Daniel L Smith1, Bisrat G Debeb1, Howard D Thames2, Wendy A Woodward3. 1. Department of Radiation Oncology, The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, Texas; Morgan Welch Inflammatory Breast Cancer Research Program and Clinic, The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, Texas. 2. Department of Biostatistics, The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, Texas. 3. Department of Radiation Oncology, The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, Texas; Morgan Welch Inflammatory Breast Cancer Research Program and Clinic, The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, Texas. Electronic address: wwoodward@mdanderson.org.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Prophylactic cranial irradiation (PCI) involves giving radiation to the entire brain with the goals of reducing the incidence of brain metastasis and improving overall survival. Experimentally, we have demonstrated that PCI prevents brain metastases in a breast cancer mouse model. We developed a computational model to expand on and aid in the interpretation of our experimental results. METHODS AND MATERIALS: MATLAB was used to develop a computational model of brain metastasis and PCI in mice. Model input parameters were optimized such that the model output would match the experimental number of metastases per mouse from the unirradiated group. An independent in vivo-limiting dilution experiment was performed to validate the model. The effect of whole brain irradiation at different measurement points after tumor cells were injected was evaluated in terms of the incidence, number of metastases, and tumor burden and was then compared with the corresponding experimental data. RESULTS: In the optimized model, the correlation between the number of metastases per mouse and the experimental fits was >95. Our attempt to validate the model with a limiting dilution assay produced 99.9% correlation with respect to the incidence of metastases. The model accurately predicted the effect of whole-brain irradiation given 3 weeks after cell injection but substantially underestimated its effect when delivered 5 days after cell injection. The model further demonstrated that delaying whole-brain irradiation until the development of gross disease introduces a dose threshold that must be reached before a reduction in incidence can be realized. CONCLUSIONS: Our computational model of mouse brain metastasis and PCI correlated strongly with our experiments with unirradiated mice. The results further suggest that early treatment of subclinical disease is more effective than irradiating established disease.
PURPOSE: Prophylactic cranial irradiation (PCI) involves giving radiation to the entire brain with the goals of reducing the incidence of brain metastasis and improving overall survival. Experimentally, we have demonstrated that PCI prevents brain metastases in a breast cancermouse model. We developed a computational model to expand on and aid in the interpretation of our experimental results. METHODS AND MATERIALS: MATLAB was used to develop a computational model of brain metastasis and PCI in mice. Model input parameters were optimized such that the model output would match the experimental number of metastases per mouse from the unirradiated group. An independent in vivo-limiting dilution experiment was performed to validate the model. The effect of whole brain irradiation at different measurement points after tumor cells were injected was evaluated in terms of the incidence, number of metastases, and tumor burden and was then compared with the corresponding experimental data. RESULTS: In the optimized model, the correlation between the number of metastases per mouse and the experimental fits was >95. Our attempt to validate the model with a limiting dilution assay produced 99.9% correlation with respect to the incidence of metastases. The model accurately predicted the effect of whole-brain irradiation given 3 weeks after cell injection but substantially underestimated its effect when delivered 5 days after cell injection. The model further demonstrated that delaying whole-brain irradiation until the development of gross disease introduces a dose threshold that must be reached before a reduction in incidence can be realized. CONCLUSIONS: Our computational model of mousebrain metastasis and PCI correlated strongly with our experiments with unirradiated mice. The results further suggest that early treatment of subclinical disease is more effective than irradiating established disease.
Authors: A Aupérin; R Arriagada; J P Pignon; C Le Péchoux; A Gregor; R J Stephens; P E Kristjansen; B E Johnson; H Ueoka; H Wagner; J Aisner Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 1999-08-12 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Jing Lu; Patricia S Steeg; Janet E Price; Savitri Krishnamurthy; Sendurai A Mani; James Reuben; Massimo Cristofanilli; Gabriela Dontu; Luc Bidaut; Vicente Valero; Gabriel N Hortobagyi; Dihua Yu Journal: Cancer Res Date: 2009-05-26 Impact factor: 12.701
Authors: Paul D Brown; Stephanie Pugh; Nadia N Laack; Jeffrey S Wefel; Deepak Khuntia; Christina Meyers; Ali Choucair; Sherry Fox; John H Suh; David Roberge; Vivek Kavadi; Soren M Bentzen; Minesh P Mehta; Deborah Watkins-Bruner Journal: Neuro Oncol Date: 2013-08-16 Impact factor: 12.300
Authors: Ann H Klopp; Lara Lacerda; Anshul Gupta; Bisrat G Debeb; Travis Solley; Li Li; Erika Spaeth; Wei Xu; Xiaomei Zhang; Michael T Lewis; James M Reuben; Savitri Krishnamurthy; Mauro Ferrari; Rogério Gaspar; Thomas A Buchholz; Massimo Cristofanilli; Frank Marini; Michael Andreeff; Wendy A Woodward Journal: PLoS One Date: 2010-08-16 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Emilly S Villodre; Xiaoding Hu; Bedrich L Eckhardt; Richard Larson; Lei Huo; Ester C Yoon; Yun Gong; Juhee Song; Shuying Liu; Naoto T Ueno; Savitri Krishnamurthy; Stefan Pusch; Debu Tripathy; Wendy A Woodward; Bisrat G Debeb Journal: J Natl Cancer Inst Date: 2022-04-11 Impact factor: 11.816
Authors: Cátia Monteiro; Lauritz Miarka; María Perea-García; Neibla Priego; Pedro García-Gómez; Laura Álvaro-Espinosa; Ana de Pablos-Aragoneses; Natalia Yebra; Diana Retana; Patricia Baena; Coral Fustero-Torre; Osvaldo Graña-Castro; Kevin Troulé; Eduardo Caleiras; Patricia Tezanos; Pablo Muela; Elisa Cintado; José Luis Trejo; Juan Manuel Sepúlveda; Pedro González-León; Luis Jiménez-Roldán; Luis Miguel Moreno; Olga Esteban; Ángel Pérez-Núñez; Aurelio Hernández-Lain; José Mazarico Gallego; Irene Ferrer; Rocío Suárez; Eva M Garrido-Martín; Luis Paz-Ares; Celine Dalmasso; Elizabeth Cohen-Jonathan Moyal; Aurore Siegfried; Aisling Hegarty; Stephen Keelan; Damir Varešlija; Leonie S Young; Malte Mohme; Yvonne Goy; Harriet Wikman; Jose Fernández-Alén; Guillermo Blasco; Lucía Alcázar; Clara Cabañuz; Sergei I Grivennikov; Andrada Ianus; Noam Shemesh; Claudia C Faria; Rebecca Lee; Paul Lorigan; Emilie Le Rhun; Michael Weller; Riccardo Soffietti; Luca Bertero; Umberto Ricardi; Joaquim Bosch-Barrera; Elia Sais; Eduard Teixidor; Alejandro Hernández-Martínez; Alfonso Calvo; Javier Aristu; Santiago M Martin; Alvaro Gonzalez; Omer Adler; Neta Erez; Manuel Valiente Journal: Nat Med Date: 2022-04-11 Impact factor: 87.241
Authors: Daniel L Smith; Bisrat G Debeb; Parmeswaran Diagaradjane; Richard Larson; Swaminathan Kumar; Jing Ning; Lara Lacerda; Li Li; Wendy A Woodward Journal: Genes Cancer Date: 2021-03-13
Authors: Manuel Valiente; Amanda E D Van Swearingen; Carey K Anders; Amos Bairoch; Adrienne Boire; Paula D Bos; Diana M Cittelly; Neta Erez; Gino B Ferraro; Dai Fukumura; Brunilde Gril; Meenhard Herlyn; Sheri L Holmen; Rakesh K Jain; Johanna A Joyce; Mihaela Lorger; Joan Massague; Josh Neman; Nicola R Sibson; Patricia S Steeg; Frits Thorsen; Leonie S Young; Damir Varešlija; Adina Vultur; Frances Weis-Garcia; Frank Winkler Journal: Cancer Res Date: 2020-07-08 Impact factor: 12.701
Authors: Emilly S Villodre; Xiaoding Hu; Richard Larson; Pascal Finetti; Kristen Gomez; Wintana Balema; Shane R Stecklein; Ginette Santiago-Sanchez; Savitri Krishnamurthy; Juhee Song; Xiaoping Su; Naoto T Ueno; Debu Tripathy; Steven Van Laere; François Bertucci; Pablo Vivas-Mejía; Wendy A Woodward; Bisrat G Debeb Journal: Mol Oncol Date: 2021-08-27 Impact factor: 6.603