Kristen K Wolfe1, Machelle D Wilson2, Melody Y Hou1, Mitchell D Creinin3. 1. Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of California, Davis Health. 2. Department of Public Health Sciences, University of California, Davis. 3. Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of California, Davis Health. Electronic address: mdcreinin@ucdavis.edu.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To describe sterilization completion rates after vaginal delivery and indications for unfulfilled procedures. STUDY DESIGN: We used labor and delivery operating room and delivery logs to identify all women over 20years of age with a completed live vaginal birth beyond 24weeks gestation over a 33-month period (March 1, 2012 to November 30, 2014). We reviewed the electronic medical records of all of these patients and identified those who requested a sterilization procedure as indicated in a physician's admission note or antenatal record. RESULTS: We identified 3514 live vaginal births beyond 24weeks gestation during the study period of which 219 requested postpartum sterilization. Sterilization occurred in 114 (52%). The most common reason for unfulfilled procedures was lack of valid federally mandated consent (n=46 [44%]). Fifty-nine percent (27 of 46) of these women had little or no prenatal care. Only one (0.5%) woman had documented completion of consent with the required time elapsed prior to delivery and no consent form available. Of the women with valid consent documentation, the most common indication for an unfulfilled procedure was patient refusal (n=30 [51%]). Body mass index was an independent predictor of an unfulfilled procedure (p<.001) among women with adequate consent. CONCLUSIONS: Inability to complete federally mandated consent is a principal cause of unfulfilled postpartum sterilization and primarily affects women desiring sterilization who lack sufficient prenatal care. Of women who meet consent criteria, the primary reason women eligible for sterilization did not undergo the procedure was due to withdrawing their request. IMPLICATIONS: Because women commonly do not undergo a requested sterilization after vaginal deliveries, antepartum counseling should include alternate contraception choices. Documented consent that fulfills all federally mandated criteria remains the most common barrier to requested sterilization after vaginal delivery; providers and policymakers should work together to help unburden women from this mandate.
OBJECTIVE: To describe sterilization completion rates after vaginal delivery and indications for unfulfilled procedures. STUDY DESIGN: We used labor and delivery operating room and delivery logs to identify all women over 20years of age with a completed live vaginal birth beyond 24weeks gestation over a 33-month period (March 1, 2012 to November 30, 2014). We reviewed the electronic medical records of all of these patients and identified those who requested a sterilization procedure as indicated in a physician's admission note or antenatal record. RESULTS: We identified 3514 live vaginal births beyond 24weeks gestation during the study period of which 219 requested postpartum sterilization. Sterilization occurred in 114 (52%). The most common reason for unfulfilled procedures was lack of valid federally mandated consent (n=46 [44%]). Fifty-nine percent (27 of 46) of these women had little or no prenatal care. Only one (0.5%) woman had documented completion of consent with the required time elapsed prior to delivery and no consent form available. Of the women with valid consent documentation, the most common indication for an unfulfilled procedure was patient refusal (n=30 [51%]). Body mass index was an independent predictor of an unfulfilled procedure (p<.001) among women with adequate consent. CONCLUSIONS: Inability to complete federally mandated consent is a principal cause of unfulfilled postpartum sterilization and primarily affects women desiring sterilization who lack sufficient prenatal care. Of women who meet consent criteria, the primary reason women eligible for sterilization did not undergo the procedure was due to withdrawing their request. IMPLICATIONS: Because women commonly do not undergo a requested sterilization after vaginal deliveries, antepartum counseling should include alternate contraception choices. Documented consent that fulfills all federally mandated criteria remains the most common barrier to requested sterilization after vaginal delivery; providers and policymakers should work together to help unburden women from this mandate.
Authors: Amirhossein Moaddab; Laurence B McCullough; Frank A Chervenak; Karin A Fox; Kjersti Marie Aagaard; Bahram Salmanian; Susan P Raine; Alireza A Shamshirsaz Journal: Am J Obstet Gynecol Date: 2015-04-29 Impact factor: 8.661
Authors: Jane Morris; Mustafa Ascha; Barbara Wilkinson; Emily Verbus; Mary Montague; Brian M Mercer; Kavita Shah Arora Journal: Obstet Gynecol Date: 2019-12 Impact factor: 7.661
Authors: Kavita Shah Arora; Barbara Wilkinson; Emily Verbus; Mary Montague; Jane Morris; Mustafa Ascha; Brian M Mercer Journal: Contraception Date: 2018-02-25 Impact factor: 3.375
Authors: Neha A Deshpande; Amanda Labora; Mary D Sammel; Courtney A Schreiber; Sarita Sonalkar Journal: Contraception Date: 2019-05-10 Impact factor: 3.375