OBJECTIVE: to investigate the knowledge of managers and health professionals, social workers and education professionals regarding the principal barriers to universal health coverage and universal access to health on the part of the extremely poor population; and to point to the contributions made by nursing for the promotion of this right. METHOD: a qualitative study whose reference was, for ensuring the right to health, the reorientation of the Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) towards universal coverage and access in these territories. Interviews were held with 27 members of the multi-professional team of a municipality with high social vulnerability. The data were worked on using thematic content analysis. RESULTS: the following were ascertained as the principal barriers to universal health coverage and access to health: failures in the expansion and strengthening of the services; absence of diagnosis of the priority demands; shortage of technology, equipment, and material and human resources; poor local infrastructure; and actions with low resolutive power and absence of interdepartmental policies. Within the multi-professional team, nursing acts in the SUS in unique health actions and social practices in these territories, presenting an in-depth perspective on this harsh reality, being able to contribute with indispensable support for confronting these disparities in universal health coverage and universal access to health. CONCLUSION: nursing's in-depth understanding regarding these barriers is essential for encouraging the processes reorienting the SUS, geared towards equality in the right to health.
OBJECTIVE: to investigate the knowledge of managers and health professionals, social workers and education professionals regarding the principal barriers to universal health coverage and universal access to health on the part of the extremely poor population; and to point to the contributions made by nursing for the promotion of this right. METHOD: a qualitative study whose reference was, for ensuring the right to health, the reorientation of the Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) towards universal coverage and access in these territories. Interviews were held with 27 members of the multi-professional team of a municipality with high social vulnerability. The data were worked on using thematic content analysis. RESULTS: the following were ascertained as the principal barriers to universal health coverage and access to health: failures in the expansion and strengthening of the services; absence of diagnosis of the priority demands; shortage of technology, equipment, and material and human resources; poor local infrastructure; and actions with low resolutive power and absence of interdepartmental policies. Within the multi-professional team, nursing acts in the SUS in unique health actions and social practices in these territories, presenting an in-depth perspective on this harsh reality, being able to contribute with indispensable support for confronting these disparities in universal health coverage and universal access to health. CONCLUSION: nursing's in-depth understanding regarding these barriers is essential for encouraging the processes reorienting the SUS, geared towards equality in the right to health.
In theory, the organization of the health services in Brazil is based on the Federal
Constitution of 1998 and on the organic laws of the Unified Health System (SUS). For
universal health coverage and universal access to health, in the municipalities, the
following are stipulated by the SUS: financial investments, resources, and tripartite
management processes, respecting the federal single management and decentralized
municipal management, in order to prioritize the ensuring of attendance to the
population's needs and their local requirements, taking into account the geographical,
biological, social, economic and cultural adversities for care which is comprehensive,
fair and inclusive(
1
).The availability or absence of equipment and devices which mediate universal health
coverage and access to health in the municipalities is associated with various public
services, health services, social work services, education, basic sanitation, productive
inclusion and urban infrastructure, which can configure - or not - scenarios which are
propitious for actions preventing disease and promoting health, treatment,
rehabilitation and protection, favoring situations which can either reproduce or repair
the context of poverty; and contribute - or not - to these groups gradually increasing
or reducing their distance from achieving justice and citizenship(
1
-
2
).Health is a social, physical, biological, psychic, cultural and affective good, which is
manifested as a condition of positive well-being when its achievement is mediated
through the offering of easily-accessed equipment, facilities and devices, strengthening
it in the face of life's challenges. The processes of expansion and broadening in the
offering of tools which are compatible with meeting the population's health requirements
require, therefore, public policies and actions which are coherent and legitimate for
each context. These must be sustainable if they are to progressively meet the
population's needs, using efficacious management processes, sufficient financial
resources, and a professional team which has been empowered to eliminate the barriers to
access to attendance and care and to integral health with fairness. In this regard, the
strengthening of the interdepartmental actions is an essential effort(
2
).Resolution CP 53.14, of 2014, of the Pan-American Health Organization (PAHO), presents
the essential requirements for encouraging actions preventing disease, and promoting
health, treatment, rehabilitation, protection, and the construction of conditions which
are favorable to the assistance and integral care of the population, in particular those
groups in social vulnerability, and to create opportunities which ensure them the right
to universal health coverage and to universal access to health. In order to analyze
these groups' living conditions, it is not enough to identify the causes and
consequences which act in this context, reinforcing the processes of inequality and
social exclusion. It is necessary to reflect on the reality in these territories, aiming
for a society which is more just and righteous, and to ask the question: inequality in
what?(3).In addressing the mismatches present in extremely poor territories, and seeking
responses to the main problems and gaps in meeting these subjects' needs, the authors
adopted the PAHO resolutions providing information on the principles and guidelines
which are considered pillars for the planning and execution of public policies in favor
of legitimate and sustainable actions capable of guaranteeing universal health coverage
and universal access to health for the population of Latin America, in particular, for
the vulnerable groups.Among the world's population - 7.2 billion, in 2015 - 836 million were considered
extremely poor, surviving on less than $1.25 per day(
4
). In Latin America, social inequality is high, as is the proportion of the
population which is poor, with 29% below the poverty line, 30% without access to health
for financial reasons, and 21% unable to seek attendance due to geographical
barriers(
5
)
In Brazil, 16.27 million people are poor (8.6%), and the eradication of poverty
is a major socioeconomic challenge. The Poverty Line, in Brazil,
defines extreme poverty as family income per capita less than or equal
to R$77.00 (seventy-seven reais) per month(
6
).In order to define the degree of poverty, one can use unidimensional or multidimensional
criteria which are capable of measuring the attendance to these subjects' basic needs.
The multidimensional measuring is part of the criteria of privation of income, crucial
aspects such as the lack of, or poor access to, the attendance of basic needs, material
resources, goods, services, and social support. In the scenarios of extreme poverty, the
access to integral healthcare facilitates the achieving of other social rights such as
access to education, nutrition, basic sanitation, housing, and social and productive
inclusion(
7
).In the big cities, extreme poverty is surrounded by a ring of disadvantages, acting as
geographical, environmental, social, economic, and affective barriers which are
difficult to overcome. Examples of these disadvantages are the prevalence of neglected
diseases, mainly affecting families with worse living conditions, and contributing to
the low level of social development found in some regions. These diseases reinforce
these subjects' imprisonment in a repetitive cycle of disadvantages, marked by the
absence of health or perspectives for work or social inclusion, with severe financial
consequences(
8
).The guidelines of the Pan-American Health Organization, in line with the Unified Health
System (SUS), can strengthen the resolutive capacity of the health services to meet the
needs of families in extreme poverty in Brazil, overcoming the barriers to universal
health coverage and universal access to health. Primary Health Care (APS) and the Family
Health Strategy (ESF) have as their goal to promote health, holistic care, and initial
access to this right in the SUS. Nursing is an area of health, management and care with
great relevance in this context. The multi-professional team which acts in the public
services, in particular nurses, can contribute to the reflection regarding problems of
universal health coverage and universal access to health in these territories. This
study aimed to investigate the knowledge of managers and health professionals, social
workers, and educational professionals regarding the principal barriers to universal
health coverage and universal access to health for the population in extreme poverty,
and to point to the contributions which may be made by nursing for promoting this right.
Method
This is exploratory-descriptive qualitative research, seeking to identify the meanings
attributed to the barriers present to universal health coverage and universal access to
health in the ambit of the SUS, in extremely poor territories.The study scenario is one of the 37 municipalities which make up the Metropolitan Region
of Belo Horizonte (RMBH), which was selected as a result of the high incidence of
poverty among its inhabitants, and because it is characterized by its shortage of public
services, spatial segregation, and social exclusion. Its growth results from the logic
of the center-periphery expansion of RMBH, amply defined by the already-established
processes of immigration, with the concentration of a large number of inhabitants
characterized by low income and low educational level. In the region where these
families live, historically, there has been poor organization of urban infrastructure,
with a large number of areas where people have built illegally and areas where people
squat illegally. These aspects contribute to the vulnerability and social disadvantages
of these extremely poor families in the region, due to the absence of an economic base
capable of absorbing part of this workforce, associated with the presence of a prison
complex, made up of five institutions, favoring a misrepresented and prejudiced view of
the populationIn order to collect the variety of information on the life context and health actions
undertaken with families in extreme poverty in this region, and the local barriers to
universal health coverage and universal access to health, the researchers chose to
interview key informants from the municipality's multi-professional team from the areas
of health, social work and education, so as to investigate this context in depth.
Interviews were held with managers and professionals who work in planning and executing
public policies at a central and regional level in these territories of extreme poverty.
In order to select these subjects, 27 informants were invited. These participated in the
research after signing the Terms of Free and Informed Consent (TFIC). The number of
subjects was defined by the criteria of theoretical saturation, proceeding or not with
the interviews according to the absence or presence of new elements which made it
possible to deepen the analysis and theoretical understanding regarding the meanings.A semistructured script was previously validated, addressing the following themes:
health, quality of life, and the principal problems experienced by the families in
extreme poverty; public services available for meeting their needs; public health
policies and interdepartmental policies in place in the region; the effects on their
quality of life and health; and suggestions for improvements for ensuring the rights to
health and gains in quality of life, in this context.The data were worked on by applying Thematic Content Analysis, with systematic
procedures for organizing, codifying and categorizing the ideas, so as to indicate
significant qualitative indicators on the phenomenon. As a result, the interviews were
read exhaustively and in depth, based on the reference of the strategic lines proposed
by PAHO in order to transform the SUS in relation to universal health coverage and
universal access to health.This study is integrated into a research project on the assessment of the quality of
life of the population in extreme poverty in a municipality in the RMBH. In order to
undertake this, all the ethical criteria found in the National Health Council Resolution
N.466, 2012, were respected. The project was approved by the Research Ethics Committee,
under Opinion N. 188,866. The collaboration of the municipal departments was established
with the signing of the Institutional Co-participation Declaration. All interviewees'
anonymity was preserved. The profile of the multi-professional team is presented in
Figure 1, identifying them by numbers and
acronyms referent to the Municipal Health Department (SMS), Social Work Department
(SMAS) and Education Department (SME), in which they work. For example: "7th
subject from Health" (7 SMS).
Figure 1
- The multi-professional team of the Municipal Health Department (SMS),
Social Work Department (SMAS), Education Department (SME); by Department or
Center where placed; Job and Training, in a municipality of the Metropolitan
Region of Belo Horizonte, State of Minas Gerais (MG), Brazil
Results
The sociodemographic profile of the multi-professional team: of the 27 interviewees
(Figure 1), 11 worked in the SMS, 11 in the
SMAS, and 5 in the SME. A total of 7 of them were educated to senior high school level,
20 had degrees (5 SMS; 10 SMAS; 5 SME), and 14 had latu-sensu
postgraduate qualifications (5 SMS; 5 SMAS, 4 SME). The mean age was 35 years old; the
oldest person was 63, and the youngest, 25 years old. A total of 16 lived in other
municipalities of the RMBH.Five nurses and one nutritionist had worked in positions in the SMS, on average, for one
year and eight months; the Community Health Workers (ACS) had worked for 11 years and
one month; the others from the SMAS had worked for three years and one month, and those
from the SME had worked for six years and six months. Among those with degrees, nine (1
SMS; 5 SMAS; 3 SME) and one educated to senior high school level (SMAS) worked under the
statutory arrangement, and four worked in statutory commissioned positions (1 SMS; 1
SMAS; 2 SME). A total of 17 worked under employment links with temporary contracts (10
SMS; 6 SMAS; 1 SME), of whom four worked in commissioned positions (1 SMS; 2 SMAS; 1
SME).The interviewees' knowledge regarding the principal barriers stopping the families in
extreme poverty from benefiting from universal health coverage and universal access to
health are described below. PAHO's 4 Strategic Lines, considered indispensable for
reorienting the public policies towards universal health coverage through the SUS,
encompassed the thematic axes. 1st Strategic Line: expansion of fair access
to the integral health services with person-centered quality.There is a hopelessness on the part of the population: I won't go to the clinic,
it won't resolve anything, it won't work, they won't attend me, there aren't any
doctors. This infrastructure, in general, leads to despondency: there is never
anybody there to attend you, so will there be today? There is no point taking me
there, I can't manage to get a consultation... Am I likely to get one now?
(27 SME).The majority complain about poor health, in spite of there being 50 or so Family
Health Programs (PSF), the teams are understaffed [...] There isn't a doctor [...]
and it is difficult to arrange a consultation with a specialist (18
SMAS).There are shortcomings in many areas [...] Primary Care could help, help in the
community. This is not just a health problem, it's much bigger, it's about
infrastructure, lack of links, absence of strengthening of the network (1
SMS).When I came to the PSF, the Community Health Workers would say: we have been
abandoned. They would sit on the rubbish bins, they had nothing, absolutely, nothing,
do you understand what I mean by 'nothing'? Everything here has been donated, these
chairs and the other furniture in our PSF and others. [...] I said, I will get
somebody who is doing community service to rip out those rotten wooden floortiles, I
received donations and we changed the floor. I became tired of asking for help from
the City Council and nobody doing anything. Over there, there used to be a
brick-built septic tank, which, one day, collapsed! The ground fell in! We didn't
know whether to receive patients or dispense medications, I was watching a boy
playing there in the middle, or to telephone for the department... They didn't do
anything there! I said to them: I deeply respect your work, but mine also needs to be
respected, won't anybody do something? I will telephone health surveillance for them
to close this over. I'm going to the health surveillance people now, if you won't do
something. [...] And then the person responsible appeared... What public authority is
there, that we can count on? (5 SMS).The absence of a multidisciplinary approach to the problems, in the attendance to these
families' health and needs, ends up exceeding the PSF's resolutive capacityThese families are invisible, they are nowhere: they are only in that place
where they are living, they are not going to be registered in the PSF, they are not
going to be registered with the Center of Reference in Social Work (CRAS),
they are not going to be registered on the Family Allowance Program; they are
there, but in the eyes of the governmental bodies and their facilities, they don't
exist... (15 SMAS).In this neighborhood, there are 1,600 unregistered families, dissatisfied that
they are living there, there is no school, there's no healthcare, there is no PSF and
there are no buses [...] I don't know all the neighborhoods, there are various
registered by the Basic Reference Units (UBR), but these families
are not monitored! (19 SMS). The PSF is much closer
to these families than the other health bodies or departments, it is a center of
reference; but it cannot do everything, it doesn't have the conditions to carry out
the role of the CRAS. There is a certain limitation, there is a
space where it can act, and another where it cannot. There is a tendency to throw
more things to the PSF, but the conditions are not provided to do what they already
are doing, and less still to undertake anything else which might come along! The
managers have a lot of difficulty promoting interdepartmental actions! If you don't
do it in an integrated way and empower people, things don't work! If the work was
interlinked, it would have greater resolutive power. It is necessary to provide
working conditions, and to know what facilities the network has available; but people
don't know about the viable facilities! The institution itself doesn't create them
and does not seek to interlink them! If the institutions' missions were defined, it
would be easier! (3 SMS).2nd Strategic line: strengthening of the management and governance. The
public policies and actions currently in place in territories of extreme poverty must be
structured and planned in a contextualized way, so as to favor universal health coverage
and universal access to health.Before, the population of areas X and Y was attended by the same PSF. Then they
separated the PSFs into area X and area Y, but the areas were badly divided. Those
who worked and lived in X are now given consultations only in Y. What sense does that
make if she belongs to area X? Whoever made this division didn't look at the area to
find out about the micro-areas... This has already been put to the department and the
coordinators. When this division took place, and the PSF was separated by areas X and
Y, it was terrible! All the windows were broken! The population did not accept
it... (5 SMS).There is a lot of respect for the professionals, even when they are circulating
in areas where there is a lot of conflict because of the drugs trade... The school
only works with the permission of the drugs trade, as it is located in the territory
of great social vulnerability. This is the system which these people live with. [...]
This oppression all the time [...]... It is very, very difficult! (26 SME).
In the city, there are the PSFs and the UBRs. The UBR is
like a clinic for people who don't have a PSF. In this area, there is the PSF, but if
you don't live in the area of the PSF, there is no clinic. The UBR
is the clinic for those who are not registered at the PSF. These people go to
the UBR, which attends about 50,000 people. The PSF's coverage is very low!
(14 SMS).They took her to the Emergency Room and nobody knew what was happening. The
doctor said: this is negligence on the part of the municipality! Negligence regarding
the community, which is there to be attended. If she has diabetes and all these
health problems, she needs to be monitored! There is no doctor here, but there is the
health department to provide assistance and specialities which do not exist, and
which need to be arranged in another place, as they are not available here, and have
to be arranged in another locale, if one is to have the privilege of this attendance!
They have lost sight of what is important... ! The respect for rights, which should
be offered! (27 SME).The social participation of the population in extreme poverty and of the health
professionals is essential if one is to re-elaborate public policies which are coherent
and sustainable in the long term, in these territories, and directed towards the
resolution of their principal health problems. Professionals establish a bond?
There's no way to do that! For the programs of that department, the bond
(with the population) exists and has to exist... When the person is welcomed,
and embracement is present, she goes back to work saying that she was attended well,
and creates a reference: you can go to so-and-so, in such-and-such a place!
(25 SME).The operative groups used to take place before the PSF changed place. The
house (rented) was very bad, so the PSF was deactivated for a while,
and now it has moved here! This has affected things enormously! It is very difficult
for the population to get here. The neighborhood is big, they only come here when
there is nothing else for it! Now, the population has a lot of difficulty! The PSF is
too far away! There is transport, but not everybody has the money to pay for it. The
price of the bus ticket is R$2.65. The bus used to pass close by the PSF, and the
people used it. Nowadays, if they need to come to the PSF, the bus doesn't come here
anymore! They need to get another bus which goes into the city center, and that costs
them R$4.10. They complain, but... (11 SMS).If the person is dying, I say: no, go to the PSF! Here, there is no equipment,
the doctor can't do anything, and there are no drugs for the assistance! [...] When
there is an emergency situation in the PSF, we call the Emergency Care Units
(UPA). The nurse provides the attendance, blood pressure, pulse, and sends the
patient to whichever UPA has a doctor. There is no ambulance to take them, they have
to take care of that themselves! Police, only if you can manage it! The population
doesn't always have vehicles. It is a difficulty! You can only get health transport
if you arrange it 15 days beforehand! (10 SMS).For the elaboration of public policies, it is necessary to include the evaluation of the
availability of the local technologies in this process, thus favoring possible
improvements in coverage and access. The service users who are not attended in
the PSF overload the UPA! We do not have the ideal for the population's health! The
new medical staff promised under the "Mais Médicos" ["More Doctors"]*
program have arrived. We will see if they will meet all of the population's
needs! [...] She complains a lot about this abandonment, about the expense and the
strain when they need to do tests.. (22 SMAS).The PSF should treat what is basic, and have a general practitioner, a
gynecologist and a pediatrician. There are three places available a month, but I have
20 children on the books! When will the last consultation be? For a gynecological
issue involving infection, you have to wait more than 60 days to be seen!
(10 SMS).We spent more than one year without having the prevention Kit. Now, there are no
specimen pots! There is no pediatrics service, but there are 95 children; we have
been waiting for cardiology for two years; for orthopedics, there are more than 40
people in the queue; a gastric specialist only came because we took legal
action (5 SMS).3rd Strategic line: an increase and improvement in the financing, promotion
of equality, efficiency and elimination of direct payment on the part of the service
users.Today, there were two children for the pediatric service, but they had been
referred to "X Center". These two twins have sickle-cell anemia. I requested an
urgent blood test... The parents didn't have the money to take them there to do the
test, to take the bus! The test was authorized, but, due to the difficulties caused
by their low purchasing power... [...] The PSF has 15 places for tests in the UBR;
but in this case, it was a test which needed to be processed urgently! There was no
point taking the blood sample here, we would have waited one week to get the
result... (3 SMS).4th Strategic line: Strengthening of the interdepartmental actions in order
to address the social determinants of health. It is essential to carry out diagnoses in
order to promote viable mechanisms for confronting the local priority problems in
relation to access.It is impossible to provide care in the long-term in the PSF, its structure does
not allow this! [...] How wonderful it would be if they could deal with this stream,
put a structure over it, a bridge, so that the children could go over it and get to
school! (10 SMS).The PSF's structure is very poor, and too far away! We haven't been able to put
together the basic team to provide attendance... There are various PSFs without
doctors or nurses. It becomes difficult!! It is impossible to provide high complexity
care. Many service users have abandoned basic treatment for hypertension and
diabetes! And the management, what do they understand of this? (21
SMAS).We try to work more broadly with the families, referring them to the CRAS, but
there is no referral or counter referral, no joint action with the health service.
The public policies are piecemeal! Teams, infrastructure and transport are missing.
We tried to articulate with health in the schools; this does not resolve the problem
of students with priority for health reports, because there is still a lack of
transport for them to go to the consultations! (24 SME).The interdepartmental public policies aim to strengthen the social programs and to
improve these families' health conditions and living conditions; their effects must be
assessed.In order to improve, it's necessary to work on interdepartmentality and to
investigate other instruments (23 SME).If you have a child whose weight is low, you have recourse to the Child's Health
Program, to the low weight department, vitamins, and the low-weight diet. However,
the population does not benefit. It has to be directed towards a specific type of
bond, because the PSF provides a general attendance. [...] You're not going to
succeed in resolving the cause! (10 SMS). It is the City Council's job to
structure the public policies and contextualize them, and to promote progressive
improvements in the health and quality of life of extremely poor families, contributing
to their autonomy and to the promotion and protection of their health over time.If a person is coming to the center a lot, I go without lunch and say this:
today, I am for so-and-so! I dedicate myself to the patient, I listen to them
carefully, I don't stop to write things down, and when she leaves, I write it in the
medical records. That way, she tells me everything in front of me! And then I can see
why her hypertension is not controlled, her diabetes is not controlled, and the
doctor just increasing the medications and antidepressants. I see the entire context
which surrounds this family, and then I can resolve the issue which is not
controlled... (4 SMS).In a situation of extreme poverty, you can't access anything! They are ill,
depressed! (18 SMS).Here, the policies and the management needs to improve in everything! The
politicians come into power, t hey are in the job for four years, and then another
one comes who doesn't know about the conditions here [...] The only thing they like
to do here is prisons! (7 SMS).What does it mean to be a citizen? The people don't know, they haven't had
access to health, culture or education! This needs to be presented if they are to be
able to make choices! These were the choices which they had... (4 SMAS).Continuous attendance does not exist in the PSF... Nowadays, all the departments
are relying on the PSF, like they're on top of a little ant. The spontaneous demand
can swallow any PSF! We try to plan, but are unable to promote health... There should
be more teams, so that each could have a smaller population. The quality of the work
would be better! (4 SMS).Health is the most department which suffers most from governmental cuts;
however, if there is no health, there is no life, and no way of getting
anything! (3 SMS).
Discussion
The universal health coverage provided through the APS in the municipality studied has
the capacity to attend only half of the areas covered and of the local population. These
subjects do not represent the families in extreme poverty in the region, who are
described as invisible; it is estimated that the number of these
subjects is probably far higher. The Constitution of the World Health Organization
(WHO), the PAHO guidelines and the organic laws of the SUS aim to promote improvements
in the population's health, with emphasis on groups with the greatest social
vulnerability(
1
). In the context studied, there is a gap in relation to the PAHO guidelines
in line with the actions of the SUS, leading to barriers which, for families in extreme
poverty attempting to access healthcare holistically, are unsurpassable. These barriers
result from failures in the process of mediation, implementation, assessment and
re-elaboration of the local public policies.The access to health actions denied to these families who are subjected to intense
social inequalities reinforces their lack of access to the other opportunities for
quality of life. The inadequate management and governance of the local public policies -
associated with the inconsistent application of financial resources, lack of equipment
and sufficient material and human resources for implanting health actions and
interdepartmental actions capable of resolving issues in the APS - represent the
principal barriers to universal health coverage and universal access to health for these
subjects. These data are corroborated by other studies emphasizing that increasing the
APS's capacity for offering services can maximize the responses to the priority
requirements in territories of poverty(
9
-
10
).The profile and the accounts of the multi-professional team, described in this study,
point to the existence of poor working conditions, and weak employment links of the
majority, who work under temporary contracts. This context favors the discontinuity of
the actions in the public services network and, in particular, in health, over time, the
breaking of the bonds established with the families in these territories, and the
devalorization of the knowledge and experiences of the team which are necessary if
improvements have to be provided in the attendance to the needs of these groups,
resulting from the absence of their participation in the processes of elaboration of the
public policies.This disinterest on the part of the municipal management in providing these people with
a voice in the decision-making processes and implementation of the priority health
actions in each micro-region to meet the requirements of the population in extreme
poverty, in a hierarchical and resolutive way, in order of importance, maximizing the
APS's capacity, causes severe consequences in the planning and execution of the local
public policies, and culminates in barriers which, for these families, are impossible to
overcome if they are to access their rights to health and social rights, such as
education, quality-of-life, social inclusion, productive inclusion, citizenship and
autonomy.These issues also reveal the absence of a prior local diagnosis in order to elaborate,
implement and assess the health actions in the APS, and signify a mismatch in the light
of the urgent need to reverse the adversities in relation to the social inequality. This
scenario contributes to the imprisonment of these families in a repetitive lifecycle,
characterized by disadvantages in access to health and to the rights to
citizenship(
9
,
11
). Studies carried out by the United Nations on the offering of integral
health services through the APS, in Latin America, Brazil, South Africa, Ethiopia and
other countries consider that, if there is to be equal health attendance, it is
necessary to act on the social determinants, seeking responses which foster progress in
the models of (re-)structuring in the health systems(
11
-
15
). When the offering of services is limited due to failures in the coverage,
the team's work is made difficult, as is the access to health, leading to the APS having
a poor resolutive capacity(
13
).In these territories of extreme poverty, it is essential to undertake health actions
which are consistent and endowed with social responsibility and sensitivity to valuing
the local problems; and to adopting measures which are sustainable in the long term for
confronting these with resolutive capacity. Aspects such as the poor urban
infrastructure of the public services in these territories, local violence resulting
from the drugs trade, absence of accessible public transport and lack of professionals
and equipment for the continuity of the care are social determinants which neglect these
groups' universal access to health, causing them hopelessness in relation to the
attendance offered by the public services, discouragement to seek assistance, and
failure in adherence to - or abandonment of - the treatments and care measures
instituted.This study identifies the collective social responsibility established by the
multi-professional team in response to the urgent need to promote an effort integrating
all the departments in resolving the problems indicated, as suggested in the scientific
literature(
9
-
15
). It is important to undertake further research - testing possible tools for
applying in local diagnosis with extremely poor communities, addressing multidimensional
instruments for evaluating the obstacles to, and the gains obtained in, universal health
coverage and universal access to health - making it possible to indicate sustainable
paths for maximizing the resolutive capacity of the APS and ESF in these territories.
There is, however, a shortage of such studies in Brazil and worldwide(
15
-
17
).The multi-professional team responsible for the municipal public services, in dealing
with problems arising from these social inequalities, both knows and experiences in its
routine the health needs of these communities in extreme poverty. Among the managers and
professionals interviewed, nursing stands out due to its in-depth work and knowledge
regarding the barriers which these families suffer in relation to universal health
coverage and universal access to health.The nurses described the undertaking of actions which are committed to confronting the
social inequalities experienced in these territories when they promote person-centered
and humanized embracement, viabilize integral health care, provide improvements in the
infrastructure of the PSFs, and minimize the local barriers to equal access to health.
Nursing is an important leadership in the APS for the territories in extreme poverty;
they are managers and care professionals who work in various processes reflecting on and
promoting health actions and comprehensive care in this context, and present relevant
evidence for the assessment, reconstruction and reorientation of the SUS's public
policies in Brazil. Their perspective and work in the APS represent a social practice
which is respectful, attentive and warm-hearted, understanding and politically-engaged
with the adversities suffered by these groups. It is essential to value Nursing's
perspective regarding the social determinants of health in these territories of extreme
poverty, as a legitimate process for obtaining essential support for confronting the
causes of the disparities in universal health coverage and universal access to health -
and to the social rights which are denied to these families.
Conclusion
Privation in the access to health rights of families in extreme poverty impedes them
from achieving or making proper use of universal health coverage or universal access to
health. This worsens their social exclusion and spatial segregation and the social
determinants of health in these territories. The principal barriers to this access are;
shortcomings in the expansion and strengthening of the APS; absence of diagnosis of
priority needs; shortage of technology and material and human resources; poor
infrastructure of the services; APS with low resolutive capacity, and absence of
interdepartmental public policies. Within the multiprofessional team, Nursing stands out
as it acts in these territories with an indepth view, adopting social practices which
are unique and committed regarding the problems of coverage and fair access to health.
This knowledge provides nursing with support which is essential for fostering the
processes inherent to public policies geared towards the re-orientation of the SUS and
towards fairness in the right to health.
Authors: Stéphane Verguet; Zachary D Olson; Joseph B Babigumira; Dawit Desalegn; Kjell Arne Johansson; Margaret E Kruk; Carol E Levin; Rachel A Nugent; Clint Pecenka; Mark G Shrime; Solomon Tessema Memirie; David A Watkins; Dean T Jamison Journal: Lancet Glob Health Date: 2015-05 Impact factor: 26.763