John A Mills1, Steven J Colligan2. 1. 1 MACS-Quality Control Provider, Hinckley, UK. 2. 2 Radiotherapy Physics Department, Raigmore Hospital, Inverness, UK.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Satisfactory radiotherapy treatment requires quality control (QC) of the equipment as well as patient-specific checks. Increased complexity and extended use of equipment plus greater demand for complex treatment has brought pressure on QC resources. The benefits of integrating patient-specific checks and QC and the efficient use of resources is examined. METHODS: A non-linear model for the probability of undetected machine failure is proposed which enables the comparative efficiency of resource to be assessed. Benefits of adopting an integrated view of patient-specific and treatment machine QC is considered, considering performance tolerance levels in the context of measurement uncertainty and patient-specific tolerances. RESULTS: Essential, machine-only QC is identified. A realistic approach to equipment-only QC is identified for 70% efficient use of resources and a relationship established to determine resource required for a QC programme. Integration of patient-specific and equipment QC is shown to half the resource required for equipment QC. CONCLUSION: Increasing benefit from QC requires greater resource, working at lower efficiency. A pragmatic approach is having guaranteed checks supplemented with additional, non-guaranteed checks performed within an integrated approach to machine- and patient-specific QC, bearing in mind the occasions when machine-only QC is essential. ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: The work reveals on a quantitative basis a rational approach to accommodating the QC requirements for safe and effective treatment.
OBJECTIVE: Satisfactory radiotherapy treatment requires quality control (QC) of the equipment as well as patient-specific checks. Increased complexity and extended use of equipment plus greater demand for complex treatment has brought pressure on QC resources. The benefits of integrating patient-specific checks and QC and the efficient use of resources is examined. METHODS: A non-linear model for the probability of undetected machine failure is proposed which enables the comparative efficiency of resource to be assessed. Benefits of adopting an integrated view of patient-specific and treatment machine QC is considered, considering performance tolerance levels in the context of measurement uncertainty and patient-specific tolerances. RESULTS: Essential, machine-only QC is identified. A realistic approach to equipment-only QC is identified for 70% efficient use of resources and a relationship established to determine resource required for a QC programme. Integration of patient-specific and equipment QC is shown to half the resource required for equipment QC. CONCLUSION: Increasing benefit from QC requires greater resource, working at lower efficiency. A pragmatic approach is having guaranteed checks supplemented with additional, non-guaranteed checks performed within an integrated approach to machine- and patient-specific QC, bearing in mind the occasions when machine-only QC is essential. ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: The work reveals on a quantitative basis a rational approach to accommodating the QC requirements for safe and effective treatment.
Authors: Gary A Ezzell; James M Galvin; Daniel Low; Jatinder R Palta; Isaac Rosen; Michael B Sharpe; Ping Xia; Ying Xiao; Lei Xing; Cedric X Yu Journal: Med Phys Date: 2003-08 Impact factor: 4.071
Authors: Eric E Klein; Joseph Hanley; John Bayouth; Fang-Fang Yin; William Simon; Sean Dresser; Christopher Serago; Francisco Aguirre; Lijun Ma; Bijan Arjomandy; Chihray Liu; Carlos Sandin; Todd Holmes Journal: Med Phys Date: 2009-09 Impact factor: 4.071
Authors: Yolande Lievens; Noémie Defourny; Mary Coffey; Josep M Borras; Peter Dunscombe; Ben Slotman; Julian Malicki; Marta Bogusz; Chiara Gasparotto; Cai Grau; Arianit Kokobobo; Felix Sedlmayer; Elena Slobina; Philippe Coucke; Roumen Gabrovski; Milan Vosmik; Jesper Grau Eriksen; Jana Jaal; Catherine Dejean; Csaba Polgar; Jakob Johannsson; Moya Cunningham; Vydmantas Atkocius; Carlo Back; Martin Pirotta; Vanja Karadjinovic; Sverre Levernes; Boguslaw Maciejewski; Maria Lurdes Trigo; Barbara Šegedin; Amalia Palacios; Bert Pastoors; Charlotte Beardmore; Sara Erridge; Gaile Smyth; Ramon Cleries Soler Journal: Radiother Oncol Date: 2014-11-12 Impact factor: 6.280
Authors: G J Kutcher; L Coia; M Gillin; W F Hanson; S Leibel; R J Morton; J R Palta; J A Purdy; L E Reinstein; G K Svensson Journal: Med Phys Date: 1994-04 Impact factor: 4.071