| Literature DB >> 27350891 |
Eric Hau1, Han Shen2, Catherine Clark3, Peter H Graham4, Eng-Siew Koh5, Kerrie L McDonald6.
Abstract
Numerous randomised controlled trials have demonstrated the benefit of radiation therapy in patients with newly diagnosed glioblastoma and it has been the cornerstone of treatment for decades. The aims of this review are to (1) Briefly outline the historical studies which resulted in radiation being the current standard of care as used in the Stupp et al. trial (2) Discuss the evolving role of radiation therapy in the management of elderly patients (3) Review the current evidence and ongoing studies of radiation use in the recurrent/salvage setting and (4) Discuss the continuing controversies of volume delineation in the planning of radiation delivery.Entities:
Keywords: Brain tumour; glioblastoma; radiation; radiotherapy
Mesh:
Year: 2016 PMID: 27350891 PMCID: PMC4914819 DOI: 10.1002/jmrs.149
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Med Radiat Sci ISSN: 2051-3895
Randomised studies of radiation therapy in the management of newly diagnosed glioblastoma
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reagan et al | Whole brain radiation 50Gy in 25‐28# | MS = 11 months | CCNU + radiation | MS = 12 months | CCNU alone | MS = 6 months | NA | NA |
| Walker et al | Whole brain radiation 50Gy‐60Gy | MS = 35 weeks | BCNU + radiation | MS = 34.5 weeks | BCNU alone | MS = 18.5 weeks | Best supportive care | MS = 14 weeks |
| Kristiansen et al | Whole brain radiation 45Gy in 25# | MS = 10.8 months | Radiation + IV bleomycin | MS = 10.8 months | No radiation or chemotherapy | MS = 5.2 months | NA | NA |
| Walker et al | Whole brain 60Gy in 30‐35# | MS = 367weeks | BCNU + radiation | MS = 49 weeks | Semustine + radiation | MS = 43 weeks | Semustine alone | 31 weeks |
| Andersen et al | Radiation alone | 1 yr survival 19% | No radiation | 1 year survival 0% | NA | NA | NA | NA |
| Sandberg‐Wollheim | Radiation to 58Gy + PVC | MS = 62 weeks | PVC alone | MS = 42 weeks | NA | NA | NA | NA |
BCNU, 1,3‐bis(2‐chloroethyl)‐1‐nitrosourea (Carmustine); CCNU, lomustine; PVC, procarbazine, vincristine, and lomustine; MS, median survival
Examples of the variability in radiation volume delineation in glioblastoma
| Technique | Chemotherapy | Pre‐ versus post‐op MRI | Phase 1 | Phase 2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minniti et al | Yes, concurrent and adjuvant TMZ | Post‐op | GTV = resection cavity + residual volume on contrast enhancing T1 images. CTV = GTV + 2 cm. Dose = 60 Gy/30#. For CTV > 250 cm3 Phase I treated to dose = 50 Gy/25#. PTV = CTV + 0.3 cm | For CTV > 250 cm3. GTV as described. CTV = GTV + 1 cm. Dose = 10 Gy/5#. PTV = CTV + 0.3 cm |
| RTOG 0837 | Yes, concurrent and adjuvant TMZ | Post‐op but use pre‐op for correlation | GTV1 = T2 or FLAIR abnormality including post‐operative enhancement and resection cavity. CTV1 = GTV1 + 2 cm limited to natural barriers to tumour growth. If no oedema then PTV = Contrast enhanced lesion + surgical cavity + 2.5 cm margin. PTV1 = CTV1 + 3–5 mm. Dose = 46 Gy/23# | GTV2 = contrast enhancing T1 lesion and surgical cavity. CTV2 = GTV2 + 2 cm limited to natural barriers of tumour growth. PTV2 = CTV2 + 3–5 mm. Dose = 14 Gy/7# |
| MD Anderson | 44% had some form of systemic therapy. Only 1 patient concurrent TMZ | Post‐op | GTV = resection cavity and T1 contrast enhancement. CTV = GTV + 2 cm. PTV = CTV + 0.5 cm. Dose = 50 Gy/25# | PTV = GTV + 0.5 cm. Dose = 10 Gy/5# |
| NABTT | Yes | Post‐op | GTV1 = T1 enhancing and non‐enhancing tumour volume (T2 or FLAIR). CTV1 = GTV1 plus a margin of 5 mm. PTV1 = CTV1 plus a margin of 3–5 mm. Dose = 46 Gy in 23 # | GTV2 = T1 enhancing tumour volume. CTV2 = GTV2 + 5 mm. PTV2 = CTV2 + 3–5 mm. Dose = 14 Gy/7# |
| Jansen et al | No | Pre‐ and post‐op | CTV = T2 high signal and contrast enhancing on CT. PTV = CTV + 5 mm. 60 Gy in 30# in single phase | If CTV > 250 cm3 then 2nd target volume for boost after 40–50 Gy |
| Stupp et al | Yes | Pre‐op | CTV = GTV + 2–3 cm. 1 phase 60 Gy in 30 # | Nil |
| Clinical Practice Guidelines for the management of adult gliomas: Astrocytomas and Oligodendrogliomas | Yes | Post‐op | GTV = contrast enhancing area on CT or T1 weighted MRI. CTV = GTV + high signal area on T2 weighted MRI or perifocal hypodense zone on CT. PTV = CTV + 5 mm. Dose = 60 Gy in 30# | No recommendations given |
GTV, gross tumour volume; CTV, clinical target volume; PTV, planning target volume; RTOG, radiation therapy oncology group; NABTT, new approaches to brain treatment therapy.
Suggested dose/fractionation for glioblastoma
| Technique | Phase | Dose | Fractionation | Fractions per fortnight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3D Conformal Technique single phase | 60 Gy | 30 | 10 | |
| 3D Conformal Technique 2 phase | ||||
| Phase 1 | 46 Gy | 23 | 10 | |
| Phase 2 | 14 Gy | 7 | 10 | |
| Intensity modulated simultaneous integrated boost | ||||
| Phase 1 | 50 Gy | 30 | 10 | |
| Phase 2 | 60 Gy | 30 | 10 |
Guidelines are consistent with that published by eviQ.75
Suggested delineation method for glioblastoma using single phase technique
| GTV |
| Where tumour has been biopsied (open biopsy only, stereotactic biopsy excluded) ‐ GTV consists of the region of enhancement without oedema on the pre‐operative CT/MRI |
| Where the tumour has been resected – GTV consists of the surgical tumour bed plus any residual enhancing tumour as seen on the planning scan |
| CTV |
| GTV + 10–15 mm |
| The CTV should account for the new position of the abnormality/tumour bed shift on the planning scan and any post‐operative imaging whilst respecting anatomical boundaries |
| The CTV extends to the contralateral hemisphere only when a midline structure as the corpus callosum is invaded by tumour as visualised on T2 weighted MRI |
| The tentorium and meninges should be considered as anatomical borders and therefore a margin of 5 mm is sufficient to encompass the microscopic spread at these borders |
| PTV |
| CTV + 3–5 mm |
| For all PTV expansions, a smaller CTV‐PTV expansion may be appropriate in departments which have quantified their set‐up errors |
Guidelines are consistent with that published by eviQ.75
Suggested delineation method for glioblastoma using 2 phase technique
| Phase 1 | |
| Phase 1 GTV | Where tumour has been GTV consists of the region of enhancement without oedema on the pre‐operative CT/MRI Where the tumour has been GTV consists of the surgical tumour bed plus any residual enhancing tumour as seen on the planning scan |
| Phase 1 CTV |
GTV + 10–15 mm (consider inclusion of any oedema on the CT/MRI scans) The CTV should account for the new position of the abnormality/tumour bed shift on the planning scan and any post‐operative imaging whilst respecting anatomical boundaries |
| Phase 1 PTV | CTV + 3–5 mm margin plus additional margin to account for department setup accuracy |
| Phase 2 | |
| Phase 2 GTV | GTV consists of region of enhancement without oedema on the pre‐operative CT/MRI |
| Phase 2 CTV | GTV + 5 mm (respecting OAR tolerances) |
| Phase 2 PTV | CTV + 3–5 mm margin plus additional margin to account for department setup accuracy |
Guidelines are consistent with that published by eviQ.75 GTV, gross tumour volume; CTV, clinical target volume; PTV, planning target volume.