Spherical Body Protein 2 truncated copy 11 as a specific Babesia bovis attenuation marker.

Background

Bovine babesiosis, caused by B. bovis, is a tick-borne hemoparasitic disease that affects more than 500 million cattle annually worldwide [1]. Currently, the only effective strategy to alleviate economic losses and acute clinical pathologies is the use of live, attenuated vaccines. These live vaccines are produced from virulent parasites that undergo a series of quick passages in splenectomized calves [2]. However, such live vaccines have inherent risks and application issues, including reversion to virulence, contamination with other blood-borne pathogens, and the requirement of cold chain storage during transportation, as well as a high cost of production [3]. To improve upon this preventive care, a subunit vaccine is a preferred alternative, but none is currently available [4]. Crucial elements necessary to facilitate the development of subunit vaccines include a better understanding of the attenuation mechanisms or virulence determinants, and the identification of factors in the vaccine strains that contribute to protective immunity. Until a subunit vaccine can be developed, a stable live vaccine that cannot revert to virulence is important. Thus, if the factors involved in attenuation are identified, then a stable, live vaccine with no virulence reversion capability is possible.

At present, little is known about the identity of Babesia virulence factors. Attempts to decipher these factors resulted in recent reports that illustrate the alterations towards a reduced genome diversity in the attenuated strains obtained after repeated calf passages [5] as well as strain and phenotype-specific gene regulatory differences between virulent and derived attenuated strains [6]. Specifically, members of a Babesia-specific gene family, spherical body proteins (SBPs), were shown to be transcriptionally upregulated exclusively in the attenuated derivatives. Why these transcripts were upregulated in attenuated B. bovis remains unknown, but it is reasonable to hypothesize they may directly or indirectly be involved in the attenuation of virulence.

SBPs are localized within spherical body organelles in B. bovis, which are homologous to the dense granules found in other apicomplexans [7]. There are four spherical body proteins, SBP1-4, expressed in B. bovis erythrocyte stages. All contain signal peptides at the amino (N') terminus and are expected to be secreted proteins. The function of these SBPs is currently unknown; however, as all SBPs are released after merozoite invasion, they may contribute to growth, development, and/or survival of the intraerythrocytic parasites [7-12]. In addition, SBPs are hypothesized to participate in altered membrane permeability of infected erythrocytes, development of membrane protrusions, and infected-erythrocyte attachment to host endothelial cells at membrane protrusion sites [7]. SBP4 has been characterized as a specific marker for ELISA-based detection of different B. bovis strains [9, 12].

SBP2 is a protein conserved between different geographically isolates [8] and, unlike the other SBPs, consists of a 13-member sbp2 gene family. In contrast to the larger 225 kDa SBP2 protein, the rest of the family members are truncated copies between 25–48 kDa. In truncated copies, a high sequence identity compared to SBP2 resides at the N’ terminus while the carboxyl terminus (C') identity varies.

The full-length sbp2 (BBOV_II000740) and truncated copy 12 (sbp2t12, BBOV_II000680) genes are localized on chromosome 2, while the remaining eleven truncated copies are on chromosome 3. The truncated genes on chromosome 3 occur in three clusters of two, four, and five genes. Transcripts of all spherical body protein 2 truncated copies (sbp2t) were detected in blood stages [6]. The sbp2t11 gene is expressed in B. bovis blood stages as a 30 kDa protein, which results in a 17 kDa product upon proteolytic cleavage mediated by a PEXEL-like motif (PLM) [13]. SBP2t11 is localized in a vesicle, likely the spherical body, and probably secreted to the infected intra-erythrocyte milieu [13].

Interestingly, transcripts of the spherical body protein 2 truncated copies (sbp2t) 7, 9 and 11 (BBOV_III006460, BBOV_III006500 and BBOV_III006540, respectively) were found to be upregulated by as much as five-fold in attenuated strains as compared to the virulent parental isolates [6]. In the current study, we extended the analysis of transcript levels of these three sbp2t genes using additional geographically distant strains to test the hypothesis that sbp2 truncated gene members 7, 9 and 11 are attenuation markers for B. bovis.

Methods

In vitro propagation of B. bovis culture

Babesia bovis strains were maintained as in vitro blood culture in micro-aerophilus stationary-phase culture at 10% hematocrit using bovine erythrocytes as previously described [14]. These strains are geographically divergent virulent (vir) parental field isolates and their respective attenuated (att) derivatives were previously characterized [5]. They include Texas (Tx) and two Australian strains (T and D). Both Australian strains were provided by Dr Peter Rolls (Tick Fever Research Centre, Queensland, Australia).

Genomic and complementary DNA synthesis

An in vitro B. bovis culture with approximately 25% parasitized erythrocytes (PPE) was used for the isolation of genomic DNA (gDNA) using Puregene Blood Core Kit C (Qiagen, MD, USA). Briefly, cells were centrifuged at 1048× g for 10 min at 4 °C and washed with cold phosphate buffered saline (PBS). The pellet was frozen at -80 °C and stored overnight to lyse erythrocytes and release merozoites. To extract gDNA, the frozen cell pellet was thawed on ice, washed in 10 ml of ice-cold PBS, centrifuged at 1509× g for 20 min at 4 °C and suspended in 500 μl of Puregene Cell Lysis Buffer (Qiagen). Two microliters of RNaseA solution was added and incubated at 37 °C for 20 min followed by the addition of 25 μl of 20 mg/ml proteinase K and 1 μl of 20 mg/ml glycogen. The mixture was incubated overnight at 56 °C. Two hundred microliters of protein precipitation solution (Qiagen) was added and centrifuged at 8900× g for 5 min. Five hundred microliters of 100% isopropanol at room temperature (RT) was added to the supernatant and mixed by inverting, followed by incubation at RT for 10 min and subsequent centrifugation at 17,530× g for another 10 min at 4 °C. The pellet was washed in 70% ethanol, allowed to air dry and suspended in 25 μl of DNA hydration buffer (Qiagen).

For the generation of cDNA, in vitro B. bovis cultures with 25% PPE were used for Trizol RNA isolation (Ambion, MA, USA). Babesia bovis cultures were centrifuged and the pellets suspended in 3 ml of Trizol. Total RNA was isolated as indicated by the manufacturer (J.T. Baker, PA, USA). Total RNA was suspended in 25 μl of diethylpyrocarbonate-treated water. Total RNA was treated with Turbo DNA free-DNase (Ambion). Reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) was carried out for cDNA synthesis using random hexamers in the RT reaction (Retroscript, Ambion). cDNA from Txvir B. bovis kinetes was prepared as previously published [15].

Analysis of transcriptional profile sbp2t11 in kinete and blood stages

cDNA from Txvir B. bovis kinete and blood stage parasites was used to amplify a fragment of sbp2t11 and the control gene ubiquitin by PCR. Sets of primers were designed to amplify a specific 155 bp fragment of sbp2t11 and a 393 bp fragment from the ubiquitin gene BBOV_IV003190 (see Additional file 1: Table S1) at 1 cycle at 95 °C for 10 min; 35 cycles of 95°C for 10 s, 50 or 55 °C for 30 s, 72 °C for 30 s and finally 1 cycle at 72 °C for 5 min as reported previously [15] . Amplicons were cloned and sequenced as previously published [15].

Identification of sbp2t7, 9 and 11 in Australian T and D strains

Degenerate primers were designed using MacVector v.11.1, NCBI Blast and known sbp2 truncated copy 7, 9 and 11 gene sequences from the Tx strains, to amplify and clone the three orthologous genes from the Australia T and D strain pairs (see Additional file 1: Table S1). Amplifications were carried out using the following PCR conditions: 1 cycle at 95 °C for 180 s; 39 cycles of 95 °C for 30 s, 54 °C for 30 s, 72 °C for 120 s and finally 1 cycle at 72 °C for 300 s (Sigma-Aldrich RedTaq reaction mix, MO, USA). The amplicons were gel purified, cloned using pCR®4-TOPO® vector system (Invitrogen, MA, USA) and sequenced (Qiagen Miniprep and Eurofins SimpleSeq DNA sequencing kit, Thermo Fisher Scientific, NV, USA). Subsequent strain-specific primers were designed to amplify the full-length of sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 from cDNA of the Australian B. bovis strains. Validation of correct amplification was conducted by cloning and sequencing. Full-length of sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 from the cDNA of Australian B. bovis strain pairs (T and D) were reported under the GenBank accession numbers MG430176, MG430177 and MG430178, respectively.

Quantitative polymerase chain reaction (QPCR)

QPCR of sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 was carried out as previously described [6]. Briefly, sybr green supermix (Biorad, CA, USA), specific primers and 70 ng cDNA was used for qPCR at 1 cycle at 95 °C for 10 min; 39 cycles of 95 °C for 10 s, 57.5 °C for 30 s, 72 °C for 30 s and finally 1 cycle at 72 °C for 5 min and 55 °C for 1 min. Expected amplicons were between 155 and 200 bp. Three replicates per strain were used. To normalize the reactions, amplification of BBOV_II004820 which encodes for a single copy topoisomerase II gene was also set up using the same template source. The transcript level of topoisomerase II remains the same in the virulent and attenuated B. bovis strain pairs [6]. Final data are represented as cycle threshold ratio (CT ratio) rather than the actual CT values. Additional file 1: Table S2 shows all qPCR primer sequences.

Quantitation of SBP2t11 protein expression by densitometry and ELISA

Three biological replicates of Txvir and Txatt B. bovis protein lysates were prepared as reported previously [13] and used in three independent western blot analyses [13]. Band intensities were analyzed using the Alphaimager system and software (Cell Biosciences, CA, USA). The 17 kDa band intensity was normalized to the merozoite surface antigen 1 (MSA-1) protein expression using MSA-1-specific monoclonal antibody (mAb) BABB35 [16]. Txvir and Txatt B. bovis protein lysates with equal percent parasitized erythrocytes (PPE) were used in an indirect ELISA. Flat bottomed plates (Immulon-thermo, MA, USA) were coated overnight with 0.02 μg/μl of protein lysates in coating buffer (75 mM sodium carbonate and 16 mM sodium bicarbonate, pH 9.4). Plates were blocked for 1 h with 1× PBS, 0.05% Tween 20 and 5% bovine serum albumin (BSA). Fifty microliters of anti-SBP2t11 affinity purified antibody [13] or anti-MSA-1 (BABB35) at a dilution of 1:50 was incubated in the plates for 1 h. Washing was performed in an automated washing machine with 1× PBS, 0.05% Tween 20. The secondary antibodies used were goat anti-rabbit or goat anti-mouse IgG conjugated to horseradish peroxidase HRP (KPL 474-1516) at a dilution of 1:500 and plates were incubated for 1 h and washed. To develop the enzymatic reaction, 100 μl of 3,3',5,5'-tetramethylbenzidine (KPL 5300-01) was added to each well and the reaction terminated by adding 100 μl/well of stop solution (KPL 50-85-05). Results were read at 450 nm. Results are presented as the expression level of SBP2t11: MSA-1.

Statistical analysis

Expression values represented as cycle thresholds were normalized to the housekeeping gene, DNA topoisomerase II (putative). The final data were plotted as CT ratio where a lower ratio value corresponds to higher expression. Upregulation of sbp2t genes was statistically significant if P < 0.01 using a one-way ANOVA with Bonferroni post-hoc analysis (GraphPad Prism v.6.0a). The expression levels of SBP2t11:MSA-1 represent the mean of three independent samples. Standard errors of the mean (SEM) are indicated. Statistically significant differences were analyzed at P < 0.05 using a Student’s t-test (GraphPad Prism v.6.0a).

Results and discussion

The sbp2t11 gene is consistently upregulated among distinct attenuated B. bovis strains

We used two additional distinct B. bovis virulent and attenuated strain pairs to confirm the previously observed differential expression of the sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 genes in attenuated strains [6]. These strain pairs originated in Australia where Tvir and Dvir were virulent field isolates and Tatt and Datt were their corresponding attenuated derivatives [17-19]. Attenuation of these two strains was achieved using a similar rapid in vivo passage method as previously described [5, 17]. These strain pairs were chosen for their geographically distant isolation as compared to those from North and South America.

Sequence comparisons revealed numerous size and sequence polymorphisms in sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 genes (see Additional file 2: Figure S1, Additional file 3: Figure S2, Additional file 4: Figure S3) among Tx and both Australian strain pairs (T and D). Specifically, the sbp2t7 gene in the Australian virulent and attenuated strains is 864 bp long (see Additional file 2: Figure S1) with 93.3 and 92.1% identity at the nucleotide and protein levels, respectively, as compared to the Tx strain (see Additional file 1: Table S3). The sbp2t9 gene in both Australian virulent and attenuated strains is 798 bp long. This gene has 70.6 and 64.3% identity at the nucleotide and protein levels, respectively, to the Tx strain gene (see Additional file 3: Figure S2 and Additional file 1: Table S3).

The Sbp2t11 gene in virulent and attenuated T and D strains is 837 bp long with 86.7 and 84.7% identity at the nucleotide and protein levels, respectively, to the Tx strain (see Additional file 4: Figure S3 and Additional file 1: Table S3). In addition to the protein sequence changes derived from insertions and deletions in the DNA sequences, non-synonymous single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) mutations were present (see Additional file 1: Table S3).

The transcriptional levels of sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 from in vitro cultured blood stages parasites were compared among the virulent and derived attenuated strains using qPCR under the same conditions as reported previously [6]. The results indicated that sbp2t7 was not differentially regulated between Tvir and Tatt strains while it was significantly upregulated in Datt strain (Fig. 1a). Sbp2t9 was significantly upregulated in Tvir strain but was not different in transcript levels in the D strain pairs (Fig. 1b). In contrast, transcript levels of sbp2t11 were significantly upregulated in both Australian Tatt and Datt as compared to the parental strains (Fig. 1c). The sbp2t11 transcription analysis corroborates previously published data using Argentina and Texas B. bovis strains [6] and further confirms that upregulation of sbp2t11 is a shared transcript signature among attenuated strains (Fig. 1d). Thus, the additional comparative expression analysis of new B. bovis strain pairs performed in this study allowed rejecting sbp2t7 and sbp2t9 as attenuation markers for this parasite. The sbp2t11 gene remains as the only attenuation marker so far known for B. bovis. Figure 1d summarizes the transcriptional analysis results found in Texas, Argentina [6] and the Australian strains reported in this study.

Fig. 1

Sbp2t11 is an attenuation marker upregulated in blood stages. Quantitative PCR to determine transcript levels of sbp2t7, sbp2t9, sbp2t11 genes in T and D Australian strains. Transcript levels of (a) sbp2t7, (b) sbp2t9 and (c) sbp2t11 were measured and compared between virulent (grey) and attenuated (black) B. bovis Australian strains (T and D). Experiments were done in triplicates. * represents statistically significant difference. d Summary of upregulation of sbp2t transcripts in attenuated strains of Babesia bovis. Numbers indicate the corresponding sbp2t gene. 1, sbp2t1; 4, sbp2t4; 5, sbp2t5; 7, sbp2t7; 9, sbp2t9; 11, sbp2t11. Abbreviations: CT, cycle threshold; Vir, virulent; Att, attenuated

Expression of the SBP2t11 protein

We previously reported protein expression of SBP2t11 in the Tx B. bovis strain by conducting western blot analysis using an affinity-purified polyclonal anti-SBP2t11 antibody where we demonstrated both the expression of SBP2t11 and its cleavage from the 30 kDa full-length protein to a predominant C-terminal 17 kDa protein, determined by the recognition of a PEXEL-like motif (PLM) [13]. The anti-SBP2t11 antibody was produced against a specific small synthetic peptide at the carboxyl terminus designed because of the high sequence identity shared between SBP2 truncated protein family members at the amino terminus (see Additional file 5: Figure S4 and Additional file 1: Table S4). In this study, we performed quantitative protein analysis to investigate if differences in sbp2t11 transcription levels among various attenuated and virulent strains are extended at the protein level using western blot and ELISA-based analyses. The western blot analysis data first confirmed that SBP2t11 was detectable in attenuated and virulent parasites (Fig. 2a). The ratios among SBP2t11:MSA-1 expression levels were estimated by densitometry analysis performed on the 17 kDa bands on the membranes. We were unable to repeat protein quantitation using the 30 kDa full-size SBP2t11 because signals were too weak (Fig. 2b). Based on densitometry values obtained for the 17 kDa bands, there was no statistical difference in the protein level between attenuated and virulent strain pair (Fig. 2b). In contrast, SBP2t11:MSA-1 expression levels among Txatt and Txvir strains, obtained upon analysis using quantitative ELISA, using the same antibodies, demonstrated that the attenuated strain expresses a significantly higher amount of SBP2t11 protein than the virulent strain (Fig. 2c). Importantly, the ELISA allows the measuring of anti-SBP2t11 binding to the cleaved and full-length versions of SBP2t11, rendering the comparison using the ELISA method a more inclusive approach to detect SBP2t11. Collectively, the data show that the overexpression of the sbp2t11 gene is manifested at both the transcriptional and translational levels in Txatt strain, supporting the notion that sbp2t11 is an attenuation marker for Babesia bovis. The biological significance of this observation goes beyond the scope of this study and will be further addressed in ongoing experiments. The correlation between upregulation and overexpression of sbp2t11 in attenuated strains could be present in different geographically attenuated strains but specific antibodies are needed to confirm this phenomenon.

Fig. 2

Protein expression quantitation of SBP2t11 by densitometry and ELISA. a SBP2t11 expression in Txvir and Txatt strains. Controls include the peptide used to generate antibody, uninfected red blood cells (uRBC) and as loading control MSA-1 protein expression. Pre-immune rabbit sera (1:1000) were used as a control in Panel (a). b Expression levels of SBP2t11:MSA-1. The ratios were calculated by densitometry analysis performed on the 17 kDa-SBP2t11 and the 42 kDa MSA-1 bands. Three biological replicates of protein lysates of Txvir and Txatt B. bovis strains were used to run three independent western blots. Band intensity was measured and analyzed using Alphaimager system and software (Cell Biosciences). The intensity of the 17 kDa bands was normalized to the MSA-1 protein expression. c Expression levels of SBP2t11: MSA-1 by indirect ELISA. The levels of expression of SBP2t11 and MSA-1 in protein lysates from in vitro cultures were tested using an anti-SBP2t11 and anti-MSA-1 antibodies in Txvir and Txatt by ELISA. Expression of SBP2t11 was normalized to the MSA-1 protein expression. The graphs represent the mean of three independent samples and the SEM. * represents statistically significant difference at P < 0.05 using the Student’s t-test by GraphPad Prism v.6

The antibody raised against the SBP2t11 protein of the Tx strain does not react in immunoblots with any antigen derived from the Australian strains, likely due to sequence differences in the regions used to generate the antibody among these distinct strains (Additional file 1: Table S4). This outcome prevented assessing differences in the level of protein expression of the attenuated and virulent Australian strains in this study using immunoblots.

Transcriptional profile of sbp2t11 in distinct B. bovis life stages

The transcriptional profile of sbp2t11 in B. bovis was analyzed in Tx strain kinete and blood stage parasites using RT-PCR on total RNA extracted from B. bovis kinetes present in the hemolymph of ticks infected with B. bovis and in vitro cultured blood stage parasites. Whereas the control ubiquitin transcript was detectable in all samples at relatively similar intensities, sbp2t11 was only detected in blood stages of both Txvir and Txatt (Fig. 3). Importantly, the RT-PCR products were sequenced to confirm their specificity. The data showed that sbp2t11 is differentially expressed exclusively in Tx blood stages which suggests that its function is mainly associated with the intraerythrocytic life-cycle of the parasite.

Fig. 3

Expression of sbp2t11 gene in kinete and blood stages of B. bovis. sbp2t11 was amplified from cDNA of Txvir kinetes and Txvir/Txatt blood stages of B. bovis. BBOV_IV003190, a ubiquitin gene was used a control. tRNA not reverse transcribed was also used as control. (+) cDNA; (-) RNA represents not reverse-transcribed total RNA. Abbreviations: K, kinetes; Txvir, virulent Texas strain; Txatt, attenuated Texas strain; M, marker 1 kb molecular weight ladder

Conclusions

In this study, we hypothesized that sbp2 truncated gene members 7, 9 and 11 were attenuation markers for B. bovis. Comparative in silico analysis showed that there are significant size variations and SNPs present in the three sbp2 truncated genes among different geographically divergent B. bovis strains. Also, we found strain-specific regulatory transcript patterns in sbp2t7 and sbp2t9 (Fig. 1a and b) which rejects sbp2t7 and sbp2t9 as reliable attenuation markers. The observation that only sbp2t11 was consistently upregulated at the transcriptional level in blood stages of all evaluated attenuated strains places sbp2t11 as a strong candidate for a reliable/consistent attenuation marker (Fig. 1d). In addition, overexpression of SBP2t11 in a Txatt strain as compared to Txvir strain was confirmed at the protein level. The transcriptional profile of sbp2t11 demonstrated that expression of this gene is downregulated in Tx strain kinetes, suggesting a functional role of sbp2t11 exclusively in B. bovis blood stages. Further studies including the phenotypical characterization of a B. bovis sbp2t11 knockout model system and mutants overexpressing SBP2t11 combined with in vivo experiments will help us to elucidate the functional significance of SBP2t11 in attenuation.

Table S1. Primers used to amplify sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 in Australian T and D strains. Sequence of primers designed and used to amplify target genes from cDNA as indicated in methods. Tm and amplicon size are indicated. Table S2. Primers used for quantitative PCR of sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 in Australian T and D strains. The sequence of primers designed and used for qPCR of each gene analyzed as indicated in methods. Amplicons were validated by cloning and sequencing. Tm and amplicon size are indicated. Table S3. Nucleotide comparison of sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 between Texas and Australian strains. Sbp2t7, sbp2t9 and sbp2t11 in T and Dixie Australian B. bovis strains were reported in GenBank with accession numbers MG430176, MG430177 and MG430178, respectively. These sequences were compared with the reference Texas strain of B. bovis by MacVector 12.0.5. Base pair (bp), nucleotide percent identity and amino acid percent identity are indicated. DOC. Table S4. Percentage identity between SBP2 and its 12 truncated proteins. Amino acid sequence alignment of SBP2 protein and its twelve truncated proteins (SBP2t) in Texas Babesia bovis strain were performed by MacVector 12.0.5. Identity scores are indicated in percentages. (DOCX 32 kb)

Figure S1. Nucleotide alignment of sbp2t7 gene in Australian and Texas B. bovis. (PDF 198 kb)

Figure S2. Nucleotide alignment of sbp2t9 gene in Australian and Texas B. bovis. (PDF 203 kb)

Figure S3. Nucleotide alignment of sbp2t11 gene in Australian and Texas B. bovis. (PDF 193 kb)

Figure S4. Comprehensive amino acid sequence alignment of the SBP2 family members (n = 13). Members of the SBP2 proteins are highly conserved at the N’ terminus and more variable at the C’ terminus. Exact identity values are shown in Additional file 1: Table S4. Red boxes indicate the PEXEL-like motif (PLM) and number of amino acids of each protein. Abbreviations: T, truncated; SBP, spherical body protein. (PDF 682 kb)