Jennifer Morozink Boylan1, Stephanie A Robert2. 1. University of Colorado Denver, United States. Electronic address: Jennifer.boylan@ucdenver.edu. 2. University of Wisconsin-Madison, United States.
Abstract
RATIONALE: Health disparities defined by neighborhood socioeconomic status (SES) are well established; it is less well understood whether neighborhood SES is differentially associated with health depending on one's own SES. OBJECTIVE: The double jeopardy hypothesis, collective resources model, fundamental cause theory, and relative deprivation hypothesis support differential patterns of association between neighborhood and individual SES with health. The first three models suggest that higher neighborhood SES predicts health more strongly among lower, as compared to higher, SES individuals. The relative deprivation hypothesis suggests that higher SES neighborhoods bring no extra health benefit to low SES individuals and could even bring a health deficit. This study examined competing hypotheses with prospective associations between cardiovascular (CV) health and individual SES, neighborhood SES, and their interaction. METHOD: Data were from two waves of the Midlife in the United States (MIDUS) Study (N = 1012), a national survey of adults ages 25 and older at baseline. Neighborhood SES was a composite of five census tract-level SES indicators from the 1990 census. Individual SES was a composite of educational attainment and household income at wave one (1995-1996). CV health at wave two (2004-2008), was computed as a composite based on smoking status, body mass index, physical activity, diet, total cholesterol, blood pressure, and glucose. RESULTS: Individual and neighborhood SES were each associated with CV health net of baseline health status and other covariates. Interactions between individual and neighborhood SES showed that higher neighborhood SES was associated with better CV health for those of lower, not higher, individual SES. CONCLUSION: Results are consistent with the double jeopardy hypothesis, the collective resources model, and the fundamental cause theory, but not with a relative deprivation hypothesis. Results suggest that additional attention to the neighborhood socioeconomic context of lower SES individuals may reduce SES disparities in cardiovascular health.
RATIONALE: Health disparities defined by neighborhood socioeconomic status (SES) are well established; it is less well understood whether neighborhood SES is differentially associated with health depending on one's own SES. OBJECTIVE: The double jeopardy hypothesis, collective resources model, fundamental cause theory, and relative deprivation hypothesis support differential patterns of association between neighborhood and individual SES with health. The first three models suggest that higher neighborhood SES predicts health more strongly among lower, as compared to higher, SES individuals. The relative deprivation hypothesis suggests that higher SES neighborhoods bring no extra health benefit to low SES individuals and could even bring a health deficit. This study examined competing hypotheses with prospective associations between cardiovascular (CV) health and individual SES, neighborhood SES, and their interaction. METHOD: Data were from two waves of the Midlife in the United States (MIDUS) Study (N = 1012), a national survey of adults ages 25 and older at baseline. Neighborhood SES was a composite of five census tract-level SES indicators from the 1990 census. Individual SES was a composite of educational attainment and household income at wave one (1995-1996). CV health at wave two (2004-2008), was computed as a composite based on smoking status, body mass index, physical activity, diet, total cholesterol, blood pressure, and glucose. RESULTS: Individual and neighborhood SES were each associated with CV health net of baseline health status and other covariates. Interactions between individual and neighborhood SES showed that higher neighborhood SES was associated with better CV health for those of lower, not higher, individual SES. CONCLUSION: Results are consistent with the double jeopardy hypothesis, the collective resources model, and the fundamental cause theory, but not with a relative deprivation hypothesis. Results suggest that additional attention to the neighborhood socioeconomic context of lower SES individuals may reduce SES disparities in cardiovascular health.
Authors: Jens Ludwig; Lisa Sanbonmatsu; Lisa Gennetian; Emma Adam; Greg J Duncan; Lawrence F Katz; Ronald C Kessler; Jeffrey R Kling; Stacy Tessler Lindau; Robert C Whitaker; Thomas W McDade Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2011-10-20 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: William L Haskell; I-Min Lee; Russell R Pate; Kenneth E Powell; Steven N Blair; Barry A Franklin; Caroline A Macera; Gregory W Heath; Paul D Thompson; Adrian Bauman Journal: Med Sci Sports Exerc Date: 2007-08 Impact factor: 5.411
Authors: Andrew Rundle; Sam Field; Yoosun Park; Lance Freeman; Christopher C Weiss; Kathryn Neckerman Journal: Soc Sci Med Date: 2008-10-25 Impact factor: 4.634
Authors: Karen L Petersen; Anna L Marsland; Janine Flory; Elizabeth Votruba-Drzal; Matthew F Muldoon; Stephen B Manuck Journal: Psychosom Med Date: 2008-07 Impact factor: 4.312
Authors: Ahmed Tawakol; Michael T Osborne; Ying Wang; Basma Hammed; Brian Tung; Tomas Patrich; Blake Oberfeld; Amorina Ishai; Lisa M Shin; Matthias Nahrendorf; Erica T Warner; Jason Wasfy; Zahi A Fayad; Karestan Koenen; Paul M Ridker; Roger K Pitman; Katrina A Armstrong Journal: J Am Coll Cardiol Date: 2019-07-02 Impact factor: 24.094
Authors: Michelle S Wong; Sonya Gabrielian; Kristine E Lynch; Gregorio Coronado; Benjamin Viernes; Lillian Gelberg; Stephanie L Taylor Journal: Psychol Serv Date: 2021-06-03
Authors: Billy A Caceres; Veronica Barcelona; Danny Vo; Niurka Suero-Tejeda; Kasey Jackman; Jacquelyn Taylor; Elizabeth Corwin Journal: Biol Res Nurs Date: 2021-02-25 Impact factor: 2.318
Authors: Lili Zhang; Shady Abohashem; Michael T Osborne; Nicki Naddaf; Rebecca Park; Kelvin Moore; Tomas Patrich; Steven G Deeks; Priscilla Y Hsue; Ahmed A Tawakol Journal: J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Date: 2021-05-01 Impact factor: 3.771
Authors: Kaitlyn G Lawrence; Jacob K Kresovich; Katie M O'Brien; Thanh T Hoang; Zongli Xu; Jack A Taylor; Dale P Sandler Journal: JAMA Netw Open Date: 2020-11-02
Authors: Jennifer L Holmgren; Jordan A Carlson; Linda C Gallo; Aubrey L Doede; Marta M Jankowska; James F Sallis; Krista M Perreira; Lena M C Andersson; Gregory A Talavera; Sheila F Castaneda; Melawhy L Garcia; Matthew A Allison Journal: Am J Community Psychol Date: 2021-06-25