Nida Naushad1, Laura B Dunn2, Ricardo F Muñoz3, Yan Leykin4. 1. University of California, San Francisco, United States. 2. Stanford University, United States. 3. University of California, San Francisco, United States; Institute for International Internet Interventions for Health, United States; Palo Alto University, United States. 4. University of California, San Francisco, United States; Palo Alto University, United States. Electronic address: yleykin@paloaltou.edu.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Individuals suffering from mental as well as physical conditions often face stigma, which can adversely affect functioning, treatment seeking, and emotional health. We compared levels of stigma experienced by individuals with depression and/or chronic pain, to contrast the perception of stigma experienced by the sufferers with that of individuals who have never experienced these conditions, and to determine whether depression is related to greater experience of stigma for chronic pain. METHODS: Four groups of participants (N=236) took part in the study: depression only, chronic pain only, comorbid depression and chronic pain, and healthy controls. Participants underwent a clinical interview and completed a stigma measure that assessed general self-stigma, public stigma, treatment stigma, secrecy, and stigmatizing experiences. RESULTS: Healthy controls largely underestimated the stigma experienced by individuals with depression, but were not inaccurate in estimating stigma experienced by individuals with chronic pain. Further, individuals with chronic pain alone generally perceived less stigma for their condition than did those with depression alone. However, comorbid individuals perceived worse stigma of chronic pain compared to individuals with chronic pain alone, suggesting that depression may affect the stigma felt by sufferers of conditions other than depression. LIMITATIONS: Social desirability may have influenced stigma scores. Comparing several groups required adapting a standardized instrument. CONCLUSIONS: Results suggest that depression may play a role in the social experience of having a health condition, as well as indicate that the general public continues to fail to appreciate the negative social pressures experienced by individuals with mental health conditions.
BACKGROUND: Individuals suffering from mental as well as physical conditions often face stigma, which can adversely affect functioning, treatment seeking, and emotional health. We compared levels of stigma experienced by individuals with depression and/or chronic pain, to contrast the perception of stigma experienced by the sufferers with that of individuals who have never experienced these conditions, and to determine whether depression is related to greater experience of stigma for chronic pain. METHODS: Four groups of participants (N=236) took part in the study: depression only, chronic pain only, comorbid depression and chronic pain, and healthy controls. Participants underwent a clinical interview and completed a stigma measure that assessed general self-stigma, public stigma, treatment stigma, secrecy, and stigmatizing experiences. RESULTS: Healthy controls largely underestimated the stigma experienced by individuals with depression, but were not inaccurate in estimating stigma experienced by individuals with chronic pain. Further, individuals with chronic pain alone generally perceived less stigma for their condition than did those with depression alone. However, comorbid individuals perceived worse stigma of chronic pain compared to individuals with chronic pain alone, suggesting that depression may affect the stigma felt by sufferers of conditions other than depression. LIMITATIONS: Social desirability may have influenced stigma scores. Comparing several groups required adapting a standardized instrument. CONCLUSIONS: Results suggest that depression may play a role in the social experience of having a health condition, as well as indicate that the general public continues to fail to appreciate the negative social pressures experienced by individuals with mental health conditions.
Authors: Heidi A Hamann; Jamie S Ostroff; Emily G Marks; David E Gerber; Joan H Schiller; Simon J Craddock Lee Journal: Psychooncology Date: 2013-10-03 Impact factor: 3.894
Authors: Ana Miriam Velly; John O Look; Charles Carlson; Patricia A Lenton; Wenjun Kang; Christina A Holcroft; James R Fricton Journal: Pain Date: 2011-08-25 Impact factor: 6.961
Authors: Victoria N Mutiso; Christine W Musyimi; Tahilia J Rebello; Isaiah Gitonga; Albert Tele; Kathleen M Pike; David M Ndetei Journal: Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol Date: 2018-07-30 Impact factor: 4.328
Authors: Frank D Buono; Seddon R Savage; Brianna Cerrito; Julianne O'Connell; Amir Garakani; Sigurd Ackerman; Christopher J Cutter Journal: J Pain Res Date: 2020-06-24 Impact factor: 3.133
Authors: Paula Gardiner; Man Luo; Salvatore D'Amico; Katherine Gergen-Barnett; Laura F White; Robert Saper; Suzanne Mitchell; Jane M Liebschutz Journal: PLoS One Date: 2019-12-18 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Arlete Modelli; Viviane P Candal Setti; Martinus Theodorus van de Bilt; Wagner Farid Gattaz; Alexandre Andrade Loch; Wulf Rössler Journal: Front Psychiatry Date: 2021-02-10 Impact factor: 4.157