| Literature DB >> 29320415 |
Alfredo Mazza1,2, Prisco Piscitelli3,4, Andrea Falco5,6, Maria Lucia Santoro7, Manuela Colangelo8, Giovanni Imbriani9, Adele Idolo10, Antonella De Donno11, Leopoldo Iannuzzi12, Annamaria Colao13.
Abstract
The area of Naples and Campania region, in Italy, are experiencing the dramatic consequences of diffuse and illegal waste dumping, resulting in possible threats to human health. This area has been referred to as the "Land of Fires" because of the common practice of waste burning. International interest in the Campania "waste emergency" has triggered several epidemiological studies. This article is aimed at highlighting the body of evidence available concerning human and environmental contamination in the Campania region, and considers the possible lack of comparable knowledge about the situation in other areas suffering from high environmental pollution. We analyzed the results of studies addressing environmental pollution and population health in the Campania region, starting from the most recent reviews on this topic, and compared their findings with those concerning other regions. We reviewed 18 studies of epidemiological/cancer surveillance and human or animal biomonitoring. These studies show worrying results, which could be considered comparable to those available for other Italian areas impacted by heavy industrial activities. The release of environmental contaminants associated with waste incineration and waste disposal in landfills poses a risk to public health, as shown by a number of studies (although not conclusively). The current knowledge available for the Campania region is better than that available for other areas which are facing similar problems due to anthropic activities, including illegal waste trafficking. Thus, Naples and Campania could represent a valuable setting to develop general models for studies of environmental and human contamination.Entities:
Keywords: cancer incidence; environment and health; environmental monitoring; illegal dumping
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 29320415 PMCID: PMC5800204 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph15010105
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Figure 1Map of illegal waste dumping sites in the region of Campania, Italy. Data from [3].
Summary table of studies on human or animal biomonitoring.
| Authors | Donors | Biomarkers Studied | Reported Findings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rivezzi et al. [ | 94 young breastfeeding women (aged 19–32) living in the Naples and Caserta provinces according to the WHO standardized protocol | PCDDs, PCDFs and dl-PCBs in individual milk samples | All milk samples were contaminated by dioxins and dl-PCBs with an average level of dioxins of 16.6 pg TEQ/g of fat. Dioxins concentration in breast milk significantly increased with age |
| Ulaszewska et al. [ | 59 healthy mothers (21 mothers from Giugliano, 22 from Piacenza and 16 from Milan) | PCDDs, PCDFs and dl-PCBs in individual milk samples | Total levels of PCDDs, PCDFs and dl-PCBs in milk samples collected in Giugliano were significantly lower than those observed in controls of Milan and Piacenza |
| Giovannini et al. [ | 94 young breastfeeding women (aged 19–32) living in the Naples and Caserta provinces according to the WHO standardized protocol | PCDDs, PCDFs and dl-PCBs in individual milk samples | Overlapping between dioxin levels detected in these 94 breastfeeding women and those of buffalo milk was observed |
| Esposito et al. [ | 25 subjects residing in the “Triangle of Death” area and 33 control subjects living in a different area of the Naples province | Serum PCDDs, PCDFs and dl-PCBs | No difference in serum levels of these pollutants between 25 subjects residing in the “Triangle of Death” area and 33 control subjects was observed |
| De Felip et al. [ | For serum and blood samples: 859 subjects living in Naples and Caserta; for milk samples: 52 women from same areas | PCDDs, PCDFs, dl-PCBs, As, Hg, Cd and Pb in blood, serum and in breast milk | Biomarkers’ concentrations in serum and blood samples were found to be compatible with their current values in European countries. Dioxin concentrations in human milk samples were found to be strongly age-dependent and positively associated with the risk area where mothers were living |
| Basile et al. [ | Mosses collected in the town of Acerra | Ultrastructural abnormalities | Ultrastructural abnormalities, including cytoplasm vesicles and concentric multilamellar/multivesicular bodies, were observed |
| Maselli et al. [ | 200 frogs collected from polluted areas and uncontaminated sites of the Campania Region | DNA damage | Frogs collected from polluted areas exhibited higher levels of DNA damage |
| Genualdo et al. [ | Two groups of 25 river buffalo cows, respectively from the Caserta and Salerno provinces of Campania | PCDDs, PCDFs and dl-PCBs; chromosome fragility | Higher mean values of PCDDs, PCDFs and dl-PCBs were reported along with a higher chromosome fragility in the Caserta samples compared those ones collected in Salerno area |
| Triassi et al. (review) [ | Milk samples of sheep and cows bred in farms located in the north-western area of Campania | PCDDs | About two thirds of the samples assessed had dioxin level >3.0 pg TEQ/g fat, that is the safety threshold identified by the European Commission before 2011 |
WHO: World Health Organization; PCDDs: polychloro-dibenzo-dioxins; PCDFs: polychloro-dibenzo-furans; dl-PCBs: dioxin-like polychlorobiphenyls; TEQ: Toxic Equivalent.
Summary table of studies on health effects.
| Authors | Study Subjects (Years of Observation) | Health Outcames | Reported Findings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Senior and Mazza [ | 250,000 residents in “Triangle of Death” area (2002) | Cancer mortality | All cancers SDR * = 321.7 (M) vs. regional rate 305.6 Liver SDR = 35.9 (M) vs. regional rate 15.0 Larynx SDR = 12.8 (M) vs. regional rate 8.7 Bladder SDR = 29.3 (M) vs. regional rate 21.7 Colorectal SDR = 29 (F) vs. regional rate 26.4 Leukemia and lymphoma SDR = 28.2 vs. regional rate 17.9 (M); 18.7 vs. regional rate 16.1 (F) |
| Altavista et al. [ | 150,000 residents in 3 municipalities of Naples (Giugliano, Qualiano and Villaricca) (1986–2000) | Cancer mortality and congenital malformations | All cancers SMR = 107.23 (M) − 111.08 (F) Liver SMR = 181.13 (F) Lung SMR = 121.85 (M) − 176.94 (F) Larynx SMR = 211.85 (M) Bladder SMR = 130.12 (M) Stomach SMR = 56.1 (M) |
| Triassi et al. (review) [ | 250,000 residents in “Triangle of Death” area (2002) | Cancer mortality | In the “Triangle of Death” area, an increased in standardized death rate (vs. regional expected rate) for all cancers (SDR = 321.7 vs. 305.6 per 100,000 males) was reported, along with increases in standardized mortality rates for specific tumors such as liver, larynx, bladder, colorectal cancer and leukemia/lymphoma, especially in male population |
| Comba et al. [ | About 4 million residents in 196 municipalities of Caserta and Naples (1994–2001) | Cancer mortality and congenital malformations | A statistically significant excess of cancer mortality was found in the provinces of Naples (+8.7% in men and +9.2% in women) and Caserta (+2.3% but only in males). In particular, significant excesses of liver, lung, bladder, stomach, non-Hodgkin lymphoma and kidney cancer were reported. Malformations: total, cardiovascular and urogenital |
| Martuzzi et al. [ | About 4 million residents in 196 municipalities of Caserta and Naples (1994–2001) | Cancer mortality and congenital malformations | An excess of cancer mortality was reported to be associated with measures of environmental contamination. Statistically significant excess relative risks in high-index (exposed) compared with low-index (unexposed) municipalities were found for all-cause mortality (both sexes), for all cancers (both sexes), and stomach and lung cancer (in men) |
| Fazzo et al. [ | About 4 million residents in 196 municipalities of Caserta and Naples (1994–2001) | Cancer incidence and congenital malformations | Clusters of significant increases of cancer incidence were detected for liver, lung, bladder, stomach and kidney cancer. Malformations: total, cardiovascular, urogenital and limb |
| Fazzo et al. [ | About 5 million residents in 35 municipalities of Naples Province (1997–2005) | Cancer incidence and congenital malformations | Clusters of increased cancer incidence during the years 1997–2005 were detected in the total population for liver and lung cancer, leukemia and soft tissue sarcomas |
| Comba et al. [ | Residents in 55 municipalities of the “Land of Fires” (2007–2010) | Cancer incidence and mortality causes | Excesses of incidence, hospitalization and mortality rates were reported in the Province of Naples for stomach, liver, lung, bladder, pancreatic, laryngeal, kidney, breast cancer, and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma. |
| Pirastu et al. [ | Residents in 55 municipalities of the “Land of Fires” (2007–2010) | Cancer incidence and mortality causes | In the Caserta province, excesses of mortality and hospitalization rates were reported for stomach, liver, lung, bladder, laryngeal cancer and leukemia. |
| Barba et al. (review) [ | Residents in polluted areas of the Campania region | Cancer mortality and congenital malformations | Significant increase in cancer mortality and malformation occurrence in specific areas of the Campania region, where improper waste management and illegal waste trafficking have been repeatedly documented, was reported |
M = male; F = female. SDR: standardized death rate; * Per 100,000 population.