing early intervention | 7 (54) | |
| Adolescent preferences | The belief that the service was an appropriate platform for this age group because of adolescent preferences for technology and spending time online | 8 (62) | |
| School context | The belief that the service would lead to greater access of care because it is free, online, delivered in the school environment, and complements traditional modes of therapy (eg, face-to-face) | 8 (62) | |
| Anonymity | The belief that this type of service would provide anonymity, reducing stigma and ensuring privacy | 5 (39) |
Type of patient feedback desired by general practitioners (N=11).
| Type of feedback notifications | n (%) |
| Patient registration to online service | 9 (82) |
| Clinical improvement | 10 (91) |
| Clinical deterioration | 11 (100) |
| Suicidality | 11 (100) |
| Number and type of modules completed | 6 (55) |
| Ceasing use | 10 (91) |
| Other: information about referral pathways, who the general practitioner has permission to speak to (eg, caregivers and health professionals); child protection or domestic violence issues; and details of specific areas covered in online modules | 3 (27) |
Duration of follow-up desired by general practitioners (N=11).
| Duration of follow-up | n (%) |
| 1 to 3 months | 2 (18) |
| 6 months | 4 (36) |
| 12 months | 3 (27) |
| Other: depends on duration of involvement and time taken to recover; should be determined by the clinical presentation and patient | 2 (18) |
Potential barriers to the proposed service model (N=13). GPs: general practitioners. CBT: cognitive behavioral therapy.
| Issues and theme | Definition | n (%) | Example | |
| Confidence and knowledge of eHealth | The degree to which GPs thought that there was a shortage of evidence-based online care and the personal preference for face-to-face treatment | 11 (85) | ||
| Privacy and confidentiality | The degree to which GPs were concerned with data storage, access, and privacy between GPs, school counselors, and caregivers (eg, data being mishandled or accessed without authorization) | 6 (46) | ||
| Effectiveness and accuracy of the proposed model | The degree to which GPs were concerned about youth not receiving appropriate care | 5 (38) | ||
| Noncompliance from adolescents | A concern that there may be a risk that some young people do not engage with the program and motivation to complete the online modules may be low | 8 (62) | ||
| Access issues | Potential constraints regarding availability of these services (eg, internet and phone access, and rural location) and client characteristics (eg, the inability to access service because of learning difficulties, cultural barriers, low school attendance, or complex clinical presentations) | 5 (38) | ||
| Lack of services | Limited availability of appropriate services in rural and remote areas (eg, limited options for referral, lack of qualified professionals, and adolescent specific services) | 4 (31) | ||
| Differences amongst GPs | Perceived differences in GPs’ mental health knowledge and experience with adolescents | 5 (38) | ||
| Noncompliance by GPs | Risk that GPs will not use service or have no incentive to use the service (ie, without rebate or ability to bulk bill for time spent outside direct consultation) | 3 (23) | ||
Themes influencing likelihood of referral of the proposed Web-based service (N=13). GPs: general practitioners.
| Theme | Definition | n (%) | Example |
| Perceived need | Whether the GPdentified a need for the service | 11 (85) | |
| Beliefs | Whether the GP felt the service would be helpful, promote help-seeking, or support clinical practice | 4 (31) |
General practitioner (GP) needs for service integration (N=13).
| Need | Definition | n (%) | Example |
| Collaborative approach to management of patient | A belief that the service was likely to be integrated if a coordinated approach between adolescents, caregivers, school counselors, GPs, and other health professionals is adopted | 10 (77) | |
| Duty of care and medico-legal implications | The need for delineation about who is part of the team and who is responsible for responding to alerts. Informed consent, transparent information about client progress, and a user-friendly feedback system were also discussed. GPs also outlined the need for legal advice (eg, notifying parents, consent, and medico-legal responsibility) and mandatory reporting guides (eg, self-harm, underage sex, substance use, and domestic violence) | 8 (62) | |
| Encourage relationship with GP | A belief that the program should encourage adolescents to build a relationship with a GP, for example, include information about how to find a GP, the types of issues a GP can assist with, and help adolescents with appointments | 10 (77) | |
| Quality of service information provided to GPs | The need for concise information provision, for example, specific details about how the service works and links to relevant information as a reference for GPs | 8 (62) | |
| Community awareness and promotion of the service | Strategies to overcome a lack of community awareness, for example, promotion in schools, advertising in newspapers, and promotion in health centers by health professionals | 11 (85) | |
| Training | A request for training for GPs and school counselors on how to use the service and provide feedback | 6 (46) |
Frequency of patient feedback desired by general practitioners (N=11).
| Frequency of feedback notifications | n (%) |
| Daily | 2 (18) |
| Weekly | 0 |
| Fortnightly | 3 (27) |
| Monthly | 3 (27) |
| Other: frequency should decrease over time; should be dependent on client progress or step allocation or symptom severity | 3 (27) |