Amber E Barnato1, Chung-Chou H Chang2,3, Judith R Lave4, Derek C Angus4,5. 1. 1 The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice , Geisel School of Medicine, Lebanon , New Hampshire. 2. 2 Department of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine , Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 3. 3 Department of Biostatistics, University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health , Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 4. 4 Department of Health Care Policy and Management, University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health , Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 5. 5 Department of Critical Care Medicine, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine , Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Black patients are more likely than white patients to die in the hospital with intensive care and life-sustaining treatments and less likely to use hospice. Regional concentration of high end-of-life (EOL) treatment intensity practice patterns may disproportionately affect black patients. We calculated and compared race-specific hospital-level EOL treatment intensity in Pennsylvania. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective cohort analysis of Pennsylvania acute care hospital admissions, 2001-2007, among black and white admissions ≥21 years old at high probability of dying (HPD) (≥15% predicted probability of dying at admission). We calculated hospitals' race-specific observed, expected, and Bayes' shrunken observed-to-expected ratios of intensive care unit (ICU) admission, ICU length of stay (LOS), intubation/mechanical ventilation, hemodialysis, tracheostomy, and gastrostomy among HPD admissions; and an empirically weighted EOL treatment intensity index summing these ratios. RESULTS: There were 35,609 black HPD admissions (27,576 unique patients) and 311,896 white HPD admissions (252,662 unique patients) to 182 hospitals. Among 95 hospitals with ≥30 black HPD admissions, 80% of black admissions were concentrated in 29 hospitals, where black-specific observed and expected EOL measures were usually higher than white-specific measures (p < 0.001 for all but 5/24 measures). Hospitals' black-specific and white-specific observed-to-expected ratios of ICU and life-sustaining treatment (LST) (rho 0.52-0.90) and EOL index (rho = 0.92) were highly correlated. However, black-specific observed-to-expected ratios and overall EOL intensity index were consistently lower than white-specific ratios (p < 0.001 for all except hemodialysis). CONCLUSIONS: In Pennsylvania, black-serving hospitals have higher standardized EOL treatment intensity than nonblack-serving hospitals, contributing to black patients' relatively higher use of intensive treatment. However, conditional on being admitted to the same high-intensity hospital and after risk adjustment, blacks are less intensively treated than whites.
OBJECTIVE: Black patients are more likely than white patients to die in the hospital with intensive care and life-sustaining treatments and less likely to use hospice. Regional concentration of high end-of-life (EOL) treatment intensity practice patterns may disproportionately affect black patients. We calculated and compared race-specific hospital-level EOL treatment intensity in Pennsylvania. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective cohort analysis of Pennsylvania acute care hospital admissions, 2001-2007, among black and white admissions ≥21 years old at high probability of dying (HPD) (≥15% predicted probability of dying at admission). We calculated hospitals' race-specific observed, expected, and Bayes' shrunken observed-to-expected ratios of intensive care unit (ICU) admission, ICU length of stay (LOS), intubation/mechanical ventilation, hemodialysis, tracheostomy, and gastrostomy among HPD admissions; and an empirically weighted EOL treatment intensity index summing these ratios. RESULTS: There were 35,609 black HPD admissions (27,576 unique patients) and 311,896 white HPD admissions (252,662 unique patients) to 182 hospitals. Among 95 hospitals with ≥30 black HPD admissions, 80% of black admissions were concentrated in 29 hospitals, where black-specific observed and expected EOL measures were usually higher than white-specific measures (p < 0.001 for all but 5/24 measures). Hospitals' black-specific and white-specific observed-to-expected ratios of ICU and life-sustaining treatment (LST) (rho 0.52-0.90) and EOL index (rho = 0.92) were highly correlated. However, black-specific observed-to-expected ratios and overall EOL intensity index were consistently lower than white-specific ratios (p < 0.001 for all except hemodialysis). CONCLUSIONS: In Pennsylvania, black-serving hospitals have higher standardized EOL treatment intensity than nonblack-serving hospitals, contributing to black patients' relatively higher use of intensive treatment. However, conditional on being admitted to the same high-intensity hospital and after risk adjustment, blacks are less intensively treated than whites.
Entities:
Keywords:
disparity; hospital profiling; intensive care; life support; race; terminal care
Authors: Amber E Barnato; Zekarias Berhane; Lisa A Weissfeld; Chung-Chou H Chang; Walter T Linde-Zwirble; Derek C Angus Journal: Health Serv Res Date: 2006-12 Impact factor: 3.402
Authors: Elliott S Fisher; David E Wennberg; Thérèse A Stukel; Daniel J Gottlieb; F L Lucas; Etoile L Pinder Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2003-02-18 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: Angelo E Volandes; Michael Paasche-Orlow; Muriel R Gillick; E F Cook; Shimon Shaykevich; Elmer D Abbo; Lisa Lehmann Journal: J Palliat Med Date: 2008-06 Impact factor: 2.947
Authors: Amber E Barnato; Max H Farrell; Chung-Chou H Chang; Judith R Lave; Mark S Roberts; Derek C Angus Journal: Med Care Date: 2009-10 Impact factor: 2.983
Authors: R S Pritchard; E S Fisher; J M Teno; S M Sharp; D J Reding; W A Knaus; J E Wennberg; J Lynn Journal: J Am Geriatr Soc Date: 1998-10 Impact factor: 5.562
Authors: Laura M Perry; Leah E Walsh; Ronald Horswell; Lucio Miele; San Chu; Brian Melancon; John Lefante; Christopher M Blais; James L Rogers; Michael Hoerger Journal: J Pain Symptom Manage Date: 2020-09-15 Impact factor: 3.612
Authors: Deepshikha Charan Ashana; George L Anesi; Vincent X Liu; Gabriel J Escobar; Christopher Chesley; Nwamaka D Eneanya; Gary E Weissman; William Dwight Miller; Michael O Harhay; Scott D Halpern Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 2021-07-15 Impact factor: 30.528
Authors: Garrett T Wasp; Shama S Alam; Gabriel A Brooks; Inas S Khayal; Nirav S Kapadia; Donald Q Carmichael; Andrea M Austin; Amber E Barnato Journal: Cancer Med Date: 2020-01-11 Impact factor: 4.452
Authors: Alison E Turnbull; Margaret M Hayes; Roy G Brower; Elizabeth Colantuoni; Pragyashree Sharma Basyal; Douglas B White; J Randall Curtis; Dale M Needham Journal: Crit Care Med Date: 2019-06 Impact factor: 7.598
Authors: Amber E Barnato; Gregory R Johnson; John D Birkmeyer; Jonathan S Skinner; Allistair James O'Malley; Nancy J O Birkmeyer Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2022-04-11 Impact factor: 6.473