Andreas Heindl1, Ivana Sestak1, Kalnisha Naidoo1, Jack Cuzick1, Mitchell Dowsett1, Yinyin Yuan1. 1. Centre for Evolution and Cancer, The Institute of Cancer Research, London, UK; Centre for Molecular Pathology, Royal Marsden Hospital, London, UK; Division of Molecular Pathology, The Institute of Cancer Research, London, UK; Centre for Cancer Prevention, Wolfson Institute of Preventive Medicine, Queen Mary University of London, London, UK; The Breast Cancer Now Toby Robins Research Centre, Institute of Cancer Research, London, UK; Cellular Pathology, Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Trust, Westminster Bridge Rd, London, UK; Ralph Lauren Centre for Breast Cancer Research, Royal Marsden Hospital, London, UK.
Abstract
Background: Despite increasing evidence supporting the clinical utility of immune infiltration in the estrogen receptor-negative (ER-) subtype, the prognostic value of immune infiltration for ER+ disease is not well defined. Methods: Quantitative immune scores of cell abundance and spatial heterogeneity were computed using a fully automated hematoxylin and eosin-stained image analysis algorithm and spatial statistics for 1178 postmenopausal patients with ER+ breast cancer treated with five years' tamoxifen or anastrozole. The prognostic significance of immune scores was compared with Oncotype DX 21-gene recurrence score (RS), PAM50 risk of recurrence (ROR) score, IHC4, and clinical treatment score, available for 963 patients. Statistical tests were two-sided. Results: Scores of immune cell abundance were not associated with recurrence-free survival. In contrast, high immune spatial scores indicating increased cell spatial clustering were associated with poor 10-year, early (0-5 years), and late (5-10 years) recurrence-free survival (Immune Hotspot: LR-χ2 = 14.06, P < .001, for 0-10 years; LR-χ2 = 6.24, P = .01, for 0-5 years; LR-χ2 = 7.89, P = .005, for 5-10 years). The prognostic value of spatial scores for late recurrence was similar to that of IHC4 and RS in both populations, but was not as strong as other tests in comparison for recurrence across 10 years. Conclusions: These results provide a missing link between tumor immunity and disease outcome in ER+ disease by examining tumor spatial architecture. The association between spatial scores and late recurrence suggests a lasting memory of protumor immunity that may impact disease progression and evolution of endocrine treatment resistance, which may be exploited for therapeutic advances.
Background: Despite increasing evidence supporting the clinical utility of immune infiltration in the estrogen receptor-negative (ER-) subtype, the prognostic value of immune infiltration for ER+ disease is not well defined. Methods: Quantitative immune scores of cell abundance and spatial heterogeneity were computed using a fully automated hematoxylin and eosin-stained image analysis algorithm and spatial statistics for 1178 postmenopausal patients with ER+ breast cancer treated with five years' tamoxifen or anastrozole. The prognostic significance of immune scores was compared with Oncotype DX 21-gene recurrence score (RS), PAM50 risk of recurrence (ROR) score, IHC4, and clinical treatment score, available for 963 patients. Statistical tests were two-sided. Results: Scores of immune cell abundance were not associated with recurrence-free survival. In contrast, high immune spatial scores indicating increased cell spatial clustering were associated with poor 10-year, early (0-5 years), and late (5-10 years) recurrence-free survival (Immune Hotspot: LR-χ2 = 14.06, P < .001, for 0-10 years; LR-χ2 = 6.24, P = .01, for 0-5 years; LR-χ2 = 7.89, P = .005, for 5-10 years). The prognostic value of spatial scores for late recurrence was similar to that of IHC4 and RS in both populations, but was not as strong as other tests in comparison for recurrence across 10 years. Conclusions: These results provide a missing link between tumor immunity and disease outcome in ER+ disease by examining tumor spatial architecture. The association between spatial scores and late recurrence suggests a lasting memory of protumor immunity that may impact disease progression and evolution of endocrine treatment resistance, which may be exploited for therapeutic advances.
Authors: Soonmyung Paik; Steven Shak; Gong Tang; Chungyeul Kim; Joffre Baker; Maureen Cronin; Frederick L Baehner; Michael G Walker; Drew Watson; Taesung Park; William Hiller; Edwin R Fisher; D Lawrence Wickerham; John Bryant; Norman Wolmark Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2004-12-10 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: R Salgado; C Denkert; S Demaria; N Sirtaine; F Klauschen; G Pruneri; S Wienert; G Van den Eynden; F L Baehner; F Penault-Llorca; E A Perez; E A Thompson; W F Symmans; A L Richardson; J Brock; C Criscitiello; H Bailey; M Ignatiadis; G Floris; J Sparano; Z Kos; T Nielsen; D L Rimm; K H Allison; J S Reis-Filho; S Loibl; C Sotiriou; G Viale; S Badve; S Adams; K Willard-Gallo; S Loi Journal: Ann Oncol Date: 2014-09-11 Impact factor: 32.976
Authors: S Loi; S Michiels; R Salgado; N Sirtaine; V Jose; D Fumagalli; P-L Kellokumpu-Lehtinen; P Bono; V Kataja; C Desmedt; M J Piccart; S Loibl; C Denkert; M J Smyth; H Joensuu; C Sotiriou Journal: Ann Oncol Date: 2014-03-07 Impact factor: 32.976
Authors: Sandra Demaria; Noriko Kawashima; Anne Marie Yang; Mary Louise Devitt; James S Babb; James P Allison; Silvia C Formenti Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2005-01-15 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Anita K Dunbier; Zara Ghazoui; Helen Anderson; Janine Salter; Ashutosh Nerurkar; Peter Osin; Roger A'hern; William R Miller; Ian E Smith; Mitch Dowsett Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2013-03-14 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Ivana Sestak; Mitch Dowsett; Lila Zabaglo; Elena Lopez-Knowles; Sean Ferree; J Wayne Cowens; Jack Cuzick Journal: J Natl Cancer Inst Date: 2013-09-12 Impact factor: 13.506
Authors: Ivana Sestak; Mitch Dowsett; Sean Ferree; Frederick L Baehner; Jack Cuzick Journal: Breast Cancer Res Treat Date: 2016-07-22 Impact factor: 4.872
Authors: Khalid El Bairi; Harry R Haynes; Elizabeth Blackley; Susan Fineberg; Jeffrey Shear; Sophia Turner; Juliana Ribeiro de Freitas; Daniel Sur; Luis Claudio Amendola; Masoumeh Gharib; Amine Kallala; Indu Arun; Farid Azmoudeh-Ardalan; Luciana Fujimoto; Luz F Sua; Shi-Wei Liu; Huang-Chun Lien; Pawan Kirtani; Marcelo Balancin; Hicham El Attar; Prerna Guleria; Wenxian Yang; Emad Shash; I-Chun Chen; Veronica Bautista; Jose Fernando Do Prado Moura; Bernardo L Rapoport; Carlos Castaneda; Eunice Spengler; Gabriela Acosta-Haab; Isabel Frahm; Joselyn Sanchez; Miluska Castillo; Najat Bouchmaa; Reena R Md Zin; Ruohong Shui; Timothy Onyuma; Wentao Yang; Zaheed Husain; Karen Willard-Gallo; An Coosemans; Edith A Perez; Elena Provenzano; Paula Gonzalez Ericsson; Eduardo Richardet; Ravi Mehrotra; Sandra Sarancone; Anna Ehinger; David L Rimm; John M S Bartlett; Giuseppe Viale; Carsten Denkert; Akira I Hida; Christos Sotiriou; Sibylle Loibl; Stephen M Hewitt; Sunil Badve; William Fraser Symmans; Rim S Kim; Giancarlo Pruneri; Shom Goel; Prudence A Francis; Gloria Inurrigarro; Rin Yamaguchi; Hernan Garcia-Rivello; Hugo Horlings; Said Afqir; Roberto Salgado; Sylvia Adams; Marleen Kok; Maria Vittoria Dieci; Stefan Michiels; Sandra Demaria; Sherene Loi Journal: NPJ Breast Cancer Date: 2021-12-01
Authors: Leisha A Emens; Sylvia Adams; Ashley Cimino-Mathews; Mary L Disis; Margaret E Gatti-Mays; Alice Y Ho; Kevin Kalinsky; Heather L McArthur; Elizabeth A Mittendorf; Rita Nanda; David B Page; Hope S Rugo; Krista M Rubin; Hatem Soliman; Patricia A Spears; Sara M Tolaney; Jennifer K Litton Journal: J Immunother Cancer Date: 2021-08 Impact factor: 13.751
Authors: Balazs Acs; David L Rimm; Yalai Bai; Kimberly Cole; Sandra Martinez-Morilla; Fahad Shabbir Ahmed; Jon Zugazagoitia; Johan Staaf; Ana Bosch; Anna Ehinger; Emma Nimeus; Johan Hartman Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2021-06-04 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Montserrat Garcia-Closas; Xiaohong Rose Yang; Mustapha Abubakar; Jing Zhang; Thomas U Ahearn; Hela Koka; Changyuan Guo; Scott M Lawrence; Karun Mutreja; Jonine D Figueroa; Jianming Ying; Jolanta Lissowska; Ning Lyu Journal: Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev Date: 2021-05-05 Impact factor: 4.090
Authors: Zheqi Li; Olivia McGinn; Yang Wu; Amir Bahreini; Nolan M Priedigkeit; Kai Ding; Sayali Onkar; Caleb Lampenfeld; Carol A Sartorius; Lori Miller; Margaret Rosenzweig; Ofir Cohen; Nikhil Wagle; Jennifer K Richer; William J Muller; Laki Buluwela; Simak Ali; Tullia C Bruno; Dario A A Vignali; Yusi Fang; Li Zhu; George C Tseng; Jason Gertz; Jennifer M Atkinson; Adrian V Lee; Steffi Oesterreich Journal: Nat Commun Date: 2022-04-19 Impact factor: 17.694