| Literature DB >> 27695703 |
Dhruvee Sangani1, Akiko Suzuki2, Helena VonVille3, James E Hixson4, Junichi Iwata5.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The temporomandibular joint (TMJ) is a bilateral synovial joint between the mandible and the temporal bone of the skull. TMJ disorders (TMDs) are a set of complicated and poorly understood clinical conditions, in which TMDs are associated with a number of symptoms including pain and limited jaw movement. The increasing scientific evidence suggests that genetic factors play a significant role in the pathology of TMDs. However, the underlying mechanism of TMDs remains largely unknown.Entities:
Keywords: Systematic Review; Temporomandibular Joint; Temporomandibular Joint Disorders
Year: 2015 PMID: 27695703 PMCID: PMC5045035 DOI: 10.4236/oalib.1101583
Source DB: PubMed Journal: OAlib ISSN: 2333-9705
Figure 1Prisma flowchart for selection of articles.
Human studies.
| Author publication year country of study | Study population characteristics | Diagnosis diagnostic criteria | Gene(s) studied | Results | Study limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planello [ | Mean Age of Cases | Osteophytes, erosion, avascular necrosis, subchondral cyst, loose bodies, OA | MMP1 | Only MMP1 2G/2G genotype was found to be significant (P < 0.003). Effect of age on TMJ degeneration was significant (P < 0.002) | Small sample size to detect association of MMP3 gene |
| Huang [ | Mean Age of Cases | TMJ clicking (disc displacement with reduction) or closed lock (disc displacement without reduction) and not having previous history of trauma, neoplasm and/or surgery in the TMJ; TMJ clicking used as controls Clinical evaluation, MRI | ANKH | Two alleles of ANKH-OR polymorphism were identified. ANKH-OR homozygotes were more likely to develop closed lock compared to controls (P = 0.011) | Calculation of minimal sample size was unattainable, Low response rate could have resulted in sampling bias, application of cohort study would have explored the influence of age on TMD, high percentage of patients were unwilling to take a blood test for assessment, study failed to indicate equivalence between fibrous ankylosis in mice and closed lock in humans |
| Kim [ | Mean Age of Cases | MPDS, IDD with reduction, IDD without reduction, OA, Osteoarthrosis RDC/TMD | ESR1 | No statistical difference between study group and control group (P > 0.5) | Small sample size |
| Ribeiro-Dasilva [ | Age for Cases 18 – 44 | Disc displacement with and without reduction, with limited mouth opening, without reduction and without limited mouth opening RDC/TMD | ESR1 | Presence of [GC] haplotype in ER | Small sample size, admixed Brazilian population limits generalizability of data, only data from articular pain included and not muscular pain |
| Matsumoto [ | Mean Age of Cases | ID, OA | ADAMTS-5 | ADAMTS-5 is involved in deformation of the TMJ discs with ID and OA (P < 0.01) | Small sample size, limited use of TMJ disc cells |
| Helenius [ | Mean Age of Cases | RA, MCTD, AS, SPA ARA 1987 for RA, Alarcon-Segovia for MCTD, MNYC for AS, ESSG for SPA | HLA-DRB1 | In the whole patient population, HLA-DRB1 allele was significantly associated with TMJ erosions (P = 0.0014) | Controls were not clinically or radiologically examined |
| Li [ | Mean Age of Cases NR | Synovial chondromatosis for cases; Open Reduction for controls NR | FGF2 | FGF2 was involved in the pathogenesis of synovial chondromatosis (P < 0.01) | NR |
| Yamaguchi [ | Mean Age of Cases | Osteophytes, erosion, flattening of TMJ bone Interview, CT, MRI, Panoramic Radiograph | APOL3 | All the genes were found to be significantly associated. TSPAN9 showed strongest association (P = 8.1 × 10−6) | Small sample size, age and gender differed between Japanese and Korean data sets |
| Etoz [ | Mean Age of Cases | Difficulty or pain while opening mouth, locking of jaw, pain, noises, unusual bite, frequent headache, MRI findings-NR | TNF | TNFα-308GA polymorphism is not associated with TMD | NR |
| Mutlu [ | Mean Age of Cases: | Difficulty or pain while opening mouth, locking of jaw, pain, noises, unusual bite, frequent headache, MRI findings-NR | MAOA | No evidence to support the involvement of MAOA gene in TMD | NR |
NR: Not Reported; RA: Rheumatoid Arthritis; MCTD: Mixed Connective Tissue disease; AS: Ankylosing Spondylitis; SPA: Spondyloarthropathy; ARA: American Rheumatism Association; MNYC: Modified New York Criteria; ESSG: European Spondyloarthropathy Study Group; ID: Internal Derangement; OA: Osteoarthritis; MPDS: Myofacial Pain Dysfunction Syndrome; MRI: Magnetic Resonance Imaging; CT: Computed Tomography.
Animal studies.
| Author publication year | Animal studies | TMD condition method of inducing | Gene studied | Results | Study limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jing [ | Mice | TMD Mutant condylar cartilage | Osx | Defect in coupling chondrogenesis and osteogenesis in cKO mice, calcified cartilage in hypertrophic zone, few signs of endochondral bone formation, disorganized intramembranous bone | NR |
| Ishizuka [ | Mice | OA-like changes | Samp8 | Abnormal condylar organization, condylar degeneration, decreased chondroprogenitor cell proliferation and increased cell death | NR |
| Li [ | Mice | Disc Disorder | Shox2 | Genetic association with congenital articular disc degeneration, suggesting that SHOX2 represents a susceptible locus for OA of the TMJ | NR |
| Jiao [ | Mice | Cartilage degradation | Tgfb1 | Abnormalities in the subchondral bone which induced cartilage degradation | Small sample size |
| Inman [ | Mice | Syngnathia, agenesis of TMJ | Foxc1 | Foxc1−/− mutant mice exhibit bilateral fusion of the upper jaw zygomatic complex to the dentary bone (syngnathia) | NR |
| Ricks [ | Mice | OA | Col2a1 | TMJ in Dmm/+ mice displayed premature articular cartilage and greater defects in chondrocyte arrangement, known biomarkers of OA were significantly expressed (P < 0.01) | NR |
| Yasuda [ | Mice | Abnormal endochondral ossification and Class 3 dental malocclusion, shortening of cranial base | Fgfr3 | Articular disc fused with temporal bone, articular surface developed fissures, defects in endochondral ossification, abnormal glenoid fossa, defective trabecular bone formation | NR |
| Purcell [ | Mice | NR | Spry1 | Combined inactivation of Spry1 and Spry2 genes leads to absence of glenoid fossa and overgrowth of lateral pterygoid and temporalis muscles | NR |
| Huang [ | Mice | Internal derangement | Ank | Fibrous ankylosis, narrower and/or ankylosed superior and inferior synovial cavities filled with fibrous connective tissue throughout the entire joint space | Utilization of 3-to-5 month old mice in this study might be responsible for the absence of erosive changes in the TMJ. |
| Embree [ | Mice | OA | 4833416E15Rik | The microarray analysis discovered 22 genes differentially expressed in | NR |
| Purcell [ | Mice | Targeted disruption of the Gli2 zinc finger domain (Gli2zfd/zfd) Crossbreeding | Gli2 | TMJ disk was missing, small condyle, cellular organization of growth plate was lost | NR |
| Gu [ | Mice | Inactivation of Shox2 | Shox2 | Dysplasia of glenoid fossa, congenital | NR |
| Shibukawa [ | Mice | Absence of articular disc | Ihh | Mandible development was defective, condyle zonal architecture was abnormal, complete absence of functional disc and joint cavity | NR |
| Meng [ | Mice | OA | Angpt12, Aqp3 | Swelling, superficial fibrillation, early osteoarthritic changes | NR |
| Xu [ | Mice | Cartilage Degeneration | cho | At age 6 months OA-like changes became more severe, including flattening of the condylar head, loss of proteoglycans, and a reduced hypertrophic zone | NR |
| Gu [ | Mice | Apoptotic cells | Bmpr1a | Agenesis Failed formation of functional fibrocartilage layer, Failure of disc separation from hypoplastic condyle | NR |
| Li [ | Mice | Dysplasia | Shox2 | Increased number of apoptotic cells in the glenoid fossa causing glenoid fossa dysplasia, dysplasia of condyle | NR |
| Wang [ | Mice | TMJ Cartilage | Ctnnb1 | Significant reduction in TMJ joint space, cartilage thickness was significantly decreased, increase in cartilage degrading enzymes, OA-like phenotype | NR |
| Meng [ | Rats | OA | Aqp1 | High expression and different localization of AQP3 in OA cartilage. No significant difference between OA and normal controls | NR |
| Yu [ | Rats | Condyle cartilage | Igf1 | Obvious OA-like changes were observed in 2 week female experimental group than those in control group (P < 0.01) and 2 week male experimental group (P < 0.05), Expression of IGF1 in the 2 week females was lower than males (P < 0.01), IGFR1 was significantly lower in 2 week female (P < 0.05) but increased in 2 week male experimental group, IGFBP3 in all female subgroups was significantly lower than that in their male counterparts | Differences in occlusion between rats and humans |
| Asakawa-Tanne [ | Porcine | Disc indentation | Cox2 | Compromised lubrication in TMJ is associated with altered frictional properties and surface wear of condylar cartilage | Amount and nature of loading used in the study do not represent the actual TMJ dynamics |
| Ge [ | Rabbit | Cartilage destruction | Wnt5a | WNT5A is associated with cartilage destruction by promoting expression of MMP1, MMP3, MMP9, MMP13 | NR |
NR: Not reported; OA: Osteoarthritis.