Doug Brugge1,2,3, Matthew C Simon3, Neelakshi Hudda3, Marisa Zellmer3, Laura Corlin3, Stephanie Cleland4, Eda Yiqi Lu5, Sonja Rivera1, Megan Byrne4, Mei Chung1, John L Durant3. 1. Department of Public Health and Community Medicine, Tufts University School of Medicine, 136 Harrison Ave., Boston, MA 02111. 2. Jonathan M. Tisch College of Civic Life, Lincoln Filene Hall, Tufts University, Medford, MA 02155. 3. Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Tufts University School of Engineering, Tufts University, Medford, MA 02155. 4. Department of Community Health, Tufts University, Medford, MA 02155. 5. University of Massachusetts Amherst, 360 Campus Center Way, Amherst, MA 01003.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Exposure to airborne ultrafine particle (UFP; <100 nm in aerodynamic diameter) is an emerging public health problem. Nevertheless, the benefit of using high efficiency particulate arrestance (HEPA) filtration to reduce UFP concentrations in homes is not yet clear. METHODS: We conducted a randomized crossover study of HEPA filtration without a washout period in 23 homes of low-income Puerto Ricans in Boston and Chelsea, MA (USA). Most participants were female, older adults who were overweight or obese. Particle number concentrations (PNC, a proxy for UFP) were measured indoors and outdoors at each home continuously for six weeks. Homes received both HEPA filtration and sham filtration for three weeks each in random order. RESULTS: Median PNC under HEPA filtration was 50-85% lower compared to sham filtration in most homes, but we found no benefit in terms of reduced inflammation; associations between hsCRP, IL-6, or TNFRII in blood samples and indoor PNC were inverse and not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: Limitations to our study design likely contributed to our findings. Limitations included carry-over effects, a population that may have been relatively unresponsive to UFP, reduction in PNC even during sham filtration that limited differences between HEPA and sham filtration, window opening by participants, and lack of fine-grained (room-specific) participant time-activity information. Our approach was similar to other recent HEPA intervention studies of particulate matter exposure and cardiovascular risk, suggesting that there is a need for better study designs.
BACKGROUND: Exposure to airborne ultrafine particle (UFP; <100 nm in aerodynamic diameter) is an emerging public health problem. Nevertheless, the benefit of using high efficiency particulate arrestance (HEPA) filtration to reduce UFP concentrations in homes is not yet clear. METHODS: We conducted a randomized crossover study of HEPA filtration without a washout period in 23 homes of low-income Puerto Ricans in Boston and Chelsea, MA (USA). Most participants were female, older adults who were overweight or obese. Particle number concentrations (PNC, a proxy for UFP) were measured indoors and outdoors at each home continuously for six weeks. Homes received both HEPA filtration and sham filtration for three weeks each in random order. RESULTS: Median PNC under HEPA filtration was 50-85% lower compared to sham filtration in most homes, but we found no benefit in terms of reduced inflammation; associations between hsCRP, IL-6, or TNFRII in blood samples and indoor PNC were inverse and not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: Limitations to our study design likely contributed to our findings. Limitations included carry-over effects, a population that may have been relatively unresponsive to UFP, reduction in PNC even during sham filtration that limited differences between HEPA and sham filtration, window opening by participants, and lack of fine-grained (room-specific) participant time-activity information. Our approach was similar to other recent HEPA intervention studies of particulate matter exposure and cardiovascular risk, suggesting that there is a need for better study designs.
Entities:
Keywords:
HEPA; Puerto Rican; Urban air pollution; air filtration; community-based; intervention; ultrafine particles
Authors: S Weichenthal; G Mallach; R Kulka; A Black; A Wheeler; H You; M St-Jean; R Kwiatkowski; D Sharp Journal: Indoor Air Date: 2013-01-19 Impact factor: 5.770
Authors: Stephen S Lim; Theo Vos; Abraham D Flaxman; Goodarz Danaei; Kenji Shibuya; Heather Adair-Rohani; Markus Amann; H Ross Anderson; Kathryn G Andrews; Martin Aryee; Charles Atkinson; Loraine J Bacchus; Adil N Bahalim; Kalpana Balakrishnan; John Balmes; Suzanne Barker-Collo; Amanda Baxter; Michelle L Bell; Jed D Blore; Fiona Blyth; Carissa Bonner; Guilherme Borges; Rupert Bourne; Michel Boussinesq; Michael Brauer; Peter Brooks; Nigel G Bruce; Bert Brunekreef; Claire Bryan-Hancock; Chiara Bucello; Rachelle Buchbinder; Fiona Bull; Richard T Burnett; Tim E Byers; Bianca Calabria; Jonathan Carapetis; Emily Carnahan; Zoe Chafe; Fiona Charlson; Honglei Chen; Jian Shen Chen; Andrew Tai-Ann Cheng; Jennifer Christine Child; Aaron Cohen; K Ellicott Colson; Benjamin C Cowie; Sarah Darby; Susan Darling; Adrian Davis; Louisa Degenhardt; Frank Dentener; Don C Des Jarlais; Karen Devries; Mukesh Dherani; Eric L Ding; E Ray Dorsey; Tim Driscoll; Karen Edmond; Suad Eltahir Ali; Rebecca E Engell; Patricia J Erwin; Saman Fahimi; Gail Falder; Farshad Farzadfar; Alize Ferrari; Mariel M Finucane; Seth Flaxman; Francis Gerry R Fowkes; Greg Freedman; Michael K Freeman; Emmanuela Gakidou; Santu Ghosh; Edward Giovannucci; Gerhard Gmel; Kathryn Graham; Rebecca Grainger; Bridget Grant; David Gunnell; Hialy R Gutierrez; Wayne Hall; Hans W Hoek; Anthony Hogan; H Dean Hosgood; Damian Hoy; Howard Hu; Bryan J Hubbell; Sally J Hutchings; Sydney E Ibeanusi; Gemma L Jacklyn; Rashmi Jasrasaria; Jost B Jonas; Haidong Kan; John A Kanis; Nicholas Kassebaum; Norito Kawakami; Young-Ho Khang; Shahab Khatibzadeh; Jon-Paul Khoo; Cindy Kok; Francine Laden; Ratilal Lalloo; Qing Lan; Tim Lathlean; Janet L Leasher; James Leigh; Yang Li; John Kent Lin; Steven E Lipshultz; Stephanie London; Rafael Lozano; Yuan Lu; Joelle Mak; Reza Malekzadeh; Leslie Mallinger; Wagner Marcenes; Lyn March; Robin Marks; Randall Martin; Paul McGale; John McGrath; Sumi Mehta; George A Mensah; Tony R Merriman; Renata Micha; Catherine Michaud; Vinod Mishra; Khayriyyah Mohd Hanafiah; Ali A Mokdad; Lidia Morawska; Dariush Mozaffarian; Tasha Murphy; Mohsen Naghavi; Bruce Neal; Paul K Nelson; Joan Miquel Nolla; Rosana Norman; Casey Olives; Saad B Omer; Jessica Orchard; Richard Osborne; Bart Ostro; Andrew Page; Kiran D Pandey; Charles D H Parry; Erin Passmore; Jayadeep Patra; Neil Pearce; Pamela M Pelizzari; Max Petzold; Michael R Phillips; Dan Pope; C Arden Pope; John Powles; Mayuree Rao; Homie Razavi; Eva A Rehfuess; Jürgen T Rehm; Beate Ritz; Frederick P Rivara; Thomas Roberts; Carolyn Robinson; Jose A Rodriguez-Portales; Isabelle Romieu; Robin Room; Lisa C Rosenfeld; Ananya Roy; Lesley Rushton; Joshua A Salomon; Uchechukwu Sampson; Lidia Sanchez-Riera; Ella Sanman; Amir Sapkota; Soraya Seedat; Peilin Shi; Kevin Shield; Rupak Shivakoti; Gitanjali M Singh; David A Sleet; Emma Smith; Kirk R Smith; Nicolas J C Stapelberg; Kyle Steenland; Heidi Stöckl; Lars Jacob Stovner; Kurt Straif; Lahn Straney; George D Thurston; Jimmy H Tran; Rita Van Dingenen; Aaron van Donkelaar; J Lennert Veerman; Lakshmi Vijayakumar; Robert Weintraub; Myrna M Weissman; Richard A White; Harvey Whiteford; Steven T Wiersma; James D Wilkinson; Hywel C Williams; Warwick Williams; Nicholas Wilson; Anthony D Woolf; Paul Yip; Jan M Zielinski; Alan D Lopez; Christopher J L Murray; Majid Ezzati; Mohammad A AlMazroa; Ziad A Memish Journal: Lancet Date: 2012-12-15 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Christina H Fuller; Allison P Patton; Kevin Lane; M Barton Laws; Aaron Marden; Edna Carrasco; John Spengler; Mkaya Mwamburi; Wig Zamore; John L Durant; Doug Brugge Journal: Rev Environ Health Date: 2013 Impact factor: 3.458
Authors: Elvira Vaclavik Bräuner; Lykke Forchhammer; Peter Møller; Lars Barregard; Lars Gunnarsen; Alireza Afshari; Peter Wåhlin; Marianne Glasius; Lars Ove Dragsted; Samar Basu; Ole Raaschou-Nielsen; Steffen Loft Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 2007-10-11 Impact factor: 21.405
Authors: Ralph J Delfino; Norbert Staimer; Thomas Tjoa; Daniel L Gillen; Andrea Polidori; Mohammad Arhami; Micheal T Kleinman; Nosratola D Vaziri; John Longhurst; Constantinos Sioutas Journal: Environ Health Perspect Date: 2009-04-29 Impact factor: 9.031
Authors: Melissa M Maestas; Robert D Brook; Rosemary A Ziemba; Fengyao Li; Ryan C Crane; Zachary M Klaver; Robert L Bard; Catherine A Spino; Sara D Adar; Masako Morishita Journal: J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol Date: 2018-11-12 Impact factor: 5.563
Authors: Christine James; David I Bernstein; Jennie Cox; Patrick Ryan; Christopher Wolfe; Roman Jandarov; Nicholas Newman; Reshmi Indugula; Tiina Reponen Journal: Indoor Air Date: 2019-12-08 Impact factor: 5.770
Authors: Jonathan D Newman; Deepak L Bhatt; Sanjay Rajagopalan; John R Balmes; Michael Brauer; Patrick N Breysse; Alison G M Brown; Mercedes R Carnethon; Wayne E Cascio; Gwen W Collman; Lawrence J Fine; Nadia N Hansel; Adrian Hernandez; Judith S Hochman; Michael Jerrett; Bonnie R Joubert; Joel D Kaufman; Ali O Malik; George A Mensah; David E Newby; Jennifer L Peel; Jeffrey Siegel; David Siscovick; Betsy L Thompson; Junfeng Zhang; Robert D Brook Journal: J Am Coll Cardiol Date: 2020-12-15 Impact factor: 24.094
Authors: Neelakshi Hudda; Misha Eliasziw; Scott O Hersey; Ellin Reisner; Robert D Brook; Wig Zamore; John L Durant; Doug Brugge Journal: Hypertension Date: 2021-01-25 Impact factor: 10.190
Authors: Araliya M Senerat; Sheila M Manemann; Nicholas S Clements; Robert D Brook; Leslie C Hassett; Véronique L Roger Journal: J Clin Transl Sci Date: 2020-09-04
Authors: Doug Brugge; Shir Lerman Ginzburg; Neelakshi Hudda; Linda Sprague Martinez; Leigh Meunier; Scott P Hersey; Ira Hochman; Douglas I Walker; Ben Echevarria; Mohan Thanikachalam; John L Durant; Wig Zamore; Misha Eliasziw Journal: Contemp Clin Trials Date: 2021-07-28 Impact factor: 2.261