| Literature DB >> 29187418 |
Jack Luscombe1,2, Andrew D Murray2,3, Evan Jenkins1,2, Daryll Archibald4,5.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To identify physical activity (PA) accrued while playing golf and modifiers of PA accrued.Entities:
Keywords: golf; health; physical activity
Mesh:
Year: 2017 PMID: 29187418 PMCID: PMC5719314 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-018993
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Figure 1Results of systematic electronic search.
EE for a round of golf
| Study | Quality assessment | No. of holes | Club transportation | Course profile | EE | Net EE (kcal) | Gross EE | EE |
| Burkett and | Fair | 18 | Carrying clubs | Flat | 7.25±1.75 | – | – | – |
| Medium | 8.15±1.79 | |||||||
| Hilly | 8.25±1.83 | |||||||
| Crowell | Fair | 9 | Riding a golf cart | Not reported | 5.2 | – | – | – |
| Pulling clubs | 6.8 | |||||||
| Carrying clubs | 7.5 | |||||||
| Dear | Fair | 9 | Pulling clubs | Not reported | – | 310.3±83.9 | 511.6±115.5 | – |
| Dobrosielski | Fair | 9 | Pulling clubs | Mixed | – | 458 | – | – |
| Gabellieri | Fair | 18 | Carrying clubs | ‘Undulating’ | – | – | 1202.8±465.2 | |
| Lampley | Fair | 9 | Pulling clubs | Not reported | – | – | – | 4.2±0.6 (male) |
| 4.8±0.4 (female) | ||||||||
| Loy | Fair | 18 | Carrying clubs | Hilly | 6.2±0.6 | – | – | 4.8* |
| Zunzer | Good | 9 | Mixed | Mixed | – | – | 520±133 (male) | – |
| 273±66 (female) | ||||||||
| 926±292 (male) | ||||||||
| 18 | 556±180 (female) | |||||||
| Tangen | Fair | 18 | Mixed | Hilly | – | – | 2467 (male) | – |
| 1587 (female) |
Please refer to online supplementary appendix 6 for characteristics of the above studies.
*Calculated for a 68 kg man.
EE, energy expenditure.
MET of a round of golf
| Study | Quality assessment | No. of holes | Club transportation | METs (mean±SD) |
| Dear | Fair | 9 | Pulling clubs | 2.8±0.5 |
| Dobrosielski | Fair | 9 | Pulling clubs | 4.1±0.1 (cardiac disease) |
| Gabellieri | Fair | 18 | Carrying clubs | 8.6±3.1 |
| Unverdorben | Good | 18 | Pulling clubs | 3.1 (cardiac disease) |
| 18 | Pulling clubs | 3.1 (controls) | ||
| Zunzer | Good | 9 | Mixed | 2.9±0.8 (male) |
| 2.2±0.6 (female) | ||||
| 18 | Mixed | 2.8±0.7 (male) | ||
| 2.1±0.7 (female) | ||||
| Tangen | Fair | 18 | Mixed | 5.8 (male) |
| 4.9 (female) |
Please refer to online supplementary appendix 6 for characteristics of the above studies.
MET, metabolic equivalent of task.
Mean HR and percentage of maximum HR during a round of golf
| Study | Quality assessment | No. of holes | Club transportation | Course profile | Mean HR (bpm) | Mean %HRmax |
| Burkett and | Fair | 18 | Carrying clubs | Flat | 108.20±13.16 (GS) | – |
| 110.80±7.26 (AS) | ||||||
| Medium | 121.80±18.54 (GS) | |||||
| 117.80±13.54 (AS) | ||||||
| Hilly | 123.80±21.81 (GS) | |||||
| 116.20±14.97 (AS) | ||||||
| Crowell | Fair | 9 | Riding a golf cart | Not reported | 89.1±10.6 | – |
| Pulling clubs | 103±9.2 | |||||
| Carrying clubs | 113.1±8.8 | |||||
| Gabellieri | Fair | 18 | Carrying clubs | ‘Undulating’ | 103.5±13.2 | 55.2±7.4 |
| Loy | Fair | 18 | Carrying clubs | Hilly | 124.7±8.6 | |
| Stauch | Fair | 18 | Riding a golf cart | Hilly | 111.0±14.0 | – |
| Pulling clubs | 107.2±11.0 | |||||
| Carrying clubs | 118.4±17.0 | |||||
| Unverdorben | Good | 18 | Pulling clubs | Hilly | 105.4±10.6 (patients with cardiac disease) | – |
| 100.5±7.3 (controls) | ||||||
| Zunzer | Good | 9 | Mixed | Mixed | 101±12 (male) | 59.2±3.1 (male) |
| 99±13 (female) | 59.2±8.9 (female) | |||||
| 18 | 105±14 (male) | 60.9±8.6 (male) | ||||
| 103±12 (female) | 61.6±7.7 (female) | |||||
| Tangen | Fair | 18 | Mixed | Hilly | 104.1±14.5 (male) | – |
| 110.8±16.9 (female) |
Please refer to online supplementary appendix 6 for characteristics of the above studies.
AS, average skill (score 80–95); GS, good skill (score <80); HR, heart rate.
Oxygen uptake during a round of golf
| Study | Quality assessment | No. of holes | Club transportation | Oxygen uptake (l min–1) (mean±SD) | Oxygen uptake (ml kg–1 min–1) (mean±SD) | %VO2max |
| Crowell | Fair | 9 | Riding a golf cart | 1.05±0.11 | 8.5 | – |
| 9 | Pulling clubs | 1.37±0.03 | 9.1 | |||
| 9 | Carrying clubs | 1.50±0.11 | 9.7 | |||
| Dear | Fair | 9 | Pulling clubs | – | 9.9±1.7 | – |
| Loy | Fair | 18 | Carrying clubs | 1.23±0.11 | – | |
| Unverdorben | Good | 18 | Pulling clubs | – | – | 76.0±13.1 (patients with cardiac disease) |
| 18 | 55.3±9.1 (controls) |
Please refer to online supplementary appendix 6 for characteristics of the above studies.
Distance covered in a round of golf
| Study | Quality assessment | No. of holes | Club transportation | Sex | Distance (km, mean±SD) |
| Crowell | Fair | 18 | Riding a golf cart | Male | 3.18±0.56* |
| Pull cart | 7.37±0.71* | ||||
| Carrying clubs | 6.47±0.84* | ||||
| Dear | Fair | 9 | Pull cart | Male | 4.4±3.6 |
| Gabellieri | Fair | 18 | Carrying clubs | Male | 8.7±0.6* |
| Zunzer | Good | 18 | Mixed | Male | 10.54±0.94 |
| Mixed | Female | 9.89±0.81 | |||
| 9 | Mixed | Male | 5.32±0.48 | ||
| Mixed | Female | 5.25±0.76 | |||
| Tangen | Fair | 18 | Mixed | Male | 11.25±0.83 |
| Mixed | Female | 10.00±0.56 |
Please refer to online supplementary appendix 6 for characteristics of the above studies.
*Converted to kilometres.