| Literature DB >> 27936006 |
Rubin Luo1, Jian Hu1, Libing Jiang1, Mao Zhang1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: RDW (red cell distribution width) has been reported to been associated with the prognosis of patients with cardiovascular diseases. However, RDW is often overlooked by clinicians in treating patients with non-cardiovascular diseases, especially in an emergency. The objective of this systematic review is to explore the prognostic value of RDW in non-cardiovascular emergencies.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2016 PMID: 27936006 PMCID: PMC5147853 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0167000
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Fig 1Flowchart of study selection.
Characteristics of Included Studies.
| Study/Year | Study Design | Population | No. Total | Age, Yr | Male (%) | RDW Categorization | Outcomes Assessed | Type of Analysis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wang et al.[ | Prospective, single center | Adult ICU patients | 602 | Mean:70.39 | 58.1 | Continuous (per 1% increase); Ordered Categorical (11.2 -13. 4%, 13.5-14.6%, 14.7-26.9%) | Primary: ICU mortality Secondary: length of hospital stay | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Bazick et al. [ | Retrospective, multiple center | Adult critically ill patients | 51413 | Mean:61.7 | 58.21 | Ordered Categorical (≤13.3%, 13.3-14%, 14-14.7%, 14.7-15.8%, >15.8%) | Primary:30-day mortality Secondary: 90-day, 365- day, in-hospital mortality and blood stream infection | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Hunziker et al. [ | Retrospective, multiple center | Adult ICU patients | 17922 | Mean:63.2 | 56.9 | Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary: in-hospital mortality Secondary: ICU mortality and 1-year mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Meynaar et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Adult ICU patients | 2915 | Mean:65.1 | 57.15 | Continuous (per 1% increase), Ordered Categorical (<43.2fl, 43.2-46.09fl, 46.1-49.69fl, >49.7fl | Primary: in-hospital mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Zhang et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Adult ICU patients | 1539 | Mean:61.8 | 65.35 | Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary: in-hospital mortality Secondary: ICU length of stay | Multivariable analysis |
| Hatice et al. 2015/[ | Retrospective, single center | Adult ICU patients with community acquired intra- abdominal sepsis | 103 | Mean: 64 | 53.4 | Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary: hospital mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Sadaka et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Adult sepsis patients | 279 | Mean:67.4 | 51.4 | Continuous (per 1% increase), Ordered Categorical (<13.5%, 13.5-15.5%, 15.6-17.5%, 17.6-19.4%, >19.4%) | Primary: in-hospital mortality Secondary: ICU mortality | Multivariable analysis |
| Jo et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Adult sepsis and septic shock patients | 566 | Mean:70 | 55.5 | Ordered Categorical(≤14, 14.1-15.7, ≥15.8) | Primary:28-day mortality Secondary: the rate of positive blood culture, renal replacement therapy, and admission to ICU | Multivariable Cox analysis |
| Tian et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Adult septic shock patients | 132 | Mean of survivor: 69.28, Mean of nonsurvivor: 74.42 | 65.2 | Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary:28-day mortality | Multivariable analysis |
| Chen et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Adult septic shock patients | 219 | Mean:69.89 | 59.4 | Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary:90-day mortality | Multivariable Cox analysis |
| Lee et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with CAP (age>18y) | 744 | Mean:70.1 | 32 | Ordered Categorical (≤13.3%, 13.3-14.1%, 14.1-15.2%, >15.2%) | Primary:30-day mortality Secondary: hospital length of stay, use of vasopressors, ICU admission and mechanical ventilator requirement | Multivariable regression/Cox analysis |
| Braun et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with CAP (age>18y) | 3815 | Median:70 | 56.4 | Binary (≤15% vs >15%) | Primary:90-day mortality Secondary: complicated hospitalization(defined as at least one of the following: In- hospital mortality, length of stay of at least 10 days or ICU admission) | Multivariable analysis |
| Ku et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with Gram- negative bacteremia | 161 | Mean:64.98 | 44.7 | Binary (≤14.6% vs >14.6%) Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary:28-day mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable Cox analysis |
| Seyhan et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients diagnosed with COPD | 270 | Mean: 61 | 77 | Binary (≤15.5% vs >15.5%) Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary: mortality. Median follow-up was 36 months. | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Guray et al. [ | Retrospective, multiple center | Patients diagnosed with definite infective endocarditis | 100 | Mean: 47.8 | 61 | Binary (≤15.3% vs >15.3%) | Primary:1-year mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable Cox analysis |
| Kim et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Out-of- hospital cardiac arrest victims | 219 | 62.1 | Ordered Categorical (≤13.1%, 13.2-14.%, 14.1-15.4%, >15.5%) | Primary:30-day mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable cox analysis | |
| Oh et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with AKI who were treated with CRRT | 470 | Mean of RDW<14.6% 62.8; RDW≥14.6%, 61.5 | RDW<14.6%, 66; RDW≥14.6%, 63.7 | Binary (<14.6% vs ≥14.6%) Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary:28-day mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable cox analysis |
| Hong et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with acute dyspnea who visited the ED | 907 | 54 | Continuous (per 1% increase), Ordered Categorical (<12.9%, 12.9-14.3%, >14.3%) | Primary:30-day mortality Secondary: composite of 30- day mortality or re-hospitalization | Unadjusted and multivariable cox analysis | |
| Senol et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with acute pancreatitis | 102 | Median:56.5 | 42.2 | Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary: in-hospital mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Majercik et al. [ | Retrospective, multiple center | Adult trauma patients | 9538 | Mean: 48 | 62.1 | Continuous (per 1% increase), Ordered Categorical (11.3- 13.0%, 13.1-13.5%, 13.6- 14.0%, 14.1-14.9%, 15.0- 32.4%) | Primary:30-day mortality Secondary:1-year mortality (from 31 to 365 days of follow -up) | Multivariable Cox analysis |
| Garbharran et al. [ | Prospective, single center | Hip fracture cases | 698 | Mean: 78 | 33 | Continuous (per 1% increase), Ordered categorical(10-13%, 13.1-14.1%, 14.2-15.2%, >15.3) | Primary: in-hospital mortality, 120-day mortality and 1-year mortality | Multivariable Cox analysis |
| Bilgic et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with acute mesenteric ischemia | 61 | Median: 72 | 59 | Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary: in-hospital mortality | ROC analysis |
| Kang et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients after organophos phate insecticide poisoning | 102 | Mean:57.5 | 66.7 | Binary (≤13.5% vs >13.5%) | Primary: 30-day mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable cox analysis |
| Zorlu et al. [ | Prospective, multiple center | Patients with acute pulmonary embolism | 136 | Mean:63 | 48 | Binary (≤14.6% vs >14.6%) | Primary: in-hospital mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable cox analysis |
| Sen et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with acute pulmonary embolism | 208 | Mean:57.87 | 38 | Binary (≤16.25% vs >16.25%) | Primary:100-day mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Ozsu et al. [ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with acute pulmonary embolism | 702 | Median:68 | 35 | Continuous (per 1% increase), Ordered categorical(≤13.6%, 13.7-14.5%, 14.6-16.3%, >16.3%) | Primary: in-hospital mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Mucsi et al. [ | Prospective, Single center | Prevalent kidney transplant recipients | 723 | Mean:51 | 50 | Continuous (per 1% increase), Binary: (≤13.7% vs >13.7%) | Primary: all -cause mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable cox analysis |
| Miriam et al. 2015/[ | Retrospective, single center | Adult internal medicine ward patients | 586 | Mean: 62.3 | 46.6 | Binary (≤14.7% vs >14.7%); Continuous (per 1% increase) | Primary: 60-month mortality | Multivariable analysis |
| Yao et al. 2014/[ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with acute pancreatitis | 106 | MAP:48.2 SAP:60.5 | 49 | Ordered categorical (>13.3%, 12.6-13.3%, <12.6%) | Primary: 3-month mortality | Unadjusted |
| Lv et al. 2015/[ | Prospective, single center | Hip fracture cases | 1479 | Median: 73 | 41.6 | Ordered categorical (< 12.50%,12.51%-13.10%,13.11%- 13.80%, >13.81%) | Primary: 2- year mortality | Unadjusted and multivariable analysis |
| Dinc et al. 2015/[ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with acute mesenteric ischemia | 73 | Mean: 69.3 | 57.53 | Continuous (per 1% increase), | Primary: post-operative mortality | Multivariable analysis |
| Wang et al. 2015/[ | Retrospective, single center | Patients with acute pancreatitis | 120 | Mean: 51.2 | 41.7 | Ordered categorical (>13.4%, 12.6%-13.4%,≤12.6%) | Primary: 3-month mortality | None |
RDW = red cell distribution width, ROC = receiver operating characteristic.
The Effect of RDW on Mortality.
| Study/Year | Mortality | Univariable Analysis or Multivariable Analysis | Adjusted Variables | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wang et al. [ | ICU: 21.1% Within categories: 11.2-13.4: 11.2%, 13.5-14.6: 18.8%, 14.7-26.9: 33.8% | Univariable Analysis ICU mortality OR: 1.784 (1.475-2.158) per 1% increase | Multivariable Analysis ICU mortality OR: 1.551 (1.25-1.926) per 1% increase | Age, APACHE-II, CRP, GFR, hemoglobin, albumin | ICU mortality AUC:0.672 (0.645-0.699) Cut-off: 14.8% Sensitivity: 51.2% Specificity: 74.7% |
| Bazick et al. [ | 30-day: 14.15% 90-day: 18.67% 365-day: 26.27% In-hospital: 12.80% | Univariable Analysis 30-day mortality ≤13.3%, OR: 1 13.3-14%,OR: 1.52(1.4-1.66) 14-14.7%,OR: 1.91(1.74-2.1) 14.7-15.8%, OR: 2.84(2.6- 3.11) >15.8%, OR: 5.02(4.64-5.44) Bloodstream infection ≤13.3%, OR:1 13.3–14%, OR: 1.30 (1.13– 1.50) 14–14.7%, OR: 1.56 (1.35– 1.81) 14.7–15.8%,OR: 1.75 (1.52– 2.01) >15.8%, OR: 1.96 (1.73– 2.23) | Multivariable Analysis 30-day mortality ≤13.3%, OR: 1 13.3-14%, OR: 1.19(1.08-1.3) 14-14.7%,OR:1.28(1.16-1.42) 14.7-15.8%, OR: 1.69(1.53- 1.86) >15.8%, OR: 2.61(2.23-2.86) Bloodstream infection ≤13.3%, OR: 1 13.3–14%, OR: 1.19 (1.03– 1.38) 14–14.7%, OR: 1.34(1.15– 1.56) 14.7–15.8%, OR: 1.40(1.20– 1.63) >15.8%, OR: 1.44(1.24–1.66) | Age, sex, race, patient type, Charlson index, Cr, Hct, WBC, BUN, MCV, sepsis, AMI, transfusion, CHF, CABG | 30-day mortality: AUC:0.67 (CI not given) Bloodstream infection: AUC: 0.57 (CI not given) |
| Hunziker et al. [ | In-hospital: 11.2% ICU: 7.6% | Univariable Analysis In-hospital mortality OR: 1.2 (1.16-1.24) per 1% increase ICU mortality OR: 1.18 (1.14-1.22) per 1% increase | Multivariable Analysis In-hospital mortality OR: 1.14 (1.08-1.19) per 1% increase ICU mortality OR: 1.10 (1.06-1.15) per 1% increase | SAPS, age, gender, Hct, and different comorbidities | The multivariable adjusted OR for 1-year mortality was 1.20 (1.14–1.26) per 1% increase 1-year mortality: AUC: 0.73 (0.72- 0.74) |
| Meynaaret al. [ | In-hospital: 13.3% Within categories: <43.2fl: 7.4% 43.2-46.09fl: 10.9% 46.1-49.69fl: 11.5% >49.7fl: 23% | Univariable Analysis In-hospital mortality <43.2fl,OR:1 43.2-46.09fl, OR: 1.53 (1.06- 2.19) 46.1-49.69fl, OR: 1.62 (1.13- 2.34) >49.7fl, OR: 3.73 (2.79-5.18) | Multivariable Analysis In-hospital mortality OR: 1.04 (1.02-1.06) per 1% increase | APACHEⅡ, age, Hct, Hb, MCV, MCH, MCHC, CRP, sepsis, mechanical ventilation, admission type, leukocyte count | None |
| Zhang et al. [ | In-hospital: 29.6% | None | Multivariable Analysis In-hospital mortality: OR, 1.11 (1.04-1.18) per 1% increase | Age, gender, RRT, albumin, CRP, Hb, Charlson index | In-hospital mortality AUC:0.6202(0.589- 0.651) Patients with higher RDW will have longer LOS in ICU. Changes in RDW during a short follow up period were not associated with mortality |
| Hatice et al. 2015/[ | In-hospital: 50% | None | Multivare Analysis In-hospital: for male HR, 1.07 (0.92–1.25); for female HR, 1.20 (0.95–1.54) per 1% increase | Age, source of sepsis, comorbidity, WBC, CRP, RDW, APACHE II and length of hospital stay | In-hospital mortality AUC: 0.867 (0.791-0.942) Cut-off 16% Sensitivity: 94.23% Specificity: 76.47% |
| Sadaka et al. [ | In-hospital: 47.1% ICU: 33.6% | None | Multivariable Analysis In-hospital mortality: OR, 1.27 (1.11-1.46) per 1% increase <13.5%, OR:1 13.5-15.5%, OR: 4.6 (1.0- 23.4) 15.6-17.5%, OR: 8.0 (1.5- 41.6) 17.6-19.4%, OR: 25.3 (4.3- 149.2) >19.4% OR:12.3 (2.1-73.3) ICU mortality: OR, 1.29 (1.13-1.48) per 1% increase <13.5%, OR:1 13.5-15.5%, OR: 4.6 (0.6- 38.9) 15.6-17.5%, OR: 9.1 (1.1- 78.2) 17.6-19.4%, OR: 20.4 (2.3- 183.4) >19.4% OR: 18.8 (2.0-178.2) | Age, gender, BMI,APACHE II score, SOFA score, comorbidities, and number of organ failures | In-hospital mortality:AUC: 0.74 (CI not given). The AUC was 0.69 for APACHE II and 0.69 for SOFA. When adding RDW to APACHE II, the AUC increased from 0.69 to 0.77 |
| Jo et al. [ | 28-day:29% Within categories: ≤14: 13.1% 14.1-15.7: 30.1% ≥15.8: 44.9% | None | Multivariable Analysis 28-day mortality: ≤14, HR:1 14.1-15.7, HR: 1.66(1-2.76) ≥15.8, HR: 2.57(1.53-4.34) | Age, gender, APACHE II score, albumin, cholesterol, Creatine, BUN, potassium, MCH, MCV, Hct, WBC, PH, MAP, liver disease, infection site | 28-day mortality: AUC: 0.678(0.631- 0.724). The rates of renal replacement therapy, mechanical ventilation, and admission to ICU were not different across RDW tertiles |
| Tian et al. [ | 28-day:50.8% | None | Multivariable Analysis 28-day mortality: OR, 1.402 (1.01-1.947) per 1% increase | SOFA score, APACHE II score, WBC, Hct, MCV, Hb | 28-day mortality: AUC: 0.632(0.535- 0.729). Changes in RDW during a short follow up period were associated with mortality |
| Chen et al. [ | 90-day:52.1% Within categories: ≤15: 38.9% >15: 77.3% 30-day:13.4% | None | Multivariable Analysis 90-day mortality: HR,1.122 (CI not given) | SOFA score, APACHE II score | 90-day mortality: AUC: 0.723(CI not given) |
| Lee et al. [ | Within categories: ≤13.3%: 5.6% 13.3-14.1%: 7% 14.1-15.2%: 12.6% >15.2%: 28.5% | None | Multivariable Analysis 30-day mortality: ≤13.3%, OR:1 13.3-14.1%, OR: 0.73 (0.28- 1.91) 14.1-15.2%, OR: 1.11 (0.47- 2.62) >15.2% OR: 2.37 (1.04-5.42) | CURB-65, albumin, cholesterol, prothrombin time | Secondary outcomes, also differed significantly among the RDW quartiles |
| Braun et al. [ | In-hospital: 14.3% 90-day: 24.6% | Univariable Analysis 90-day mortality: >15%, OR: 3.04(2.61-3.54) Complicated admissions: >15%, OR: 2.1(1.88-2.44) | Multivariable Analysis 90-day mortality: >15%, OR: 2.1(1.8-2.5) Complicated admissions: >15%, OR: 1.5(1.3-1.8) | Age, Na, SBP, HR, SaO2, WBC, Hb, BUN, Charlson index | None |
| Ku et al. [ | 28-day:14.3% Within categories: ≤14.6%: 4.4% >14.6%: 27.1% | Univariable Analysis 28-day mortality: HR: 1.194 (1.073-1.329) per 1% increase | Multivariable Analysis 28-day mortality: HR: 1.174 (1.011-1.365) per 1% increase | Age, BUN, SOFA, Charlson index | 28-day mortality: AUC: 0.764(0.65- 0.879). |
| Seyhan et al. [ | Within categories: ≤15.5%: 23% >15.5%: 78% | Univariable Analysis OR: 1.2 (1.15-1.3) per 1% increase | Multivariable Analysis OR: 1.12 (1.01-1.24) per 1% increase | Age, CVD, FEV1, PaCO2, albumin, anemia, CRP, PAH, RVD | RDW was positively correlated with CRP (r=0.21), RVD (r = 0.25), and PAH (r = 0.14) |
| Guray et al. [ | 1-year:41% Within categories: ≤15.3%: 14% >15.3%: 56% | Univariable Analysis 1-year mortality: RDW>15.3%,HR:5.63(2.2- 14.38) | Multivariable Analysis 1-year mortality: RDW>15.3%,HR:3.07(1.06- 8.86) | Heart failure, renal failure, cardiac abscess, severe valvular regurgitation and presence of dehiscence | 1-year mortality AUC: 0.7(0.59-0.8) Cut-off: 15.3% Sensitivity: 88% Specificity: 53% |
| Kim et al. [ | 30-day:73.1% Within categories: ≤13.1%: 60% 13.2-14.%: 71.2% 14.1-15.4%: 72.7% >15.5%: 88.2% | Univariable Analysis 30-day mortality: ≤13.1%,HR:1 13.2-14.%, HR: 1.32 (0.83– 2.11) 14.1-15.4%, HR: 1.42 (0.89– 2.29) >15.5%, HR: 2.21 (1.38– 3.52) | Multivariable Analysis 30-day mortality: ≤13.1%,HR:1 13.2-14.%, HR: 1.25 (0.76– 2.06) 14.1-15.4%, HR: 1.29 (0.76– 2.19) >15.5%, HR: 1.95 (1.05–3.60) | Age, gender, initial shockable rhythm, Hct, platelet, BUN, Cr, albumin | 30-day mortality: AUC: 0.61(0.53- 0.69) |
| Oh et al. [ | 28-day:62.8% | Univariable Analysis 28-day mortality: ≥14.6,HR: 1.29(1.02–1.62) HR: 1.07 (1.02–1.12) per 1% increase | Multivariable Analysis 28-day mortality: ≥14.6,HR: 1.21 (1.01–1.71) HR: 1.06 (1.01–1.17) per 1% increase | Age, gender, CRP, Hb, albumin, total cholesterol, MAP, SOFA score | 28-day mortality: AUC: 0.586(CI not given) |
| Hong et al. [ | 30-day: 9.5% Within categories: <12.9%: 1.4% 12.9-14.3%: 8.5% >14.3%: 18.3% | Univariable Analysis 30-day mortality: HR: 1.33 (1.25–1.42) per 1% increase | Multivariable Analysis 30-day mortality: <12.9%, HR:1 12.9-14.3%, HR: 3.52 (1.20– 10.28) >14.3%, HR: 7.207, (2.49– 21.23) HR: 1.23 (1.12–1.34) per 1% increase | Charlson index, HR, previous use of angiotensin inhibitors, presence of pulmonary edema, hemoglobin, MCV, WBC, serum sodium, and albumin | 30-day mortality: AUC: 0.746(0.7- 0.796) Cut-off: 14.5% Sensitivity: 66.3% Specificity: 70.2% |
| Senol et al. [ | In-hospital:13% | Univariable Analysis In-hospital mortality P=0.000(OR and its CI not given) | Multivariable Analysis In-hospital mortality P=0.001(OR and its CI not given) | Age, BUN, platelet, WBC, albumin, calcium | In-hospital mortality: AUC: 0.817(0.689- 0.946) Cut-off: 14.8% |
| Majercik et al. [ | 30-day: Within categories: 11.3-13.0%: 2.2%,3.4% 13.1-13.5%: 1.8%,1.9% 13.6-14%: 3.6%, 3% 14.1-14.9%: 4.8%,3.9% 15-32.4%: 10%,6.2% | None | Multivariable Analysis 30-day mortality Male: HR: 1.17 (1.04-1.3) per quintile. 11.3-13.5%, HR: 1; 13.6-14%, HR: 1.41 (p = 0.10); 14.1- 14.9%, HR: 1.54 (p = 0.039); 15.0-32.4%, HR: 2.09 (p<0.001) HR, 1.19 (1.12-1.26) per 1% increase Female: HR: 1.17 (1.01-1.35) per quintile. 11.3-13.5%,HR: 1; 13.6-14%, HR: 1.06 (p = 0.85); 14.1- 14.9%, HR: 1.01 (p = 0.96); 15.0-32.4%, HR: 2.38 (p<0.001) HR, 1.08 (1.01-1.16) per 1% increase | Age, injury severity score, LOS, type of trauma, and each of the other complete blood cell count parameters | 30-day mortality: AUC: 0.705 in males and 0.625 in females |
| Majercik et al. [ | 1-year: Within categories: 11.3-13.0%: 0.5%,0.5% 13.1-13.5%: 0.4%,2.1% 13.6-14%: 0.8%,3% 14.1-14.9%: 1.7%,4.2% 15-32.4%: 8.3%,8.8% | None | Multivariable Analysis 1-year mortality: Male: HR: 1.52 (1.24-1.88) per quintile. 11.3-13.5%,HR: 1; 13.6-14%, HR: 1.05 (p = 0.92); 14.1- 14.9%, HR: 1.28 (p = 0.52); 15.0-32.4%, HR: 3.82 (p<0.001) HR, 1.27 (1.2-1.35) per 1% increase Female: HR: 1.43 (1.21-1.69) per quintile. 11.3-13.5%, HR: 1; 13.6-14%, HR: 1.45 (p = 0.27); 14.1- 14.9%, HR: 1.72 (p = 0.09); 15.0-32.4%, HR: 2.94 (p<0.001) HR, 1.22 (1.17-1.28) per 1% increase | Age, injury severity score, LOS, type of trauma, and each of the other complete blood cell count parameters | 1-year mortality AUC: 0.820 in males and 0.723 in females |
| Garbharran et al. [ | 1-year: 23% Within categories: 10-13%: 12% 13.1-14.1%: 15% 14.2-15.2%: 29% >15.3%: 36% | None | Multivariable Analysis In-hospital morality: HR:1.119(1-1.253) per 1% increase 120-day mortality: HR:1.134(1.047-1.227) per 1% increase 1-year mortality: HR:1.131(1.067-1.199) per 1% increase | Hb, MCV, age, gender, pre- fracture residence, required aid to mobilise indoors pre-fracture, ASA, Charlson index, post-operative delirium, cardiac, respiratory GI complicationsand serum creatinine | After excluding anaemic patients: In-hospital morality HR:1.21(1.04-1.41) per 1% increase 120-day mortality HR:1.17(1.04-1.31) per 1% increase 1-year mortality HR:1.27(1.16-1.4) per 1% increase |
| Bilgic et al. [ | In-hospital:57.4% | None | None | None | In-hospital mortality: AUC: 0.713(0.584- 0.841) Cut-off: 14.85% Sensitivity: 68.42% Specificity: 53.85% |
| Kang et al. [ | 30-day: 20.6% Within categories: ≤13.5%: 1.7% >13.5: 48% | Univariable Analysis 30-day mortality: >13.5, HR: 4.76(2-11.33) | Multivariable Analysis 30-day mortality: >13.5, HR: 2.64(1.05-6.6) | Age, SBP, Hct, Cr, albumin unresponsive in AVPU scale | 30-day mortality: AUC:0.675(0.522- 0.829) Cut-off: 13.5% Sensitivity: 57.1% Specificity: 84% |
| Zorlu et al. [ | In-hospital: 15.4% Within categories: ≤14.6%: 1.6% >14.6%: 27% | Univariable Analysis In-hospital mortality: >14.6%, HR: 19.789 (2.654– 147.5) | Multivariable Analysis In-hospital mortality: >14.6%, HR: 15.465 (1.811– 132.064) | Age, presence of shock, heart rate, oxygen saturation, Cr | In-hospital mortality: AUC: 0.734(0.646- 0.822) Cut-off: 14.6% Sensitivity: 95.2% Specificity: 53% |
| Sen et al. [ | 100-day:14.42% | Univariable Analysis 100-day mortality: >16.25%, OR: 6.55 (2.153– 19.975) | Multivariable Analysis 100-day mortality: >16.25%, OR: 4.06 (1.229– 13.335) | Neutrophil/ lymphocyte ratio, platelet distribution width, sPESI, oxygen saturation, and CRP | 100-day mortality: AUC: 0.646(0.557- 0.736) Cut-off: 16.25% Sensitivity: 79.2% Specificity: 55.6% |
| Ozsu et al. [ | In-hospital:12% Within categories: ≤13.6%: 5.8% 13.7-14.5%: 9.7% 14.6-16.3%: 13.1% >16.3%: 20% | Univariable Analysis In-hospital mortality: OR:1.2(1.1-1.3) per 1% increase | Multivariable Analysis In-hospital mortality: OR:1.2 (1.1-1.4) per 1% increase | Sex, RR, sPESI, CRP, D-dimer, MCV, and serum Tn-T, oxygen saturation | In-hospital mortality: AUC:0.649(0.584- 0.715) Cut-off: 15% Sensitivity:66% Specificity:59% |
| Mucsi et al. [ | Mortality:11% Median follow up time 35 months | Univariable Analysis HR:1.63(1.41–1.89) per 1% increase >13.7, HR: 2.74 (1.68–4.48) | Multivariable Analysis HR:1.60 (1.27–2.02) per 1% increase >13.7,HR: 1.33 0.76–2.35 | age, gender, GFR, iron markers inflammatory markers, Charlson index, total time in ESRD,steroid use, mammalian target of rapamycin use, ACEi or ARB use | AUC:0.689(CI not given) Cut-off: 14% Sensitivity:63% Specificity:65% |
| Miriam et al. 2015/ [ | 60-month: 30% Within categories: ≤14.7: 39.8% >14.7: 17.5% | None | Multivariable Analysis 60-month mortality: >14.7, RR: 1.53 (1.11-2.11) Continuous, RR:1.21(1.13- 1.32) | Age, anemia, renal dysfunction, diabetes mellitus, coronary artery disease, chronic lung disease, heart failure, history of malignancy, complex nursing care and mechanical ventilation | None |
| Yao et al. 2014/[ | 3-month: 7.5% | None | None | None | 3-month mortality AUC: 0.846(0.727- 0.964) Cut-off: 14.2% Sensitivity: 75% Specificity: 89.8% |
| Lv et al. 2015/[ | 2-year: 12.9% Within categories: < 12.50%: 7.2% 12.51%-13.1%: 10.9% 13.11%-13.8%: 12.2%, >13.81%: 22.2% | None | Multivariable Analysis 2-year mortality: RDW was examined as quartiles, HR 1.224 (1.057- 1.417) <12.50%, 1; 12.51%-13.10% 1.17 (0.71-1.91); 13.11%- 13.80% 1.14(0.70-1.86); >13.81% 1.83(1.14-2.93) | age, prior-myocardial infarction, chronic renal failure, ASA score, treatment, in-hospital pneumonia, in-hospital circulatory complications | None |
| Dinc et al. 2015/[ | Post-operative Mortality: 54.8% | Multivariable Analysis Post-operative mortality: OR, 1.5115 (1.3287-6.8084) | age, gender, comorbid diseases, medications, blood biochemistry, complete blood cell count, pathology results and type of surgery | None | |
| Wang et al. 2015/[ | 3-month: 50% | None | None | 3-month mortality AUC: 0.894 (0.823-0.966) Cut-off: 14.35% Sensitivity: 88.2% Specificity: 91.8% | |
CRP = C-reactive protein, GFR = glomerular filtration rate, Cr = creatinine, Hct = hematocrit, WBC = white blood count, BUN = blood urea nitrogen, MCV = mean corpuscular volume, SBP = systolic blood pressure, MCHC = mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration, RRT = renal replacement therapy, SAPS = simplified acute physiology score, Hb = haemoglobin, AMI = acute myocardial infarction, CHF = congestive heart failure, CABG = coronary artery bypass grafting, SOFA = sequential organ failure assessment, BMI = body mass index, LOS = length of stay, CVD = cardio vascular disorder, FEV1 = forced expiratory volume in 1 second, PAH = pulmonary arterial hypertension, RVD = right ventricular diameter, ACEi = angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor, ARB = angiotensin receptor blocker, sPESI = simplified pulmonary embolism severity index.
Study Quality as Assessed by The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.
| Study | Selection | Comparability | Outcome | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Representativenessof exposed | Selection of non-exposed | Ascertainment of exposure | Outcome of interestwas not present at start of study | Assessment of outcome | Duration of follow-up | Adequacy of follow-up | ||
| Wang et al.[ | ||||||||
| Bazick et al.[ | ||||||||
| Hunziker et al.[ | ||||||||
| Meynaaret al.[ | ||||||||
| Zhang et al.[ | ||||||||
| Hatice et al.[ | * | * | * | * | ** | * | * | |
| Sadaka et al.[ | ||||||||
| Jo et al.[ | ||||||||
| Tian et al.[ | ||||||||
| Chen et al.[ | ||||||||
| Lee et al.[ | ||||||||
| Braun et al.[ | ||||||||
| Ku et al.[ | ||||||||
| Seyhan et al.[ | ||||||||
| Guray et al.[ | ||||||||
| Kim et al.[ | ||||||||
| Oh et al.[ | ||||||||
| Hong et al.[ | ||||||||
| Senol et al.[ | ||||||||
| Majercik et al.[ | ||||||||
| Garbharran et al.[ | ||||||||
| Bilgic et al.[ | ||||||||
| Kang et al.[ | ||||||||
| Zorlu et al.[ | ||||||||
| Sen et al.[ | ||||||||
| Ozsu et al.[ | ||||||||
| Mucsi et al.[ | ||||||||
| Miriam et al.[ | * | * | * | * | ** | * | * | * |
| Yao et al.[ | * | * | * | * | ** | * | * | * |
| Lv et al.[ | * | * | * | * | ** | * | * | * |
| Dinc et al.[ | * | * | * | * | ** | * | * | * |
| Wang et al.[ | * | * | * | * | ** | * | * | * |
*, the quality of according domain.