Lara M J Lorenzetti1, Sheila Leatherman1, Valerie L Flax2. 1. Department of Health Policy & Management, Gillings School of Global Public Health, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, NC, USA. 2. Department of Nutrition, Gillings School of Global Public Health, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, RTI International, NC, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Solutions delivered within firm sectoral boundaries are inadequate in achieving income security and better health for poor populations. Integrated microfinance and health interventions leverage networks of women to promote financial inclusion, build livelihoods, and safeguard against high cost illnesses. Our understanding of the effect of integrated interventions has been limited by variability in intervention, outcome, design, and methodological rigour. This systematic review synthesises the literature through 2015 to understand the effect of integrated microfinance and health programs. METHODS: We searched PubMed, Scopus, Embase, EconLit, and Global Health databases and sourced bibliographies, identifying 964 articles exclusive of duplicates. Title, abstract, and full text review yielded 35 articles. Articles evaluated the effect of intentionally integrated microfinance and health programs on client outcomes. We rated the quality of evidence for each article. RESULTS: Most interventions combined microfinance with health education, which demonstrated positive effects on health knowledge and behaviours, though not health status. Among programs that integrated microfinance with other health components ( i.e. health micro-insurance, linkages to health providers, and access to health products), results were generally positive but mixed due to the smaller number and quality of studies. Interventions combining multiple health components in a given study demonstrated positive effects, though it was unclear which component was driving the effect. Most articles (57%) were moderate in quality. DISCUSSION: Integrated microfinance and health education programs were effective, though longer intervention periods are necessary to measure more complex pathways to health status. The effect of microfinance combined with other health components was less clear. Stronger randomized research designs with multiple study arms are required to improve evidence and disentangle the effects of multiple component microfinance and health interventions. Few studies attempted to understand changes in economic outcomes, limiting our understanding of the relationship between health and income effects.
BACKGROUND: Solutions delivered within firm sectoral boundaries are inadequate in achieving income security and better health for poor populations. Integrated microfinance and health interventions leverage networks of women to promote financial inclusion, build livelihoods, and safeguard against high cost illnesses. Our understanding of the effect of integrated interventions has been limited by variability in intervention, outcome, design, and methodological rigour. This systematic review synthesises the literature through 2015 to understand the effect of integrated microfinance and health programs. METHODS: We searched PubMed, Scopus, Embase, EconLit, and Global Health databases and sourced bibliographies, identifying 964 articles exclusive of duplicates. Title, abstract, and full text review yielded 35 articles. Articles evaluated the effect of intentionally integrated microfinance and health programs on client outcomes. We rated the quality of evidence for each article. RESULTS: Most interventions combined microfinance with health education, which demonstrated positive effects on health knowledge and behaviours, though not health status. Among programs that integrated microfinance with other health components ( i.e. health micro-insurance, linkages to health providers, and access to health products), results were generally positive but mixed due to the smaller number and quality of studies. Interventions combining multiple health components in a given study demonstrated positive effects, though it was unclear which component was driving the effect. Most articles (57%) were moderate in quality. DISCUSSION: Integrated microfinance and health education programs were effective, though longer intervention periods are necessary to measure more complex pathways to health status. The effect of microfinance combined with other health components was less clear. Stronger randomized research designs with multiple study arms are required to improve evidence and disentangle the effects of multiple component microfinance and health interventions. Few studies attempted to understand changes in economic outcomes, limiting our understanding of the relationship between health and income effects.
Authors: Rajesh Vedanthan; Jemima H Kamano; Stavroula A Chrysanthopoulou; Richard Mugo; Benjamin Andama; Gerald S Bloomfield; Cleophas W Chesoli; Allison K DeLong; David Edelman; Eric A Finkelstein; Carol R Horowitz; Simon Manyara; Diana Menya; Violet Naanyu; Vitalis Orango; Sonak D Pastakia; Thomas W Valente; Joseph W Hogan; Valentin Fuster Journal: J Am Coll Cardiol Date: 2021-04-27 Impact factor: 27.203
Authors: S Chandrashekar; S Saha; B Varghese; L Mohan; G Shetty; A Porwal; A Hazra; S Mondal; R Das Journal: PLoS One Date: 2019-03-28 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Sapna Desai; Kala M Mehta; Roopal Jyoti Singh; Allie K Westley; Osasuyi Dirisu; Connie Wong; Thomas De Hoop; Gary L Darmstadt Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2021-07-12 Impact factor: 2.692
Authors: Lauren Y Maldonado; Julia J Songok; John W Snelgrove; Christian B Ochieng; Sheilah Chelagat; Justus E Ikemeri; Monica A Okwanyi; Donald C Cole; Laura J Ruhl; Astrid Christoffersen-Deb Journal: BMC Pregnancy Childbirth Date: 2020-05-12 Impact factor: 3.007
Authors: Claudia L Leung; Mackenzie Naert; Benjamin Andama; Rae Dong; David Edelman; Carol Horowitz; Peninah Kiptoo; Simon Manyara; Winnie Matelong; Esther Matini; Violet Naanyu; Sarah Nyariki; Sonak Pastakia; Thomas Valente; Valentin Fuster; Gerald S Bloomfield; Jemima Kamano; Rajesh Vedanthan Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2020-05-12 Impact factor: 2.655
Authors: Molly Rosenberg; James Akiruga Amisi; Daria Szkwarko; Dan N Tran; Becky Genberg; Maya Luetke; Sina Kianersi; Jane Namae; Jeremiah Laktabai; Sonak Pastakia Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2020-09-14 Impact factor: 2.655