| Literature DB >> 29112153 |
Paulina Lipińska1, Atanas G Atanasov2,3, Marek Palka4, Artur Jóźwik5.
Abstract
Despite being a plant by-product, chokeberry pomace is believed to exert some therapeutic effects because it is one of the richest sources of highly bioavailable non-enzymatic antioxidants. The aim of this study was to determine the functionality of bioactive compounds present in the Aronia melanocarpa pomace (chokeberry) based on enzymatic and non-enzymatic parameters related to the active defence of liver and blood against the effects of oxidative stress. The experiment was conducted with 48 lambs of two breeds-Polish Merino and Wrzosówka. Experimental groups were administered the basic feed with the addition of 150 g or 300 g of black chokeberry pomace per each kg of the complete feed. The activities of antioxidative enzymes (superoxide dismutase, glutathione peroxidase), peptides (glutathione, glutathione disulfide), and a lipid peroxidation indicator (malondialdehyde), as well as the capacity of non-enzymatic antioxidants were investigated. The results proved a strong effect of bioactive compounds contained in the black chokeberry pomace on the estimated parameters. The inclusion of chokeberry pomace in feed mixtures brought many benefits linked with the antioxidative protection. Parameters responsible for the oxidative status were significantly modified despite the commonly-held view about a limited possibility of transferring phenolic compounds to the organs.Entities:
Keywords: antioxidative enzymes; antioxidative peptides; lipid peroxidation; nutraceuticals; oxidative stress; phenolic compounds
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2017 PMID: 29112153 PMCID: PMC6150199 DOI: 10.3390/molecules22111461
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Molecules ISSN: 1420-3049 Impact factor: 4.411
Activity of superoxide dismutase (U/mL) in serum and liver samples collected from both breeds as affected by the dose of the additive.
| Type of Sample | Breed | Mean | Statistical Significance | Standard Deviation | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Serum | Polish Merino | ExPM150 | 5.921 U/mL | ExPM300 | 1.000 | ±0.714 |
| CPM | 0.000 ** | |||||
| ExPM300 | 5.882 U/mL | ExPM150 | 1.000 | ±0.978 | ||
| CPM | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CPM | 8.591 U/mL | ExPM150 | 0.000 ** | ±1.150 | ||
| ExPM300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
| Wrzosówka | ExW150 | 5.651 U/mL | ExW300 | 0.003 ** | ±0.969 | |
| CW | 1.000 | |||||
| ExW300 | 3.803 U/mL | ExW150 | 0.003 ** | ±1.117 | ||
| CW | 0.001 ** | |||||
| CW | 5.788 U/mL | ExW150 | 1.000 | ±1.198 | ||
| ExW300 | 0.001 ** | |||||
| Liver | Polish Merino | ExPM150 | 34.033 U/mL | ExPM300 | 0.791 | ±2.776 |
| CPM | 0.000 ** | |||||
| ExPM300 | 36.438 U/mL | ExPM150 | 0.791 | ±4.120 | ||
| CPM | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CPM | 10.176 U/mL | ExPM150 | 0.000 ** | ±2.543 | ||
| ExPM300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
| Wrzosówka | ExW150 | 33.935 U/mL | ExW300 | 0.305 | ±6.473 | |
| CW | 0.000 ** | |||||
| ExW300 | 37.488 U/mL | ExW150 | 0.305 | ±5.517 | ||
| CW | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CW | 15.343 U/mL | ExW150 | 0.000 ** | ±2.146 | ||
| ExW300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
The multiple pairwise comparisons test and post hoc Bonferroni procedure showed some significant differences between the averages for each pair of groups: * means p ≤ 0.05, ** means p ≤ 0.01. CPM, CW—control group, Experimental groups—ExPM150, ExPM300, and ExW150, ExW300 (150 or 300 g of chokeberry pomace additive per each kg of the complete compound feed).
Differences between the antioxidative enzyme activity of each pair of breeds.
| Type of Sample and Enzyme | Amount of Additive | Polish Merino compared to Wrzosówka | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Statistical Significance | Difference between Averages | Standard Error | ||
| Serum SOD | 150 g | 0.603 | ±0.271 | 0.517 |
| 300 g | 0.000 ** | ±2.079 | 0.517 | |
| control | 0.000 ** | ±2.803 | 0.517 | |
| Liver SOD | 150 g | 0.963 | ±0.098 | 2.122 |
| 300 g | 0.624 | ±1.049 | 2.122 | |
| control | 0.019 * | ±5.168 | 2.122 | |
| Plasma GPx | 150 g | 0.259 | ±14.375 | 12.553 |
| 300 g | 0.325 | ±12.500 | 12.553 | |
| control | 0.692 | ±5.000 | 12.553 | |
| Liver GPx | 150 g | 0.124 | ±9.125 | 5.812 |
| 300 g | 0.008 ** | ±16.057 | 5.812 | |
| control | 0.308 | ±6.000 | 5.812 | |
The multiple pairwise comparisons test and post hoc Bonferroni procedure showed some significant differences between antioxidative enzymes activity of each pair of breeds: * means p ≤ 0.05, ** means p ≤ 0.01. GPx: glutathione peroxidase; SOD: superoxide dismutase.
Activity of glutathione peroxidase (nmol/min/mL) in plasma and liver samples collected from both breeds as affected by the dose of the additive.
| Type of Sample | Breed | Mean | Statistical Significance | Standard Deviation | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plasma | Polish Merino | ExPM150 | 233.375 nmol/min/mL | ExPM300 | 0.056 | ±23.766 |
| CPM | 0.001 ** | |||||
| ExPM300 | 264.125 nmol/min/mL | ExPM150 | 0.056 | ±19.276 | ||
| CPM | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CPM | 183.750 nmol/min/mL | ExPM150 | 0.001 ** | ±23.927 | ||
| ExPM300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
| Wrzosówka | ExW150 | 247.750 nmol/min/mL | ExW300 | 0.079 | ±34.400 | |
| CW | 0.000 ** | |||||
| ExW300 | 276.625 nmol/min/mL | ExW150 | 0.079 | ±27.076 | ||
| CW | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CW | 188.750 nmol/min/mL | ExW150 | 0.000 ** | ±18.889 | ||
| ExW300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
| Liver | Polish Merino | ExPM150 | 56.125 nmol/min/mL | ExPM300 | 0.030 * | ±9.613 |
| CPM | 0.548 | |||||
| ExPM300 | 40.443 nmol/min/mL | ExPM150 | 0.030 * | ±8.596 | ||
| CPM | 0.001 ** | |||||
| CPM | 64.000 nmol/min/mL | ExPM150 | 0.548 | ±13.564 | ||
| ExPM300 | 0.001 ** | |||||
| Wrzosówka | ExW150 | 65.250 nmol/min/mL | ExW300 | 0.419 | ±9.377 | |
| CW | 1.000 | |||||
| ExW300 | 56.500 nmol/min/mL | ExW150 | 0.419 | ±7.760 | ||
| CW | 0.075 | |||||
| CW | 70.000 nmol/min/mL | ExW150 | 1.000 | ±7.559 | ||
| ExW300 | 0.075 | |||||
The multiple pairwise comparisons test and post hoc Bonferroni procedure showed significant differences between the averages for each pair of groups: * means p ≤ 0.05, ** means p ≤ 0.01. CPM, CW—control group, Experimental groups—ExPM150, ExPM300 and ExW150, ExW300 (150 or 300 g of chokeberry pomace additive per each kg of the complete compound feed).
Capacity of reduced glutathione (µM) in full blood collected from both breeds as affected by the dose of the additive.
| Type of Sample | Breed | Mean | Statistical Significance | Standard Deviation | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full blood | Polish Merino | ExPM150 | 357.625 µM | ExPM300 | 0.003 ** | ±35.230 |
| CPM | 0.005 ** | |||||
| ExPM300 | 556.625 µM | ExPM150 | 0.002 ** | ±76.052 | ||
| CPM | 0.008 ** | |||||
| CPM | 267.875 µM | ExPM150 | 0.005 ** | ±39.244 | ||
| ExPM300 | 0.008 ** | |||||
| Wrzosówka | ExW150 | 408.500 µM | ExW300 | 0.008 ** | ±59.809 | |
| CW | 0.007 ** | |||||
| ExW300 | 544.375 µM | ExW150 | 0.003 ** | ±63.895 | ||
| CW | 0.006 ** | |||||
| CW | 263.375 µM | ExW150 | 0.006 ** | ±31.122 | ||
| ExW300 | 0.006 ** | |||||
The multiple pairwise comparisons test and post hoc Bonferroni procedure showed significant differences between the averages for each pair of groups: * means p ≤ 0.05, ** means p ≤ 0.01. CPM, CW—control group, Experimental groups—ExPM150, ExPM300 and ExW150, ExW300 (150 or 300 g of chokeberry pomace additive per each kg of the complete compound feed).
Differences between the level of oxidative status indicators for each pair of breeds.
| Type of Sample and Enzyme | Amount of Additive | Polish Merino compared to Wrzosówka | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Statistical Significance | Difference between Averages | Standard Error | ||
| Full blood GSH | 150 g | 0.064 | ±50.875 | 18.926 |
| 300 g | 0.650 | ±12.250 | 18.926 | |
| control | 0.867 | ±4.500 | 18.926 | |
| Liver MDA | 150 g | 0.000 ** | ±7.625 | 1.316 |
| 300 g | 0.020 * | ±4.500 | 1.316 | |
| control | 0.088 | ±3.250 | 1.316 | |
| Serum NEAC | 150 g | 0.582 | ±0.864 | 1.100 |
| 300 g | 0.041 * | ±3.277 | 1.100 | |
| control | 0.463 | ±1.153 | 1.100 | |
| Liver NEAC | 150 g | 0.825 | ±0.293 | 0.931 |
| 300 g | 0.272 | ±1.467 | 0.931 | |
| control | 0.930 | ±0.117 | 0.931 | |
The multiple pairwise comparisons test and post hoc Bonferroni procedure showed some significant differences between the level of oxidative status indicators for each pair of breeds: * means p ≤ 0.05, ** means p ≤ 0.01. MDA: malondialdehyde; NEAC: non-enzymatic antioxidant capacity.
The level of malondialdehyde (µM) in liver as affected by the dose of the additive.
| Type of Sample | Breed | Mean | Statistical Significance | Standard Deviation | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Liver | Polish Merino | ExPM150 | 28.500 µM | ExPM300 | 0.000 ** | ±4.175 |
| CPM | 0.139 | |||||
| ExPM300 | 17.250 µM | ExPM150 | 0.000 ** | ±4.234 | ||
| CPM | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CPM | 32.125 µM | ExPM150 | 0.174 | ±4.390 | ||
| ExPM300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
| Wrzosówka | ExW150 | 20.875 µM | ExW300 | 0.000 ** | ±3.563 | |
| CW | 0.000 ** | |||||
| ExW300 | 12.750 µM | ExW150 | 0.000 ** | ±1.832 | ||
| CW | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CW | 28.875 µM | ExW150 | 0.000 ** | ±3.523 | ||
| ExW300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
The multiple pairwise comparisons test and post hoc Bonferroni procedure showed significant differences between the averages for each pair of groups: * means p ≤ 0.05, ** means p ≤ 0.01. CPM, CW—control group, Experimental groups—ExPM150, ExPM300 and ExW150, ExW300 (150 or 300 g of chokeberry pomace additive per each kg of the complete compound feed).
Non-enzymatic total antioxidant capacity (mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent) in serum and liver as affected by the dose of the additive.
| Type of Sample | Breed | Mean | Statistical Significance | Standard Deviation | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plasma | Polish Merino | ExPM150 | 19.046 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExPM300 | 0.007 ** | ±2.960 |
| CPM | 0.026 * | |||||
| ExPM300 | 24.123 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExPM150 | 0.007 ** | ±2.795 | ||
| CPM | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CPM | 14.751 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExPM150 | 0.026 * | ±3.086 | ||
| ExPM300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
| Wrzosówka | ExW150 | 19.910 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExW300 | 0.000 ** | ±4.993 | |
| CW | 0.041 * | |||||
| ExW300 | 27.400 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExW150 | 0.000 ** | ±2.298 | ||
| CW | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CW | 15.904 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExW150 | 0.041 * | ±1.530 | ||
| ExW300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
| Liver | Polish Merino | ExPM150 | 24.997 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExPM300 | 0.000 ** | ±1.874 |
| CPM | 0.000 ** | |||||
| ExPM300 | 36.293 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExPM150 | 0.000 ** | ±1.486 | ||
| CPM | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CPM | 12.923 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExPM150 | 0.000 ** | ±0.674 | ||
| ExPM300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
| Wrzosówka | ExW150 | 25.290 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExW300 | 0.000 ** | ±2.016 | |
| CW | 0.000 ** | |||||
| ExW300 | 34.826 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExW150 | 0.000 ** | ±5.467 | ||
| CW | 0.000 ** | |||||
| CW | 12.807 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent | ExW150 | 0.000 ** | ±1.222 | ||
| ExW300 | 0.000 ** | |||||
The multiple pairwise comparisons test and post hoc Bonferroni procedure showed significant differences between the averages for each pair of groups : * means p ≤ 0.05, ** means p ≤ 0.01. CPM, CW—control group, Experimental groups—ExPM150, ExPM300 and ExW150, ExW300 (150 or 300 g of chokeberry pomace additive per each kg of the complete compound feed).
Analytical composition of applied feed.
| Calculated Analyses (kg) | Basic Feed | Chokeberry Pomace |
|---|---|---|
| UFV 1 | 0.98 | NA |
| Crude protein (%) | 19.79 | 3.2 |
| PDIA 2 | 13.4 | NA |
| PDIN 2 | 6.8 | NA |
| PDIE 2 | 13.0 | NA |
| Fat (%) | 3.23 | 0.64 |
| Crude fibre (%) | 6.87 | 29.69 |
| Ash (%) | 7.64 | 2.87 |
1 The energy value by INRA system [36]; 2 Protein composition value by INRA system [36]; NA—not analysed; UFV—feed unit for maintenance and meat production, PDIA—the dietary protein undegraded in the rumen but truly digestible in the small intestine, PDIN—proteins digestible in the intestine when fermentable nitrogen is limiting, PDIE—proteins digestible in the intestine when rumen fermentable energy are limiting; Vitamins, pro-vitamins, and chemicals in basic feed: Vit A 18,000 j.m.; Vit D3 6050 j.m.; Vit E (DL-Alfa-Tocoferol acetate) 42.0 j.m.; Mixtures of trace elements: Iron (ferrous sulphate monohydrate) 12.5 mg; Selenium (sodium selenite) 0.2 mg; Copper (copper sulphate pentahydrate) 5.0 mg; Manganese (manganese oxide), 27.5 mg; Zinc (zinc oxide) 37.5 mg; Iodine (anhydrous calcium iodate) 0.5 mg; Cobalt (cobalt carbonate monohydrate) 0.1 mg.
Nonenzymatic antioxidants capacity in all types of feed.
| All types of feed | Nonenzymatic Antioxidant Capacity |
|---|---|
| Chokeberry pomace | 974.56 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent |
| Basic feed | 247.45 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent |
| Basic feed + 150 g chokeberry pomace | 497.33 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent |
| Basic feed + 300 g chokeberry pomace | 744.55 mM/single-electron Trolox equivalent |