Literature DB >> 27468864

The moral unacceptability of abandoning human embryos.

Ryan Tonkens1.   

Abstract

The focus of this paper is on the ethics of the act of wilfully "abandoning" human embryos. I offer a critique of this unique behaviour, which draws on empirical data about who wilfully abandons their surplus embryos and why. I argue that wilful embryo abandonment is in all cases avoidable. Given this, I make three observations which speak to the moral unacceptability of embryo abandonment. The first has to do with the abandoner's unfair treatment of the clinic storing their abandoned embryos, and the second the abandoner's apparent lack of sympathy for the plight of other people like them, who require assistance (e.g. donated embryos) in pursuing their family-building goals. The third observation has to do with the abandoner's failure to meet their responsibility for directing the handling of their embryos, and what their reaction to that responsibility (through abandonment) says about their moral character in certain respects. There is good reason to conclude that wilful embryo abandonment is morally unacceptable. One implication of this normative conclusion is that clinics have reasonable grounds for justifying the design of their policies and practices so as to make wilful embryo abandonment impossible.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Abandoned human embryos; Final disposition decisions; Responsibility; Wilful embryo abandonment

Mesh:

Year:  2016        PMID: 27468864     DOI: 10.1007/s40592-016-0060-4

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Monash Bioeth Rev        ISSN: 1321-2753


  9 in total

1.  Abandonment and accumulation: embryonic futures in the United States and Ecuador.

Authors:  Elizabeth F S Roberts
Journal:  Med Anthropol Q       Date:  2011-06

2.  Are alcoholics less deserving of liver transplants?

Authors:  Daniel Brudney
Journal:  Hastings Cent Rep       Date:  2007 Jan-Feb       Impact factor: 2.683

3.  A Theory of Unborn Life: From Abortion to Genetic Manipulation.

Authors:  Matt James
Journal:  New Bioeth       Date:  2016-04

4.  Disposition of abandoned embryos: a committee opinion.

Authors: 
Journal:  Fertil Steril       Date:  2013-03-05       Impact factor: 7.329

5.  Who abandons embryos after IVF?

Authors:  A P H Walsh; O M Tsar; D J Walsh; P M Baldwin; L V Shkrobot; E S Sills
Journal:  Ir Med J       Date:  2010-04

6.  The frozen embryo and its nonresponding parents.

Authors:  Veerle Provoost; Guido Pennings; Petra De Sutter; Marc Dhont
Journal:  Fertil Steril       Date:  2011-03-15       Impact factor: 7.329

7.  To continue or discontinue storage of cryopreserved embryos? Patients' decisions in view of their child wish.

Authors:  V Provoost; G Pennings; P De Sutter; J Gerris; A Van de Velde; M Dhont
Journal:  Hum Reprod       Date:  2011-01-18       Impact factor: 6.918

8.  A private matter: how patients decide what to do with cryopreserved embryos after infertility treatment.

Authors:  Veerle Provoost; Guido Pennings; Petra De Sutter; Marc Dhont
Journal:  Hum Fertil (Camb)       Date:  2012-12       Impact factor: 2.767

9.  Adoption first? The disposition of human embryos.

Authors:  Timothy F Murphy
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2013-06-11       Impact factor: 2.903

  9 in total
  3 in total

1.  An alternative proposal to the destruction of abandoned human embryos.

Authors:  Norbert Gleicher; Arthur L Caplan
Journal:  Nat Biotechnol       Date:  2018-02-06       Impact factor: 54.908

2.  Discarding IVF embryos: reporting on global practices.

Authors:  M Simopoulou; K Sfakianoudis; P Giannelou; A Rapani; E Maziotis; P Tsioulou; S Grigoriadis; E Simopoulos; D Mantas; M Lambropoulou; M Koutsilieris; K Pantos; J C Harper
Journal:  J Assist Reprod Genet       Date:  2019-12-01       Impact factor: 3.412

3.  Abandoned embryos in Brazil: advances in the decisions. Are we there yet?

Authors:  Maria do Carmo Borges de Souza; Roberto de Azevedo Antunes; Ana Cristina Allemand Mancebo
Journal:  JBRA Assist Reprod       Date:  2018-06-01
  3 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.