Chi Yan Hui1, Robert Walton2, Brian McKinstry3, Tracy Jackson1, Richard Parker4, Hilary Pinnock1. 1. Asthma UK Centre for Applied Research, Usher Institute of Population Health Sciences and Informatics, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK. 2. Centre for Primary Care and Public Health, Barts and The London School of Medicine and Dentistry, Blizard Institute, Queen Mary University of London, London, UK. 3. Primary Care eHealth, Usher Institute of Population Health Sciences and Informatics, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK. 4. Health Services Research Unit, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Telehealth is promoted as a strategy to support self-management of long-term conditions. The aim of this systematic review is to identify which information and communication technology features implemented in mobile apps to support asthma self-management are associated with adoption, adherence to usage, and clinical effectiveness. METHODS: We systematically searched 9 databases, scanned reference lists, and undertook manual searches (January 2000 to April 2016). We include randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and quasiexperimental studies with adults. All eligible papers were assessed for quality, and we extracted data on the features included, health-related outcomes (asthma control, exacerbation rate), process/intermediate outcomes (adherence to monitoring or treatment, self-efficacy), and level of adoption of and adherence to use of technology. Meta-analysis and narrative synthesis were used. RESULTS: We included 12 RCTs employing a range of technologies. A meta-analysis (n = 3) showed improved asthma control (mean difference -0.25 [95% CI, -0.37 to -0.12]). Included studies incorporated 10 features grouped into 7 categories (education, monitoring/electronic diary, action plans, medication reminders/prompts, facilitating professional support, raising patient awareness of asthma control, and decision support for professionals). The most successful interventions included multiple features, but effects on health-related outcomes were inconsistent. No studies explicitly reported adoption of and adherence to the technology system. CONCLUSION: Meta-analysis of data from 3 trials showed improved asthma control, though overall the clinical effectiveness of apps, typically incorporating multiple features, varied. Further studies are needed to identify the features that are associated with adoption of and adherence to use of the mobile app and those that improve health outcomes.
OBJECTIVES: Telehealth is promoted as a strategy to support self-management of long-term conditions. The aim of this systematic review is to identify which information and communication technology features implemented in mobile apps to support asthma self-management are associated with adoption, adherence to usage, and clinical effectiveness. METHODS: We systematically searched 9 databases, scanned reference lists, and undertook manual searches (January 2000 to April 2016). We include randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and quasiexperimental studies with adults. All eligible papers were assessed for quality, and we extracted data on the features included, health-related outcomes (asthma control, exacerbation rate), process/intermediate outcomes (adherence to monitoring or treatment, self-efficacy), and level of adoption of and adherence to use of technology. Meta-analysis and narrative synthesis were used. RESULTS: We included 12 RCTs employing a range of technologies. A meta-analysis (n = 3) showed improved asthma control (mean difference -0.25 [95% CI, -0.37 to -0.12]). Included studies incorporated 10 features grouped into 7 categories (education, monitoring/electronic diary, action plans, medication reminders/prompts, facilitating professional support, raising patient awareness of asthma control, and decision support for professionals). The most successful interventions included multiple features, but effects on health-related outcomes were inconsistent. No studies explicitly reported adoption of and adherence to the technology system. CONCLUSION: Meta-analysis of data from 3 trials showed improved asthma control, though overall the clinical effectiveness of apps, typically incorporating multiple features, varied. Further studies are needed to identify the features that are associated with adoption of and adherence to use of the mobile app and those that improve health outcomes.
Authors: Helen K Reddel; D Robin Taylor; Eric D Bateman; Louis-Philippe Boulet; Homer A Boushey; William W Busse; Thomas B Casale; Pascal Chanez; Paul L Enright; Peter G Gibson; Johan C de Jongste; Huib A M Kerstjens; Stephen C Lazarus; Mark L Levy; Paul M O'Byrne; Martyn R Partridge; Ian D Pavord; Malcolm R Sears; Peter J Sterk; Stuart W Stoloff; Sean D Sullivan; Stanley J Szefler; Mike D Thomas; Sally E Wenzel Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 2009-07-01 Impact factor: 21.405
Authors: L Araújo; T Jacinto; A Moreira; M G Castel-Branco; L Delgado; A Costa-Pereira; J Fonseca Journal: J Investig Allergol Clin Immunol Date: 2012 Impact factor: 4.333
Authors: Judith S Jacobson; Andrea Lieblein; Arthur H Fierman; Edward R Fishkin; Vincent E Hutchinson; Luis Rodriguez; Denise Serebrisky; Michelle Chau; Arnold Saperstein Journal: Am J Manag Care Date: 2009-11 Impact factor: 2.229
Authors: Deborah Morrison; Sally Wyke; Karolina Agur; Euan J Cameron; Robert I Docking; Alison M Mackenzie; Alex McConnachie; Vandana Raghuvir; Neil C Thomson; Frances S Mair Journal: J Med Internet Res Date: 2014-02-18 Impact factor: 5.428
Authors: Robert S Rudin; Christopher H Fanta; Nabeel Qureshi; Erin Duffy; Maria O Edelen; Anuj K Dalal; David W Bates Journal: Appl Clin Inform Date: 2019-10-16 Impact factor: 2.342
Authors: Suzanne Bakken; Sue Marden; S Sonia Arteaga; Lisa Grossman; Alla Keselman; Phuong-Tu Le; Ruth Masterson Creber; Tiffany M Powell-Wiley; Rebecca Schnall; Derrick Tabor; Rina Das; Tilda Farhat Journal: Am J Public Health Date: 2019-01 Impact factor: 9.308
Authors: Jean Bousquet; Nhân Pham-Thi; Anna Bedbrook; Ioana Agache; Isabella Annesi-Maesano; Ignacio Ansotegui; Josep M Anto; Claus Bachert; Samuel Benveniste; Mike Bewick; Nils Billo; Sinthia Bosnic-Anticevich; Isabelle Bosse; Guy Brusselle; Moïses A Calderon; G Walter Canonica; Luis Caraballo; Victoria Cardona; Ana Maria Carriazo; Eugene Cash; Lorenzo Cecchi; Derek K Chu; Elaine Colgan; Elisio Costa; Alvaro A Cruz; Wienczyslawa Czarlewski; Stephen Durham; Motohiro Ebisawa; Marina Erhola; Jean-Luc Fauquert; Wytske J Fokkens; Joao A Fonseca; Nick Guldemond; Tomohisa Iinuma; Maddalena Illario; Ludger Klimek; Piotr Kuna; Violeta Kvedariene; Désirée Larenas-Linneman; Daniel Laune; Lan T T Le; Olga Lourenço; Joao O Malva; Gert Marien; Enrica Menditto; Joaquim Mullol; Lars Münter; Yoshitaka Okamoto; Gabrielle L Onorato; Nikos G Papadopoulos; Maritta Perala; Oliver Pfaar; Abigail Phillips; Jim Phillips; Hilary Pinnock; Fabienne Portejoie; Pablo Quinones-Delgado; Christine Rolland; Ulysse Rodts; Boleslaw Samolinski; Mario Sanchez-Borges; Holger J Schünemann; Mohamed Shamji; David Somekh; Alkis Togias; Sanna Toppila-Salmi; Ioanna Tsiligianni; Omar Usmani; Samantha Walker; Dana Wallace; Arunas Valiulis; Rianne Van der Kleij; Maria Teresa Ventura; Sian Williams; Arzu Yorgancioglu; Torsten Zuberbier Journal: J Thorac Dis Date: 2019-09 Impact factor: 2.895
Authors: Robert S Rudin; Christopher H Fanta; Zachary Predmore; Kevin Kron; Maria O Edelen; Adam B Landman; Eyal Zimlichman; David W Bates Journal: Appl Clin Inform Date: 2017-12-14 Impact factor: 2.342
Authors: Heather M Starmer; Rina Abrams; Kimberly Webster; Jennifer Kizner; Beth Beadle; F Christopher Holsinger; Harry Quon; Jeremy Richmon Journal: Dysphagia Date: 2017-09-30 Impact factor: 3.438