OBJECTIVE: We designed a questionnaire to collect data on surgeons' views and experiences of operating on friends or relatives. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: A link to a 38-item online survey was sent to all 16,849 members of the Professional Board of German Surgeons (Bund Deutscher Chirurgen, BDC) several times. Standard interview software was used. The questionnaire collected a wide variety of information concerning how surgeons have experienced, think about, and deal with the situation when they operate on friends or relatives. RESULTS: Of the 16,849 BDC members notified of the survey, 1,643 completed the questionnaires (9.8%). Of these, 1,275 (77.6%) had previously performed surgery on friends or relatives. Overall, the surgeons willingly accepted doing so without experiencing any difficulties. However, the surgeons frequently used different techniques when operating on friends and relatives (123 [10%] when self-assessed compared to 527 [35%] when observed by others). Out of the whole sample, 506 (30.8%) would appreciate having a guideline or ethical code and 370 (41.2%) of those who have not yet operated on friends and relatives would like to have such an ethical code. CONCLUSION: Most of the surgeons who responded accepted the task of operating on friends or relatives. Performing surgery on friends or relatives was a complex matter because objectivity was not guaranteed. Negative implications on personal relationships were rare. We recommend that this matter should be well considered and discussed with the patient and an ethical guideline or code should be created.
OBJECTIVE: We designed a questionnaire to collect data on surgeons' views and experiences of operating on friends or relatives. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: A link to a 38-item online survey was sent to all 16,849 members of the Professional Board of German Surgeons (Bund Deutscher Chirurgen, BDC) several times. Standard interview software was used. The questionnaire collected a wide variety of information concerning how surgeons have experienced, think about, and deal with the situation when they operate on friends or relatives. RESULTS: Of the 16,849 BDC members notified of the survey, 1,643 completed the questionnaires (9.8%). Of these, 1,275 (77.6%) had previously performed surgery on friends or relatives. Overall, the surgeons willingly accepted doing so without experiencing any difficulties. However, the surgeons frequently used different techniques when operating on friends and relatives (123 [10%] when self-assessed compared to 527 [35%] when observed by others). Out of the whole sample, 506 (30.8%) would appreciate having a guideline or ethical code and 370 (41.2%) of those who have not yet operated on friends and relatives would like to have such an ethical code. CONCLUSION: Most of the surgeons who responded accepted the task of operating on friends or relatives. Performing surgery on friends or relatives was a complex matter because objectivity was not guaranteed. Negative implications on personal relationships were rare. We recommend that this matter should be well considered and discussed with the patient and an ethical guideline or code should be created.
Authors: Katherine J Gold; Edward B Goldman; Leslie H Kamil; Sarah Walton; Tommy G Burdette; Kathryn L Moseley Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2014-09-25 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Marieke Zegers; Martine C de Bruijne; Bertus de Keizer; Hanneke Merten; Peter P Groenewegen; Gerrit van der Wal; Cordula Wagner Journal: Patient Saf Surg Date: 2011-05-20
Authors: Natalie Alida Mücke; Alexandra Schmidt; Christine Kersting; Vera Kalitzkus; Michael Pentzek; Stefan Wilm; Achim Mortsiefer Journal: BMC Prim Care Date: 2022-02-03