Farzaneh Pazandeh1, Barbara Potrata2, Reinhard Huss3, Janet Hirst4, Allan House5. 1. Infertility and Reproductive Health Research Centre (IRHRC), Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran; Department of Midwifery and Reproductive Health, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. Electronic address: pazandehf@gmail.com. 2. Leeds Institute of Health Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK. Electronic address: b.potrata@leeds.ac.uk. 3. Leeds Institute of Health Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK. Electronic address: r.huss@leeds.ac.uk. 4. School of Health Care, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK. Electronic address: j.hirst@leeds.ac.uk. 5. Leeds Institute of Health Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK. Electronic address: a.o.house@leeds.ac.uk.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: to understand women's experiences of routine care during labor and childbirth in a medicalised context. DESIGN: twenty-six in-depth interviews were conducted during the late postpartum period and thematic analysis was applied. SETTING: four public hospitals in Tehran with a high rate of births, providing services to low and middle income families. PARTICIPANTS: women who had a low risk pregnancies and gave a birth to a healthy infant by normal vaginal delivery. FINDINGS: two main themes emerged: 'An ethos of medicalisation' which indicates that women's perception of childbirth was influenced by the medicalised context of childbirth. And 'The reality of fostered medicalisation' which illustrates the process by which interventions during labor affected women's pathway through childbirth, and how the medicalisation resulted in a birth experience which often included a preference for Caesarean Section rather than vaginal birth with multiple interventions. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: contextual factors such as legal issues, state's regulations and the organisational framework of maternity services foster medicalised childbirth in Tehran public hospitals. These factors influence the quality of care and should be considered in any intervention for change. The aim should be a high quality birth experience with minimal interventions during normal vaginal delivery. A midwifery model of care combining scientific evidence with empathy may address this need for change.
OBJECTIVE: to understand women's experiences of routine care during labor and childbirth in a medicalised context. DESIGN: twenty-six in-depth interviews were conducted during the late postpartum period and thematic analysis was applied. SETTING: four public hospitals in Tehran with a high rate of births, providing services to low and middle income families. PARTICIPANTS: women who had a low risk pregnancies and gave a birth to a healthy infant by normal vaginal delivery. FINDINGS: two main themes emerged: 'An ethos of medicalisation' which indicates that women's perception of childbirth was influenced by the medicalised context of childbirth. And 'The reality of fostered medicalisation' which illustrates the process by which interventions during labor affected women's pathway through childbirth, and how the medicalisation resulted in a birth experience which often included a preference for Caesarean Section rather than vaginal birth with multiple interventions. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: contextual factors such as legal issues, state's regulations and the organisational framework of maternity services foster medicalised childbirth in Tehran public hospitals. These factors influence the quality of care and should be considered in any intervention for change. The aim should be a high quality birth experience with minimal interventions during normal vaginal delivery. A midwifery model of care combining scientific evidence with empathy may address this need for change.