| Literature DB >> 26909303 |
Rachel McDonald1, Edward Chow1, Leigha Rowbottom1, Carlo DeAngelis1, Hany Soliman1.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Pain flare is a temporary increase in pain and is a potential side effect of radiotherapy treatment. However, its incidence has been reported only in recent studies, and with great variability. A few studies have reported on the use of dexamethasone as a prophylactic agent in the prevention of pain flare. The objective of this study is to present a review of the available literature regarding the incidence of pain flare and use of dexamethasone as a preventative measure.Entities:
Keywords: Dexamethasone; Pain flare; Radiation therapy; Stereotactic body radiation therapy
Year: 2014 PMID: 26909303 PMCID: PMC4723641 DOI: 10.1016/j.jbo.2014.10.001
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Bone Oncol ISSN: 2212-1366 Impact factor: 4.072
Characteristics of the literature investigating pain flare incidence and use of dexamethasone.
| EBRT | Prospective, medications and pain score on a 0–10 score were collected at baseline, daily during treatment, and daily for 10 days post treatment | June 2000–Feb 2001 | A 2-point increase in pain scale of 0–10 (0 meaning no pain, 10 meaning worst possible pain) with no decrease in analgesic intake or 25% increase in analgesic intake with no decrease in pain score. Pain score and analgesic intake must return back to normal to differentiate pain flare from pain progression | ||
| EBRT | Prospective, medications and pain score were recorded using the BPI at baseline, and daily for 10 days following treatment | A 2-point increase in pain scale of 0–10 (0 meaning no pain, 10 meaning worst possible pain) with no decrease in analgesic intake or 25% increase in analgesic intake with no decrease in pain score. Pain score and analgesic intake must return back to normal to differentiate pain flare from pain progression | |||
| EBRT | Prospective, medications were recorded and pain collected using the Present Pain Intensity (PPI) at baseline, in a daily diary for the first week following treatment, at 14 days, 1 month, and 3 months post treatment | Jan 29, 1997–Jan 20, 1999 | Firstly as a 2-point increase in the PPI with no decrease in analgesic score or a 50% increase in analgesic score with no decrease in PPI on at least two consecutive days. Also defined as a 2-point increase in PPI with no decrease in analgesic score or a 25% increase in analgesic score with no decrease in PPI on at least two consecutive days | ||
| EBRT | Prospective; pain and medications were recorded with the BPI at baseline and then using a daily diary during treatment and 10 days after completion of treatment | Feb 2006–May 2008 | A 2-point increase in pain scale of 0–10 (0 meaning no pain, 10 meaning worst possible pain) with no decrease in analgesic intake or 25% increase in analgesic intake with no decrease in pain score. Pain score and analgesic intake must return back to normal to differentiate pain flare from pain progression | ||
| EBRT | Prospective; pain, medications, and quality of life recorded through the BPI and EORTC QLQ-C30 at baseline, daily for 10 days, and at 6 weeks following treatment | Jan 2007–July 2008 | A 2-point increase in pain scale of 0–10 (0 meaning no pain, 10 meaning worst possible pain) with no decrease in analgesic intake or 25% increase in analgesic intake with no decrease in pain score. Pain score and analgesic intake must return back to normal to differentiate pain flare from pain progression | ||
| EBRT | Prospective; worst pain scores and analgesic consumption were collected before, daily during, and 10 days post treatment | June 2010–Dec 2013 | A 2-point increase in pain scale of 0–10 (0 meaning no pain, 10 meaning worst possible pain) with no decrease in analgesic intake or 25% increase in analgesic intake with no decrease in pain score | ||
| EBRT | Prospective; BPI collected at baseline. Worst pain scores and analgesic information collected before, daily during, and at the end of follow-up | Nov 2012–May 2013 | A 2-point increase in worst pain score with no decrease in analgesic intake or a 25% increase in daily analgesic intake with no decrease in worst pain score | ||
| SBRT | Prospective, data collected using BPI at baseline, during, and for 10 days following treatment | Feb 2010–April 2012 | (1) A 2-point increase in worst pain score with no decrease in analgesic intake, (2) 25% increase in analgesic intake as compared with baseline, and no decrease in worst pain score, or (3) if corticosteroids were initiated during or after SBRT due to pain | ||
| SBRT | Retrospective, pain flare documented during follow-up clinic visits typically 1–3 months after treatment | Jan 1, 2008–Aug 1, 2012 | Measured using the CTCAE v.4.03 | ||
| SBRT | Retrospective, pain at metastatic sites measured using BPI (including current pain medications and concurrent medications). Follow-up with BPI occurred 1 and 2 weeks after treatment for single fraction courses, and 2 and 4 weeks after treatment for multiple fraction courses | 2002–2011 | First identified through clinical notes indicating an increase in pain at the site of treatment. By survey, defined as either (1) an ≥2-point increase in worst pain score, (2) an ≥25% increase in opioid intake, or (3) initiation of steroids | ||
| SBRT | Prospective; patients competed the BPI daily during treatment and for 10 days post treatment | Feb 2012–Feb 2014 | a 2-point increase in worst pain score with no decrease in analgesic intake or 25% increase in analgesic intake as compared with baseline, and no decrease in worst pain score |
Characteristics of pain flare and use of dexamethasone.
| 14% on day 1 and 2 for patients who received a single treatment 15% on day 1 for patients who received 20 Gy/5 Overall range of pain flare from 2 to 16% | Most commonly experienced days 1 and 2 post-treatment (14% and 16%, respectively) | N/A | ||
| 24% experienced pain flare during 10-day follow-up | Of the 24% who experienced pain flare, two of these patients experienced a one-day pain flare on day 3, three patients had 1-day pain flare on day 7, three had prolonged pain flare (one from day 2–4, one days 4–6, and one days 3–8) | All patients were prescribed two tablets of 4 mg dexamethasone by mouth 1 h before radiation treatment | ||
| Using the first pain flare definition: 34.1% Using second pain flare definition: 40.9% | Median duration of three days | N/A | ||
| Overall incidence of 40%. For patients treated with 8 Gy/1, incidence was 39%, and for those treated with multiple fractions, the incidence was 41%. | Pain flare occurred within first 5 days following radiation in 80% of patients | N/A | ||
| 22% experienced a total of 11 pain flares | Median duration of pain flare was 1 day, and these occurred on days 1, 2, and 4. Two separate 3 day pain flares occurred on days 6 and 8. Six of 11 (55%) pain flares occurred on day 5. | Dexamethasone was prescribed 8 mg orally at least 1 h before radiotherapy and 8 mg daily for 3 consecutive days after treatment | ||
| 44.7% | Median duration of 2 days Majority of pain flares occurred days 1–5 (88%) | N/A | ||
| 6.6% in those who received a methylprednisolone infusion 20% in those who received placebo | Methylprednisolone Group: two patients with 1 day pain flare up on day 3, one patient with 1 day pain flare on day 7, one patient with 2 day pain flare on days 2–3 Placebo Group: five patients had 3 day pain flare days 4–6, other three had 6 day pain flare on days 4–9 | A methylprednisolone infusion was administered to 60 patients for two hours before treatment. For the other 60 patients, placebo (saline solution) was infused. | ||
| 68.3% | Most commonly before day 3 following SBRT (71%) | |||
| 10% | N/A | N/A | ||
| 23% | Overall median time to pain flare of 5 days; when determined by clinical evaluation median time to pain flare was 2.5 days | Of 27 patients who were identified with pain flare by clinical evaluation, 16 (59%) were prescribed dexamethasone | ||
| 19% overall 25% in patients who received 4 mg (24) and 13% in patients who received 8 mg (23) | Occurred most frequently during and up to day 1 post treatment (66%) | Dexamethasone was prescribed to all patients, with 24 patients prescribed 4 mg and 23 patients prescribed 8 mg. All patients took dexamethasone 1 hr prior to daily treatment and for 4 days post treatment |