| Literature DB >> 28962558 |
Lawrence Paszat1, Rinku Sutradhar2, Mary Ann O'Brien3, Aisha Lofters4, Andrew Pinto5, Peter Selby6, Nancy Baxter7, Peter D Donnelly8, Regina Elliott9, Richard H Glazier2, Robert Kyle9, Donna Manca10, Mary-Anne Pietrusiak9, Linda Rabeneck11, Nicolette Sopcak12, Jill Tinmouth13, Becky Wall9, Eva Grunfeld3.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The Building on Existing Tools to Improve Chronic Disease Prevention and Screening (BETTER) cluster randomized trial in primary care settings demonstrated a 30% improvement in adherence to evidence-based Chronic Disease Prevention and Screening (CDPS) activities. CDPS activities included healthy activities, lifestyle modifications, and screening tests. We present a protocol for the adaptation of BETTER to a public health setting, and testing the adaptation in a cluster randomized trial (BETTER HEALTH: Durham) among low income neighbourhoods in Durham Region, Ontario (Canada).Entities:
Keywords: Chronic disease; Cluster randomized trial; Deprivation; Prevention; Screening
Mesh:
Year: 2017 PMID: 28962558 PMCID: PMC5622533 DOI: 10.1186/s12889-017-4797-3
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Public Health ISSN: 1471-2458 Impact factor: 3.295
SPIRIT flow diagram of BETTER HEALTH: Durham Cluster Randomized Trial
| Timepoint |
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Cluster randomization | X | ||
| Individual enrollment | |||
| Eligibility screen | X | ||
| Informed consent | X | ||
| Baseline assessments | |||
| BETTER Health Survey (First Visit) [ | X | ||
| Determination of CDPS eligibility (Table | |||
| MOS Social Supports Scale [ | X | ||
| Income Security Survey [ | X | ||
| Food Security Survey [ | X | ||
| Intervention | |||
| Prevention meeting | |||
| Immediate intervention clusters | X | ||
| Wait-list control clusters | X | ||
| Outcome assessment | |||
| BETTER Health Survey (Followup Visit) [ | |||
| Immediate intervention clusters | X | ||
| Wait-list control clusters | X prior to prevention meeting |
Comparison of Chronic Disease Prevention and Screening actions eligible for the composite outcome measure in the first BETTER trial to BETTER HEALTH: Durham
| Better | Better Health: Durham | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fasting blood sugar screening | yes |
| 2 | Fasting blood sugar monitoring | no |
| 3 | Blood pressure screening | yes |
| 4 | Blood pressure monitoring | yes |
| 5 | Hypertension treatment | no |
| 6 | Framingham calculated | Changed to LDL measurement |
| 7 | Framingham improved | no |
| 8 | LDL improved | no |
| 9 | Cholesterol treatment | no |
| 10 | Breast cancer screening | yes |
| 11 | Colorectal cancer screening | yes |
| 12 | Cervical cancer screening | yes |
| 13 | BMI screening | yes |
| 14 | Waist circumference measured | yes |
| 15 | Weight control | yes |
| 16 | Weight control referral | yes |
| 17 | Smoking screening | no |
| 18 | Smoking cessation | yes |
| 19 | Smoking cessation referral | yes |
| 20 | Alcohol screening | no |
| 21 | Alcohol control | yes |
| 22 | Alcohol control referral | yes |
| 23 | Physical activity screening | no |
| 24 | Physical activity > = 90 min / week | yes |
| 25 | Physical activity program referral | yes |
| 26 | Nutrition screening | no |
| 27 | Healthy diet score improved | yes |
| 28 | Nutrition counselling referral | yes |
Comparison of the first ‘BETTER’ trial to ‘BETTER HEALTH: Durham’
| Better | Better Health: Durham | |
|---|---|---|
| Physical location of prevention practitioner (PP) | In Family Health Team clinics | Imbedded in Durham Region Health Department, for community outreach |
| Identification of participants | From electronic medical record (EMR) | Community-based recruitment strategies in low income areas |
| Informed consent | For collection of personal health information, by prevention practitioner | For collection of self-reported personal health information, by research assistant |
| Identification of completed and current behaviours and activities | Abstraction from EMR, and from self-report in self-administered survey | From self-report responses to survey administered by research assistant, in the community |
| Survey data collection | Paper, by patient | Electronic, self-report responses to survey administered by research assistant, in the community |
| Identification of risk factors | Lab tests, survey, EMR | From self-report, as above |
| Identification of eligible CDPS actions | Prevention practitioner manually extracted and compiled | Electronically identified and compiled from self-report, as above |
| Prevention meeting and goal-setting by participants | By prevention practitioner in primary care team clinics | By prevention practitioners at various community locations |
| Strategy to find primary care provider for participants who lack provider. | Not applicable | Prevention practitioners supported by primary care strategy engaging primary care providers near the participant. |
| Height, weight, waist circumference, blood pressure | EMR entry or by prevention practitioner or primary care provider | By prevention practitioner or primary care provider, self-report on baseline or 6 month survey |
| Specimen collection for laboratory-based screening | In laboratories by requisition from primary care providers | In laboratories by requisition from primary care providers or from nurse practitioner for participants without primary care provider |
| Facilitation of goal achievement | Clinic staff, prevention practitioner, links, and self | Prevention practitioners, links, and self |
| Followup of abnormal results | By primary care physician | By primary care providers, or by nurse practitioners engaged by study if prevention practitioners unable to link participant with primary care provider |
| Ascertainment of outcomes | Abstraction from EMR and self-report responses at repeat self-administered survey by prevention practitioner | Self-report responses to 6-month survey administered by research assistant |
| Primary outcome measure | “composite index, expressed as the ratio (multiplied by 100) of the number of eligible CDPS (chronic disease prevention and screening) actions at baseline (denominator) that were subsequently met at follow-up (numerator), measured at the patient level.” (Grunfeld 2013) | |
Fig. 1Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research adapted to BETTER HEALTH: Durham. Adapted from: Damschroder [25]
Fig. 2Adapted Knowledge to Action Process for BETTER HEALTH: Durham. Adapted from Canadian Institues for Health Research [35]