| Literature DB >> 27601179 |
Corinne Willame1, Laurence Baril2, Judith van den Bosch3, Germano L C Ferreira4, Rachael Williams5, Dominique Rosillon2, Catherine Cohet2.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Investigational and marketed vaccines are increasingly evaluated, and manufacturers are required to put in place mechanisms to monitor long-term benefit-risk profiles. However, generating such evidence in real-world settings remains challenging, especially when rare adverse events are assessed. Planning of an appropriate study design is key to conducting a valid study. The aim of this paper is to illustrate how feasibility assessments support the generation of robust pharmacoepidemiological data.Entities:
Keywords: feasibility assessment; lessons learned; pharmacoepidemiology; recommendations; study design; toolbox
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2016 PMID: 27601179 PMCID: PMC5157751 DOI: 10.1002/pds.4081
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf ISSN: 1053-8569 Impact factor: 2.890
Description of selected post‐licensure studies for which feasibility had been assessed
| Study # | Vaccine | Study objective | Study design/setting | Registered at |
ENCePP | Related publication |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| CervarixTM HPV‐16/18 vaccine | To assess the risk of spontaneous abortion after inadvertent exposure to HPV‐16/18‐vaccine during pregnancy | Observational cohort study in the CPRD database | NCT01905462 | ENCePP id 3310 | Baril |
|
| CervarixTM, HPV‐16/18 vaccine | To assess the risk of autoimmune diseases in women aged 9–25 years within 1 year after the first vaccine dose | Observational cohort study in the CPRD database | NCT01953822 | ENCePP id 4584 | Submitted |
|
| PandemrixTM, H1N1 pandemic influenza vaccine | To assess the risk of solid organ transplant (SOT) rejection | Retrospective self‐controlled case series in the CPRD database and HES | NCT01715792 | ENCePP id7070 | Cohet |
|
| RotarixTM, rotavirus vaccine | To assess the association between Rotarix™ and intussusception in infants in the context of the mass vaccination initiated in 2006 in Mexico | Prospective active surveillance study in hospital setting | NCT00595205 | NA | Vélazquez |
|
| Mosquirix™, Malaria vaccine | To determine baseline rates of pre‐defined diseases and meningitis leading to hospitalization or death | Prospective cohort field study in health care facilities | NCT02374450 | NA | NA |
CPRD: Clinical Practice Research Datalink database, ENCePP: European Network for Centers for Pharmacoepidemiology and Pharmacovigilance; HES: Hospital Episodes Statistics; id: identifier; NA: not applicable; NCT: National Clinical Trial. Note: All studies were approved by the respective ethics committees/ethical review boards.
Summary of feasibility assessment outputs
| Study (exposure, outcome) | Design criteria | Feasibility assessment outputs | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What was known before the feasibility assessment? | What was found by conducting the feasibility assessment? | ||
|
| Population and setting information |
‐Pivotal clinical trial data showed a potential risk. |
‐Deep understanding of the database (CPRD), for example benefit of using linked data sources. |
| Exposure |
‐Known vaccine coverage in the UK. | ‐Implementation of blinded procedure for exposure status during the case ascertainment. | |
| Outcome |
‐Data on background rates of spontaneous abortion published in the literature. |
‐Development of algorithms with high PPV for case finding. | |
|
| Population and setting information |
‐Theoretical risk of autoimmune diseases with novel adjuvanted vaccine. |
‐Agreement with regulatory authorities reached on a pre‐defined list of adverse events of special interest. |
| Exposure |
‐Known vaccine coverage in the UK. | ‐Implementation of procedure blinded to exposure status for case ascertainment. | |
| Outcome | ‐Medical management of the outcome mainly in hospital/specialist settings. |
‐Systematic literature review conducted to reinforce background incidence data. | |
|
| Population and setting information |
‐A signal emerged from real‐world use of the vaccine. |
‐Important proportion of missing data in the CPRD triggered need for collecting complementary information from GPs through questionnaire. However, lack of comprehensive information returned led to the use of HES as primary data source for case identification. |
| Exposure |
‐H1N1 mass immunization through GPs in the UK. | NA | |
| Outcome |
‐Clinical complexity of the outcome involving numerous risk factors. |
‐Development of specific algorithms for case finding, using HES as primary data source. | |
|
| Population and setting information |
‐A signal emerged from the real‐world use of a similar vaccine. | ‐Implementation of an active surveillance system. |
| Exposure | ‐Known vaccine coverage in Mexico. | NA | |
| Outcome | ‐Medical management of the outcome in hospital settings. | ‐Evaluation of the active surveillance system performed by an external company as part of a pilot study. | |
|
| Population and setting information |
‐Theoretical risk of autoimmune diseases with novel adjuvanted vaccine. |
‐Comprehensive literature review conducted to reinforce background incidence data. |
| Exposure | NA | NA | |
| Outcome | ‐Multiple outcomes (AEs) of interest | ‐Support of an expert panel for case ascertainment. | |
AE: Adverse Event; CPRD: Clinical Practice Research Datalink; GP: General Practice; HDSS: Health and Demographic Surveillance Sites; HES: Hospital Episode Statistics; HPV: human papillomavirus; KD: Kawasaki Disease; NA: Not Applicable; PPV: Positive Predictive Value; SSA: Sub‐Saharan Africa; UK: United Kingdom.
Figure 1Schematic representation of the toolbox
Figure 2Toolbox