Daniel Y Wang1, Fei Ye2, Shilin Zhao2, Douglas B Johnson1. 1. Department of Medicine, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN, USA. 2. Department of Biostatistics, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN, USA.
Abstract
Background: With the rising use of immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICI) across varying tumors types, immune-related colitis is an increasingly encountered, serious adverse event requiring appropriate management. The incidence across ICI treatment regimens and tumor types is unclear. Objective: To characterize the incidence of immune-related colitis among various ICI regimens and tumor types. Methods: Thirty-four original studies of prospective ICI trials were identified based on a PubMed search completed on November 1st, 2016. Seventeen studies compared incidences across tumor types. The incidences of all-grade, grade 3-4 (severe) colitis, and grade 3-4 (severe) diarrhea were collected. Results: Thirty-four studies containing 8863 patients were included in the meta-analysis. The overall incidence during ipilimumab monotherapy was 9.1% for all-grade colitis, 6.8% for severe colitis, and 7.9% for severe diarrhea. The incidence was lowest during PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitor monotherapy with 1.3% for all-grade colitis, 0.9% for severe colitis and 1.2% for severe diarrhea, while combination ipilimumab and nivolumab resulted in the highest incidences of all-grade colitis (13.6%), severe colitis (9.4%) and severe diarrhea (9.2%) among ICIs. Among melanoma, NSCLC, RCC patients, incidences of colitis and diarrhea with PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitor monotherapy did not significantly differ. Severe colitis incidence was similar with ipilimumab monotherapy at 3 mg/kg and 10 mg/kg (7.1% vs 5.1%, respectively), but significantly higher for severe diarrhea with 10mg/kg (11.5% vs 5.2%). Conclusions: The incidence of immune-related colitis and severe diarrhea was higher with ipilimumab-containing regimens compared with PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitors. There was no significant difference in immune-related colitis between different tumor types with PD-1/L1 inhibitors.
Background: With the rising use of immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICI) across varying tumors types, immune-related colitis is an increasingly encountered, serious adverse event requiring appropriate management. The incidence across ICI treatment regimens and tumor types is unclear. Objective: To characterize the incidence of immune-related colitis among various ICI regimens and tumor types. Methods: Thirty-four original studies of prospective ICI trials were identified based on a PubMed search completed on November 1st, 2016. Seventeen studies compared incidences across tumor types. The incidences of all-grade, grade 3-4 (severe) colitis, and grade 3-4 (severe) diarrhea were collected. Results: Thirty-four studies containing 8863 patients were included in the meta-analysis. The overall incidence during ipilimumab monotherapy was 9.1% for all-grade colitis, 6.8% for severe colitis, and 7.9% for severe diarrhea. The incidence was lowest during PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitor monotherapy with 1.3% for all-grade colitis, 0.9% for severe colitis and 1.2% for severe diarrhea, while combination ipilimumab and nivolumab resulted in the highest incidences of all-grade colitis (13.6%), severe colitis (9.4%) and severe diarrhea (9.2%) among ICIs. Among melanoma, NSCLC, RCCpatients, incidences of colitis and diarrhea with PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitor monotherapy did not significantly differ. Severe colitis incidence was similar with ipilimumab monotherapy at 3 mg/kg and 10 mg/kg (7.1% vs 5.1%, respectively), but significantly higher for severe diarrhea with 10mg/kg (11.5% vs 5.2%). Conclusions: The incidence of immune-related colitis and severe diarrhea was higher with ipilimumab-containing regimens compared with PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitors. There was no significant difference in immune-related colitis between different tumor types with PD-1/L1 inhibitors.
Authors: Roy S Herbst; Jean-Charles Soria; Marcin Kowanetz; Gregg D Fine; Omid Hamid; Michael S Gordon; Jeffery A Sosman; David F McDermott; John D Powderly; Scott N Gettinger; Holbrook E K Kohrt; Leora Horn; Donald P Lawrence; Sandra Rost; Maya Leabman; Yuanyuan Xiao; Ahmad Mokatrin; Hartmut Koeppen; Priti S Hegde; Ira Mellman; Daniel S Chen; F Stephen Hodi Journal: Nature Date: 2014-11-27 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: David F McDermott; Charles G Drake; Mario Sznol; Toni K Choueiri; John D Powderly; David C Smith; Julie R Brahmer; Richard D Carvajal; Hans J Hammers; Igor Puzanov; F Stephen Hodi; Harriet M Kluger; Suzanne L Topalian; Drew M Pardoll; Jon M Wigginton; Georgia D Kollia; Ashok Gupta; Dan McDonald; Vindira Sankar; Jeffrey A Sosman; Michael B Atkins Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2015-03-30 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Julie R Brahmer; Charles G Drake; Ira Wollner; John D Powderly; Joel Picus; William H Sharfman; Elizabeth Stankevich; Alice Pons; Theresa M Salay; Tracee L McMiller; Marta M Gilson; Changyu Wang; Mark Selby; Janis M Taube; Robert Anders; Lieping Chen; Alan J Korman; Drew M Pardoll; Israel Lowy; Suzanne L Topalian Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2010-06-01 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Jedd D Wolchok; Bart Neyns; Gerald Linette; Sylvie Negrier; Jose Lutzky; Luc Thomas; William Waterfield; Dirk Schadendorf; Michael Smylie; Troy Guthrie; Jean-Jacques Grob; Jason Chesney; Kevin Chin; Kun Chen; Axel Hoos; Steven J O'Day; Celeste Lebbé Journal: Lancet Oncol Date: 2009-12-08 Impact factor: 41.316
Authors: Jonathan E Rosenberg; Jean Hoffman-Censits; Tom Powles; Michiel S van der Heijden; Arjun V Balar; Andrea Necchi; Nancy Dawson; Peter H O'Donnell; Ani Balmanoukian; Yohann Loriot; Sandy Srinivas; Margitta M Retz; Petros Grivas; Richard W Joseph; Matthew D Galsky; Mark T Fleming; Daniel P Petrylak; Jose Luis Perez-Gracia; Howard A Burris; Daniel Castellano; Christina Canil; Joaquim Bellmunt; Dean Bajorin; Dorothee Nickles; Richard Bourgon; Garrett M Frampton; Na Cui; Sanjeev Mariathasan; Oyewale Abidoye; Gregg D Fine; Robert Dreicer Journal: Lancet Date: 2016-03-04 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Hossein Borghaei; Luis Paz-Ares; Leora Horn; David R Spigel; Martin Steins; Neal E Ready; Laura Q Chow; Everett E Vokes; Enriqueta Felip; Esther Holgado; Fabrice Barlesi; Martin Kohlhäufl; Oscar Arrieta; Marco Angelo Burgio; Jérôme Fayette; Hervé Lena; Elena Poddubskaya; David E Gerber; Scott N Gettinger; Charles M Rudin; Naiyer Rizvi; Lucio Crinò; George R Blumenschein; Scott J Antonia; Cécile Dorange; Christopher T Harbison; Friedrich Graf Finckenstein; Julie R Brahmer Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2015-09-27 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Jedd D Wolchok; Harriet Kluger; Margaret K Callahan; Michael A Postow; Naiyer A Rizvi; Alexander M Lesokhin; Neil H Segal; Charlotte E Ariyan; Ruth-Ann Gordon; Kathleen Reed; Matthew M Burke; Anne Caldwell; Stephanie A Kronenberg; Blessing U Agunwamba; Xiaoling Zhang; Israel Lowy; Hector David Inzunza; William Feely; Christine E Horak; Quan Hong; Alan J Korman; Jon M Wigginton; Ashok Gupta; Mario Sznol Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2013-06-02 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Shilpa Grover; Michael Dougan; Kevin Tyan; Anita Giobbie-Hurder; Steven M Blum; Jeffrey Ishizuka; Taha Qazi; Rawad Elias; Kruti B Vora; Alex B Ruan; William Martin-Doyle; Michael Manos; Lauren Eastman; Meredith Davis; Maria Gargano; Rizwan Haq; Elizabeth I Buchbinder; Ryan J Sullivan; Patrick A Ott; F Stephen Hodi; Osama E Rahma Journal: Cancer Date: 2020-06-22 Impact factor: 6.860
Authors: Daniel Y Wang; Meghan J Mooradian; DaeWon Kim; Neil J Shah; Sarah E Fenton; Robert M Conry; Rutika Mehta; Ann W Silk; Alice Zhou; Margaret L Compton; Rami N Al-Rohil; Sunyoung Lee; Amber L Voorhees; Lisa Ha; Svetlana McKee; Jacqueline T Norrell; Janice Mehnert; Igor Puzanov; Jeffrey A Sosman; Sunandana Chandra; Geoffrey T Gibney; Suthee Rapisuwon; Zeynep Eroglu; Ryan Sullivan; Douglas B Johnson Journal: Oncoimmunology Date: 2018-10-31 Impact factor: 8.110
Authors: Daniel Y Wang; Joe-Elie Salem; Justine V Cohen; Sunandana Chandra; Christian Menzer; Fei Ye; Shilin Zhao; Satya Das; Kathryn E Beckermann; Lisa Ha; W Kimryn Rathmell; Kristin K Ancell; Justin M Balko; Caitlin Bowman; Elizabeth J Davis; David D Chism; Leora Horn; Georgina V Long; Matteo S Carlino; Benedicte Lebrun-Vignes; Zeynep Eroglu; Jessica C Hassel; Alexander M Menzies; Jeffrey A Sosman; Ryan J Sullivan; Javid J Moslehi; Douglas B Johnson Journal: JAMA Oncol Date: 2018-12-01 Impact factor: 31.777
Authors: Julie R Brahmer; Hamzah Abu-Sbeih; Paolo Antonio Ascierto; Jill Brufsky; Laura C Cappelli; Frank B Cortazar; David E Gerber; Lamya Hamad; Eric Hansen; Douglas B Johnson; Mario E Lacouture; Gregory A Masters; Jarushka Naidoo; Michele Nanni; Miguel-Angel Perales; Igor Puzanov; Bianca D Santomasso; Satish P Shanbhag; Rajeev Sharma; Dimitra Skondra; Jeffrey A Sosman; Michelle Turner; Marc S Ernstoff Journal: J Immunother Cancer Date: 2021-06 Impact factor: 13.751