Melissa Spina1, Jamie Arndt2, Mark J Landau3, Linda D Cameron4. 1. Department of Counseling, San Francisco State University, CA, USA. 2. Department of Psychological Sciences, University of Missouri, MO, USA. 3. Department of Psychology, University of Kansas, KS, USA. 4. Psychological Sciences, University of California Merced, CA, USA.
Abstract
Background: An integration of message framing and sociocultural literature suggests that ethnic health disparities may be reduced by incorporating minority groups' cultural values into persuasive health messages. Framing messages with metaphors represents one promising strategy for harnessing cultural values to change health outcomes. Still, the effectiveness of metaphoric health messages in minority populations has received virtually no empirical attention. Purpose: To fill this gap, the present study tested whether a health message using a cancer-screening metaphor targeting collectivism and familism values would engage individual differences in these values to predict Papanicolaou (Pap) smear intentions among Latinas. Methods: Latina women (N = 168) completed an online survey including measures of collectivism and familism. They were randomized to read a message about Pap smears featuring the metaphor the body is a family or no metaphor before reporting their Pap smear intentions. Results: Regression analyses revealed a pattern of interactions suggesting metaphoric messages engage targeted cultural values: For Latinas reading the family metaphor message, collectivism and familism positively predicted Pap smear intentions, whereas for Latinas reading the no-metaphor message, these values did not predict intentions. Conclusions: This study offers a foundation for further examination of the potential for metaphoric health messages that connect to cultural values to reduce ethnic health disparities. Implications and directions for future research are discussed.
Background: An integration of message framing and sociocultural literature suggests that ethnic health disparities may be reduced by incorporating minority groups' cultural values into persuasive health messages. Framing messages with metaphors represents one promising strategy for harnessing cultural values to change health outcomes. Still, the effectiveness of metaphoric health messages in minority populations has received virtually no empirical attention. Purpose: To fill this gap, the present study tested whether a health message using a cancer-screening metaphor targeting collectivism and familism values would engage individual differences in these values to predict Papanicolaou (Pap) smear intentions among Latinas. Methods: Latina women (N = 168) completed an online survey including measures of collectivism and familism. They were randomized to read a message about Pap smears featuring the metaphor the body is a family or no metaphor before reporting their Pap smear intentions. Results: Regression analyses revealed a pattern of interactions suggesting metaphoric messages engage targeted cultural values: For Latinas reading the family metaphor message, collectivism and familism positively predicted Pap smear intentions, whereas for Latinas reading the no-metaphor message, these values did not predict intentions. Conclusions: This study offers a foundation for further examination of the potential for metaphoric health messages that connect to cultural values to reduce ethnic health disparities. Implications and directions for future research are discussed.
Authors: María E Fernández; Alicia Gonzales; Guillermo Tortolero-Luna; Janet Williams; Monica Saavedra-Embesi; Wenyaw Chan; Sally W Vernon Journal: Am J Public Health Date: 2009-03-19 Impact factor: 9.308
Authors: Marielena Lara; Cristina Gamboa; M Iya Kahramanian; Leo S Morales; David E Hayes Bautista Journal: Annu Rev Public Health Date: 2005 Impact factor: 21.870
Authors: Cornelia Betsch; Robert Böhm; Collins O Airhihenbuwa; Robb Butler; Gretchen B Chapman; Niels Haase; Benedikt Herrmann; Tasuku Igarashi; Shinobu Kitayama; Lars Korn; Ülla-Karin Nurm; Bernd Rohrmann; Alexander J Rothman; Sharon Shavitt; John A Updegraff; Ayse K Uskul Journal: Med Decis Making Date: 2015-08-21 Impact factor: 2.583
Authors: John Charles A Lacson; Scarlet H Doyle; Jocelyn Del Rio; Stephanie M Forgas; Rodrigo Carvajal; Guillermo Gonzalez-Calderon; Adriana Ramírez Feliciano; Youngchul Kim; Richard G Roetzheim; Steven K Sutton; Susan T Vadaparampil; Brenda Soto-Torres; Peter A Kanetsky Journal: Cancer Res Commun Date: 2022-01-11