Black Phosphorus and its Biomedical Applications.

Black phosphorus (BP), also known as phosphorene, has attracted recent scientific attention since its first successful exfoliation in 2014 owing to its unique structure and properties. In particular, its exceptional attributes, such as the excellent optical and mechanical properties, electrical conductivity and electron-transfer capacity, contribute to its increasing demand as an alternative to graphene-based materials in biomedical applications. Although the outlook of this material seems promising, its practical applications are still highly challenging. In this review article, we discuss the unique properties of BP, which make it a potential platform for biomedical applications compared to other 2D materials, including graphene, molybdenum disulphide (MoS2), tungsten diselenide (WSe2) and hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN). We then introduce various synthesis methods of BP and review its latest progress in biomedical applications, such as biosensing, drug delivery, photoacoustic imaging and cancer therapies (i.e., photothermal and photodynamic therapies). Lastly, the existing challenges and future perspective of BP in biomedical applications are briefly discussed.

Introduction

Two-dimensional (2D) materials, particularly graphene and its derivative graphene oxide (GO), are increasingly gaining scientific interest due to their excellent mechanical properties and electrical conductivity, large surface area-to-volume ratio and easy functionalization 1, 2. Similarly, inorganic graphene analogues based upon the transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs; e.g., molybdenum disulfide (MoS2)) are of great interest due to their thickness-dependent semiconducting properties 3. However, the utility of these nanomaterials is limited by a few intrinsic shortcomings, such as a lack of a bandgap in graphene 4 and relatively low carrier mobility in MoS2 5. Taken together, this has motivated the search for alternative 2D materials.

Black phosphorus (BP) has sparked enormous research interest since its discovery in 2014 due to its distinctive structures and useful properties 6. In the monolayer BP (also known as phosphorene), each phosphorus atom is covalently bonded with three adjacent phosphorus atoms, thereby forming a bilayer structure along the zigzag direction and puckered structure along the armchair direction 7. This structural anisotropy contributes to its exceptional properties, including its optical properties 8, mechanical properties 9, electrical conductivity 10, thermoelectric properties 11, and topological features 12, distinguishing it from other 2D materials [e.g., graphene molybdenum disulphide (MoS2), tungsten diselenide (WSe2) and hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN)]. Although numerous studies have been conducted to investigate the nano- and opto-electronic applications of BP, including its photonic applications based on its saturable absorption properties 13, 14, little attention has been paid to its potential biomedical applications 15, 16. This might be mainly due to the lack of stability of black phosphorus when it is exposed to the aqueous environment or air. Several recent studies have demonstrated the feasibility of synthesizing novel BP nanostructures that are stable in water and air 17-20. Phosphorus that forms BP is a benign, vital element that acts as a bone constituent, constituting ~1% of the total body weight 21, 22. As one of the main components of nucleic acids, phosphorus is essential in maintaining human health, leading to a biocompatible material with extensive application potential in the biomedical field 23, 24. BP has been employed as a biosensing substance for the detection of target analytes (e.g., immunoglobulin G (IgG) 25 and myoglobin (Mb) 26) due to its inherent electrochemical properties. It has also emerged as a potential agent for drug delivery and anti-tumour therapy owing to its high drug loading efficiency, good biocompatibility, and excellent photothermal and photodynamic properties 27, 28. Although BP-based biomedical application is still in its infancy with numerous technical challenges remaining to be solved, it may bring novel opportunities for future medical diagnosis and treatment. Therefore, extensive investigation on the potential of BP in biomedical applications, such as biosensing applications and regenerative medicine, would be highly desirable.

The sources of review articles on the fundamental properties of BP and its nano- and opto-electronic applications are extensive and readily available 29-32. Recently, BP nanomedicine and sensing applications have been reviewed 33, 34. However, the unique fundamental properties of BP compared to other 2D materials and its advantages for diverse biomedical applications have not yet been clearly discussed. In light of the rising demand for BP as an alternative to graphene-based materials, there is a strong need for a timely and comprehensive review on a wide range of biomedical applications of BP, including colorimetric sensing, fluorescent sensing, electrochemical sensing, field effect transistor sensing, cancer imaging, cancer therapy and drug delivery (Figure . In this review article, the unique and fascinating characteristics of BP that contribute to its biomedical applications are first discussed and compared with the properties of other 2D materials (e.g., graphene, MoS2, WSe2 and h-BN). The different synthesis methods of BP are then summarized. The advantages of using BP and its biomedical applications in biosensing, bioimaging, drug delivery, and cancer therapy are subsequently reviewed. Finally, the existing challenges and future perspective of BP are briefly discussed.

Fundamental properties of black phosphorus for biomedical applications

Compared to other 2D materials, BP has been known as a more favorable material for biomedical applications due to its exceptional properties. A comparison of the unique properties of BP and other 2D materials is summarized in Table Generally, graphene shows the highest carrier mobility, but it possesses zero-band gap and low ON-OFF current ratio, which may hinder its application in optical sensing, bio-imaging, and field effect transistor (FET) sensing 35, 36. MoS2 and WSe2 display a high ON-OFF current ratio due to their finite band gap structures, enabling them to be used in FET sensing. However, their narrow range of band gap and low carrier mobility may hinder their applications in many fields (e.g., optical sensor, bio-imaging, and gas sensor) 37. The 2D hexagonal boron nitrite (h-BN) has been known to be a good proton conductor with high electrical resistance, adding its value to water electrolysis and fuel cells. However, its insulating properties limit its other applications (e.g., electrochemical sensing) 38.

BP exhibits a direct and tunable band gap, which is dependent upon the number of layers (i.e., bulk: ~0.3 eV, bilayer: ~1.88 eV, monolayer: ~2.0 eV) 39. BP can be easily exfoliated into monolayer or few-layer nanosheets due to the weak van der Waals forces among the stacked BP layers 40. The wide tuning range of the BP band gap allows broad absorption across the visible light, infrared and ultraviolet regions 39, hence contributing to its excellent optical property compared to other 2D materials, which enables fluorescent and colorimetric detection of various types of bioanalytes (e.g., DNA, proteins and inorganic ions). This unique optical property also allows BP to be effectively used in biosensing, photoacoustic imaging, photodynamic therapy, photothermal therapy, and drug delivery 41. BP also exhibits a high carrier mobility (i.e., 1000 cm2/Vs for a 10 nm thick BP nanoflake) that is superior to TMDs (e.g., MoS2: 100 cm2/Vs) 39, 42. This may contribute to its high sensitivity to electrical perturbation, allowing it to detect gases based upon the electrical conductivity measurement 43. In addition, BP possesses a high ON-OFF current ratio, which supports its application in FET sensing. Its ambipolar characteristic also enables it to detect both positively and negatively charged bioanalytes. The most attractive physical property of BP over other 2D materials is its high in-plane anisotropic properties. For instance, the physical properties of BP (e.g., structural holes and mass of electrons) have been known to be highly anisotropic because of its band dispersion, a critical factor for anisotropic electrical conductance and electron mobility 44. These properties enable BP to be used for a variety of biosensing applications 25.

Generally, biocompatibility or toxicity of 2D materials is material-, size- and concentration-dependent 45. For instance, BP has demonstrated less cytotoxicity than graphene but more cytotoxicity than MoS2 and WSe2 46. Large BP (~884 nm ± 102.2 nm) was identified to have higher cytotoxicity than small BP (~208.5 nm ± 46.9 nm) 47. BP was also identified to induce cytotoxicity when applied at a high concentration (>50 μg/mL) 46, 48. Hence, it is essential to optimize the parameters of BP including, but not limited to, size and concentration before being used for biomedical applications. Overall, BP exhibits relatively low cytotoxicity or good biocompatibility; therefore, it is eligible for biomedical applications. Another distinct property of BP over other 2D materials is its natural in vivo biodegradability. BP is readily biodegradable inside the human body, producing nontoxic intermediates, such as phosphate, phosphite and other PxOy, upon exposure to water and oxygen; therefore, it is safe to be used for in vivo applications 22. Recent studies have demonstrated that BP nanosheets, particularly those with a small size, have a relatively high reactivity with water and oxygen and are easily degradable in aqueous media 40, 49, 50. Other 2D materials are not readily degradable and may accumulate inside the human body, which can cause cytotoxicity, and therefore require functionalization with other materials (e.g., polyethylene glycol (PEG), chitosan or glutathione) to enable effective body clearance when they are used for in vivo applications 51, 52. In short, BP exhibits a wide range of tunable bandgap, high carrier mobility, high ON-OFF current ratio, ambipolar characteristic, good biocompatibility, and in vivo biodegradability, indicating its greater potential in biomedical applications, including biosensing (optical, FET and gas sensing), photoacoustic imaging, photodynamic and photothermal therapy, and drug delivery over other 2D materials. This will be comprehensively discussed in Section 4.

Synthesis of black phosphorus nanosheets

The fabrication of thin 2D nanostructures can be categorized into “top-down methods” and “bottom-up methods”. In fact, various fabrication methods of BP have been reviewed 53. Top-down methods generally involve the exfoliation of bulk material into single or a few layered nanosheets through the application of driving force (e.g., liquid exfoliation and mechanical cleavage). The interlayer distance of two BP layers that are stacked together by weak van der Waals force is ~3.20-3.73 Å. Therefore, compared to other 2D materials, thin layers of BP could be more easily produced by the aforementioned exfoliation methods. On the other hand, bottom-up methods involve the direct fabrication of nanomaterial from a specific precursor through chemical reactions (e.g., wet-chemical methods and chemical vapor deposition (CVD)) 30.

In general, mechanical cleavage and liquid exfoliation represent the most commonly used methods of fabricating BP 30, 54-58. Mechanical cleavage has been widely used to produce BP nanosheets with high purity (Figure . Briefly, the thin flakes are mechanically peeled off from a bulk BP using an adhesive tape 39. The BP nanosheets are then transferred onto a silicon-based substrate and cleaned with alcohol for removing the residual adhesive tape. The as-prepared BP is then heated up to 180 °C to remove solvent residue 30. Notably, this method can produce nanosheets with relatively large surface area-to-volume ratio. However, the limitations of this method include the low yield and the limited ability to control size, shape and thickness of BP, which have restricted its practical applications. Another disadvantage of this method is the presence of chemical traces from the adhesive tapes after the process of exfoliation.

To address these challenges, one group has improved the mechanical cleavage method to optimize the deposition of thin BP flakes 40. The conventional mechanical exfoliation with adhesive tape produces low density BP flakes with trace level of adhesive left on the surface. The authors introduced the cleavage of bulk BP with tape. Then, the thin BP crystallites maintained on the tape was slightly pressed against a polydimethylsiloxane-based substrate. This exfoliation method could substantially increase the yield and reduce the contamination risk of BP flakes. In another study, a combination of mechanical cleavage and plasma-assisted methods were demonstrated to produce a much more stable monolayer BP 59. To date, the major drawbacks of mechanical exfoliated BP are the difficulty in achieving uniform samples with well-controlled shape, thickness and size and low production yield 53. Therefore, there is a high demand to develop advanced mass production approaches for practical applications.

Plasma etching has been introduced, which represents another exfoliation method that can be used to produce monolayer or a few layers of BP through thermal ablation 60. One group demonstrated the use of an oxygen plasma dry etching method to reduce the thickness of BP flakes layer-by-layer with atomic precision, demonstrating a new method for fabricating high quality, air-stable BP films with a designated number of layers 61. Combination of the aforementioned method with mechanical cleavage could regulate BP thickness; however, this is not practical in mass production.

Liquid exfoliation has also been extensively used to synthesize ultrathin BP nanosheets 31. This refers to the exfoliation of mono- to few-layered BP nanosheets and is classified into the following categories: (i) oxidation followed by subsequent dispersion into the solvents, (ii) ion intercalation, (iii) ion exchange, (iv) shear exfoliation, and (v) ultrasonication-assisted exfoliation, which has been reviewed elsewhere 53. The most recent approach was ultrasonication-assisted exfoliation that involves ultrasonication of BP in a solvent to cleave the monolayered crystals to few-layered BP nanosheets (Figure . This method offers several advantages, including simplicity, low cost, high scalability, and the ability to form thin film and hybrid-composite materials 30, 62. The first BP liquid exfoliation method was based on surface passivation using N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP). After that, various types of solvents such as dimethylformamide (DMF), N-cyclohexyl-2-pyrrolidone (CHP), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and isopropyl alcohol (IPA) were introduced 55, 63. Particularly, DMF and DMSO have been widely used as solvents for the synthesis of BP nanosheets (Figure with lateral size of a few hundred nanometers (Figure 64. In addition to the typical nanosheet structure, quantum dots have also been explored in numerous studies. BP quantum dots (BPQDs) have been known to be a very promising structure due to their size-dependent and tunable electronic and optical properties based upon their crystallographic orientations. BPQDs have also been synthesized using the liquid exfoliation method (Figure . For example, one study has demonstrated that BPQDs synthesized with this method have a thickness of 1.9±0.9 nm and size of 4.9±1.6 nm 65.

Even though the bulk BP could be effectively exfoliated into BP flakes using those organic solvents, the organic residue could not be removed easily, which might potentially affect the subsequent bio-analysis. More recently, ultrathin BP nanosheets were prepared by exfoliating bulk BP into water instead of solvent 66. Bulk BP was dispersed in distilled water with argon supply to remove dissolved oxygen molecules, which might cause oxidation, followed by swelling by H2O and sonication for 8 h. The supernatant was collected after the centrifugation to eliminate the unexfoliated particles. The BP nanosheets could be stable in water without degradation for more than two weeks.

To date, a long duration of sonication process (~10-20 h) is normally required by liquid exfoliation, which could create structural defects and reduce the flake size of BP 54, 67. For instance, one study has reported that the flake size of BP prepared by NMP was relatively smaller than that of mechanically exfoliated BP (Figure . Therefore, it is important to prevent BP from fracturing during the process of sonication in obtaining a large quantity of high quality BP. Ball milling has been introduced to control the particle size of BP 68. This method could weaken the van der Waals interaction between BP layers with an optimum speed and sonication duration. Additionally, probe-type sonication has also been demonstrated, which requires shorter exfoliation time (~ 5 h) than bath sonication due to its exceptionally high ultrasonic power input, which generates a strong sonication 63, 69. In short, both mechanical cleavage and liquid exfoliation have showed a lack of ability to produce BP with a precise thickness or size. To address this drawback, it is critical to optimize the centrifugation condition such as centrifugation power 70 and speed 71 to control both size and thickness of BP (e.g., BP nanosheets or BPQDs).

Categorized as one of the liquid exfoliation methods, electrochemical exfoliation has also been introduced to synthesize few-layered BP 60. The bulk BP crystal was used as a working electrode while a platinum wire was used as a counter electrode. A voltage was applied between the two electrodes, producing both •OH and •O radicals through the oxidation of water molecules, which accumulate around the BP crystal. The presence of radicals between the consecutive layers of bulk BP weaken the van der Waals interaction between layers, and the production of oxygen gas from the radical oxidation results in the separation of BP layers 72. Additionally, the electrochemical lithium intercalation method has also been widely used to synthesize 2D materials using layered material as the cathode and lithium foil as the anode 73. However, this method has not yet been used for BP synthesis due to the fact that upon lithiation process, Li3P is produced through breakage of the P-P bonds, leading to a phase change and structural instability 74. Therefore, this challenge has to be addressed prior to its real application. Other liquid exfoliation methods such as microwave-assisted and sheer exfoliation have also been introduced for the synthesis of 2D materials, which offer the potential to produce high-quality and large quantities of BP. The major advantages of electrochemical synthesis methods involve the rapid synthesis process, high crystalline quality of the sample and high production yield 72. These methods have been reviewed elsewhere 60.

CVD is one of the typical bottom-up methods used to fabricate 2D nanomaterials. This method is performed on a given substrate with precursors at high temperature 30. As a result, this can produce ultrathin nanomaterials with a large surface area, tunable size and thickness, and excellent crystal quality. Another widely available bottom-up method for preparation of 2D materials is wet-chemical methods 75, 76. These methods include templated synthesis, solvothermal, hydrothermal and self-assembly of nanocrystals, which offer a low-cost and high-yield production of nanomaterials. Such bottom-up methods have been extensively used in fabricating various nanomaterials, such as graphene and TMDs (e.g., MoS2, WSe2) 77-79. A recent study has demonstrated the synthesis of BP using a wet-chemical method 80. This approach involves vapor-solid transformation triggered by continuous vaporization condensation, followed by bottom-up assembly growth. In fact, using a bottom-up method is highly challenging, especially to achieve large-scale synthesis of BP accompanied by large-area growth and well-controlled layer thickness. Therefore, in the future, investigating advanced methods for BP synthesis may be promising to explore various biomedical applications.

Surface modification of BP nanomaterials has been demonstrated to provide protection against degradation 32 or for functionality improvement 81. For the purpose of improving BP stability upon environmental exposure, BP is usually coated with chemicals (e.g., polylactic-co-glycolic acid, polyethylene glycol, aryl diazonium, titanium sulfonate ligand (TiL4), TiO2 and Al2O3) or other 2D layered materials, such as graphene and h-BN 20, 32. For instance, coating of BP nanosheets with Al2O3 by atomic layer deposition method mitigated BP degradation, and thus maintained the stability and performance of a BP-based FET sensor 17. In order to use BP for in vivo studies, it can be coordinated with polylactic-co-glycolic acid (by oil-in-water emulsion solvent evaporation method), polyethylene glycol (by high energy mechanical milling method) or TiL4 to protect BP from degradation in vivo by water and oxygen 24, 82, 83. On the other hand, graphene or h-BN, known to be an excellent gas barrier, can also be used to passivate BP nanosheets to improve its stability 84.

Besides protection, surface modification can also improve the properties of BP and subsequently contribute to its potential use in biomedical applications. For instance, passivation of aryl diazonium on BP nanosheets enhanced the BP ON-OFF current ratio, and thus improved the performance of a BP-based FET sensor 81. BP nanosheets coated with poly-L-lysine (PLL) facilitated the functionalization of BP with aptamers, which could be used as electrodes to detect biomarkers via electrochemical detection methods 15. In addition, BP nanosheets functionalized with gold nanoparticles displayed strong catalytic activity in which BP acted as an electron donor for reducing 4-nitrophenol, which is usually used for colorimetric detection of biomarkers 85. Further, BP nanosheets functionalized with gold and iron oxide nanoparticles showed a higher generation potential of reactive oxygen species (ROS) than that of bare BP upon irradiation with near-infrared (NIR) excitation light source (650 nm), indicating their greater photodynamic capability to promote their application in cancer therapy 86. To further improve the photodynamic capability of BP, BP nanosheets can be integrated with NaGdF4:Yb,Er@Yb@Nd@Yb upconversion nanoparticles (UCNPs) through electrostatic adsorption. This integration produces a larger amount of ROS upon irradiation with NIR excitation light source at 808 nm than those irradiated at 650 nm and 980 nm, which enhances BP anti-tumour efficiency 87. The properties of BP and its applications in biomedical fields will be discussed in detail in the next section.

Biomedical applications of black phosphorus

Black phosphorus for sensing

Targeted biomarkers are normally present in an extremely low concentration in clinical blood samples, requiring the development of highly sensitive and specific medical biosensors. BP has been employed as a biosensing platform for sensitive diagnosis of diseases, such as cardiovascular disease and breast cancer. BP nanosheets and BP nanoparticles (BPNPs) have been used for electrical, electrochemical, fluorescent and colorimetric biosensing due to their excellent electrical and electrochemical properties 26, fluorescent nature 88, and electron transfer capability 89, 90.

Field Effect Transistor (FET) biosensors

There have been a number of published research works regarding the FET sensing applications of 2D materials. A recent study demonstrated that a biotin-functionalized few layer MoS2 FET sensor could be used to detect streptavidin as a model analyte with a detection limit of 1 x 10-4 nM. This sensor had a higher sensitivity than graphene-based sensors (streptavidin with a detection limit of 7 x 10-3 nM) due to its high ON-OFF current ratio 91. There is no direct comparison between BP and other 2D materials in terms of FET detection of the same target analytes. The special characteristics of BP, such as direct bandgap, high ON-OFF current ratio and high carrier mobility, contributes to its excellent electrical properties, hence making it a good candidate for FET sensing. A recent study demonstrated the utilization of surface-passivated BP as a FET biosensing platform for the detection of IgG 25 (Figure . The BP-based FET biosensor was developed using BP nanosheets coupled with gold nanoparticle-antibody conjugates through surface functionalization. The mechanically exfoliated BP nanosheets were used as the sensing channel in the FET, with an Al2O3 thin film as the dielectric layer for surface passivation. The response of the biosensor was determined by the change in the electrical resistance of BP in the presence of antigen. The antigen-antibody interaction induced a gate potential that changed the drain-source current, showing both high selectivity and sensitivity (with a detection limit of ~10 ng/mL) towards human IgG (Figure . Although this platform showed good stability and high detection sensitivity, its conventional FET setup consists of multiple components (i.e., a semiconductor path as channel, two electrodes as source and drain, and a control electrode as gate) and requires an external electric field, making the fabrication and operation process complicated 92. Therefore, an easier design was explored to increase the portability of the sensor for point-of-care use 93.

Compared to other 2D materials, BP may be more suitable for use in FET biosensing due to its highly sensitive electrical properties and functionalizable surface. Importantly, BP shows excellent sensing performance particularly due to its finite band gap and high carrier mobility 93, which allows it to be used for the sensitive detection of other biomolecules. BP-based FET biosensors can potentially be used for rapid and sensitive diagnosis of various diseases, such as cardiovascular diseases and cancer by detecting their specific biomarkers.

Electrochemical biosensor

BP has also been extensively explored in developing electrochemical biosensors 26. In fact, several 2D materials (e.g., graphene and GO) show great potential in electrochemical sensing due to their good conductivity 94, 95. For example, GO has been used for sensitive electrochemical detection of leukemia cells at leukemia fraction of ~10-11 96 and cervical cancer biomarkers 97 (e.g., carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) and squamous cell carcinoma antigen (SCCA)) with detection limits of 0.013 ng/mL and 0.010 ng/mL, respectively. Due to its inherent redox properties, BP possesses superior electrochemical properties to further enhance the sensitivity and selectivity of an assay 26. A recent study reported the label-free electrochemical detection of the cardiac biomarker Mb in serum samples by using a simple aptamer-functionalized BP nanostructured electrode 26 (Figure . The BP nanosheets were modified by cationic polymer PLL that functioned as a linker for further biomolecule interaction with the underlying BP through the nitrogen atoms on PLL. The developed material was subsequently applied for the detection of specific biomarkers. Negatively charged DNA aptamers for Mb were immobilized onto the nanosheets via coulombic interaction between PLL and DNA. Mb can be directly oxidized to iron (III) at the electrode surface by an electron transfer mechanism. This biosensor showed high detection specificity and sensitivity imparted by the synergy of high affinity screened aptamers and enhanced electrochemical properties of the BP (Figure . It could achieve a lower detection limit (i.e., down to pg level) compared to the reduced GO (rGO)-based biosensor (i.e., ng level).

Besides BP nanosheets, developing either BPNPs or BPQDs is of great interest and can lead to versatile applications. For example, BPNPs were used as electrocatalytic tags for the detection of rabbit IgG 16 (Figure . The layered BP microparticles were exfoliated and downsized to nanoparticles with improved electrocatalytic activity for hydrogen evolution reaction. Briefly, the anti-rabbit IgG was conjugated with paramagnetic beads (MB). In the presence of target rabbit IgG, the target was labeled with BPNPs, which was in turn conjugated with MB-anti-rabbit IgG. The addition of acid H2SO4 into the complexes resulted in the denaturation of the protein complex and eventually impacted the electrode surface. The concentration of target IgG was determined by electrocatalysis of impacting BPNPs via proton reduction (i.e., hydrogen evolution reaction). This detection strategy was highly sensitive and specific (Figure , presenting a new concept in biosensing technology.

Another study demonstrated the synthesis of BPQDs with well-crystallized and tunable morphology and size by a high turbulent shear rate produced by a household kitchen blender, which could potentially be used as a humidity sensor for biomedical applications 98. Upon exposure to water molecules and oxygen, the BP was oxidized to phosphoric acid or phosphorus oxides, which were further ionically dissolved in the moist media to enhance the concentration of H+ ions 98. The modulation in ionic conduction of the BPQDs film with the variation in humidity was proposed to contribute to the excellent performance of the BPQDs-based humidity sensor. Due to the water molecule autoionization process (mobile H+ ion formation), the absorbed moisture layer on the BPQDs surface film can be ionically conductive. Its outstanding humidity sensing performance with high stability and sensitivity suggests its potential use for humidity sensors. In biomedical application, humidity sensors are mandatory to provide an indication of the moisture level for equipment, such as incubators, sterilizers and respiratory equipment for a variety of bioassays.

In short, BP-based biosensors have been reported to achieve more sensitive detection of target analyte(s) compared to other nanomaterial-based biosensors (e.g., graphene-based biosensors) due to their outstanding electrical conductivity, optical response and excellent electrochemical properties 26. Although other materials (e.g., graphene and rGO) have shown great potential in electrochemical sensing due to their good conductivity, the application of BP could dramatically enhance the detection sensitivity, and hence are more suitable to be used in electrochemical biosensing.

Fluorescent biosensor

Apart from electrochemical detection, BPNPs have been employed as nanofluorophores in fluorescence-based sensing. Similar to other 2D materials (e.g., GO), BP has excellent optical properties and fluorescent nature, making it a highly efficient fluorescence quencher 88. In particular, BPQDs offer many advantages, including high quantum yield, good photostability and size-tunable absorption and emission 99. A variety of parameters including size, shape and composition of BP can be readily manipulated to achieve the desired optoelectrical properties for highly sensitive fluorescence detection 99. Thus, the quenching efficiency of BP might be superior to the existing organic quenchers.

BPNPs were reported to be used as fluorophores for developing a novel fluorescence-based detection platform for nucleic acids 88 (Figure . In the presence of the targeted single-stranded DNA, the DNA would hybridize with a dark quencher label probe, namely dabcyl-L probe, to form a double-stranded DNA complex. This probe is likely to absorb onto the BPNP fluorophores via hydrophobic interactions and dispersive forces. However, the complex would reduce its affinity to BPNPs and hence would not be adsorbed onto the fluorophore surface. In contrast, the absence of the targeted DNA or double stranded DNA complex would result in photoluminescence quenching of the BPNPs following the adsorption of probe onto the BPNPs, subsequently producing a reduced fluorescence signal. Maximum fluorescence emission was observed at 200 nm, presenting the fluorescent nature of the BPNPs (Figure . The proposed detection platform was able to detect DNAs with limits of detection and quantification of 5.9 pM and 19.7 pM, respectively 88 (Figure . High specificity was observed with the only positive fluorescence response of BPNPs towards the complementary DNA, whereas negative controls (i.e., mismatched DNA and non-complementary DNA) showed negative results (Figure . Although no study has compared the quenching ability of BP with other materials, this finding promotes the investigation of BPNPs as a potential nanomaterial for fluorescent detection of various target analytes, including enzymes, proteins and inorganic ions. For a better understanding of their fluorescent nature, further investigation should involve comparison of the quenching ability of BP with other 2D materials.

More recently, a BPNP-based fluorescence detection platform was used for the study of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) activity, which plays a very important role in drug screening, toxin identification and disease diagnosis 100-102. In general, thiocholine, the product of AChE-catalyzed hydrolysis of acetylthiocholine, can react with 5,5'-dithiobis-(2-nitrobenzoic acid) (DTNB) to produce 2-nitro-5-thiobenzoate anion (TNB) 103. TNB exhibits considerable spectral overlap with the excitation spectrum of BPNPs and hence it is able to quench the fluorescence of BPNPs 100. Owing to the unique features of BPNPs such as good photostability, relative high quantum yield and strong green fluorescence, they are highly suitable to be used as a fluorescent biosensing system for the detection of sensitive fluorescent signals. Further experiments using different parameters of BP (e.g., size and shape) as the fluorophores could be beneficial to improving the detection sensitivity and specificity of the targeted component(s) in fluorescent sensing.

Colorimetric biosensor

Besides electrochemical and fluorescent detection, BP has also been demonstrated as a versatile platform for label-free colorimetric detection of targeted biomarkers. Based upon their enhanced AuNP leaching 104 and improved DNA assembly properties 105, some colorimetric detection technologies have been developed using 2D materials (e.g., GO and functionalized graphene). Since different materials may have different outstanding properties, the benefits of BP should be explored for potential improvement in colorimetric sensing.

In fact, BP has demonstrated a lack of stability in water and air, which hinders its optoelectronic applications. The relatively easy degradation of BP could in turn contribute to its strong electron-transfer properties 89, 90, which may potentially improve the detection sensitivity of colorimetric assays. These properties were demonstrated in a recent study using AuNP-decorated few-layered BP (Au-BP) for the detection of cancer biomarkers (i.e., carcinoembryonic antigens (CEA)) in clinical serum samples 106 (Figure . By mixing hexachloroauric acid and BP, the prepared Au-BP demonstrated a high catalytic activity of reduction of 4-nitrophenol (4-NP). This reaction produced a colorimetric signal from yellow 4-NP to the colorless 4-aminophenol. Upon the addition of anti-CEA antibody, the catalytic activity was switched off due to the adsorption of anti-CEA onto the surface of Au-BP. In the presence of CEA, the formation of antigen-antibody complex switched on the catalytic reaction of Au-BP. This reaction resulted in a good relationship between the intensity of colorimetric signal and the concentration of CEA (Figure .

As mentioned previously, BP has a thickness-dependent, direct band gap that is different from graphene 6. This feature caused the Fermi level of BP to be higher than the reduction potential of AuCl4- (i.e., +1.002 V). As a result, a redox reaction was created between BP and AuCl4-, allowing spontaneous electron transfer from BP to gold ions that lead to the formation of AuNPs. Therefore, BP presents excellent electron-transfer properties, which could be tuned with different sizes and loading amounts. These properties would enhance the reducibility of catalyst in a redox reaction, and subsequently improve the analytical sensitivity of the developed biosensor. The developed sensor showed a high sensitivity (0.20 pg/mL) and selectivity for the detection of CEA, a biomarker to monitor colon and breast cancer 106. Therefore, the instability or reducibility of BP could also be used to prepare BP-noble metal hybrids for biosensing applications. Further interesting properties of BP should be explored in future to enhance the performance of colorimetric sensing.

Gas sensor

BP has superior gas sensing performance, which can be applied to detect environmental hazardous gases. In fact, some other 2D materials, such as GO, have been utilized for fabricating gas sensing platforms because their electrical properties are strongly affected by the absorption of gas molecules 107. The adsorption of gas molecules by BP is stronger than that of other 2D materials, which greatly enhances the electrical properties of BP and subsequently enables the construction of highly sensitive gas sensors 108. For example, a principle study of the adsorption of NH3, CO, CO2, NO, and NO2 onto monolayer BP was conducted. Detection of the gas adsorption by monolayer BP was more sensitive than that of graphene and MoS2 109. The stable conductance and relatively low degradation of BP upon exposure to the gases suggest BP as an excellent gas sensor for biomedical applications.

Another study reported the experimental verification of a BP-based gas sensor and showed increased conduction upon NO2 exposure (detection sensitivity: 5 ppb) compared to other 2D materials 110. Due to its reduced charge density, thin BP has a larger surface-to-volume ratio and larger bandgaps than other 2D materials, which is more readily affected by oxidation. Therefore, thicker BP flakes were used to enhance the stability of the device and reduce degradation upon gas exposure 110. BP was able to maintain its relative stability after sensing, as shown by no significant changes in its Raman spectra before and after exposure to NO2. The sensing performance fitted well with the Langmuir Isotherm based upon the adsorption of molecules onto the surface, validating charge transfer as the sensing mechanism. In addition, the conductance increased along with the increase in the concentration of NO2. These findings shed light on the importance of the gas sensing characteristics of BP, which can be used in biomedical applications (e.g., breath gas analysis for medical diagnosis).

In short, the sensitivity of BP in detecting the targeted chemical gases was ~20-fold higher than that of graphene and MoS2 108. Compared to other 2D materials, BP shows superior molecular adsorption energy, presenting distinct response to a visible change in the I-V relation either along the zigzag or armchair direction on the basis of the targeted molecules 93, 111. Moreover, BP has a much higher surface-to-volume ratio due to its puckered structure, maximizing the effect of molecule adsorption 112. BP also displays less out-of-plane electrical conductance, inducing more sensitive response to the target analytes that are close to the surface of phosphorus 110. Finally, superior mechanical properties of the P-P bond 9, high operating frequencies 113 and ambipolar behavior of BP 114 are also beneficial to practical applications.

Black phosphorus for cancer imaging

As one of the promising noninvasive cancer imaging technologies, photoacoustic (PA) imaging offers high image contrast and sensitivity, high spatial resolution and depth-resolved 3D imaging. Therefore, it has been shown to be superior to many other traditional optical imaging technologies that facilitate imaging-guided therapy 115. PA is able to produce high spatial resolution images with optical contrast in the region of 5-6 cm deep in tissues and achieves background-free detection of tumor 116. Although PA signal originates from the tumor site, the signal intensity is relatively low particularly at the early stage of cancer. Hence, effective exogenous contrast agents, such as NIR absorbing nanomaterials, have been explored for in vivo PA imaging of tumor 117, 118. For instance, reduced GO was used for in vivo PA imaging in theranostic biomedicine due to its intrinsic optical properties 119. However, the chemical routes for rGO reduction normally require toxic reductants (e.g., hydrazine). Due to P-P stacking interactions, rGO always tends to aggregate, influencing the bioimaging process 120. To address this issue, functionalized rGO has been introduced to enhance its stability for biomedical imaging 121. However, alternative materials have been explored to achieve enhanced photodetecting ability while maintaining their stability.

BP has been known as an alternative material for bioimaging due to its unique electronic and optical properties. This material has a tunable band gap ranging from 0.3 eV for bulk to 2.0 eV for a monolayer 7. Therefore, a multilayer BP could allow photodetection over a broad spectral region 24. Although BP is very reactive to water and oxygen, surface modification can be performed to enhance its stability. For example, one study demonstrated the surface coordination of a sulfonic ester of titanium ligand (TiL4) with BPQDs to improve its stability for use as a PA imaging agent for bioimaging of cancer 122 (Figure . Compared to the bare BPQDs, TiL4-coordinated BPQDs presented higher stability in water dispersion. They also exhibited better PA performance than AuNPs due to their large NIR extinction coefficient. In addition, BPQDs could passively accumulate in tumor at a large concentration via the enhanced permeability and retention effect 122, 123. Their high spatial resolution in the detection of tumor and excellent sensitivity demonstrate their potential use in clinical applications (Figure .

Recently, another study reported the use of polyethylene glycol-(PEG)ylated BPNP for both PA imaging and cancer therapy application 24 (Figure . The surface polyethylene glycol coating and the partial oxidation of BPNPs allow their excellent stability and solubility in water. In vivo studies showed that after 24 h of intravenous injection with PEGylated BPNP, the tumor retained higher intensity of signal compared to kidney and liver (Figure . Thus, the nanoparticles have a long retention period in the tumor through the influence of improved permeability and retention, while they can also be readily excreted from the liver and kidney. These properties make them highly suitable for PA imaging of cancer. The role of BP in cancer therapy will be briefly discussed in the next section.

Black phosphorus for cancer therapy

As an alternative to traditional cancer therapy, BP has been employed in phototherapy, which offers many advantages, such as minimal invasiveness and high therapeutic efficiency 66, 124, 125. Generally, phototherapy is divided into photothermal therapy (PTT) and photodynamic therapy (PDT) 126. In PTT, a photothermal agent is used for selective local heating for ablation of cancer cells using NIR light-absorbing agents. In PDT, the treatment is based upon a series of photochemical reactions triggered by a photosensitizer with specific wavelengths of light. The excitation leads to energy transfer to oxygen molecules in the surrounding areas, which generates cytotoxic ROS that can kill the targeted cancer cells 127. At present, many nanomaterials (e.g., graphene oxides) have been explored in cancer therapy 128, 129. BP in particular has scientific interest due to its impressive carrier mobility and tunable band gap that lead to its broad absorption across UV and visible light. Therefore, it could be an excellent photosensitizer to improve PDT and PTT.

For instance, exfoliated BP nanosheets were reported to be effective photosensitizers for the generation of singlet oxygen that can be applied in PDT of cancer 66. The photodegradable properties of BP from elemental phosphorus to biocompatible phosphorus oxides under light irradiation illustrate its potential use for cancer therapy. However, the irradiation wavelength within the visible light region possesses strong tissue interference that limits its tissue penetration depth. In addition to therapy, imaging should also be performed to show the theranostic properties of BP. To achieve both functions, a study was conducted to demonstrate a novel multifunctional composite by integrating both NaGdF4:Yb,Er@Yb@Nd@Yb UCNPs and BP sheets for single 808 nm laser light-mediated photodynamic therapy 87 (Figure . Combining UCNP and BP allows the activation of BP by a single light source, which produces visible light that could be used as an imaging signal for cell tracking and tumor therapy. Both in vitro and in vivo studies showed that UCNP-BP with 808-nm light irradiation presented the highest effect of tumor inhibition. However, the relatively low quantum yield of the up-converted process for the energy donor limits its clinical applications (Figure . To this end, a novel nanocomposite that assembles AuNP and iron oxide nanoparticles on BP nanosheets was introduced 130. By combining both the photothermal effect of AuNP and the tumor targeting and magnetic resonance imaging guiding ability of iron oxide nanoparticles, this platform presents enhanced therapeutic effect. Besides surface modification, it has been demonstrated that the size of BP nanosheets also has an important role in their PTT efficiency 131. Three different sizes of liquid exfoliated BP nanosheets, namely large BP (~394 nm ± 75 nm), medium BP (~118 nm ± 22 nm) and small BP (~4.5 nm ± 0.6 nm) were used to evaluate their PTT efficiency. Large BP exhibited a significantly higher NIR extinction coefficient, resulting in its greater PTT effect on cancer cells MCF-7 (breast adenocarcinoma) compared to that of medium BP and small BP 131.

Besides BP nanosheets, BPQDs also offer tremendous potential for cancer therapeutic applications. BPQDs have been known to have a large NIR extinction coefficient, high photothermal conversion efficiency and little cytotoxicity 132, 133. One recent study demonstrated the potential use of BPQDs for PTT 132. Due to the broad absorption of BPQDs in the NIR band, remarkable NIR photothermal converting properties were achieved, indicating their potential use for cancer treatment. NIR photoexcitation of BPQDs in the presence of C6 (glioma) and MCF7 cancer cells led to significant cell death, suggesting the potential use of BPQDs as photothermal agents 132. The enhanced stability of BPQDs after PEG conjugation and the negligible toxicity to different types of cells further suggested their potential use in cancer therapy.

Another recent study reported the synthesis of water-soluble and biocompatible PEGylated BPNPs from stable red phosphorus by the one-pot solvent-less high energy mechanical milling (HEMM) approach 24. The nanoparticles possessed a uniform size and excellent photostability, biocompatibility and ability to convert NIR light into the heat. The tumor-bearing mice completely recovered after photothermal treatment with PEGylated BPNPs as a heat mediator in comparison to the mice from the control group 24. The exceptional properties of these nanoparticles suggested their potential use as a theranostic agent for both PA and PTT, offering a perfect solution for accurate diagnosis and treatment of cancer. More recently, a BPQD-based multifunctional nanoplatform was developed for bioimaging and photodynamic/photothermal synergistic cancer therapy 134. The BPQDs were synthesized through liquid exfoliation and demonstrated high water solubility, excellent biocompatibility and strong NIR absorbance. The effectiveness of PEGylated BPQDs for PTT and PDT was verified with both in vitro and in vivo studies. Low toxicity of BPQDs was also demonstrated by histological analysis of the main organs of the mice. This study provides tremendous potential for future clinical applications.

Although ultrasmall BPQDs with good biocompatibility and photothermal performance represent potential therapeutic agents, the degradation of their optical properties in the body and rapid renal excretion still restrict their use in clinical applications 82. To address this challenge, one study demonstrated the use of poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) loaded with BPQDs to produce BPQDs/PLGA nanospheres for PTT therapy 82 (Figure . The nanospheres were formed by an oil-in-water emulsion solvent evaporation method. In fact, PLGA is known as a biocompatible and biodegradable polymer with strong hydrophobicity 135-138. The degradation rate of nanospheres can be manipulated by adjusting their chemical composition, such as molecular weight and monomer ratio. The integration of PLGA could isolate BPQDs from water and oxygen to improve their photothermal stability and control their degradation rate in the physiological medium. The proposed nanospheres have good biocompatibility and photothermal therapy capability (Figure with negligible toxicity, as shown by highly efficient tumor ablation under NIR laser illumination to achieve a high therapeutic efficiency.

In another study, BP nanosheets functionalized with gold nanoparticles (BP-Au nanosheets) were introduced to enhance NIR for breast cancer PTT 139. The BP-Au nanosheets exhibit excellent photostability, improved absorption in the NIR region and good photothermal conversion efficiency under irradiation at 808 nm compared to the bare BP nanosheets. Additionally, BP-Au nanosheets also act as effective substrates for surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) bioanalysis. Therefore, SERS was performed to monitor the PTT effect and clearly identified molecular fingerprinting features of breast tumors in vivo. BP-Au nanosheets with a high SERS activity and excellent PTT effects show promising potential for biomedicine.

Recently, BPQDs were applied as a gene delivery system for cancer therapy. BPQDs were functionalized with polyelectrolyte polymers to deliver lysine-specific demethylase 1 (LSD1) small-interfering RNA (siRNA) into human ovarian teratocarcinoma PA-1 cells 140. The BPQD-LSD1 siRNA complex exhibited superior transfection efficiency compared to commercial delivery reagents (e.g., Lipofectamine 2000 and Oligofectamine) and was able to inhibit the cell growth rate by >80% in combination with NIR light with negligible cytotoxicity, indicating the potential of applying BPQD for siRNA delivery and cancer therapy.

In fact, the instability of BP has limited its application in cancer therapy. To address this issue, BP nanoflakes were coupled with graphene oxide to create hybrid aerogels that exhibit significantly enhanced photothermal properties and electrical properties 141. The hybrid gelation of graphene oxide with BP contributes to the stability of BP and protects BP from degradation in ambient conditions, which can eventually aid in biomedical applications (e.g., photothermal therapy for cancer treatment).

Black phosphorus for drug delivery

BP has also been emerging as a suitable nanomaterial that allows drug delivery and therapeutics. Considering the high surface area of BP, it offers great potential to be used as a superior drug nanocarrier compared to the existing nanomaterials 112. BP is negatively charged in water with an interlay distance of ~5.24 Å 142. Therefore, small and positively charged molecular drugs can be encapsulated within the interlayer spaces through electrostatic interactions. One recent study designed a theranostic delivery platform based on BP nanosheets (Figure 9A) 28. BP nanosheets were functionalized with positively charged PEG-amine to enhance their physiological stability and biocompatibility. The nanoparticles were loaded with the drug doxorubicin (DOX) for chemotherapy and cyanine 7 (Cy7) for in vivo NIR imaging. DOX-loaded BP nanosheets enhanced the therapeutic effect by reducing the percentage of viable HeLa cells (Figure 9B). The excellent therapeutic effect of PEGylated BP nanosheets was confirmed, which was attributed to the photothermal effect triggered by the NIR irradiation of BP, DOX-induced chemotherapy and chloroquine (CQ)-mediated inhibition of lysosomes and autography. The potential of the PEGylated BP theranostic delivery platform for in vivo application was also evaluated via Cy7-loaded BP nanosheets. Strong fluorescence signals were observed in the tumor tissues of both BP-PEG/Cy7 and BP-PEG-FA/Cy7 nanosheets even at 24 h post-injection of drugs, demonstrating good tumor accumulation of the BP delivery platform (Figure 9C, D). Taken together, the BP nanosheets showed promising therapeutic delivery in both in vitro and in vivo experiments, suggesting their potential use for cancer theranostics.

Figure 9

Black phosphorus as a material for drug delivery. (A) BP-based theranostic delivery platform. (B) DOX loaded BP nanosheets enhanced the therapeutic effect by reducing the percentage of viable HeLa cells. (C-D) Strong fluorescence signals were observed in the tumor tissues of both BP-PEG/Cy7 and BP-PEG-FA/Cy7 nanosheets at 24 h post-injection of drugs. (G1: BP-PEG/Cy7 nanosheet group; G2: BP-PEG-FA/Cy7 nanosheet group; H: Heart; LI: Liver; S: Spleen; LU; Lung; K: Kidney; T: Tumor). Reproduced with permission from reference 28, copyright 2017 John Wiley & Sons.

Similarly, another study also demonstrated BP nanosheet as a drug delivery system with the use of DOX as a model drug 143. The photothermal effect of BP was validated by the increased temperature under 808 nm laser irradiation, which was stable after six cycles. BP-DOX nanosheets were well dispersed in water without any agglomeration. Fluorescence quenching of DOX was also shown after DOX loading onto BP. BP can carry a high amount of DOX, with a drug loading capacity of 950% in weight, which is higher than other 2D materials (e.g., graphene and MoS2). This may be due to its higher surface-to-volume ratio and puckered lattice configuration 7.

A BP drug delivery system displayed photo-responsive drug release properties, in which the drug release was accelerated by NIR irradiation at 808 nm 143. After the intracellular endocytosis of DOX-loaded BP nanosheets under the NIR irradiation, tumour ablation occurred due to the elevation of the temperature of tumour tissues. At the same time, the loaded drugs could also be triggered to release for enhanced chemotherapy. Since the DOX binding site is in the nucleus and PDT by BP nanosheets normally occurs through the oxidative damage of organelles (e.g., mitochondria) 144, 145, the local hyperthermia increases membrane permeability and promotes drug-organelle interactions. Therefore, the drug release behavior could be enhanced under NIR irradiation at 808 nm 27. The photodynamic, photothermal and chemotherapy capabilities of BP significantly improve its antitumor efficiency. In short, BP nanosheet is an excellent drug delivery system, as reflected by its improved drug loading efficiency and photo-responsive drug release properties. The drug-loaded BP nanosheet presents significantly enhanced ability to kill cancer cells, demonstrating the efficacy of synergistic chemotherapy, photothermal and photodynamic therapy.

Conclusion and future perspective

In conclusion, this review article presents an overview of the state-of-the-art research in BP for biomedical applications, including biosensing, drug delivery, PA imaging and cancer therapy. The fascinating properties of BP (e.g., direct bandgap, strong structural and functional anisotropy, high conductivity and electron transfer capacity) play a key role in a wide range of biomedical applications. These properties can be further tuned by functionalization and nanostructuring with various substrates. Therefore, BP can be an ideal candidate for practical applications.

Despite the significant advances, research in this area is still in the very early stage compared to other well-explored 2D materials. From a fundamental point of view, producing high-quality and large-scale BP samples remains a challenge. Therefore, a robust and effective method for large-scale production of high-quality BP with precise control over its parameters, including layer number, size, concentration and surface modifications, is essential for potential biomedical applications with negligible toxicity.

Although several studies have demonstrated the use of BP as a highly sensitive gas-sensing platform, its application in medical diagnosis has not been explored yet. Therefore, future studies can also involve breath gas analysis with BP (e.g., measuring the level of breath ammonia and nitric oxide), which enables the detection of various diseases, such as renal disease and asthma 146. This simple diagnosis approach can potentially substitute conventional methods for the determination of volatile organic compounds (e.g., spectroscopic methods) 147, 148, which rely on expensive equipment and highly trained personnel. All the phosphorene-based sensing devices have so far only been demonstrated in the laboratory. To make the device commercially available, it is important to deal with the stability of BP during operation to ensure its robustness and reliability for real applications.

Nanomaterials (e.g., graphene) have also been explored in the field of regenerative medicine. To date, the response of cells towards BP substrate in terms of cell functional properties has not been reported yet. Therefore, it would be interesting to study the effect of BP film towards cell functional properties (e.g., viability, proliferation and differentiation) and provide a better understanding of BP-cellular interactions for applications in regenerative medicine. Given that BP possesses greater electrical conductivity than other 2D materials (e.g., graphene) 109, interfacing BP with neurons or cardiomyocytes can potentially explore and stimulate their excellent electrical behavior to facilitate neural or cardiomyocyte regeneration. Synthetic scaffolds such as gelatin methacryloyl (GelMA) hydrogels with tunable stiffness play an important role in extracellular stiffness to convey specific mechanical cues to the adherent cells 149, 150. Cardiomyocytes seeded on carbon nanomaterials (e.g., carbon nanotube), graphene and GO-polymer hybrid hydrogels have shown improved cardiac tissue morphogenesis, stronger beating behavior and higher spontaneous beating rate compared to those cultured on the pure polymer (e.g., GelMA) 151, 152. Therefore, it is promising to investigate the potential use of BP-GelMA hybrid hydrogel as a scaffold for neural or cardiac tissue regeneration. As for cancer therapy, alternative 2D materials (i.e., antimonene quantum dots) recently demonstrated superior photothermal conversion efficiency compared to other 2D materials 153. It would be interesting to study the effect of BP in combination with this 2D material to develop a hybrid therapeutic platform for cancer therapy. With many remaining challenges and opportunities, we envision that there will be more studies focusing on the utilization of BP in biomedical applications in the near future.

Table 1

Summary of the fundamental properties of BP compared to other 2D materials and its advantages for biomedical applications

Type	Black Phosphorus (BP)	Graphene	MoS2	WSe2	h-BN	Advantages of BP for biomedical applications
Materials / Bandgap (eV)	Semiconductor/ 0.3 - 2.0	Semimetal/ 0	Semiconductor/ 1.2 - 1.8	Semiconductor/ 1.2 - 1.7	Insulator/5.9	The wide tuning range of semiconductor BP band gap (by adjusting the layer number) leads to its broad optical absorption across UV, infrared and visible light spectrum, selectively detecting various types of bioanalytes, e.g., DNA, proteins and inorganic ions. This unique optical property allows BP to be used effectively in biosensing, photoacoustic imaging, photodynamic therapy, photothermal therapy, and drug delivery 41.
Carrier mobility (cm2V-1s-1)	1000	2 x 105	10 - 200	140 - 500	-	BP with high carrier mobility is sensitive to electrical perturbation, allowing it to sensitively detect the adsorption and desorption of single gaseous molecules, particularly health hazardous gases, based on the electrical conductivity measurement, making it suitable to be used in gas sensing 43.
ON-OFF current ratio	103 - 105	5.5 - 44	106 - 108	104 - 106	-	BP with high ON-OFF current ratio can be widely used in field effect transistor-based immunosensors which contributes to its high sensitivity in detecting antigen or antibody based on the electrical resistance measurement 154.
Electrical conduction type	Ambipolar	Ambipolar	n-type	Ambipolar	-	BP exhibits ambipolar characteristic which enable it to detect both the positively and negatively charged biomolecules 154. This property makes it possible to be applied in biosensing.
Biocompatibility	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	BP exhibits a relatively good biocompatibility and low cytotoxicity; therefore, it is eligible for biomedical applications, especially in photoacoustic imaging, photodynamic and photothermal therapy, and drug delivery
In vivo Biodegradability	Yes	No, requires functionalization	No, requires functionalization	No, requires functionalization	-	BP is readily biodegradable inside human body producing nontoxic intermediates, such as phosphate, phosphite and other PxOy upon exposure to water and oxygen, therefore it is safe to be used for in vivo applications, especially for cancer therapy 22.
References	7, 155	36, 156	7, 37, 157	17, 156	38, 158