| Literature DB >> 28468746 |
Justine Slomian1, Patrick Emonts2, Lara Vigneron3, Alessandro Acconcia3, Jean-Yves Reginster4, Mina Oumourgh5, Olivier Bruyère1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The postnatal period is associated with many new needs for mothers.Entities:
Keywords: co-creating workshop; co-creation; mothers’ needs; postpartum needs; technological solutions
Year: 2017 PMID: 28468746 PMCID: PMC5438445 DOI: 10.2196/resprot.6831
Source DB: PubMed Journal: JMIR Res Protoc ISSN: 1929-0748
Illustrative examples of the co-creative methods used in the first workshop of the study.
| Need for information | Pros (I am completely in love with you because …) | … You understand that our demand evolves with the development of our child and you can even anticipate it. |
| … You are free and sexy, you attract me and you are available at all times. | ||
| … You allow me to be consistent with myself and you comfort me on the legitimacy of my requests which are common to other mothers. | ||
| Cons (I do not love you because …) | … You are too informative and not enough educational: I am drowning and I feel alone! | |
| … You’re always arriving at the wrong time; or too early or too late! | ||
| … You’ve maintained the myth of the ideal motherhood for too long and you lack realism, liar! Keep your false advertising for you! | ||
| Need for psychological support | Mind map (surrounded) | Listening |
| Be helped | ||
| Heat | ||
| Without prejudice | ||
| Presencea: if neededa; on demanda; to be heard | ||
| Non-judgment | ||
| Don’t forget yourself | ||
| Find time for yourself | ||
| To be understood/supported in their own experience | ||
| Need to share experience | Chinese portrait | “If I were a dish, I would be Spaghetti or Pizza because they are easy to prepare and shared in community, they require few dishes, they are not expensive ... This helps to lighten the daily life.” |
aThe most important criteria required for the development of potential solutions.
Role-playing exercises used during the second workshop.
| Scenario | Case | ||
| 1: Lea, 22 years old, living with her partner, gave birth to her first child 3 weeks ago. She is a nurse in a nursing home and does a lot of sport. | 2: Marie, 34 years old, is married and has 2 children including one of 6 years. She gave birth 6 weeks ago. She works as an employee in a pharmaceutical company. She feels alone during her maternity leave. | 3: Melissa, 30 years old, living with her partner, gave birth 2.5 months ago. She works as a waitress in a restaurant chain. | |
| 1 | She would like to share her experience to see if other women are in the same situation and see if what she is experiencing is normal. | ||
| 2 | She needs information about breastfeeding because her baby does not drink enough. | ||
| 3 | She feels overwhelmed by all the tasks of daily life and she is no longer able to take some time for herself. | ||
| 4 | She feels that her husband is not paying enough attention to her and that he is not invested enough since the birth of the baby. | ||
| 5 | She finds that the opinions of the different professionals she consults are different (sometimes even opposed). She tries to apply exactly everything they said (changing at each consultation) and therefore, she feels completely lost. | ||
| 6 | She must start working in 3 weeks but has not found a childcare system yet. She is panicking about the idea of leaving her baby to someone. | ||
| 7 | Her gynecologist advised her to do postnatal physiotherapy, but she does not know any physiotherapist in this field. Her friends have no children yet and do not know how to help her. | ||
Figure 1Diagram of the progression from the workshop 1 comments to the workshop 2 solutions.
List of criteria that proposed solution must meet.
| Criteria | Importance | |
| Be accepted without judgement in distress | ●●●●●●●● (8) | |
| Empathy, dramatization, lightness | ●●●●●●● (7) | |
| Comfort into “my normality,” “legitimacy of my requests” | ●●●●● (5) | |
| No judgement | ● (1) | |
| Restore confidence in myself | ● (1) | |
| Be reassured | ● (1) | |
| Be understood | ● (1) | |
| Sharing experiences of mothers | ●●●●●● (6) | |
| Comfort into “my normality,” “legitimacy of my requests” | ●●●●● (5) | |
| Counterpoint to the collective ideal | ●● (2) | |
| Self-mockery | ● (1) | |
| Presence | ●●●● (4) | |
| To anticipate needs and meet them | ●●●● (4) | |
| Nonintrusive | ●● (2) | |
| Be surrounded | ● (1) | |
| The weakest people in the middle | ● (1) | |
| <3 (= heart, love) | ● (1) | |
| Lightening daily life | ●●●●●● (6) | |
| To let go | ●●●●●● (6) | |
| Do not forget yourself | ●●●●● (5) | |
| Loophole, wellness, serenity | ●●● (3) | |
| Inspiring | ●● (2) | |
| A change of scenery | ● (1) | |
| Costume made | ●●●●●●●●● (9) | |
| Home visits | ●●●●● (5) | |
| We interpret it as we want | ●●●● (4) | |
| Do not forget the father: male perspective too | ●●● (3) | |
| You adapt yourself depending on me | ● (1) | |
| Available at all times | ●●●●●●● (6) | |
| Attractive and accessible | ●● (2) | |
| Free | ● (1) | |
| Timeliness of responses | ● (1) | |
| Modern (online) and reliable | ● (1) | |
| If needed | ●●●● (4) | |
| Identify times when a solution is needed | ● (1) | |
| Identification of unexpressed needs | ● (1) | |
| On demand | ● (1) | |
| Contact from the beginning (since the beginning of pregnancy) | ●● (2) | |
| Informal format, flexible | ●●●●●●● (7) | |
| With multiple entry points (eg, time route, keywords, experiences) | ●●●●● (5) | |
| Quiet: “we can take the time” | ●●●● (4) | |
| Language adapted at a social level | ●●● (3) | |
| Comprehension and interpretation of the questions | ●● (2) | |
| Scalable request | ●● (2) | |
| Pedagogy decision support, enlightened information | ● (1) | |
| Colored | ● (1) | |
Solutions discussed during the second workshop by the technology experts.
| Proposed solutions | Explanations of the solutions given by the experts |
| Videoconferencing system | “Women expressed a great need for information; thus, the goal of this solution would be to provide the most interactive and comprehensive responses. This approach would consist of filming experts speaking on a topic. This solution could provide access to tutorials, testimony, or to a ‘call center’ run by midwives (eg, videophone) and could also then meet the needs of shared experiences and psychological support. Indeed, midwives are able to say, thanks to their great experience with others mothers, if what a mother lives is normal or not.” |
| Online newsletter preprogrammed | “Some newsletters in paper form that mothers can receive by post already exist. These newsletters provide information corresponding to child development. The experts suggested transforming these ‘paper newsletters’ into ‘IT newsletters’. This concept would lead to a reduction in the cost of paper and provide the opportunity to create alerts corresponding with the baby’s age. The goal of this solution is to anticipate mothers’ questions.” |
| Apps compatible with existing ecosystems (eg, ) | “These applications consist of integrating data from a sensor that could be programmed to respond to the needs of mothers. For example, sensors could be used to study the baby’s sleep quality, the temperature of the baby’s room or the walk of the mother. Warning messages may also be sent when a mother walks too much or too little. Information messages could also be transmitted directly to the mother to reassure her and to decrease the level of stress caused by the arrival of a child.” |
| Virtual reality apps (eg, serious gaming) | “The experts suggested establishing some virtual scenarios to prepare mothers to learn how to become a mother (eg, deal virtually with life situations with a baby). Nevertheless, they felt that it was quite difficult to implement this solution because it would suggest an evaluation of mothers, and no one was qualified to do so. Mothers might feel judged or would compare themselves with other mothers.” |
| Extension of the Uber concept | “Uber is an intermediation platform linking users and service providers. This platform allows a request to a specialist when needed. The experts in our study believed that such a platform could connect mothers with midwives, physiotherapists, osteopaths, housekeepers, babysitters, etc.” |
| Online exchange groups (eg, Weightwatchers and Alcoholics Anonymous) | “Our previous study, evaluating the needs of mothers in the year following childbirth, showed that women are not really satisfied by forums or Facebook groups especially because there are a lot of French or Canadian mothers on these groups who live in a different environment with a different culture. Women were looking for mothers living in their area, who gave birth in the same hospital or who have the same doctor. Therefore, the experts came up with the idea of some online exchange groups where women could find mothers from their neighborhood. These online exchange groups would be created by the hospital or by a health professional to try to bring together mothers by region. With these systems, mothers would know that they are not alone.” |
| Geolocation | “Finding people close to home was deemed very interesting. Indeed, on the Internet, mothers can find people from all over (from different cities or even different countries). Geolocation would provide the possibility of finding a professional near home or to organize meetings with mothers in one region.” |
| Forums dedicated to the postpartum period, supervised by professionals | “Our previous study showed that many mothers’ forums already exist and are largely used by a lot of mothers, but they do not find them really reliable. These forums must be supervised by professionals if we want to make sure that the information given is of quality. Such geolocation-associated forums could better inform mothers with infants about meetings, which are often very poorly advertised.” |
| Centralized website dedicated to the postpartum period | “Our experts imagined a website that could address most of the questions mothers ask themselves (eg, give them information they need such as details about places where they can go with their baby). Such a website could target both mothers and fathers, meet the need for information, and also help parents find the people or professionals they need. The experts imagined that professionals could advise this website to the mothers they care for. They saw this website as intermediary middle for carers or directly for mothers during the postpartum period, but not as a substitute for professionals.” |
| “Sponsorship” system | “Every mother would have a ‘godmother’ assigned. The principle of this system would be to sponsor each young mother with a more experienced mother from the same city. The two mothers could chat online or meet (based on their desire/situation). Our experts suggested a non-profit association, which would be the first point of contact for every young mother who needs a referral or to talk with someone experienced.” |
| Centralized website dedicated to babysitting systems | “Finding a babysitting solution induces stress for many mothers. To avoid having to phone each facility and to be registered on all waiting lists, the experts envisioned a website that mothers could visit to see a list of available spots at each day nursery.” |
| Zora robotics | “Currently designed to support the elderly, such a robot could accompany mothers to fight loneliness and to provide them some psychological support.” |
| Augmented reality glasses | “Relaxation programs through virtual reality or augmented reality allow the mother to go into states of ‘total de-stress’ (eg, by putting on glasses, the mother finds herself at the sea, mountains, or wherever she wants to go for 20 minutes a day). These glasses can be rented, and this system would help meet the need to escape.” |
| “Gift vouchers” system | “Although the need for practical and material support was not explored, the idea of a ‘gift voucher’ system was outlined during the workshop. The experts thought about a system that already exists in Canada. This system invites family or friends of the parents to offer them some help with housework (eg, ironing, cooking, household chores). For example, a friend could offer two hours of ironing to the new mothers instead of a new cuddly toy.” |
| Miscellaneous | The experts also spoke about a cradle that automatically rocks the baby (which already exists) or connecting together mothers, who are living with postnatal depression. |