John B Holcomb1, Michael D Swartz, Stacia M DeSantis, Thomas J Greene, Erin E Fox, Deborah M Stein, Eileen M Bulger, Jeffrey D Kerby, Michael Goodman, Martin A Schreiber, Martin D Zielinski, Terence O'Keeffe, Kenji Inaba, Jeffrey S Tomasek, Jeanette M Podbielski, Savitri N Appana, Misung Yi, Charles E Wade. 1. From the Center for Translational Injury Research (J.B.H., M.D.S., E.E.F., J.S.T., J.M.P., C.E.W.), Division of Acute Care Surgery, Department of Surgery, Medical School, Department of Biostatistics, School of Public Health (M.D.S., S.M.D., T.J.G., S.A., M.Y.), University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston, Houston, Texas; R Adams Cowley Shock Trauma Center, Program in Trauma (D.M.S.), University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland; Division of Trauma and Critical Care, Department of Surgery (E.M.B.), School of Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington; Division of Trauma, Burns and Surgical Critical Care, Department of Surgery (J.D.K.), School of Medicine, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama; Division of Trauma/Critical Care, Department of Surgery (M.G.), College of Medicine, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio; Division of Trauma, Critical Care and Acute Care Surgery (M.A.S.), School of Medicine, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, Oregon; Division of Trauma, Critical Care, and General Surgery (M.D.Z.), Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota; Division of Trauma, Critical Care and Emergency Surgery (T.O'K.), Department of Surgery, University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona; and Division of Trauma and Critical Care (K.I.), University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Earlier use of in-hospital plasma, platelets, and red blood cells (RBCs) has improved survival in trauma patients with severe hemorrhage. Retrospective studies have associated improved early survival with prehospital blood product transfusion (PHT). We hypothesized that PHT of plasma and/or RBCs would result in improved survival after injury in patients transported by helicopter. METHODS: Adult trauma patients transported by helicopter from the scene to nine Level 1 trauma centers were prospectively observed from January to November 2015. Five helicopter systems had plasma and/or RBCs, whereas the other four helicopter systems used only crystalloid resuscitation. All patients meeting predetermined high-risk criteria were analyzed. Patients receiving PHT were compared with patients not receiving PHT. Our primary analysis compared mortality at 3 hours, 24 hours, and 30 days, using logistic regression to adjust for confounders and site heterogeneity to model patients who were matched on propensity scores. RESULTS: Twenty-five thousand one hundred eighteen trauma patients were admitted, 2,341 (9%) were transported by helicopter, of which 1,058 (45%) met the highest-risk criteria. Five hundred eighty-five of 1,058 patients were flown on helicopters carrying blood products. In the systems with blood available, prehospital median systolic blood pressure (125 vs 128) and Glasgow Coma Scale (7 vs 14) was significantly lower, whereas median Injury Severity Score was significantly higher (21 vs 14). Unadjusted mortality was significantly higher in the systems with blood products available, at 3 hours (8.4% vs 3.6%), 24 hours (12.6% vs 8.9%), and 30 days (19.3% vs 13.3%). Twenty-four percent of eligible patients received a PHT. A median of 1 unit of RBCs and plasma were transfused prehospital. Of patients receiving PHT, 24% received only plasma, 7% received only RBCs, and 69% received both. In the propensity score matching analysis (n = 109), PHT was not significantly associated with mortality at any time point, although only 10% of the high-risk sample were able to be matched. CONCLUSION: Because of the unexpected imbalance in systolic blood pressure, Glasgow Coma Scale, and Injury Severity Score between systems with and without blood products on helicopters, matching was limited, and the results of this study are inconclusive. With few units transfused to each patient and small outcome differences between groups, it is likely large, multicenter, randomized studies will be required to detect survival differences in this important population. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II.
BACKGROUND: Earlier use of in-hospital plasma, platelets, and red blood cells (RBCs) has improved survival in traumapatients with severe hemorrhage. Retrospective studies have associated improved early survival with prehospital blood product transfusion (PHT). We hypothesized that PHT of plasma and/or RBCs would result in improved survival after injury in patients transported by helicopter. METHODS: Adult traumapatients transported by helicopter from the scene to nine Level 1 trauma centers were prospectively observed from January to November 2015. Five helicopter systems had plasma and/or RBCs, whereas the other four helicopter systems used only crystalloid resuscitation. All patients meeting predetermined high-risk criteria were analyzed. Patients receiving PHT were compared with patients not receiving PHT. Our primary analysis compared mortality at 3 hours, 24 hours, and 30 days, using logistic regression to adjust for confounders and site heterogeneity to model patients who were matched on propensity scores. RESULTS: Twenty-five thousand one hundred eighteen traumapatients were admitted, 2,341 (9%) were transported by helicopter, of which 1,058 (45%) met the highest-risk criteria. Five hundred eighty-five of 1,058 patients were flown on helicopters carrying blood products. In the systems with blood available, prehospital median systolic blood pressure (125 vs 128) and Glasgow Coma Scale (7 vs 14) was significantly lower, whereas median Injury Severity Score was significantly higher (21 vs 14). Unadjusted mortality was significantly higher in the systems with blood products available, at 3 hours (8.4% vs 3.6%), 24 hours (12.6% vs 8.9%), and 30 days (19.3% vs 13.3%). Twenty-four percent of eligible patients received a PHT. A median of 1 unit of RBCs and plasma were transfused prehospital. Of patients receiving PHT, 24% received only plasma, 7% received only RBCs, and 69% received both. In the propensity score matching analysis (n = 109), PHT was not significantly associated with mortality at any time point, although only 10% of the high-risk sample were able to be matched. CONCLUSION: Because of the unexpected imbalance in systolic blood pressure, Glasgow Coma Scale, and Injury Severity Score between systems with and without blood products on helicopters, matching was limited, and the results of this study are inconclusive. With few units transfused to each patient and small outcome differences between groups, it is likely large, multicenter, randomized studies will be required to detect survival differences in this important population. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II.
Authors: John B Holcomb; Don Jenkins; Peter Rhee; Jay Johannigman; Peter Mahoney; Sumeru Mehta; E Darrin Cox; Michael J Gehrke; Greg J Beilman; Martin Schreiber; Stephen F Flaherty; Kurt W Grathwohl; Phillip C Spinella; Jeremy G Perkins; Alec C Beekley; Neil R McMullin; Myung S Park; Ernest A Gonzalez; Charles E Wade; Michael A Dubick; C William Schwab; Fred A Moore; Howard R Champion; David B Hoyt; John R Hess Journal: J Trauma Date: 2007-02
Authors: Beth H Shaz; Christopher J Dente; Jeffrey Nicholas; Jana B MacLeod; Andrew N Young; Kirk Easley; Qiang Ling; Robert S Harris; Christopher D Hillyer Journal: Transfusion Date: 2009-10-05 Impact factor: 3.157
Authors: Jeremy G Perkins; Andrew P Cap; Cap P Andrew; Philip C Spinella; Lorne H Blackbourne; Kurt W Grathwohl; Thomas B Repine; Lloyd Ketchum; Paige Waterman; Ruth E Lee; Alec C Beekley; James A Sebesta; Andrew F Shorr; Charles E Wade; John B Holcomb Journal: J Trauma Date: 2009-04
Authors: Juan C Duchesne; John P Hunt; Georgia Wahl; Alan B Marr; Yi-Zarn Wang; Sharon E Weintraub; Mary J O Wright; Norman E McSwain Journal: J Trauma Date: 2008-08
Authors: Matthew A Borgman; Philip C Spinella; Jeremy G Perkins; Kurt W Grathwohl; Thomas Repine; Alec C Beekley; James Sebesta; Donald Jenkins; Charles E Wade; John B Holcomb Journal: J Trauma Date: 2007-10
Authors: John B Holcomb; Charles E Wade; Joel E Michalek; Gary B Chisholm; Lee Ann Zarzabal; Martin A Schreiber; Ernest A Gonzalez; Gregory J Pomper; Jeremy G Perkins; Phillip C Spinella; Kari L Williams; Myung S Park Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2008-09 Impact factor: 12.969
Authors: John A Harvin; John P Sharpe; Martin A Croce; Michael D Goodman; Timothy A Pritts; Elizabeth D Dauer; Benjamin J Moran; Rachel D Rodriguez; Ben L Zarzaur; Laura A Kreiner; Jeffrey A Claridge; John B Holcomb Journal: J Trauma Acute Care Surg Date: 2019-07 Impact factor: 3.313
Authors: Hunter B Moore; Ernest E Moore; Michael P Chapman; Kevin McVaney; Gary Bryskiewicz; Robert Blechar; Theresa Chin; Clay Cothren Burlew; Fredric Pieracci; F Bernadette West; Courtney D Fleming; Arsen Ghasabyan; James Chandler; Christopher C Silliman; Anirban Banerjee; Angela Sauaia Journal: Lancet Date: 2018-07-20 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Stacia M DeSantis; Michael D Swartz; Thomas J Greene; Erin E Fox; John B Holcomb; Charles E Wade Journal: J Trauma Acute Care Surg Date: 2020-02 Impact factor: 3.697
Authors: David N Naumann; James M Hancox; James Raitt; Iain M Smith; Nicholas Crombie; Heidi Doughty; Gavin D Perkins; Mark J Midwinter Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2018-01-23 Impact factor: 2.692
Authors: Stacy A Shackelford; Deborah J Del Junco; Nicole Powell-Dunford; Edward L Mazuchowski; Jeffrey T Howard; Russ S Kotwal; Jennifer Gurney; Frank K Butler; Kirby Gross; Zsolt T Stockinger Journal: JAMA Date: 2017-10-24 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Thomas J Greene; Stacia M DeSantis; Erin E Fox; Charles E Wade; John B Holcomb; Michael D Swartz Journal: Mil Med Date: 2018-03-01 Impact factor: 1.437