Colin W Fuller1, Gordon W Fuller2, Simon P T Kemp3, Martin Raftery4. 1. Colin Fuller Consultancy Ltd, Sutton Bonington, UK. 2. Emergency Medicine Research in Sheffield Group, School of Health and Related Research, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK. 3. Rugby Football Union, London, UK. 4. World Rugby, Dublin, Ireland.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate World Rugby's concussion management process during Rugby World Cup (RWC) 2015. DESIGN: A prospective, whole population study. POPULATION: 639 international rugby players representing 20 countries. METHOD: The concussion management process consisted of 3 time-based, multifaceted stages: an initial on-pitch and/or pitch-side assessment of the injury, a follow-up assessment within 3 hours and an assessment at 36-48 hours. The initial on-pitch assessment targeted obvious signs of concussion, which, if identified, lead to a 'permanent removal from play' decision and a diagnosis of concussion. If the on-pitch diagnosis was unclear, a 10-min off-pitch assessment was undertaken for signs and symptoms of concussion leading to a 'suspected concussion with permanent removal from play' or a 'no indication of concussion with return to play' decision. Evaluations at 3 and 36-48 hours postmatch lead to diagnoses of 'confirmed concussion' or 'no concussion'. Medical staff's decision-making was supported during each stage by real-time video review of events. Players diagnosed with confirmed concussion followed a 5-stage graduated-return-to-play protocol before being allowed to return to training and/or competition. RESULTS: Players were evaluated for concussion on 49 occasions, of which 24 resulted in diagnoses of concussion. Fourteen players showing on-pitch signs of concussion were permanently removed from play: 4 of the 5 players removed from play following off-pitch medical room evaluation were later diagnosed with a confirmed concussion. Five players not exhibiting in-match signs or symptoms of concussion were later diagnosed with concussion. The overall incidence of concussion during RWC 2015 was 12.5 concussions/1000 player-match-hours. CONCLUSIONS: This study supports the implementation of a multimodal, multitime-based concussion evaluation process to ensure that immediate and late developing concussions are captured. Published by the BMJ Publishing Group Limited. For permission to use (where not already granted under a licence) please go to http://www.bmj.com/company/products-services/rights-and-licensing/.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate World Rugby's concussion management process during Rugby World Cup (RWC) 2015. DESIGN: A prospective, whole population study. POPULATION: 639 international rugby players representing 20 countries. METHOD: The concussion management process consisted of 3 time-based, multifaceted stages: an initial on-pitch and/or pitch-side assessment of the injury, a follow-up assessment within 3 hours and an assessment at 36-48 hours. The initial on-pitch assessment targeted obvious signs of concussion, which, if identified, lead to a 'permanent removal from play' decision and a diagnosis of concussion. If the on-pitch diagnosis was unclear, a 10-min off-pitch assessment was undertaken for signs and symptoms of concussion leading to a 'suspected concussion with permanent removal from play' or a 'no indication of concussion with return to play' decision. Evaluations at 3 and 36-48 hours postmatch lead to diagnoses of 'confirmed concussion' or 'no concussion'. Medical staff's decision-making was supported during each stage by real-time video review of events. Players diagnosed with confirmed concussion followed a 5-stage graduated-return-to-play protocol before being allowed to return to training and/or competition. RESULTS: Players were evaluated for concussion on 49 occasions, of which 24 resulted in diagnoses of concussion. Fourteen players showing on-pitch signs of concussion were permanently removed from play: 4 of the 5 players removed from play following off-pitch medical room evaluation were later diagnosed with a confirmed concussion. Five players not exhibiting in-match signs or symptoms of concussion were later diagnosed with concussion. The overall incidence of concussion during RWC 2015 was 12.5 concussions/1000 player-match-hours. CONCLUSIONS: This study supports the implementation of a multimodal, multitime-based concussion evaluation process to ensure that immediate and late developing concussions are captured. Published by the BMJ Publishing Group Limited. For permission to use (where not already granted under a licence) please go to http://www.bmj.com/company/products-services/rights-and-licensing/.
Authors: Kamal M Yakoub; Patrick O'Halloran; David J Davies; Conor Bentley; Callum N Watson; Mario Forcione; Ugo Scarpa; Jonathan R B Bishop; Emma Toman; Douglas Hammond; Matthew J Cross; Keith A Stokes; Simon P T Kemp; David K Menon; Valentina Di Pietro; Antonio Belli Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2018-11-25 Impact factor: 2.692
Authors: Ed Daly; Alan J Pearce; Emma Finnegan; Ciara Cooney; Maria McDonagh; Grainne Scully; Michael McCann; Rónán Doherty; Adam White; Simon Phelan; Nathan Howarth; Lisa Ryan Journal: BMC Sports Sci Med Rehabil Date: 2022-07-10
Authors: Valentina Di Pietro; Patrick O'Halloran; Callum N Watson; Ghazala Begum; Animesh Acharjee; Kamal M Yakoub; Conor Bentley; David J Davies; Paolo Iliceto; Gabriella Candilera; David K Menon; Matthew J Cross; Keith A Stokes; Simon Pt Kemp; Antonio Belli Journal: Br J Sports Med Date: 2021-03-23 Impact factor: 13.800