Maxime Boulet-Audet1,2, Chris Holland1,3, Tom Gheysens1,4, Fritz Vollrath1. 1. Department of Zoology, Oxford University , Oxford, United Kingdom. 2. Department of Life Sciences, Imperial College London , London, United Kingdom. 3. Department of Materials Science and Engineering, The University of Sheffield , Sheffield, United Kingdom. 4. Department of Organic and Macromolecular Chemistry, University of Ghent , Ghent, Belgium.
Abstract
Silk's outstanding mechanical properties and energy efficient solidification mechanisms provide inspiration for biomaterial self-assembly as well as offering a diverse platform of materials suitable for many biotechnology applications. Experiments now reveal that the mulberry silkworm Bombyx mori secretes its silk in a practically "unspun" state that retains much of the solvent water and exhibits a surprisingly low degree of molecular order (β-sheet crystallinity) compared to the state found in a fully formed and matured fiber. These new observations challenge the general understanding of silk spinning and in particular the role of the spinning duct for structure development. Building on this discovery we report that silk spun in low humidity appears to arrest a molecular annealing process crucial for β-sheet formation. This, in turn, has significant positive implications, enabling the production of a high fidelity reconstituted silk fibroin with properties akin to the gold standard of unspun native silk.
Silk's outstanding mechanical properties and energy efficient solidification mechanisms provide inspiration for biomaterial self-assembly as well as offering a diverse platform of materials suitable for many biotechnology applications. Experiments now reveal that the mulberry silkworm Bombyx mori secretes its silk in a practically "unspun" state that retains much of the solvent water and exhibits a surprisingly low degree of molecular order (β-sheet crystallinity) compared to the state found in a fully formed and matured fiber. These new observations challenge the general understanding of silk spinning and in particular the role of the spinning duct for structure development. Building on this discovery we report that silk spun in low humidity appears to arrest a molecular annealing process crucial for β-sheet formation. This, in turn, has significant positive implications, enabling the production of a high fidelity reconstituted silk fibroin with properties akin to the gold standard of unspun native silk.
The
natural silk spinning process entails a silk feedstock experiencing
carefully controlled flow stress[1−3] and lowering of pH,[4,5] as well as changing concentrations of metallic ions and salts as
it flows down the spinning duct.[5] Thus
far, the general perception is that once silk exits the animal, it
is “spun” and its natural processing is more or less
completed bar some postprocessing draw-down that further aligns the
molecules and supramolecular structures.[3,6] However, there
is evidence that further molecular self-assembly may continue even
after the fiber has left the animal.[2,7,8] To examine the roles of in vivo and ex vivo processing,
we examined Bombyx mori silk fibers
immediately after secretion using infrared spectroscopy. This technique
allowed us to monitor the β-sheet and water content of silk
fibers in controlled environments in order to infer the molecular
processes that might underlie the transition of silk from feedstock
to filament.We propose that through a fundamental understanding
of how silk
is spun, it is possible to gain technological insights into how to
‘unspin’ it. Understanding the reverse processing of
silk back from solid fiber to liquid feedstock has significant implications
for fibroin biomaterial preparation protocols (i.e., reconstitution
or regeneration) as they typically overlook the process history of
their input silk materials.[9−13] Given that reconstituted silk fibroin (RSF) feedstocks rely on the
disruption of the solid silk structure, that is, the highly ordered
hydrogen-bonded network of fibroin protein molecules, we hypothesized
that silk with lower ordered β-sheet crystalinity content would
allow for milder solubilization conditions and produce higher fidelity
reconstituted silk feedstocks. We now report that Bombyx
mori silk is highly hydrated when secreted and that
rapid dehydration stops β-sheet formation. This, in turn, makes
it possible to produce silk filaments that are more amenable to resolubilization.
Indeed, RSF prepared from cocoons spun in a dry environment compared
to native silk protein feedstocks taken straight from the gland are
spectroscopically and rheologically surprisingly similar, as we shall
discuss.
Methods
Experimental
Setup for Ex Vivo Monitoring of Silk Fibers
Bombyx mori silkworms were reared
under laboratory conditions on artificial media until the final instar.
Once silkworms started the construction of their cocoon, they were
placed inside the environmental chamber of the experimental setup
(Figure ).
Figure 1
(a) Photograph
of a Bombyx mori silkworm
laying a silk fiber mat to anchor cocoon construction. (b) Single
fiber spun directly on the ATR-IR diamond sensor as part of a figure-of-eight
pattern. (c) ATR-IR experimental setup showing the Bombyx mori silkworm, enclosed chamber with an air
inlet and adjacent humidity sensor.
(a) Photograph
of a Bombyx mori silkworm
laying a silk fiber mat to anchor cocoon construction. (b) Single
fiber spun directly on the ATR-IR diamond sensor as part of a figure-of-eight
pattern. (c) ATR-IR experimental setup showing the Bombyx mori silkworm, enclosed chamber with an air
inlet and adjacent humidity sensor.We controlled the relative humidity (RH) from 1.0 to 96.0
±
0.1% and kept the temperature at 25.0 ± 0.1 °C in the environmental
chamber via an air tube connected to a Wetsys (Setaram Instrumentation,
France) operating at a constant air flow rate of 30 mL/min. The chamber
was mounted on top of a Golden Gate Attenuated Total Reflection (ATR)
accessory (Specac Ltd., UK) within a Nicolet 6700 Fourier Transform
Infrared (FTIR) spectrometer (Thermo Scientific, USA). While spinning
its fiber in a figure-of-eight, Figure b shows that a silkworm will eventually spin a single
silk fiber onto the ATR. Once a fiber was detected via a change in
spectra, we prevented the silkworm from laying additional fibers on
the diamond sensor. The internally reflected IR beam probed samples
with a penetration depth of ∼1 μm over an area of about
1060 × 750 μm (length × width). Infrared spectra collected
were mostly representative of the two fibroin filaments (∼70%
of the mass), but also presented weaker infrared absorption bands
at 1395 and 1058 cm–1 from the sericin coating (see Figure S1, Supporting Information).[14]At a 4 cm–1 resolution, the spectrometer recorded
one spectrum every 0.25 s and averaged four scans for each time frame.
Spectra were collected and pretreated using OMNIC 7.3 (Thermo Scientific,
Madison, WI). An offset was applied from the average of the 1730–1750
cm–1 region and normalized using the side chain
region between 1330 and 1450 cm–1. To quantify the
dry weight fraction (dry mass/wet mass) from the infrared spectra,
141 silk solutions of varying dry weight fraction between 0% (a control
of pure demineralized water) and 95% were measured by infrared spectroscopy.
Subsequently, we measured the dry weight fraction of these standard
samples by gravimetry after exposure for >12 h under reduced pressure
(∼100 mbar) in a vacuum oven. Using MATLAB code, we quantified
the % dry weight fraction with a partial least-squares (PLS) method
using the first derivative of the 1330 to 1550 cm–1 region as predictors (i.e., X) against the measured dry weight fraction
via gravimetry as responses (i.e., Y), resulting in a model curve
with R2 = 0.973. To quantify the β-sheet
crystallinity fraction of the samples, a model was developed from
infrared spectra using samples fully converted by methanol exposure,
which achieves a maximum crystallinity of 56% based on DSC measurements
by Hu et al.[15] We then employed the PLS
method to evaluate the first derivative of the 1530 to 1690 cm–1 amide I band region, producing a model with R2 = 0.955. We validated the PLS model using
the leave-one-out cross-validation (LOOCV) method where 140 reference
spectra were used for the model training, leaving out one spectrum
for the validation. The LOOCV is then repeated using a different validation
spectrum every time until all 141 spectra are used once.To
monitor solubilization in situ, a droplet of 9.5 M lithium bromide
was deposited directly onto dry-spun fibers while collecting FTIR
spectra before subsequent washing with demineralized water type II
(ρ > 10 MΩ·cm).
Native Feedstock Preparation
To prepare native silk
feedstock (NSF), final instar Bombyx mori silkworms at the point of spinning had their silk glands extracted
and quickly submerged in type II (ρ > 10 MΩ·cm)
demineralized
water at 22 ± 2 °C, as described in more detail elsewhere.[2] Glands were cut between the sericin-free posterior
and posterior-median sections.[16−18] The osmotic pressure expelled
a small portion (10 ± 5 μL) of the gland’s content
from the posterior division within 60 s, enough volume to completely
fill the gap of the cone and plate geometry (2.3 μL) of the
rheometer. Samples were carefully blotted to remove excess water and
were deliberately not trimmed to reduce shear induced artifacts at
the edge of the rim.[2] All animal handling
in this study conforms to the Animals Act 1986 (Scientific Procedures)
of the United Kingdom.
Reconstituted Silk Feedstock Preparation
For convenience,
a summary of the following procedures may be found in Table . To prepare high fidelity reconstituted
silk feedstock (Hi-Fi RSF), final instar Bombyx mori silkworms starting to spin were placed in individual cardboard compartments
of 2 × 2 × 4 cm separated by steel meshes with 1 mm pore
size. The occupied compartments were placed in a sealed plastic box
purged with dry air (<4% RH via a AD140L air dryer (PEAK scientific)
at room temperature (22 ± 2 °C) and ventilated by a fan.
Five days later, cocoons were inverted and cut to remove any spoiled
sections of silk and to remove the pupae. Clean, cut cocoons were
stored in vacuum-sealed packs at room temperature (22 ± 2 °C)
until used. For Hi-Fi RSF, the degumming process differed from standard
preparations in that, to remove the sericin, a batch of 10 cocoons
were blended for 15 min in 500 mL of demineralized water at room temperature
(22 ± 2 °C) using a kitchen food processor. For standard,
low-fidelity, reconstituted silk fibroin (Lo-Fi RSF), we used commercially
available Chinese Bombyx mori cocoons
stored at ambient humidity and temperature. We degummed batches of
10 cocoons in 500 mL of a 1% sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3) solution at 70 °C while blending in a food processor for 30
min.
Table 1
Summary of the Silk Feedstock Preparation
Protocols
feedstock preparation step
native silk feedstock (NSF)
high fidelity reconstituted silk feedstock (Hi-Fi RSF)
After degumming, both Hi-Fi and Lo-Fi RSF silk fibers
were washed
with an excess of demineralized water type II (ρ > 10 MΩ·cm)
on top of a 50 μm pore size nylon mesh. Fibers were dried by
purging with dry air (<4% RH) at room temperature for 24 h in a
custom-built tumble dryer consisting of a rotating plastic tub purged
at >5L/min with an AD140L air dryer (PEAK scientific). After drying
overnight, the residual water content was estimated to be ∼5%
by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA).[12] Fibers
were again stored in vacuum packs at room temperature (22 ± 2
°C) until required for dissolution. For both types of RSF, 5
g of degummed silk fibers were dissolved in 20 mL of 9.5 M lithium
bromide solution (0.8 g/mL) within a 50 mL centrifuge tube heated
to 70 ± 2 °C using a water bath. During fiber dissolution,
the mixture was manually stirred gently using a glass rod. After 10
min, the silk/LiBr solution was poured into a dialysis bag of 10 kDa
molecular weight cutoff (MWCO) attached at one end to the dispensing
portion of a plastic syringe (whose tip was sealed). The dialysis
tube-syringe container was then dialyzed in a 1 L vessel against type
II (ρ > 10 MΩ·cm) demineralized water at 8 °C
using an automatic flushing system at 1 L per hour until the water
resistivity reached 2 MΩ·cm. At this point, the dialysis
tube-syringe container was hung to dry under a high air flow in a
cold room (4 ± 2 °C) until the RSF concentration reached
22 ± 2% dry weight (DW) as measured by gravimetry. Once the desired
concentration was reached, the dialysis tube was removed and stored
at 4 ± 2 °C, with the dispensing syringe portion containing
the RSF sealed with a plastic syringe piston to prevent further evaporation.
Rheo-IR Measurements
Oscillatory, viscosity, and in
situ infrared measurements were performed using the Rheo-IR platform
described elsewhere.[2] Hi-Fi-RSF (n = 5), Lo-Fi RSF (n = 7), and NSF (n = 4) samples were tested by oscillatory sweeps (623 to
0.623 rad/s, target strain 0.002) and linear shear (0.0018 to 150.6
s–1, γ(t) = 0.0014e0.0445). The average of the
three highest frequency points of G′ gave
the plateau modulus GN, while the five
highest viscosity data points informed on the apparent zero shear
viscosity η0. The spectrometer averaged 19 scans
per time frame of 5.05 s.
Results
To probe the properties of silk fibers as soon as possible after
secretion, we exploited the instinctive spinning behavior of the silkworms.
Silkworms start cocoon construction by laying a mat of anchoring fibers
on surrounding surfaces. We found that a silkworm will readily deposit
a fiber on the base that contains the ATR-IR sensor (Figure ).Our setup allowed
us to spectroscopically measure, for the first
time, silk fibers immediately after secretion (Figure a,b). The data demonstrated that freshly
secreted fibers were nearly as hydrated as the silk feedstock in the
gland. The FTIR-based PLS regression method[8] quantified the water content in freshly secreted silk fibers at
69 ± 4% (m/m), close to that of native feedstock at 78 ±
3% (m/m).[2,4] This suggests that silkworm silk dehydrates
primarily through evaporation outside the animal, rather than by recovery
in the spinning duct, as previously believed.[3]
Figure 2
(a)
High-wavenumber region infrared spectra of a single fiber immediately
after secretion (green) compared to unspun native silk feedstock (pink)
and dried fibers (black). (b) Low-wavenumber region infrared spectra
of a single fiber immediately after secretion (green) compared to
unconverted native silk feedstock (pink) and fully converted feedstock
using MeOH (blue). (c) Dry weight fraction and (d) crystallinity fraction
of a single fiber immediately after spinning at 1% RH (brown) and
96% RH (blue), as calculated from its infrared spectra.
(a)
High-wavenumber region infrared spectra of a single fiber immediately
after secretion (green) compared to unspun native silk feedstock (pink)
and dried fibers (black). (b) Low-wavenumber region infrared spectra
of a single fiber immediately after secretion (green) compared to
unconverted native silk feedstock (pink) and fully converted feedstock
using MeOH (blue). (c) Dry weight fraction and (d) crystallinity fraction
of a single fiber immediately after spinning at 1% RH (brown) and
96% RH (blue), as calculated from its infrared spectra.Further analysis allowed us to calculate fiber
β-sheet content
after secretion (Figure b). We see that not only do freshly secreted fibers have a high water
content, but with a weak β-sheet peak at 1618 cm–1, they bear a closer resemblance to unspun native silk feedstock
as opposed to silk that has been fully converted by exposure to MeOH.
To quantify this similarity, DSC data has previously suggested the
maximum fibroin crystallinity fraction to be 56%[15] with noncrystalline sericin constituting ∼30% of
secreted fibers.[9,18] This gives a maximum potential
fiber crystallinity fraction of our samples to be ∼39%. However,
the crystallinity fraction calculated from our FTIR-based PLS indicated
that freshly secreted fibers had a crystallinity fraction of only
6 ± 2%, which suggests that the freshly secreted silk contained
less than a sixth of the maximum potential β-sheet content.
This unexpected finding indicates that the silkworm’s spinning
apparatus may serve only to trigger, but not complete, silk’s
conversion/crystallization.Because fibers appear to dehydrate
through evaporation, we predicted
that the fiber’s water content strongly depends on the ambient
relative humidity as well as temperature, air speed and surface area.[19] As shown in Figure c, the dry weight fraction of the fiber stabilizes
within 600 s in humid air (96% RH). In contrast, flowing dry air (1%
RH) evaporated most of the water in the fiber in less than 1 min.We now propose that, following secretion, the fibers’ water
content affects the crystallization rate, which is supported by the
observation that β-sheet formation can continue spontaneously
once triggered,[2,19−21] a phenomenon
commonly referred to as water annealing.[22,23]Figure d shows that,
at 96% RH, β-sheets formed rapidly in the fiber just after secretion
before plateauing after several hours to reach a limit of 24 ±
2%. In contrast, fibers spun at 1% RH saw a much slower rate of development
of β-sheets, stabilizing at just 10 ± 2% crystallinity
fraction. Hence, it is clear that dry-spinning can limit the crystallinity
fraction to less than a quarter of the potential β-sheet content.Given that degree of crystallization relates to water content,
we probed this relationship further. Dry silk softens when undergoing
a reversible glass transition around 178 °C.[12,20,22,24] However, like
nylon[25] and elastin,[26] silk’s glass transition temperature (Tg) also depends on the moisture content.[11,12,19,21,27] Adsorbed water molecules lower the Tg by plasticizing the amorphous phase and increase
the protein chain mobility, which we predicted may permit reordering
of the proteins and allow the crystallization process to proceed (i.e.,
water annealing).Thus, to determine the effect of the glass
transition on the molecular
structure of freshly secreted silk, we rehydrated dry-spun silk fibers
by subjecting them to a controlled ramp in humidity (Figure a). Figure b shows that the dry weight fraction of the
fiber decreased with rising air moisture content before plateauing
around 83 ± 3% at 96% RH, indicating that the fiber’s
water content increases with humidity before finally equilibrating.[19]
Figure 3
(a) Relative humidity measured by the environment controller
during
the rehydration of Bombyx mori fibers
from 1 to 96% at 2% RH/min. (b) Dry weight fraction of a dry-spun Bombyx mori fiber under this humidity ramp as calculated
from its infrared spectra. (c) Crystallinity fraction of Bombyx mori dry-spun fibers under this humidity ramp
as calculated from its infrared spectra. (d) FTIR spectra averaged
from collection during the shaded time intervals of corresponding
color in panels a–c, representing a fiber’s dried (light
brown), rehydrated (green), and rehydrated/converted (orange) states.
(a) Relative humidity measured by the environment controller
during
the rehydration of Bombyx mori fibers
from 1 to 96% at 2% RH/min. (b) Dry weight fraction of a dry-spun Bombyx mori fiber under this humidity ramp as calculated
from its infrared spectra. (c) Crystallinity fraction of Bombyx mori dry-spun fibers under this humidity ramp
as calculated from its infrared spectra. (d) FTIR spectra averaged
from collection during the shaded time intervals of corresponding
color in panels a–c, representing a fiber’s dried (light
brown), rehydrated (green), and rehydrated/converted (orange) states.From a structural perspective,
below 76% RH the crystallinity fraction
of the fiber remained unaffected (Figure c,d). However, upon surpassing 76% RH crystallization
resumed quickly as seen by a rise in the characteristic 1608 cm–1 β-sheet band.[2] This
threshold is consistent with the fiber’s reported humidity
induced Tg(21,36,37) and X-ray scattering performed on reconstituted silk
films.[21] Interestingly, we observed the
same humidity related conversion behavior for fibers secreted from
the wild silkworm Saturnia pavonia (Figure S2 in Supporting Information).Therefore, as predicted, for dry spun silk fibers, β-sheet
formation resumes when exposed above the reported humidity/temperature
induced glass transition for silkworm silk.[11,28,29] We conclude that silk fibers continue to
crystallize at room temperature above 76% RH within just a few hours.
This leads us to propose that practically all commercial sources of Bombyx mori silk have already achieved their full
β-sheet content during their production, transport and storage.
To confirm this inference, we induced silkworms to naturally spin
their cocoons in conditions of both high and low humidity.From
the spectra presented in Figure , we found that when spun and stored below
the Tg, cocoons preserved their low crystallinity
(12 ± 2%), whereas wet postspinning storage results in cocoons
with 20 ± 2% crystallinity, similar to that of commercial cocoons
at 22 ± 2%. This has a profound impact on the preparation of
silk-based biomaterials: by inducing silkworms to spin at low RH,
we propose that low crystallinity cocoons could be prepared at ambient
temperature without the usual chemicals and potentially solubilized
under milder conditions.
Figure 4
Average infrared spectra of dry stored (green)
and wet stored (blue) Bombyx mori dry-spun
cocoons as well as the difference
(red) due to conversion multiplied by a factor of 5 with a spectrum
of a commercial cocoon presented as a reference (black) with numbers
stated in % representing calculated average crystallinities of silk
cocoons (n = 12).
Average infrared spectra of dry stored (green)
and wet stored (blue) Bombyx mori dry-spun
cocoons as well as the difference
(red) due to conversion multiplied by a factor of 5 with a spectrum
of a commercial cocoon presented as a reference (black) with numbers
stated in % representing calculated average crystallinities of silk
cocoons (n = 12).Degumming involves the removal of a protein, sericin, which
coats
the silk fiber and serves to bond fibers together in the cocoon. This
typically requires boiling cocoons in an alkaline solution for 5 to
90 min.[30−32] It is now widely understood that the heating process
reduces the molecular weight of the fibroin.[1,9,10,33,34] The lower average molecular weight distribution results
in decreased feedstock viscosity and solid material tensile modulus
which could limit their applications.[1,2,10,31,33] By using dry-spun cocoons we found that they can be degummed without
heat or additional chemicals via a simple mechanical blending in demineralized
water. To confirm the removal of sericin once dried, we noted that
fibers had lost approximately 30% weight,[18] did not have sericin upon microscopic inspection (data not shown)
and did not show any FTIR bands at 1395 and 1068 cm–1 that attributed to sericin.[14]We
found that these mechanically degummed low crystallinity fibers
could then be solubilized in 70 °C lithium bromide in just 5
min (as opposed to hours as previously reported[32]). Furthermore, it was also possible to solubilize these
fibers in LiBr at room temperature (Figure S3 in Supporting Information). Both approaches
resulted in a clear “optical grade” RSF.[32]To assess the quality of this newly created
RSF, we compared its
rheological properties to standard RSF and unspun native silk fibroin
(NSF) at similar concentrations (23 ± 3% DW). Our rheological
findings indicate that feedstock prepared from low crystallinity fibers
had flow properties remarkably similar to NSF. Thus, we now refer
to low crystallinity silk based RSF feedstocks as high fidelity (Hi-Fi)
and standard reconstituted silk feedstock as low fidelity (Lo-Fi).The similarity between Hi-Fi RSF and NSF is highlighted in oscillatory
rheology tests, which evaluate the capacity of the feedstock to store
and dissipate energy (Figure ).[1,2] For a typical polymer melt, the elastic
modulus (G′) dominates at high frequencies
oscillations while the viscous modulus (G″)
prevails at lower frequencies. Plotted in Figure and summarized in Table , the crossover point where G′ = G″ occurred for NSF at 10 ±
3 rad/s corresponds to a relaxation time of 0.6 ± 0.1 s. By presenting
a crossover at 15 ± 6 rad/s (τp = 0.4 ±
0.2 s), our Hi-Fi RSF also displayed a crossover. This is a key finding
as, while the crossover is common to NSF, and may in fact be a generic
feature,[35,36] it has only once been reported for a recombinant
spider silk feedstock, and never for RSF.[37]
Figure 5
Representative
elastic (i.e., storage) modulus G′ (red marker
outlines) and viscous (i.e., loss) modulus G″
(blue marker outlines) of native silk feedstocks
(NSF (green circles)), high-fidelity reconstituted silk feedstock
(Hi-Fi RSF (blue squares)) and low-fidelity reconstituted silk feedstocks
(Lo-Fi RSF (yellow diamonds)) at comparable 22 ± 3% dry weight
fraction. The solid lines represent the best fit of the modulus data
using a binary (i.e., two-unit) expressions based on the Maxwellian
“springs and dashpots” model.[35,36]
Table 2
Summary of the Oscillatory
Rheological
Results of Silk Feedstocka
property
NSF
Hi-Fi RSF
Lo-Fi RSF
g3 (kPa)
4 ± 2
1.3 ± 0.6
0.06 ± 0.04
τ3 (S)
0.22 ± 0.05
0.43 ± 0.07
3 ± 1
g4 (kPa)
11 ± 3
7 ± 2
6 ± 5
τ4 (s)
0.017 ± 0.001
0.020 ± 0.002
0.010 ± 0.008
τp (s)
0.6 ± 0.1
0.4 ± 0.2
crossover (rad/s)
10 ± 3
15 ± 6
The error on the calculated moduli
values g3 and g4 next to the relaxation times τ3 and τ4 was obtained from the standard deviation of five measurements.
Representative
elastic (i.e., storage) modulus G′ (red marker
outlines) and viscous (i.e., loss) modulus G″
(blue marker outlines) of native silk feedstocks
(NSF (green circles)), high-fidelity reconstituted silk feedstock
(Hi-Fi RSF (blue squares)) and low-fidelity reconstituted silk feedstocks
(Lo-Fi RSF (yellow diamonds)) at comparable 22 ± 3% dry weight
fraction. The solid lines represent the best fit of the modulus data
using a binary (i.e., two-unit) expressions based on the Maxwellian
“springs and dashpots” model.[35,36]The error on the calculated moduli
values g3 and g4 next to the relaxation times τ3 and τ4 was obtained from the standard deviation of five measurements.Recent rheological work performed
on NSF has indicated the presence
of relaxation processes, which can be described by parallel Maxwell
units.[35,36,38] Applying this
approach to our work a two-unit model with two modulus terms (g3 and g4) and two
relaxation times (τ3 and τ4) describes
our oscillatory data well and further highlights the similarity between
Hi-Fi RSF and NSF (Table ).[35,36] When Lo-Fi RSF is brought into
comparison, it is clear from both Figure and Table that the feedstocks’ capacity to store energy
is 2 orders of magnitude lower (0.06 ± 0.04 kPa), which largely
agrees with previous findings.[1] This is
likely a result of the significantly different relaxation mode times
brought about by a reduced molecular weight.[1,9,10,33,34]To determine Hi-Fi RSF’s response to
shear flow and to mimic
flow fields comparable to in vivo spinning,[1,2,34] we subjected samples to an exponential step
shear rate ramp while measuring their infrared absorption using our
previously developed IR-rheometry platform (Figure ).[2]
Figure 6
Viscosity,
normal force, and crystallinity fraction measured under
an exponential shear ramp from 0 to 150 s–1 for
native silk feedstocks (NSF, (green)), high-fidelity reconstituted
silk feedstock (Hi-Fi RSF, (blue)), and low-fidelity reconstituted
silk feedstocks (Lo-Fi RSF, (orange)) at 22 ± 3% DW. Shaded area
(IV) represents a period of time in which the samples were not sheared
but left stationary and structure development monitored. The instability
shear rate is denoted by the vertical dotted line and symbol .
Viscosity,
normal force, and crystallinity fraction measured under
an exponential shear ramp from 0 to 150 s–1 for
native silk feedstocks (NSF, (green)), high-fidelity reconstituted
silk feedstock (Hi-Fi RSF, (blue)), and low-fidelity reconstituted
silk feedstocks (Lo-Fi RSF, (orange)) at 22 ± 3% DW. Shaded area
(IV) represents a period of time in which the samples were not sheared
but left stationary and structure development monitored. The instability
shear rate is denoted by the vertical dotted line and symbol .Using rheo-IR,[2] viscosity results
confirmed
that our Hi-Fi RSF behaved like NSF under shear, implying comparable
spinnability.[1] Below 0.1 s–1 (region I in Figure , upper pane), Hi-Fi RSF had a zero shear viscosity η0 of 1.0 ± 0.5 kPa·s, much closer to the η0 of 1.3 ± 0.6 kPa·s for NSF than the 0.09 ± 0.05 kPa·s
for Lo-Fi RSF. In this plateau region, the normal force remained constant
(middle pane), while no changes in the crystallinity fraction were
measured (bottom pane). Region II on Figure shows that Hi-Fi RSF underwent shear thinning
and an increase in normal force comparable to that of NSF, while the
rheological properties of Lo-Fi RSF did not change significantly.
In region II, the center of gravity of the amide II band began to
downshift due to the molecular alignment for both NSF and Hi-Fi RSF
(Figure S4 in Supporting Information). The lack of infrared absorption change for Lo-Fi
RSF suggests that Lo-Fi RSF did not align as much in response to the
same shear rate.[1,2]Upon reaching an instability
shear rate () of 50 ± 20 s–1 (region
III), both Hi-Fi RSF and NSF feedstocks rapidly became unstable. Coinciding
with an increase in viscosity, the β-sheet crystallinity fraction
also started to rise. In contrast, Lo-Fi RSF clearly lacked such transition,
suggesting a completely different behavior under the same flow conditions.For both native silk and Hi-Fi RSF, following the onset of crystallization
and subsequent gelation, no further shear can be applied without sample
slippage or ejection. We find that when this occurs, native and Hi-Fi
RSF only have a crystallinity fraction of 5 to 8%, an amount similar
to the β-sheet content we measured in fibers immediately after
secretion (Figure d). Thus, by subjecting silk feedstocks to the maximum amount of
shear stress possible in this mode of deformation, Rheo-IR also corroborates
that the majority of β-sheets appear to form by postsecretion
water-annealing rather than via shear in the spinning duct.This is further corroborated by stopping the samples from being
sheared further and following their structure development (Figure , region IV). We
find that post-shearing, silk crystallization continued to increase
in both Hi-Fi RSF and NSF over many hours, akin to our findings for
freshly spun silk. These results imply that the solubilization process
for Hi-Fi RSF retained silk’s natural ability to respond to
shear processing and ability to self-assemble, something entirely
lacking in the standard Lo-Fi RSF control.
Conclusions
Through our FTIR-based approach we demonstrated that Bombyx mori silk fibers immediately after secretion
were highly hydrated and dehydrated primarily through evaporation
ex vivo. Moreover, immediately after secretion, this silk had less
than 15% of the maximum potential β-sheet content in the fiber.
By then exposing fibers to different levels of humidity, we found
the fibers’ crystallinity fraction can be arrested or increased
if exposed above the reported humidity/temperature induced glass transition
for silkworm silk (∼76% RH at ∼22 °C). These results
imply that water plays a crucial role in the self-assembly of β-sheets
and subsequently the level of crystallinity in a fiber.Moving
from single fiber to entire cocoon, we report that by interrupting
water annealing through rapid dehydration enables degumming and solubilization
under milder conditions during reconstitution. Through the use of
rheology, we demonstrated that these improved, high fidelity, reconstituted
silk feedstocks exhibited flow properties very similar to native unspun
silk and via Rheo-IR, they undergo similar structural transitions
in response to flow. This represents a significant technological step
forward which we hope will lead to novel fundamental insights into
the natural silk production process as well as open the door for new
fibroin-based biomaterial applications.[39−44]
Authors: Lindsay S Wray; Xiao Hu; Jabier Gallego; Irene Georgakoudi; Fiorenzo G Omenetto; Daniel Schmidt; David L Kaplan Journal: J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater Date: 2011-06-21 Impact factor: 3.368