Spectrum of retinal abnormalities in renal transplant patients using chronic low-dose steroids.

PURPOSE: To assess the ophthalmological characteristics of asymptomatic patients with a renal transplant on chronic low-dose steroids for at least the last 2 years prior to examination.
METHODS: Cross-sectional study. All patients underwent an extensive ophthalmological examination.
RESULTS: Of the 37 included patients [25 male, 12 female; 59 ± 11 years (range, 38-77 years)] ophthalmological phenotyping revealed abnormalities in 22 patients (59%). Findings characteristic for (subclinical) central serous chorioretinopathy were detected in ten patients (27%), including two patients with serous subretinal fluid in the macula. An epiretinal membrane of the macula was present in six patients (16%). Mean subfoveal choroidal thickness was significantly increased in patients with ophthalmological abnormalities, in comparison with patients without abnormalities.
CONCLUSIONS: Retinal abnormalities are common in the majority of renal transplant patients using chronic low-dose steroids. These retinal changes may be associated with the renal disease and/or the effect of chronic steroid use on the choroid and retina.

Introduction

For end-stage solid organ disease, transplantation is a therapeutic option in a noteworthy number of patients. Abnormal ophthalmological findings after several types of transplantation occur in more than 50% of patients [1-3], and are caused by the combination of pre-existing disease and immunosuppressive regimen [4]. Fortunately, vision-threatening conditions are seldom observed after long-term follow-up [5]. Up to 45% of the transplant patients develop typical steroid-induced bilateral posterior subcapsular cataract within the first year after transplantation [1]. Bilateral, open-angle glaucoma is detected in up to 7% of patients within the first year after transplantation, which may be caused by the use of systemic steroids [1]. Little is known about transplantation complications in the posterior segment of the eye. Documented retinal complications are of infectious, hemorrhagic, or microvascular origin and have been described after bone marrow transplantation preceded by total body irradiation [4]. Moreover, optic disc edema and pigmentary changes have been found to occur after heart transplantation [6]. The kidney is the most commonly transplanted organ worldwide. Little is known about retinal abnormalities in renal transplant patients. Some renal diseases that often require renal transplantation, for example complement-associated diseases like dense deposit disease, are known to be associated with retinal abnormalities such as drusen and macular degeneration [7]. Use of steroids as is common after transplantation, is known to be a major risk factor associated with central serous chorioretinopathy (CSC). This is a form of macular degeneration caused by an accumulation of serous subretinal fluid (SRF) due to choroidal and retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) abnormalities [8-11]. Previous steroid intake has been described in up to 52% of CSC patients, and odds ratios of up to 37 for CSC have been found for steroid using subjects [8, 12, 13].

In the current study, we performed an extensive cross-sectional ophthalmological phenotyping in renal transplant patients on low-dose steroids for at least 2 years prior to examination.

Methods

Patient selection

In this cross-sectional study, 37 sequential outpatient renal transplant patients who chronically used oral low-dose steroids for at least 2 years prior to examination and who did not have visual complaints were invited to take part in this study conducted at the Department of Ophthalmology of the Leiden University Medical Center, for ophthalmological analysis. Patients who were previously diagnosed with either retinal abnormalities or systemic disorders that may cause persistent retinal damage (for example uncontrolled diabetes mellitus or uncontrolled hypertension) were excluded. Written informed consent was signed by all subjects. The study adhered to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki, and was approved by the institutional review board and the ethics committee (NL50816.058.14). Clinical information was collected from the patients’ charts. Patients were included in this study from February 2016 to October 2016.

Ophthalmological imaging

Patients underwent an extensive ophthalmic assessment, including Early Treatment of Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) measurement, and indirect ophthalmoscopy. After administration of 1% tropicamide and 5% phenylephrine drops, digital color fundus photography of the central and peripheral retina (Topcon Corp., Tokyo, Japan) was performed, and optical coherence tomography (OCT), enhanced depth imaging (EDI-)OCT, fundus autofluorescence, and oral fluorescein angiography (FA) images were made with the spectral-domain OCT (Spectralis HRA + OCT; Heidelberg Engineering, Dublin, CA, USA). Subfoveal choroidal thickness (SFCT; distance from the outer part of the hyperreflective RPE layer to the hyperreflective line of the inner surface of the sclera) was measured on EDI-OCT. For the oral FA, patients had to ingest 10 ml of 20% fluorescein after a fasting period of at least 3 h. Oral FA images were obtained at 10, 15, 20, 25, and 30 min after the administration of fluorescein. Peripheral images were acquired between 25 and 30 min after ingestion. When the evaluation of ophthalmological imaging by an experienced retina specialist (CJFB) led to findings requiring treatment and/or follow-up, these examinations and/or visits were scheduled at the outpatient clinic of the Department of Ophthalmology of Leiden University Medical Center.

Statistical analysis

For statistical analyses, descriptive statistics were used in SPSS Statistics (version 23; IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). Independent t-tests were used to compare the patient group in whom ophthalmological abnormalities could be detected to the remaining patients for: need for and total duration of dialysis before transplantation, reason of (re)transplantation, time from the first renal transplantation (and start of steroid use) until phenotyping, number of rejection therapies, type of immunosuppressive drugs at the moment of phenotyping, age of the patient at the moment of transplantation and at phenotyping, and donor age at the moment of transplantation. Moreover, independent t-tests were used to compare the mean SFCT for patients with and without ophthalmological abnormalities. The level of statistical significance was set at p < 0.05.

Results

Patient characteristics

The mean age at phenotyping of the 37 included patients (25 male, 12 female) was 59 ± 11 years (range, 38–77 years). The mean age at which the first renal transplantation had been performed was 50 ± 12 years (range, 22–71 years). Retransplantation had been performed in four patients (11%). Eleven patients received a transplantation prior to dialysis. The total duration of dialysis was 3.2 ± 2.1 years (range, 0.3–7.5 years) in the 24 other patients, for whom this information was available.

Among other immunosuppressant medication, which was used by all patients, all patients started using steroids after their first transplantation. The estimated minimal cumulative prednisolone dose was 4000 mg and the mean cumulative prednisolone dose was 20,000 mg. At the moment of ophthalmological phenotyping, 25 patients used 5 mg and 12 used 7.5 mg prednisolone once daily. Eleven patients reported the use of other steroid-containing medication during the last year before ophthalmological phenotyping. The medical history of the participants was notable for arterial hypertension in all patients (100%) and diabetes mellitus in 12 patients (32%). Besides the diagnosis of a depression in three patients (8%), no other diseases known to be possibly associated with CSC were present [14]. Four patients used a mineralocorticoid receptor antagonist to treat hypertension, a drug which has also been described as a therapeutic option for CSC [15]. Clinical characteristics of the patients are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1

Clinical characteristics of the 37 phenotyped patients who chronically used low-dose steroids for at least the last 2 years prior to examination

Clinical characteristics
Number of patients	37
Number of males	25 (68%)
Number of females	12 (32%)
Mean age ± SD (range) at phenotyping, in years	59 ± 11 (38–77)
Mean age ± SD (range) at renal transplantation, in years	50 ± 12 (22–71)
Reason for first transplantation
Autosomal polycystic kidney disease	8 (22%)
IgA nephropathy	7 (19%)
Unknown origin of disease	6 (16%)
Acute tubular necrosis	2 (5%)
Membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis	2 (5%)
Malignancy	2 (5%)
Reflux nephropathy	2 (5%)
Alport syndrome	1 (3%)
C3 glomerulopathy	1 (3%)
Chronic urinary tract infections	1 (3%)
Hemolytic-uremic syndrome + hypertension	1 (3%)
Medullary cystic kidney disease	1 (3%)
Oxalate nephropathy	1 (3%)
Pauci-immune crescentic glomerulonephritis	1 (3%)
Tubulointerstitial nephritis	1 (3%)
Retransplantation	4 (11%)

Ophthalmic characteristics

At the visit to the Department of Ophthalmology, ETDRS BCVA was 84 ± 11 letters (range, 25–96 letters) in the included eyes. Two patients had a history of unilateral amblyopia, and one patient of recurrent unilateral herpes keratitis. In 60 eyes (79%) ETDRS BCVA was ≥ 80 letters. During slit-lamp examination, unilateral mature cataract was detected in one patient. BCVA ETDRS in this patient improved from 25 to 85 ETDRS letters, after phacoemulsification. Besides the presence of pre-existing primary open-angle glaucoma in one patient, no other abnormalities of the anterior segment were found. OCT showed the presence of macular serous SRF in three eyes of two patients (5%). On FA, hyperfluorescent changes that could fit well within the spectrum of (subclinical) CSC were detected in these eyes, without the presence of a ‘hot spot’ of leakage (Fig. 1a–e). Fundus autofluorescence revealed variable mild hypo- and hyperfluorescence of the lesions. On OCT imaging, a variable degree of outer photoreceptor/RPE changes compatible with subclinical CSC was found in eight of the remaining patients (22%), which was supported by corresponding hyperfluorescent changes on FA (Fig. 1f–j). On OCT imaging, two patients had a bilateral epiretinal membrane (ERM), and four had a unilateral ERM, resulting in a total of six patients (16%) in whom an ERM in the macula was detected (Fig. 1w–x). One of the patients with a unilateral ERM also had a macular pseudohole. Cuticular drusen, which are associated with membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis type II (dense deposit disease), were seen in one patient with this disease (Fig. 1k–o), and multiple, small yellow-white lesions in the midperiphery of the fundi, which are associated with Alport’s disease, were seen in one patient with this diagnosis (Fig. 1u–v) [16, 17]. Bilateral intermediate age-related macular degeneration with soft drusen and secondary vitelliform-like lesions was found in one patient (Fig. 1p–t), whereas bilateral RPE detachments in combination with drusenoid lesions were detected in another patient. In single patients, a unilateral RPE detachment, an old unilateral retinal venous occlusion, and unilateral RPE atrophy were detected. In patients with (subclinical) CSC, mean SFCT on EDI-OCT was 286 ± 82 μm (range, 111–451 μm). In all eyes with retinal abnormalities, mean SFCT on EDI-OCT was 301 ± 88 μm (range, 111–489 μm), and mean SFCT in all eyes of patients with either unilateral or bilateral abnormalities was 292 ± 84 μm (range, 111–489 μm). These CTs differed from the eyes of patients in whom no abnormalities were detected (232 ± 108 μm (range, 98–571 μm); p = 0.071, p = 0.01, and p = 0.006 respectively).

Fig. 1

Spectrum of retinal abnormalities in renal transplant patients who chronically used low-dose steroids for at least the last 2 years prior to examination. a–e Multimodal imaging of a 58-year-old male patient who received a renal transplant 21 years before phenotyping, because of membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis. Fundus photography of the right eye (a) showed mild foveal and extrafoveal retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) abnormalities, and on fundus autofluorescence (FAF; b) irregular changes were present. Fluorescein angiography of the right eye (FA; c), which was performed after oral administration of fluorescein, showed multifocal hyperfluorescent areas, but no clear ‘hot spot’ of leakage. On the foveal optical coherence tomography (OCT) scan of the right eye (d) RPE and outer photoreceptor changes suggestive of central serous chorioretinopathy, and a subfoveal choroidal thickness (SFCT) of 451 μm were found. No subretinal fluid (SRF) was present in the right eye. In the left eye, milder abnormalities were detected on multimodal imaging, but extrafoveal OCT scanning (e) showed SRF nasosuperiorly and RPE changes. f–j Multimodal imaging of a 43-year-old male patient who was transplanted 11 years ago, because of reflux nephropathy. On fundus photography of the right eye (f) subtle extrafoveal RPE abnormalities were observed, with corresponding changes on FAF (g). Mild hyperfluorescent changes were found on oral FA (h) of this eye, partly due to staining and partly due to a window defect. The foveal (i) and extrafoveal OCT scans (j) revealed mild outer retinal changes and the SFCT was 349 μm. Moreover, RPE detachments, which could also correspond to age-related (subclinical) small hard drusen, were found. Similar findings were observed in the left eye of this patient. k–o Multimodal imaging of a 44-year-old female patient who underwent transplantation surgery 22 years before retinal phenotyping, and had received a transplant because of membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis. Cuticular drusen, known to be associated with membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis type II (dense deposit disease), were detected on fundus photography (k), FAF (l), oral FA (m), and both foveal (n) and extrafoveal OCT images (o) of the right eye. SFCT was 297 μm at this visit. In the left eye, identical findings were detected. p–t Multimodal imaging of a 63-year-old male patient who received a renal transplant 6 years before ophthalmological phenotyping, because of IgA nephropathy, showed findings characteristic for bilateral nonexudative age-related macular degeneration and secondary vitelliform-like lesions. On fundus photography of the left eye (p), yellow-white lesions and confluent drusen were seen in the macula, together with cuticular drusen and RPE alterations peripherally. On FAF (q) hyperfluorescent changes with an irregular border were seen in the macular area. Oral FA (r) revealed cuticular drusen and irregular hyperfluorescent changes foveally and perifoveally, which could be characteristic for the vitelliform-like lesions. Foveal (s) and extrafoveal OCT images (t) showed drusen, and a hyperreflective subretinal accumulation, that was most pronounced foveally. Comparable lesions were found in the other eye of this patient. u–v In a 37-year-old male patient, who had received a renal transplant for Alport’s disease 7 years before retinal phenotyping, fundus photography of the right eye (u) showed multiple, small yellow-white lesions in the midperiphery of the fundi, known to be associated with this disease. Foveal OCT scanning (v) showed some traction of unknown origin, and a SFCT of 489 μm. Comparable lesions were found in the left eye. w–x In a 62-year-old female patient, who was previously diagnosed with autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease and was transplanted 19 years ago, a unilateral foveal epiretinal membrane was detected on OCT (w). SFCT was 238 μm, at that visit. The epiretinal membrane was also observed on fundus photography (x)

None of the clinical characteristics of the included patients could be linked with either the presence or absence of ocular abnormalities. Treatment was not needed for the retinal abnormalities that were detected in this study. For the patient with macular pseudohole and for the patient with maculopathy with secondary vitelliform-like lesions, additional follow-up visits were scheduled. The retinal findings of the patients are summarized in Table 2.

Table 2

Reason for transplantation of the 22 phenotyped patients with retinal abnormalities who chronically used low-dose steroids for at least the last 2 years prior to examination

Retinal abnormality	Reason for transplantation (number of patients)
Bilateral findings characteristic for CSC*, bilateral SRF	Membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (1)
Bilateral findings characteristic for CSC*, unilateral SRF	Unknown origin of disease (1)
Bilateral findings characteristic for CSC*, no SRF	Acute tubular necrosis after surgery (1), ADPKD (1), reflux nephropathy (1), tubulointerstitial nephritis (1)
Unilateral findings characteristic for CSC*, no SRF	Chronic urinary tract infections (1), hemolytic–uremic syndrome AND hypertension (1), IgA nephropathy (1)
Unilateral findings characteristic for CSC*, no SRF; AND a bilateral epiretinal membrane	ADPKD (1)
Bilateral epiretinal membrane	Unknown origin of disease (1)
Unilateral epiretinal membrane	ADPKD (2), pauci-immune crescentic glomerulonephritis (1)
Unilateral epiretinal membrane AND a unilateral macular pseudohole AND bilateral choroidal folds	Nephrosclerosis AND neoplasm (1)
Bilateral cuticular drusen, known for membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis	Membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (1)
Bilateral dry age-related macular degeneration AND secondary vitelliform lesions AND cuticular drusen	IgA nephropathy (1)
Bilateral peripheral yellow-white lesions, known for Alport syndrome	Alport syndrome (1)
Bilateral retinal pigment epithelium detachments AND drusenoid lesions	Oxalate nephropathy (1)
Unilateral old venous occlusion	Unknown origin of disease (1)
Unilateral retinal pigment epithelium atrophy	Unknown origin of disease (1)
Unilateral retinal pigment epithelium detachment	ADPKD (1)
No abnormalities	Acute tubular necrosis after surgery (1), ADPKD (3), C3 glomerulopathy (1), IgA nephropathy (5), medullary cystic kidney disease (1), nephrosclerosis AND neoplasm (1), reflux nephropathy (1), unknown origin of disease (2)

ADPKD autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease, CSC central serous chorioretinopathy, FA fluorescein angiography, OCT optical coherence tomography, SRF subretinal fluid

* Outer photoreceptor/retinal pigment epithelium changes on OCT, reminiscent of changes in chronic CSC, with corresponding hyperfluorescent changes on FA

Discussion

Retinal abnormalities were found in 22 of 37 renal transplant patients (59%), who were using chronic low-dose steroids for at least 2 years prior to examination and who were not previously known to have chorioretinal diseases. Findings characteristic for (subclinical) CSC were found in ten patients (27%), and two of these patients showed active SRF leakage in the macula. Moreover, in five other patients and in a total of six patients (16%) an ERM was found. These findings indicate that renal transplant patients could benefit from ophthalmological examination. The frequent occurrence of CSC-like abnormalities may have been caused by steroid use, which has been described to be its most important risk factor [12, 18, 19]. In light of the underlying disease and use of comedication, and the cross-sectional/observational nature of this study, it remains uncertain whether a causal relation exists between the use of steroids and the high prevalence of retinal abnormalities in renal transplant patients. If there is a causal relation, this might be either due to a (previous) short-term high dosage or due to the cumulative effect of a long-term low dosage.

Extensive ophthalmological phenotyping in renal transplant patients using steroids has not been conducted so far. The low prevalence of CSC with active SRF leakage in our cohort (5%) is surprising, given the fact that all patients had used high cumulative doses of steroids. This suggests that the susceptibility for developing CSC depends on more risk factors than solely the use of steroids. Still, 22% of patients had retinal abnormalities that may compatible with subclinical CSC without SRF leakage. In a previous study, in which the authors did not exclude patients with pre-existing ophthalmological diseases, and in which no ophthalmological imaging was performed and in which exact definitions of disease were lacking, retinal pigment epitheliopathy (14%), CSC (3%), retinal vein occlusion (3%), and macular edema (3%) were described [11]. The number of patients with retinal pigment epitheliopathy/CSC in our study seems to be in line with these previously published findings.

For this study, only patients who used steroids for more than 2 years and who did not have a history of either chorioretinal diseases or complaints that could be related to these diagnoses were included. Since a selection based on underlying renal pathology was not performed, patients with various renal diseases were included. In contrast with another study, we did not find a correlation between the outcome of phenotyping and the duration of dialysis before transplantation and time since transplantation [11]. Other clinical characteristics of the included patients could also not be linked to the occurrence of ophthalmological abnormalities. However, compared to patients in whom no ophthalmological abnormalities were found, a significantly increased mean SFCT was observed in patients in whom ophthalmological abnormalities were seen. In CSC patients, the choroid is usually thicker compared to the healthy population, strengthening the relevance of this finding [20-22]. Both the increased CT and percentage of patients with (subclinical) CSC in this study could thus have been caused by the effect of steroids on the choroid, in cases of administration for a prolonged period and only in a specific patient group with predisposition to develop these abnormalities [23, 24]. However, CT between patients with (subclinical) CSC and patients without ophthalmological abnormalities did not differ significantly, which may be related to the small sample size. Since younger age, shorter axial length, male gender, deeper anterior chamber, thicker lens, flatter cornea, and better BCVA have all been associated with an increase in SFCT, comparison of the measurements in our patients with matched healthy controls to whom low-dose steroids had not been prescribed chronically could have attached significance to our data [25, 26].

Even though we expected to find abnormal ocular findings in patients with chronic kidney disease, given the correlation between nephrological and ophthalmological diseases [27-29], the prevalence of abnormalities was higher than we had expected beforehand. This may have been caused by the use of other (immunosuppressive) medication, due to hypertension, due to pre-existing renal diseases, or even due to diabetes mellitus.

In conclusion, retinal abnormalities are present in the majority of renal transplant patient who use low-dose steroids chronically. Therefore, an ophthalmological examination including evaluation of the retina is indicated in these patients. However, seeing that the ophthalmological abnormalities were relatively mild and had a low likelihood for causing symptoms and complications, the dosage of prescribed steroids does not have to be lowered or discontinued in this patient group.