Literature DB >> 28273982

Method Comparison (Agreement) Studies: Myths and Rationale.

Ajay G Phatak1, Somashekhar M Nimbalkar2.   

Abstract

Unprecedented technological growth in the last quarter of twentieth century has resulted in improved health care and opened new domains of health care research. This technological leap also facilitated the paradigm shift from hospital care to home care through development of 'point of care' devices. As early diagnoses and timely referral is a key to health management, these devices play an important role in improving health. Validation of the new technology in different settings is necessary before adopting it to practice. For a binary result like pregnancy test, it is trivial to use statistical tools like sensitivity, specificity etc. For a continuous variable like blood glucose level the analysis is not straightforward. Many of us misinterpret 'association' as 'agreement'. This misinterpretation is reflected in studies which have compared two different technologies. The findings of well conducted studies do not contribute to the evidence base just because of wrong analysis strategy. We delineate on finer nuances of analysis and interpretation of method comparison studies.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Agreement; Association; Bland-Altman; Correlation; Method Comparison

Year:  2017        PMID: 28273982      PMCID: PMC5324427          DOI: 10.7860/JCDR/2017/23897.9314

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Clin Diagn Res        ISSN: 0973-709X


  19 in total

Review 1.  Measuring agreement in method comparison studies.

Authors:  J M Bland; D G Altman
Journal:  Stat Methods Med Res       Date:  1999-06       Impact factor: 3.021

2.  Performance of non-contact infrared thermometer for detecting febrile children in hospital and ambulatory settings.

Authors:  Elena Chiappini; Sara Sollai; Riccardo Longhi; Liana Morandini; Anna Laghi; Catia Emilia Osio; Mario Persiani; Silvia Lonati; Raffaella Picchi; Francesca Bonsignori; Francesco Mannelli; Luisa Galli; Maurizio de Martino
Journal:  J Clin Nurs       Date:  2011-05       Impact factor: 3.036

3.  Quantitation of HIV-1 RNA in dried blood spots by the real-time NucliSENS EasyQ HIV-1 assay in Senegal.

Authors:  Coumba Toure Kane; Halimatou Diop Ndiaye; Sada Diallo; Ibrahima Ndiaye; Abdoulaye Sidibé Wade; Papa Alassane Diaw; Aïssatou Gaye-Diallo; Souleymane Mboup
Journal:  J Virol Methods       Date:  2008-02-01       Impact factor: 2.014

Review 4.  Design, analysis, and interpretation of method-comparison studies.

Authors:  Sandra K Hanneman
Journal:  AACN Adv Crit Care       Date:  2008 Apr-Jun

5.  Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement.

Authors:  J M Bland; D G Altman
Journal:  Lancet       Date:  1986-02-08       Impact factor: 79.321

6.  Accuracy of non-contact infrared thermometry versus rectal thermometry in young children evaluated in the emergency department for fever.

Authors:  Ezio L Fortuna; Michele M Carney; Michelle Macy; Rachel M Stanley; John G Younger; Stuart A Bradin
Journal:  J Emerg Nurs       Date:  2009-09-03       Impact factor: 1.836

7.  Which is More Accurate in Measuring the Blood Pressure? A Digital or an Aneroid Sphygmomanometer.

Authors:  Bhaskar Shahbabu; Aparajita Dasgupta; Kaushik Sarkar; Sanjaya Kumar Sahoo
Journal:  J Clin Diagn Res       Date:  2016-03-01

8.  Comparison of temporal artery, mid-forehead skin and axillary temperature recordings in preterm infants <1500 g of birthweight.

Authors:  Ridvan Duran; Ulfet Vatansever; Betül Acunaş; Necdet Süt
Journal:  J Paediatr Child Health       Date:  2009 Jul-Aug       Impact factor: 1.954

9.  Evaluation of the NucliSens EasyQ HIV-1 v1.1 and RealTime HIV-1 kits for quantitation of HIV-1 RNA in plasma.

Authors:  Ju-yeon Choi; Eun-Jin Kim; Hyun Joo Rho; Jin Young Kim; Oh-Kyung Kwon; Jin-Hee Lee; Min Jee Koo; Sung Soon Kim
Journal:  J Virol Methods       Date:  2009-02-12       Impact factor: 2.014

10.  Comparison of HIV-1 RNA level estimated with plasma and DBS samples: a pilot study from India (South).

Authors:  S David; J Sachithanandham; J Jerobin; S Parasuram; R Kannangai
Journal:  Indian J Med Microbiol       Date:  2012 Oct-Dec       Impact factor: 0.985

View more
  3 in total

1.  Body temperature in premature infants during the first week of life: Exploration using infrared thermal imaging.

Authors:  Robin B Knobel-Dail; Diane Holditch-Davis; Richard Sloane; B D Guenther; Laurence M Katz
Journal:  J Therm Biol       Date:  2017-06-15       Impact factor: 2.902

2.  Use and reporting of Bland-Altman analyses in studies of self-reported versus measured weight and height.

Authors:  Katherine M Flegal; Barry Graubard; John P A Ioannidis
Journal:  Int J Obes (Lond)       Date:  2019-12-02       Impact factor: 5.095

3.  Estimating physical activity and sedentary behaviour in a free-living environment: A comparative study between Fitbit Charge 2 and Actigraph GT3X.

Authors:  Marie-Louise K Mikkelsen; Gabriele Berg-Beckhoff; Peder Frederiksen; Graham Horgan; Ruairi O'Driscoll; António L Palmeira; Sarah E Scott; James Stubbs; Berit L Heitmann; Sofus C Larsen
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2020-06-11       Impact factor: 3.240

  3 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.