Nityanand Sharma1, Hamid Keshmiri2, Xiaodong Zhou3, Ten It Wong3, Christian Petri4, Ulrich Jonas5, Bo Liedberg6, Jakub Dostalek2. 1. Biosensor Technologies, AIT-Austrian Institute of Technology, Muthgasse 11, Wien, Austria; Centre for Biomimetic Sensor Science, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, 50 Nanyang Drive, Singapore 637553, Singapore. 2. Biosensor Technologies, AIT-Austrian Institute of Technology , Muthgasse 11, Wien, Austria. 3. Institute of Materials Research & Engineering, ASTAR, Singapore , 2 Fusionopolis Way, #08-03, Innovis, Singapore 138634, Singapore. 4. Biosensor Technologies, AIT-Austrian Institute of Technology, Muthgasse 11, Wien, Austria; Macromolecular Chemistry, Department Chemistry-Biology, University of Siegen, Adolf-Reichwein-Strasse 2, Siegen 57076, Germany. 5. Macromolecular Chemistry, Department Chemistry-Biology, University of Siegen , Adolf-Reichwein-Strasse 2, Siegen 57076, Germany. 6. Centre for Biomimetic Sensor Science, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Nanyang Technological University , 50 Nanyang Drive, Singapore 637553, Singapore.
Abstract
New plasmonic structure with actively tunable optical characteristics based on thermoresponsive hydrogel is reported. It consists of a thin, template-stripped Au film with arrays of nanoholes that is tethered to a transparent support by a cross-linked poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (pNIPAAm)-based polymer network. Upon a contact of the porous Au surface with an aqueous environment, a rapid flow of water through the pores enables swelling and collapsing of the underlying pNIPAAm network. The swelling and collapsing could be triggered by small temperature changes around the lower critical solution temperature (LCST) of the hydrogel. The process is reversible, and it is associated with strong refractive index changes of Δn ∼ 0.1, which characteristically alters the spectrum of surface plasmon modes supported by the porous Au film. This approach can offer new attractive means for optical biosensors with flow-through architecture and actively tunable plasmonic transmission optical filters.
New plasmonic structure with actively tunable optical characteristics based on thermoresponsive hydrogel is reported. It consists of a thin, template-stripped Au film with arrays of nanoholes that is tethered to a transparent support by a cross-linked poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (pNIPAAm)-based polymer network. Upon a contact of the porous Au surface with an aqueous environment, a rapid flow of water through the pores enables swelling and collapsing of the underlying pNIPAAm network. The swelling and collapsing could be triggered by small temperature changes around the lower critical solution temperature (LCST) of the hydrogel. The process is reversible, and it is associated with strong refractive index changes of Δn ∼ 0.1, which characteristically alters the spectrum of surface plasmon modes supported by the porous Au film. This approach can offer new attractive means for optical biosensors with flow-through architecture and actively tunable plasmonic transmission optical filters.
The extraordinary transmission
of light through thin metallic films
with periodic nanohole arrays (NHAs)[1] has
attracted substantial attention in the past decade. This phenomenon
is attributed to the diffractive excitation of surface plasmon polaritons
(SPPs), and it enables efficient tunneling of light through (otherwise
opaque) metallic film in narrow wavelength regimes.[2,3] The
transmission characteristics of metallic NHAs can be controlled by
shape, depth, and periodicity of the nanoholes as well as by the type
of metal and refractive index of the surrounding medium.[4−6] Plasmonic NHAs have been prepared by a range of modern fabrication
techniques such as focused ion beam milling,[7] laser interference lithography,[8] electron
beam lithography,[9] and template stripping.[10] The relative simplicity of design and fabrication
of plasmonic NHAs have paved the way for their applications in detection
and observation of biomolecules by using direct refractometric format,[7,9,11] fluorescence spectroscopy,[12] surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy,[13] and surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy[14] as well for spectral filtering[15] and transparent electrode.[16] Conventional designs of plasmonic nanostructures are static, and
their optical properties are fixed once they are prepared. In order
to actuate resonant coupling to surface plasmons, metallic nanostructures
have been interfaced with inorganic materials with electro-optically[17,18] or magneto-optically[19,20] modulated refractive index. In
parallel, organic materials have been explored for actuating of surface
plasmon resonance by refractive index variations associated with the
photochromic effects[21] and liquid crystal
phase transitions[22] as well as by mechanical
changes induced by specific molecular binding[23] and by responsive polymers.[24] Among the
systems that utilize responsive polymers, poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)
(pNIPAAm) based polymers (in particular copolymers with carboxylic
acid groups) hold a prominent position due to their strong volumetric
change upon swelling and collapsing by variation of the temperature
around its lower critical solution temperature (LCST) of ∼32
°C. This polymer was explored in form of brushes that surrounded[25] or directly capped[26,27] metallic nanoparticles in order to reversibly tune localized surface
plasmon resonance. In addition, pNIPAAm microgels[28] were coupled with Au nanoparticles. Moreover, pNIPAAm-based
networks were used as a host for Au nanoparticles[29] that displayed tunable localized surface plasmon resonance
wavelength originating from near field plasmonic coupling. The swelling
and collapsing of pNIPAAm-based architectures is driven by water diffusion,
and the response in the millisecond range was measured for about micrometer
thick cross-linked pNIPAAm-based hydrogel layer by long-range surface
plasmons on the top of a indium tin oxide microheater.[30] pNIPAAm brush with a thickness of 30 nm was
characterized to respond faster in about 150 μs, when rapid
plasmonic heating was employed.[31] This
work presents a new plasmonic structure that is tunable by thermoresponsive
pNIPAAm-based hydrogel and that can be prepared by template stripping.
It consists of a thin Au film with NHA that allows for diffractive
coupling to propagating SPPs. This structure is tethered to a solid
surface by a cross-linked pNIPAAm-based hydrogel cushion which responds
to temperature variations. It can rapidly swell and collapse, which
triggers a flow of water through the plasmonic pores, and it strongly
modulates the refractive index by altereing the polymer fraction in
the hydrogel film, leading to changes in the transmission spectrum
mediated by surface plasmon modes.
Methods
Materials
Off-stoichiometry thiol–ene polymer
(OSTEmer 321) was purchased from Mercene Laboratories (Sweden). Ethanol
of analysis grade was purchased from Merck Millipore (Austria). Ethylene
glycol was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (Austria). Polydimethylsiloxane
(PDMS, Sylgard 184) was purchased from Dow Corning (USA). pNIPAAm-based
terpolymer (composed of N-isoproprylacrylamide,
methacrylic acid, and 4-methacryloyloxybenzophenone
in a ratio of 94:5:1) was synthesized as reported before.[32] (3-Thiopropyl)oxybenzophenone (benzophenone-thiol)
was synthesized as described in the literature.[33]
Preparation of Au NHA
The electron
beam lithography
system ELS-7000 from Elionix (Japan) was used to structure NEB22 resist
layer with a thickness of 220 nm on a 600 μm thick silicon wafer
with native oxide. The exposure dose of 178 μC cm–2 and a current of 800 pA were used and the resist was developed by o-xylene. Then, Au layer was deposited by vacuum evaporation
with Denton Explorer E-beam (USA) at deposition rate of 2 Å s–1. Finally, the lift-off process was accomplished by
removing the NEB22 resist by soaking the wafer in remover 1165. The
wafer was structured by a series of pads carrying A NHA, each with
an area of 1.2 × 1.2 mm2.
Responsive Polymer Deposition
The silicon wafer with
Au NHA was incubated in an ethanolic 1 mM benzophenone-thiol solution
for 24 h in order to form a self-assembled monolayer. Afterward, the
surface was rinsed with ethanol and dried in a stream of air. Thin
pNIPAAm layer was prepared by spin-coating an ethanolic pNIPAAm solution
with a polymer concentration of 3 wt % and a spin rate of 2000 rpm
for 2 min. Subsequently, the polymer layer was dried in a vacuum oven
(VT6025, Thermo Scientific) overnight at T = 50 °C.
pNIPAAm-based polymer was simultaneously cross-linked and attached
to Au surface by using a UV light at λ = 365 nm with an irradiation
dose of 25 J cm–2 (UV-lamp Bio-Link 365 from Vilber,
Germany). The cross-linked polymer network was rinsed thoroughly with
water to remove loosely bound pNIPAAm polymer chains, and it was finally
dried with a stream of air.
Template Stripping
A drop of OSTEmer
321 epoxy was
placed onto the surface of a BK7 glass substrate and contacted with
a flat block of PDMS in order to spread homogeneously. Then the OSTEmer
321 polymer was precured by UV light at λ = 365 nm (irradiation
dose of 3 J cm–2) through the PDMS block. Afterward,
the PDMS block was peeled off, yielding the glass substrate with the
rubbery OSTEmer layer on its top. The OSTEmer surface was pressed
against the pNIPAAm film covering Au NHA on the top of a silicon wafer.
In order to establish a bond between pNIPAAm and OESTEmer, the structure
was kept overnight at temperature of T = 50 °C.
The silicon wafer was then stripped off using a sharp blade leaving
the Au NHA bonded to the glass substrate via the pNIPAAm-based layer.
Imaging of the Stripped Au NHA
Au NHA structures were
characterized by scanning electron microscope (SEM) EVO from Carl
Zeiss (Germany) that was operated at a low voltage of 5 kV. Atomic
force microscope (AFM) Pico Plus from Molecular Imaging (USA) was
used in tapping mode to observe the morphology of the dry structure.
In addition, substrates with the NHA in contact with air and water
were analyzed by optical microscope (BX51 M with camera SC30 from
Olympus Soft Imaging Solution, Germany).
Optical Measurement
Transmission spectra were measured
using an in-house developed spectroscopy system. White light emitted
from a halogen lamp LSH102 from LOT-Oriel (Germany) was coupled to
a multimode optical fiber M26L02 from Thorlabs (UK) and focused by
an achromatic lens (f = 6 cm, 14 KLA 001 from CVI
Melles Griot, Germany) at the investigated structure. The focused
light beam passed through the substrate under angles between θ
= 0 and 4°. The investigated structure was clamped to a transparent
flow cell in order to flow aqueous samples over its surface. Temperature-dependent
measurements were performed by using a Peltier device that was integrated
to the flow cell. A translation stage was used to select illuminated
area that carried either Au NHA or a flat Au layer as reference. Transmitted
light was coupled via a lens (F810SMA-635 from Thorlabs, UK) into
a multimode optical fiber (M26L02 from Thorlabs, UK) that was connected
to a high-resolution spectrometer (SR-303i-B from Andor, UK). The
acquired wavelength spectra were compensated for dark current. The
spectra measured on the Au NHA were normalized with that obtained
on a reference flat Au surface.
Simulations
The
finite difference time domain (FDTD)
model implemented by Lumerical Inc. (Canada) was used for simulations
of the near field and far field optical properties of the investigated
structure. A unit cell with the width equal to the period Λ
was used and periodic Bloch boundary condition in x- and y-axes was applied (Cartesian coordinates
defined in Figure a). In the z direction, a perfectly matched layer
was placed at the distances of 1 μm above and below the layer
stack. A transmission monitor was placed 0.7 μm below the Au
layer. A 2D monitor in the xz-plane was employed
for simulating near field distribution of the electric field intensity.
The wavelength-dependent refractive index of Au nm was obtained from the literature.[34]
Figure 1
(a) Schematics of the investigated structure that comprise
Au film
with NHA that is attached to a glass substrate by a responsive pNIPAAm-based
hydrogel cushion. (b) Preparation procedure of the structure by using
template stripping from a Si wafer.
Results and Discussion
Preparation of Template
Stripped NHA with Responsive PNIPAAm
Cushion
As illustrated in Figure a, the investigated plasmonic structure consists
of an Au film with rectangular NHA that is attached to a pNIPAAm-based
hydrogel layer. When brought in contact with an aqueous environment,
water flows thought the pores in the Au membrane into the underneath
hydrogel which swells. The pNIPAAm polymer exhibits thermoresponsive
properties that cause the polymer network to collapse when the structure
is heated above the LCST expelling water through the porous Au membrane.
The Au NHA structure with a thickness of dm = 50 ± 1 nm was prepared on a silicon wafer with native oxide
by using electron beam lithography. In order to covalently attach
the pNIPAAm-based hydrogel film to the Au NHA surface, it was first
modified by a self-assembled monolayer of a thiol functionalized with
benzophenone groups that served as a linker for attachment of pNIPAAm-based
polymer. The modified Au surface was subsequently coated by a film
of the pNIPAAm-based terpolymer that carries benzophenone groups as
photo-cross-linking units, as well as carboxylic acid substituents
for improved swelling and for subsequent chemical modification (e.g.,
with biological ligands). After the pNIPAAm polymer layer was dried,
it was exposed to UV in order to cross-link the polymer chains and
simultaneously attach them to the Au surface by exploiting the photoreactivity
of the benzophenone moieties. Afterward, the Au NHA with the pNIPAAm
network layer was bonded to a UV-precured OSTEmer layer on a glass
substrate (see Figure b). This rubbery film was pressed against the surface of the pNIPAAm
film and attached via the reactive epoxy groups at elevated temperature.
Finally, the stack of layers was stripped from the Si wafer to yield
the surface of the Au NHA film on the top of a cross-linked pNIPAAm-based
hydrogel cushion.(a) Schematics of the investigated structure that comprise
Au film
with NHA that is attached to a glass substrate by a responsive pNIPAAm-based
hydrogel cushion. (b) Preparation procedure of the structure by using
template stripping from a Si wafer.As seen in Figure a, the developed process allowed successful stripping of the
Au NHA
film with an underlying hydrogel layer. SEM revealed that the arrays
of nanoholes retained their initial dimensions before stripping with
a hole diameter of D = 208 ± 8 nm and a period
of Λ = 406 ± 13 nm. Optical microscopy was used to image
a corner of rectangular structured pad, as depicted in Figure b. The dark area in this image
represents the NHA structure, and the brighter, more reflective region
corresponds to the flat Au surface. Figure c shows an optical microscope image of the
structured area that was brought in contact with water at a temperature
of T = 22 °C. It indicates that the Au layer
wrinkles due to the swelling of the underneath pNIPAAm hydrogel film.
Such wrinkling was observed for other hydrogel films, and it is associated
with stress-induced buckling, as the polymer is confined in the plane
of the substrate, and thus swelling is predominantly permitted only
in the direction perpendicular to the surface.[35] Afterward, the surface was dried and water rapidly diffused
through the NHA pores out of the hydrogel film. Interestingly, the
about 50 nm thick Au film did not exhibit cracks and defects after
the swelling and drying cycle as seen in Figure d, acquired by optical microscopy. In addition,
AFM was used for the characterization of Au NHA on the top of the
hydrogel cushion after it was swollen and subsequently dried. The
acquired image in Figure e shows that most of the pores in the Au film were filled
with the pNIPAAm-based polymer network, which partially protrudes
above the Au surface (visible by the brighter color of the pores in
height mode). In addition, one can see that the Au surface between
the pores was smooth (root-mean-square roughness of 0.5 nm) and without
cracks. It is worth mentioning that the observed low roughness at
the upper interface is comparable to that of Si wafer as observed
for other template stripped gold surfaces.[36] At a larger scale the Au surface became slightly undulated after
swelling and collapsing of the pNIPAAm-based hydrogel, which is probably
associated with the buckling and rearrangement of pNIPAAm polymer
chains below the Au membrane after swelling and drying. Nevertheless,
this large-scale undulation did not affect the regularity and integrity
of the nanoscale dimensions of the individual pores.
Figure 2
Observation of the stripped
surface of the Au NHA by using (a)
SEM and (b) optical microscopy with 100-fold magnification. (c) Optical
microscopy images of an Au NHA surface with a structured pad (dark
area) when swollen in water and (d) subsequently dried. (e) AFM observation
of the stripped Au surface with NHAs after exposure to water followed
by drying.
Observation of the stripped
surface of the Au NHA by using (a)
SEM and (b) optical microscopy with 100-fold magnification. (c) Optical
microscopy images of an Au NHA surface with a structured pad (dark
area) when swollen in water and (d) subsequently dried. (e) AFM observation
of the stripped Au surface with NHAs after exposure to water followed
by drying.
Swelling Characteristics
of Plain PNIPAAm Layer
Optical
waveguide spectroscopy was used to characterize thickness and swelling
of the pNIPAAm polymer film (analysis of measured data presented in
the Supporting Information). These measurements
were performed for a pNIPAAm layer that was prepared by using identical
protocol on a flat Au surface. This thickness of a dry film in contact
with air was measured as 212 nm, and its refractive index was ni = 1.48. When the film is brought in contact
with water at T = 22 °C, the volume fraction
of the polymer chains in the hydrogel network is reduced by its swelling.
Therefore, the corresponding refractive index of the pNIPAAm layer
decreased to ni = 1.36 (which is close
to that of water [n0 = 1.33] at the used
wavelength of λ = 633 nm), and the thickness increased to about
1.2 μm. At a temperature of T = 40 °C,
hydrogel film collapsed, and its refractive index decreased to ni = 1.46, which is about 0.1 refractive index
units (RIU) higher than that determined in its highly swollen state
at T = 22 °C. It should be noted that the thickness
of the swollen and collapsed pNIPAAm hydrogel layer is much higher
than the penetration depth of SPP field on a gold surface at wavelengths
in the visible and near-infrared parts of spectrum.
Actuating Spectrum
of the Surface Plasmons Modes
As
indicated in Figure a, the thin Au film on the top of pNIPAAm layer supports SPP modes
at its both interfaces. The mode that travels at the outer interface
(in contact with air or with aqueous solution with refractive index n0) is referred to as SPPo. The mode
supported by the opposite interface (in contact with pNIPAAm polymer
with a refractive index ni) is named SPPi. The periodic NHA on the Au film allows for diffractive coupling
of light into the SPPo and SPPi via (±1,
0), (0, ±1) and higher orders. As presented in Figure , this coupling manifests itself
as distinct resonant features in the transmission spectra. These spectra
were measured with a polychromatic light beam that was focused onto
the NHA, and the transmitted beam was analyzed by a spectrometer.
Obtained spectra were normalized by those measured on a reference
pad with a flat, nonporous 50 nm thick Au film. Two Fano resonances
can be observed for the structure in contact with air in Figure a. They appear as
a spectral band where the transmission decreases at lower wavelengths
and increases at higher wavelengths. The resonance associated with
the excitation of SPPo mode at the outer interface (between
Au and air) exhibits a minimum at λo < 550 nm
(this resonance is spectrally broad as the wavelengths are close to
the plasma frequency of Au). The second resonance due to the excitation
of the SPPi mode at the inner interface (between Au and
dry pNIPAAm) is manifested as minimum reflectivity at around λi = 720 nm. As the same figure shows, the SPPi resonance
blue-shifts after the structure is brought in contact with water at
a temperature of T = 22 °C. The SPPi resonance wavelength λi is decreased by about 15
nm, which can be attributed to the swelling of pNIPAAm cushion by
water diffusing through the nanoholes, accompanied by a decrease in
its refractive index from ni. The minimum
of the SPPo resonance at λo red-shifts
by about 50 nm as the refractive index of the medium above the AuNHA structure changes from n0 = 1 (air)
to 1.33 (water).
Figure 3
Measured transmission spectra for the Au NHA on top of a responsive
pNIPAAm hydrogel cushion (Au NHA-hydrogel) (a) in contact with air
and water at T = 22 °C. (b) The swollen hydrogel
cushion in contact with water spiked with ethylene glycol (EG, n0 = 1.33–1.37) at T =
22 °C. (c) Au NHA-hydrogel in water (n0 = 1.33) with temperature varied in the range of T = 22–45 °C in order to actuate the pNIPAAm cushion.
(d) The collapsed cushion in contact with water spiked with ethylene
glycol (n0 = 1.33–1.37) at T = 40 °C.
The controlled permeability of the Au membrane
with NHAs was tested by a series of refractometric experiments where
the upper and bottom interfaces were optically probed by resonantly
excited SPPo and SPPi modes, respectively. Aqueous
samples with water spiked by ethylene glycol at concentrations between
0 and 40 vol % were used in order to change the refractive index of
the outer medium between n0 = 1.33 and
1.37. Transmission spectra for gradually increasing n0 due to the ethylene glycol were measured for the swollen
pNIPAAm cushion at a temperature of T = 22 °C.
As presented in Figure b, both SPPo and SPPi resonances shift to longer
wavelengths when increasing the concentration of ethylene glycol.
The SPPo resonance shifts by Δλo = 9.7 nm with the increase of ethylene glycol concentration to 40
vol %. This change corresponds to the refractive index change of Δn0 = 0.04 RIU which yields the refractive index
sensitivity of SPPo mode of S = Δλo/Δn0 = 242 nm RIU–1. This value is identical to the gold grating-based SPR (∼250
nm RIU–1 for the first order coupling at a wavelength
of 600 nm),[37] and it is comparable to values
typically observed on Au NHA (400 nm RIU–1 at wavelength
of 650 nm).[11] The SPPi resonance
responds to ethylene glycol stronger, and it shifts by Δλi = 26.5 nm for the maximum concentration of 40 vol %. This
observation indicates that the ethylene glycol can diffuse through
the NHA into the underneath swollen hydrogel. The fact that Δλi is almost 3 times higher than Δλo is
probably due to a partial collapse of pNIPAAm triggered by ethylene
glycol that provides an additional change in Δni.In order to prove the identity of transmission
features that were
assumed to be associated with the excitation of SPPi and
SPPo, the refractive index was individually changed at
the inner and outer side of the Au NHA structure. First, the refractive
index change Δni was induced by
the collapse of pNIPAAm cushion that is probed by SPPi.
In order to do so, the temperature of the water flowing over the NHA
structure was gradually raised from T = 22 to 40
°C. Figure c
reveals that the SPPo resonance (that probes the outer
water medium) shifts weakly with temperature. The measured maximum
shift of Δλo = 2.5 nm can be attributed to
the effect of collapsing hydrogel that partially protrudes through
the nanoholes in Au film. An order of magnitude stronger shift of
Δλi = 24.5 nm was observed for the SPPi resonance due to an outward flux of water through the NHA
pores and a subsequent collapse of the underlying hydrogel. The dependence
of λi on temperature presented in the Supporting Information (Figure S2) confirms that
the collapse of the pNIPAAm cushion occurs at the LSCT of 31 °C
similar to the plain pNIPAAm film in direct contact with an aqueous
medium without the metallic structure on top.[38] Assuming that the refractive index sensitivity of the SPPi resonance is similar to that of SPPo, the measured spectral
shift can be converted to refractive index change due to the pNIPAAm
cushion collapse of Δni = Δλi/S ∼ 0.1. Interestingly, this value
is identical to that measured for swelling of pNIPAAm film without
Au NHA on the top (see Figure S1).Second, the structure was probed by SPPo and SPPi modes when refractive index at the upper interface n0 was varied. It was utilized by collapsing
pNIPAAm cushion at T = 40 °C and repeating the
experiment with the flow of aqueous samples spiked with ethylene glycol
over the structure. The measured data in Figure d indicate that the SPPo resonance
responds similar as at T = 22 °C (see Figure b). A strong resonant
wavelength shift of Δλo = 7.5 nm was measured
due to the increase in refractive index by ethylene glycol concentration
of 40 vol %. This value is slightly lower than that measured for swollen
pNIPAAm cushion which can be ascribed to the collapsed polymer in
the pore which partially occupies space probed in SPPo mode.
The SPPi resonance shifted much weaker by only by Δλi = 1.8 nm. This observation confirms that the hydrogel in
its collapsed state prevents diffusion of molecules through the Au
pores to the underneath interface that is probed by SPPi.Measured transmission spectra for the Au NHA on top of a responsive
pNIPAAm hydrogel cushion (Au NHA-hydrogel) (a) in contact with air
and water at T = 22 °C. (b) The swollen hydrogel
cushion in contact with water spiked with ethylene glycol (EG, n0 = 1.33–1.37) at T =
22 °C. (c) Au NHA-hydrogel in water (n0 = 1.33) with temperature varied in the range of T = 22–45 °C in order to actuate the pNIPAAm cushion.
(d) The collapsed cushion in contact with water spiked with ethylene
glycol (n0 = 1.33–1.37) at T = 40 °C.
Simulations of NHA Optical Response
The experimental
data were verified by simulating transmission spectrum for the investigated
Au NHA-hydrogel geometry. In these simulations the Au film was sandwiched
between two semi-infinite dielectrics with refractive index n0 and ni. The pores
were assumed to exhibit refractive index of ni. The transmission spectra presented in Figure a for the dry (ni = 1.48 and n0 = 1) and swollen (ni = 1.36 and n0 =
1.33) geometry qualitatively agree with those measured at T = 22 °C (compare with Figure a). For the dry structure, simulations predict
the SPPo resonance occurs at λo < 550
nm and the one associated with the SPPi mode at around
λo = 690 nm. For the swollen structure, SPPo resonance red-shifts to around λo = 570 nm and
the one associated with the SPPi mode blue-shifts to λo = 674 nm. It is worth of noting that the refractive index
swollen hydrogel is similar to water which leads to the coupling of
the surface plasmons across the Au layer. For such refractive index
symmetrical configuration SPPo mode at lower wavelengths
behaves like long-range surface plasmon for which the electric field
is weakly confined in the Au layer. The SPPi mode, on the
other hand, behaves like a short-range surface plasmon with the corresponding
electric field strongly confined in the Au film. When the hydrogel
film is collapsed (n0 = 1.33 and ni = 1.46), the symmetry is broken and individual
SPPi and SPPo modes propagate along individual
interfaces. Figure b illustrates for such a geometry the dispersion relation of SPPi and SPPo modes represented as absorption dependence
on the angle of incidence θ and wavelength λ. It reveals
complex behavior where resonances associated with the first-order
coupling to SPPo and SPPi split and cross when
increasing θ. In addition, flattening of SPP bands for low angle
θ occurs.
Figure 4
Simulated transmission spectra for an Au NHA-hydrogel
geometry
that is (a) in contact with air (n0 =
1) and a collapsed hydrogel-like medium (ni = 1.48) as well as with water (n0 =
1.33) and a swollen hydrogel-like medium (ni = 1.36), with the optical beam normal to the surface θ = 0°.
(b) Dispersion relation of excited SPPi and SPPo modes represented as absorption dependence on angle of incidence
θ and wavelength λ (n0 = 1.33, ni = 1.45). Simulation of the near field distribution
of the electric field intensity |E/E0|2 being normalized with that of the incident
plane wave for a collapsed Au NHA-hydrogel structure (n0 = 1.33, ni = 1.45) at (c)
wavelength of λ = 590 nm where the SPPo is excited
and at (d) λ = 700 nm where the SPPi occurs.
In order to check for the identity of the used
resonances, the near field distribution of the electric field intensity
was simulated at the wavelengths 590 and 700 nm, as seen in Figures c and 4d, respectively. These images confirm that the shorter wavelength
resonance SPPo is probing the outer interface of the AuNHA-hydrogel film in contact with water, while the inner interface
in contact with the polymer layer is probed by the longer wavelength
SPPi resonance.Simulated transmission spectra for an Au NHA-hydrogel
geometry
that is (a) in contact with air (n0 =
1) and a collapsed hydrogel-like medium (ni = 1.48) as well as with water (n0 =
1.33) and a swollen hydrogel-like medium (ni = 1.36), with the optical beam normal to the surface θ = 0°.
(b) Dispersion relation of excited SPPi and SPPo modes represented as absorption dependence on angle of incidence
θ and wavelength λ (n0 = 1.33, ni = 1.45). Simulation of the near field distribution
of the electric field intensity |E/E0|2 being normalized with that of the incident
plane wave for a collapsed Au NHA-hydrogel structure (n0 = 1.33, ni = 1.45) at (c)
wavelength of λ = 590 nm where the SPPo is excited
and at (d) λ = 700 nm where the SPPi occurs.Finally, sensitivity of SPPo and SPPi resonances
to the refractive index variations above and below the Au NHA was
theoretically studied. The simulated transmission spectra for ni varying between 1.35 and 1.45 and fixed n0 = 1.33 are presented in Figure a. These data resembles the temperature-dependent
experiment with collapsing the gel (presented in Figure c) They show a strong shift
in the SPPi resonance of Δλi = 24
nm, which is similar to the experimentally measured value. In accordance
with experimental results, the simulations predict less pronounced
changes in the SPPo resonance of Δλo = 11.5 nm for refractive index change in ni. Figure b
describes the complementary case when the refractive index above the
Au surface n0 is varied. These simulations
are related to the experiment in Figure d where the refractive index n0 of the liquid medium was changed from 1.33 to 1.37 (by
variation of the water/ethylene glycol mixing ratio), while the pNIPAAm
hydrogel cushion with ni = 1.46 was collapsed
above the LCST (T = 40 °C). The obtained simulation
results predict a shift of about Δλo = 13 nm
of the SPPo resonance wavelength. In accordance with the
experimental findings, the response of SPPi mode of Δλo ∼ 3 nm is much smaller. We believe that deviation
between the experiment and simulations can be mostly attributed to
the protrusion of hydrogel present in the pores beyond the upper interface.
This leads to additional refractive index changes that are not taken
into account in the model.
Figure 5
(a) Transmission spectra of an Au NHA-hydrogel
architecture simulated
for increasing refractive index ni from
1.35 to 1.45 at the Au–hydrogel interface, representing the
collapse of pNIPAAm cushion, and for an aqueous medium at the outer
interface (n0 = 1.33). (b) Transmission
spectra for increasing refractive indices n0 from 1.33 to 1.37 of the liquid medium (representative of the varying
water/ethylene glycol mixtures) above the Au NHA–hydrogel film
with a collapsed pNIPAAm cushion (ni =
1.45) beneath.
(a) Transmission spectra of an Au NHA-hydrogel
architecture simulated
for increasing refractive index ni from
1.35 to 1.45 at the Au–hydrogel interface, representing the
collapse of pNIPAAm cushion, and for an aqueous medium at the outer
interface (n0 = 1.33). (b) Transmission
spectra for increasing refractive indices n0 from 1.33 to 1.37 of the liquid medium (representative of the varying
water/ethylene glycol mixtures) above the Au NHA–hydrogel film
with a collapsed pNIPAAm cushion (ni =
1.45) beneath.
Conclusions
A
facile template-stripping approach to tether a thin Au NHA to
a thermoresponsive hydrogel cushion is reported, and the optical properties
of such structure are characterized in detail. A series of experiments
show that water flow through the pores in Au NHA can be controlled
by swelling the underneath hydrogel. When the hydrogel collapses upon
temperature increase, water is expelled through the pores, and then
they become nonpermeable/closed. In the swollen state the low polymer
volume fraction in the hydrogel generates a symmetric refractive index
configuration for both interfaces (Au-liquid medium and Au-hydrogel),
which establishes long-range and short-range SPPs. When the gel is
collapsed, the refractive index symmetry is perturbed and distinct
SPPs exist at the individual interfaces. Reversible swelling and collapsing
of the hydrogel is accompanied by a strong refractive index change
of 0.1, which can be used for tuning the wavelength at which plasmonically
enhanced transmission occurs. Because of the rapid response to the
temperature variations around the LCST,[30] this approach may find its applications in actively tunable optical
filters. The reported structure can also be implemented in plasmonic
biosensing, where analyzed samples are flowed through the plasmonic
nanoholes in order to overcome diffusion-limited mass transfer of
target analyte to the surface. In current sensor setups such an architecture
is typically realized by using thin nitride membranes which require
multiple lithography steps.[9,39] The presented approach
may provide simpler means for device preparation, and it holds potential to harness
this intriguing biosensor concept in more practical devices. In conjunction
with field intensity enhancement occurring at the nanohole plasmonic
hotspot, the more efficient capture of target analyte at the surface
offers attractive means to advance sensitivity in direct refractometric
detection of biomolecules as well as in sensors relying on plasmonically
amplified spectroscopy.
Authors: L Martín-Moreno; F J García-Vidal; H J Lezec; K M Pellerin; T Thio; J B Pendry; T W Ebbesen Journal: Phys Rev Lett Date: 2001-02-05 Impact factor: 9.161
Authors: Alexandre G Brolo; Shing C Kwok; Matthew G Moffitt; Reuven Gordon; Jason Riordon; Karen L Kavanagh Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2005-10-26 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Ahmet A Yanik; Min Huang; Osami Kamohara; Alp Artar; Thomas W Geisbert; John H Connor; Hatice Altug Journal: Nano Lett Date: 2010-11-05 Impact factor: 11.189