Robert Cooperstein1, Michael Hickey2. 1. Palmer Chiropractic College West; Palmer Center for Chiropractic Research. 2. Life Chiropractic College West.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Among pelvic landmarks routinely palpated by manual therapists, the posterior superior iliac spines (PSISs) are particularly important. In addition to serving as landmarks for identifying possible pelvic torsion, contacting the PSISs is integral to many other static and dynamic pelvic palpatory procedures. The primary study goal was to systematically review the literature on the intra- and interexaminer reliability of PSIS palpation. METHODS: Electronic databases and secondary searches led to the retrieval of articles that satisfied inclusion criteria. Two investigators rated the quality of included articles using the QAREL instrument. RESULTS: The search identified 13 articles, one judged high quality, satisfying the inclusion criteria. Intraexaminer exceeded interexaminer reliability. Among 8 studies that reported interexaminer agreement using kappa, mean ϰ=0.27 (adjusted for sample size). DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: Current methods of palpating for PSIS asymmetry do not result in levels of interexaminer reliability supporting clinical utility. Improved methods should be sought.
INTRODUCTION: Among pelvic landmarks routinely palpated by manual therapists, the posterior superior iliac spines (PSISs) are particularly important. In addition to serving as landmarks for identifying possible pelvic torsion, contacting the PSISs is integral to many other static and dynamic pelvic palpatory procedures. The primary study goal was to systematically review the literature on the intra- and interexaminer reliability of PSIS palpation. METHODS: Electronic databases and secondary searches led to the retrieval of articles that satisfied inclusion criteria. Two investigators rated the quality of included articles using the QAREL instrument. RESULTS: The search identified 13 articles, one judged high quality, satisfying the inclusion criteria. Intraexaminer exceeded interexaminer reliability. Among 8 studies that reported interexaminer agreement using kappa, mean ϰ=0.27 (adjusted for sample size). DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: Current methods of palpating for PSIS asymmetry do not result in levels of interexaminer reliability supporting clinical utility. Improved methods should be sought.
Keywords:
chiropractic; palpation; posterior superior iliac spine; systematic review
Authors: Michael A Seffinger; Wadie I Najm; Shiraz I Mishra; Alan Adams; Vivian M Dickerson; Linda S Murphy; Sibylle Reinsch Journal: Spine (Phila Pa 1976) Date: 2004-10-01 Impact factor: 3.468
Authors: Maziar Badii; Sonya Shin; William C Torreggiani; Bojana Jankovic; Paul Gustafson; Peter L Munk; John M Esdaile Journal: Spine (Phila Pa 1976) Date: 2003-06-15 Impact factor: 3.468
Authors: Pedro O P Lima; Wenya P X Melo; Márcio A Bezerra; Gabriel P L Almeida; Ana Carla L Nunes; Rodrigo R Oliveira Journal: J Chiropr Med Date: 2019-07-21
Authors: Brandon M Ness; Ramu G Sudhagoni; Hanz Tao; Olivia R Full; Lucas O Seehafer; Chelsie M Walder; Kory Zimney Journal: Int J Sports Phys Ther Date: 2018-02