| Literature DB >> 29244764 |
Kelly Ugarelli1, Seemanti Chakrabarti2, Peeter Laas3, Ulrich Stingl4.
Abstract
Seagrass meadows are ecologically and economically important components of many coastal areas worldwide. Ecosystem services provided by seagrasses include reducing the number of microbial pathogens in the water, providing food, shelter and nurseries for many species, and decreasing the impact of waves on the shorelines. A global assessment reported that 29% of the known areal extent of seagrasses has disappeared since seagrass areas were initially recorded in 1879. Several factors such as direct and indirect human activity contribute to the demise of seagrasses. One of the main reasons for seagrass die-offs all over the world is increased sulfide concentrations in the sediment that result from the activity of sulfate-reducing prokaryotes, which perform the last step of the anaerobic food chain in marine sediments and reduce sulfate to H₂S. Recent seagrass die-offs, e.g., in the Florida and Biscayne Bays, were caused by an increase in pore-water sulfide concentrations in the sediment, which were the combined result of unfavorable environmental conditions and the activities of various groups of heterotrophic bacteria in the sulfate-rich water-column and sediment that are stimulated through increased nutrient concentrations. Under normal circumstances, seagrasses are able to withstand low levels of sulfide, probably partly due to microbial symbionts, which detoxify sulfide by oxidizing it to sulfur or sulfate. Novel studies are beginning to give greater insights into the interactions of microbes and seagrasses, not only in the sulfur cycle. Here, we review the literature on the basic ecology and biology of seagrasses and focus on studies describing their microbiome.Entities:
Keywords: holobiont; microbiome; rhizosphere; seagrass; sulfide
Year: 2017 PMID: 29244764 PMCID: PMC5748590 DOI: 10.3390/microorganisms5040081
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Microorganisms ISSN: 2076-2607
List of seagrass species affected by die-off events in different regions of the world.
| Region | Species Affected | References |
|---|---|---|
| Africa | Nordlund et al., 2010 [ | |
| Asia | Unsworth et al., 2016 [ | |
| Australia | Walker and McComb 1992 [ | |
| North America | Zieman et al., 1999 [ | |
| South America | Short and Green 2003 [ | |
| Europe | Short and Green 2003 [ |
Detailed overview on studies on the microbiome of seagrasses.
| Structure, Function, or both (S, F, B) | Reference | Study Area | Methodology | Seagrass Species | Target | Compartment of Microbiome | Main Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B | Agawin et al., 2016 [ | Alcudia Bay, Mallorca, Spain | Sanger sequencing of | Phyllosphere | Identified significant nitrogen fixation activity in phyllosphere. | ||
| B | Bagwell et al., 2002 [ | Eastern Bahamas | DGGE to resolve PCR-amplified | Rhizosphere | Identified diverse diazotroph assemblages in the rhizosphere and found similarities to communities associated with an intertidal grass ( | ||
| B | Kurilenko et al., 2010 [ | Troitza Bay, Gulf of Peter the Great, Pacific Ocean | Cultivation | Phyllosphere | Described a new bacterial species. | ||
| B | Küsel et al., 1999 [ | Santa Rosa Sound, Florida, USA | Phospholipid fatty acid analysis, cultivation, oligonucleotide probes | Archaea, Bacteria | Endosphere, rhizosphere | Acetogenic bacteria were dominant on rhizoplane, and sulfate reducers in the endosphere. | |
| B | Marhaeni et al., 2010 [ | Central Java, Indonesia | Cultivation and antifouling test via agar diffusion method | Bacteria | Endosphere, phyllosphere, rhizosphere | Identified epiphytic and endophytic bacteria that potentially act as natural antifoulants. | |
| B | Newell et al., 1981 [ | Chesapeake Bay, USA | Cultivation | Fungi and Bacteria | Phyllosphere | Fungal biomass did not account for more than 0.5% of leaf mass; estimated bacterial productivity 1.4× standing stock per day. | |
| B | Nielsen et al., 2001 [ | Bay of Arcachon, France | Sulfate and acetylene reduction rate measurements, scanning electron microscopy, cultivation | Sulfate reducing and | Rhizosphere | Observed patchy distribution of bacteria on the roots and rhizomes. Addition of sucrose stimulated | |
| F | Blaabjerg and Finster, 1998 [ | Limfjorden, Denmark | Sulfate reduction rates using radiolabeled sulfate | Sulfate reducers | Endosphere, rhizosphere | Demonstrated that root surface-associated sulfate reducers have high tolerance towards oxygen. | |
| F | Blaabjerg et al., 1998 [ | Limfjorden, Denmark | Sulfate reduction rates using radiolabeled sulfate | Sulfate reducers | Rhizosphere | Sulfate reduction rates were 3 times higher in August than in April, and were significantly positively correlated to light intensity. | |
| F | Boon et al., 1986 [ | Moreton Bay, Australia | 15N isotope technique | Ammonium turnover, glycine utilization | Rhizosphere | Greater ammonification rates in rhizosphere than in adjacent bare sediments. | |
| F | Boschker et al., 2000 [ | Northwest Europe | Stable carbon-isotope ratios of bacteria, sediment organic matter and plants | Biogeochemistry of rhizosphere | Rhizosphere | Seagrass material was of limited importance as a bacterial carbon source. | |
| F | Caffrey and Kemp 1990 [ | Choptank River, USA | Rates of nitrification, denitrification and ammonification | Nitrogen cycling | Rhizosphere | Microbial communities are responsible for key nitrogen transformations in the rhizospheres of | |
| F | Capone and Taylor 1980 [ | Biscayne Bay, USA, and Bimini Harbor, Bahamas | Nitrogen fixation rates, acetylene reduction assay | Rhizosphere | Rates of | ||
| F | Frederiksen and Glud 2006 [ | Svenstrup, Denmark | Planar O2 measurements | Oxygen dynamics | Rhizosphere | Rhizospheres of seagrass are probably of minor importance for total benthic O2 uptake rates. | |
| F | Holmer et al., 2001 [ | Phuket Island, Thailand | Sulfate reduction rates; stable carbon isotope composition of seagrasses, sediments and bacteria | Carbon cycling, sulfate reducers | Rhizosphere | Determined that bacteria used organic matter derived from seagrasses and showed that the contribution of sulfate reduction to nutrient availability was low. | |
| F | Holmer et al., 2004 [ | Mallorca and Cabrera Islands, Spain | Stable carbon-isotope ratios of bacterial phospholipid derived fatty acids and sulfate reduction rates with 1-step distillation | Carbon cycling | Rhizosphere | Seagrass detritus was a major bacterial carbon source, but its importance was decreased in areas with higher external nutrient loading. | |
| F | Isaksen and Finster, 1996 [ | Bay of Arcachon, France | Sulfate reduction rates using radiotracer method | Sulfate reducers | Rhizosphere | Rates of sulfate reduction were twice as high in rhizosphere as in equivalent layer of the unvegetated sediment. | |
| F | Jones et al., 2003 [ | Lower Laguna Madre, USA | Stable carbon isotope ratios in phospholipid fatty acids | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | Majority of sedimentary organic carbon originated from seagrass plants and provided important carbon source for bacteria. | |
| F | Kim et al., 2017 [ | Southern coast of Korea | Sulfate reduction rates and turnover of acid-volatile sulfur | Sulfur cycling | Rhizosphere | Sulfate reduction was more stimulated by the dissolved organic carbon exuded from the roots of | |
| F | Kirchman et al., 1984 [ | Great Harbor, USA | Thymidine incorporation (bacterial production) | Bacteria | Phyllosphere | Heterotrophic bacterial community of the phyllosphere is almost entirely supported by their seagrass host. | |
| F | Koepfler et al., 1993 [ | Laguna Madre and Baffin Bay, USA | Pore-water dissolved organic carbon concentrations | Carbon cycling | Rhizosphere | In vegetated sediments, pore-water dissolved organic carbon concentrations were 25% higher and bacterial production rates were 4-times higher compared to unvegetated bare sediments | |
| F | Lee and Dunton, 2000 [ | Corpus Christi Bay and Laguna Madre, USA | Photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) collected with spherical quantum sensor and sulfide determined according to Cline (1969) | Biogeochemistry of rhizosphere | Rhizosphere | Determined diurnal dynamics of sulfide concentrations in pore water because of photosynthetically produced oxygen being transported to below-ground seagrass tissues. | |
| F | López et al., 1995 [ | Mediterranean Sea, Spain | Ammonification rates; | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | Benthic bacterial activity is directly related to seagrass productivity. | |
| F | McGlathery et al., 1998 [ | Limfjord, Denmark | Perfusion technique (acetylene reduction) | Rhizosphere | Nitrogen fixation activity was about 3-times higher in vegetated than unvegetated sediments. | ||
| F | Moriarty et al., 1985 [ | Pelican Banks, Australia | Thymidine incorporation and phospholipid method for bacterial production; Sulfate reduction and methane production rates | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | Spatial variability overwhelmed seasonal variability in case of seagrass productivity and bacterial productivity; strictly anaerobic bacteria. | |
| F | Moriarty et al., 1986 [ | Northern Gulf of Mexico, USA | Stable isotope labeling experiments | Carbon cycling | Phyllosphere, rhizosphere | On average 11% of the fixed carbon was exuded into the sediments and 1% into the water column. It took 6 h for the fixed carbon to be translocated from leaves to roots. | |
| F | Oremland and Taylor 1977 [ | Caesar Creek, USA, and Bimini Harbor, Bahamas | Chemical analyses of gas bubbles | Biogeochemistry of rhizosphere | Rhizosphere | Observed O2 transport via rhizomes to sediments and diurnal fluctuation of this process due photosynthetic activity of the seagrasses. | |
| F | Patriquin and Knowles 1972 [ | Clam Cove, Dear Island, Canada | Cultivation and acetylene reduction assay | Rhizosphere | Estimate that | ||
| F | Penhale and Smith 1977 [ | Newport River estuary | Release of DOC using radiocarbon techniques | Carbon cycling | Phyllosphere, rhizosphere | Excretion rates in the dark were much lower than in the light. | |
| F | Sand-Jensen et al., 2005 [ | Roskilde Fjord, Denmark | O2 microelectrodes | Oxygen dynamics | Rhizosphere | Determined diurnal dynamics of oxygen concentrations in the rhizosphere. | |
| F | Smith et al., 1984a [ | Back and Bogue Sounds, USA | Total net ammonification by rhizoplane microflora, cultivation | Rhizoplane bacteria | Rhizosphere | Rates of ammonification were inversely related to the active growth season of these seagrasses. | |
| F | Smith et al., 1984b [ | Great Harbor at Woods Hole, USA | Polarographic two-chambered apparatus fitted with O2 electrodes | Oxygen dynamics | Rhizosphere | O2 transport to the root-rhizome system supported aerobic root respiration. | |
| F | Törnblom and Søndergaard, 1999 [ | Roskilde Fjord, Denmark | Leucine and thymidine incorporation (bacterial production) | Bacteria | Phyllosphere | Observed a strong correlation between bacterial production (leaf attached communities) and host’s primary production. Biomass production of microbiome was very high compared to the standing stock of bacteria. | |
| F | Welsh et al., 1996 [ | Bassin d’Arcachon, France | Acetylene reduction and cultivation | Rhizosphere | Acetylene reduction rates up to 4-fold greater in the light compared with those measured in the dark. Sulfate-reducing bacteria were the dominant component of the nitrogen-fixing microflora. | ||
| F | Wetzel and Penhale 1979 [ | Puget Sound and northern Gulf of Mexico, USA; Bimini Harbor, Bahamas | Stable isotope tracers | Transport and excretion of carbon by seagrasses and their epiphytes | Phyllosphere, rhizosphere | Large portion of the inorganic carbon taken up by the rooting tissue was transported through the leaves and released into the water. | |
| F | Williams et al., 2009 [ | Florida Bay, USA | Stable carbon isotope ratios in phospholipid fatty acids | Pelagic, epiphytic, and sediment surface bacteria | Phyllosphere | Bacterial communities consistently incorporated seagrass-derived organic matter (13–67% of bacterial-specific stable carbon isotopic signatures). | |
| S | Bengtsson et al., 2017 [ | Baltic Sea, Germany | Amplicon sequencing of 16S and 18S rRNA genes | Bacteria and Eukaryotes | Phyllosphere | Observed local variation of microbiomes and found correlation between prokaryotic microbiome and eukaryotic epibiont communities. | |
| S | Bourque et al., 2015 [ | Biscayne Bay, USA | T-RFLP | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | Evaluated two restoration methods and found that undisturbed reference seagrass sediments had more complex microbial communities than disturbed and restoration sites. | |
| S | Cifuentes et al., 2000 [ | Bassin d’Arcachon, France | Sanger sequencing of 16S rRNA genes, clone libraries | Bacteria and Archaea | Endosphere, rhizosphere | Report sulfate-reducing bacteria and | |
| S | Crump and Koch 2008 [ | Chesapeake Bay, USA | PCR-DGGE and Sanger sequencing of clone libraries | Bacteria | Phyllosphere, rhizosphere | Leaves were dominated by typical marine Alphaproteobacteria, while roots hosted a diverse microbial assemblage. | |
| S | Cúcio et al., 2016 [ | North-eastern Atlantic Ocean | Amplicon sequencing of 16S rRNA genes | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | Rhizobiomes were similar in one geographic region, but were significantly different from the sediment bacterial communities. | |
| S | Donnelly and Herbert 1999 [ | Bassin d’Arcachon, France | Cultivation; light and scanning electron microscopy | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | Sulfate reducing bacteria were identified as the key group of bacteria involved in | |
| S | Ettinger et al., 2017 [ | Bodega Bay, USA | Amplicon sequencing of 16S rRNA genes | Bacteria | Phyllosphere, rhizosphere | Taxa that differ significantly between sample types and sites are closely related to ones commonly associated with various aspects of sulfur and nitrogen metabolism. | |
| S | Fahimipour et al., 2017 [ | Multiple locations across the Northern Hemisphere | Amplicon sequencing of 16S rRNA genes | Bacteria | Phyllosphere, rhizosphere | Provides evidence for a core eelgrass root microbiome ( | |
| S | Glazebrook et al., 1996 [ | Pelican Banks, Australia | Fluorescent microscopy studies with labeled antibodies | Rhizosphere | Members of | ||
| S | Gnavi et al., 2014 [ | 21 isolates obtained by Panno et al., 2013 | Sanger sequencing of ITS and 28S rRNA genes | Fungi | Phyllosphere, rhizosphere | Identified several putative new species belonging to orders | |
| S | Green-García and Engel 2012 [ | Cedar Key, USA | Sanger sequencing of 16S rRNA genes, clone libraries | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | 41% of the clones were more closely related to each other than to sequences retrieved from the other habitats. | |
| S | Jankowska et al., 2015 [ | Southern Baltic Sea, Poland | Epifluorescence microscopy | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | Reported significantly higher bacterial cell numbers and bacteria biomass in rhizosphere compared to bare sediments. | |
| S | Jensen et al., 2007 [ | Roskilde Fjord, Denmark | T-RFLP and Sanger sequencing of clone libraries | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | Bacterial community associated with the roots of | |
| S | Jiang et al., 2015 [ | Xincun Bay, China | Cultivation and Sanger sequencing of 16S rRNA genes | Bacteria | Phyllosphere | Diversity of the bacterial communities in the sediment was higher than that associated with seagrass. | |
| S | Kurilenko et al., 2007 [ | Troitza Bay, Gulf of Peter the Great, Pacific Ocean | Cultivation based experiments | Bacteria | Phyllosphere | Demonstrated symbiotrophic relationships between seagrass and epiphytic bacteria (selective adhesion). | |
| S | Ling et al., 2015 [ | Xincun Bay, China | PCR-DGGE, quantitative PCR and Sanger sequencing of clone libraries | Fungi | Rhizosphere | Fungal community of rhizosphere changed significantly in response to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. | |
| S | Mejia et al., 2016 [ | Gulf of Aqaba, Israel | Amplicon sequencing of 16S rRNA genes | Bacteria | Phyllosphere, rhizosphere | Proposed assessing the ecological status of seagrasses using their microbiome. | |
| S | Nielsen et al., 1999 [ | Lørgstrar Broad, Denmark | Cultivation | Sulfate reducers | Rhizosphere | Isolated a novel species of the genus | |
| S | Novak 1984 [ | Gulf of Naples, Italy | Scanning electron microscopy | Epiphytic microorganisms | Phyllosphere | Observed dynamically changing system of interactions between the host plant, environmental and epiphytic community (also within). | |
| S | Panno et al., 2013 [ | Riva Trigoso Bay, Italy | Cultivation, microscopy, Sanger sequencing of ITS | Fungi | Phyllosphere, rhizosphere | Mycoflora associated to | |
| S | Sun et al., 2015 [ | Swan Lake, Rongcheng Bay, China | Amplicon sequencing of 16S rRNA genes | Bacteria | Rhizosphere | Metabolically versatile and oxygen-tolerant anaerobic bacterial taxa were enriched in vegetated sediments. | |
| S | Weidner et al., 1996 [ | Gulf of Aqaba, Israel | ARDRA (amplified rDNA restriction analysis) | Bacteria | Phyllosphere | Improvement of the ARDRA method. |
Figure 1The most important interconnected processes within the seagrass holobiont are related to processes in the carbon-, nitrogen- and sulfur cycles. Photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) determines the photosynthetic activity of the seagrass plant that determines how much carbon dioxide is fixed, how much dissolved organic carbon (DOC) is exuded from the leaves and root system, and how much oxygen is transported into the rhizosphere. Oxygen transportation into the rhizosphere alters the redox conditions in the rhizosphere, differentiating it from the surrounding sediments that are usually anoxic and sulfidic.
Figure 2The most abundant bacterial (white fonts) and fungal groups (orange fonts) identified within different compartments of the seagrass holobiont.