| Literature DB >> 26801898 |
Agnete E Kristoffersen1, Frauke Musial2, Harald J Hamre3, Lars Björkman4, Trine Stub2, Anita Salamonsen2, Terje Alræk2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The dental filling material amalgam is generally well tolerated. However, a small proportion of dental patients experience health complaints which they attribute to amalgam. The symptom pattern is often similar to patients with medically unexplained physical symptoms (MUPS) and the health complaints may persist after amalgam removal. Among patients with MUPS, the use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) seems to be high. The aim of this survey was to describe the prevalence and range of CAM use among people with health complaints attributed to dental amalgam fillings in which the health problems persist after the removal of all amalgam fillings. Specific attention was paid to (1) self-reported effects of CAM, (2) differences in CAM use dependent on self-reported health, and (3) gender differences in self-reported CAM use.Entities:
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2016 PMID: 26801898 PMCID: PMC4722717 DOI: 10.1186/s12906-016-0996-1
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Complement Altern Med ISSN: 1472-6882 Impact factor: 3.659
Fig. 1Flow chart showing the selection of the studied population. NDPA: Norwegian Dental Patients Association
Basic characteristics of the participants
| Total | Men | Women |
| |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| % ( | % ( | % ( | ||
| Gender | ||||
| Women | 71.6 (232) | |||
| Men | 28.4 (92) | |||
| Age | ||||
| Mean | 60.0 | 58.8 (SD 11.12) | 61.3 (SD 10.26) | 0.001* |
| Education | ||||
| Primary school | 13.4 (42) | 7.9 (7) | 15.6 (35) | |
| Secondary school | 27.4 (86) | 32.6 (29) | 25.3 (57) | |
| High school | 15.6 (49) | 13.5 (12) | 16.4 (37) | |
| University, lower grade | 22.0 (69) | 25.8 (23) | 20.4 (46) | |
| University, higher grade | 27.1 (68) | 20.2 (18) | 22.2 (50) | 0.252** |
| Self-reported health | ||||
| Normal to good | 62.4 (199) | 64.8 (59) | 61.4 (140) | |
| Poor | 37.6 (32) | 35.2 (32) | 38.6 (88) | 0.568** |
| Working | ||||
| Yes | 59.0 (128) | 71.0 (49) | 53.4 (79) | |
| No | 41.0 (89) | 29.0 (20) | 46.6 (69) | 0.014** |
*One-way ANOVA test
**Pearson Chi-Square test
CAM use and perceived effect in the total population (n = 324)
| Reported use | Good effect | No effect | Worsening | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| % ( | % ( | % ( | % ( | |
| Over all CAM use | 88.9 (288) | |||
| Alternative medical systems | 68.5 (222) | |||
| Homeopathy | 54.0 (175) | 57.4 (81) | 39.7 (56) | 2.8 (4) |
| Acupuncture | 48.8 (158) | 38.8 (52) | 58.2 (78) | 3.0 (4) |
| Ear acupuncture | 32.7 (106) | 38.8 (33) | 58.8 (50) | 2.4 (2) |
| Mind-body interventions | 16.0 (52) | |||
| Thought field therapy | 12.0 (39) | 37.5 (12) | 62.5 (20) | 0 (0) |
| Lightning process | 4.9 (16) | 46.2 (6) | 53.8 (7) | 0 (0) |
| Biologically-based systems. including herbalism | 84.3 (273) | |||
| DSVMT | 66.7 (216) | 74.7 (139) | 23.1 (43) | 2.2 (4) |
| DSVMS | 59.0 (191) | 63.0 (92) | 32.2 (47) | 4.8 (7) |
| Special diet | 47.5 (154) | 74.4 (96) | 23.3 (30) | 2.3 (3) |
| Herbs | 37.7 (122) | 55.6 (50) | 38.9 (35) | 5.6 (5) |
| Biopathyb | 13.3 (43) | 40.6 (13) | 56.3 (18) | 3.1 (1) |
| Manipulative and body-based methods | 61.4 (199) | |||
| Reflexology | 42.3 (137) | 48.6 (52) | 45.8 (49) | 5.6 (6) |
| Massage | 40.1 (130) | 41.4 (41) | 43.4 (43) | 15.2 (15) |
| Kinesiology | 29.3 (95) | 43.3 (29) | 50.7 (34) | 6.0 (4) |
| Naprapathyc | 13.3 (43) | 46.4 (13) | 46.4 (13) | 7.1 (2) |
| Craniosacral therapy | 8.6 (28) | 42.9 (9) | 47.6 (10) | 9.5 (2) |
| Energy therapies | 41.7 (135) | |||
| Healing | 33.6 (109) | 33.8 (26) | 63.6 (49) | 2.6 (6) |
| Magnetic field therapy | 19.1 (62) | 29.5 (13) | 61.4 (27) | 9.1 (4) |
| Rehabilitation in a CAM institution | 9.3 (30) | 80.0 (20) | 16.0 (4) | 4.0 (1) |
aDue to missing responses to the question about effect, the n regarding effect might be lower than for use of the CAM modality
bBiopathy is a treatment system that encompasses several different alternative diagnostic tools and therapies such as homeopathy, herbs, reflexology
cNaprapathy is a system of specific examination, diagnostics, manual treatment and rehabilitation of pain and dysfunction in the neuro-musculoskeletal system
Gender- and health specific use and effect of CAM
| Use of CAM | Good effect of CAM | Use of CAM | Good effect of CAM | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Men | Women |
| Men | Women |
| Normal to good health | Poor health |
| Normal to good health | Poor health |
| |
| % ( | % ( | % ( | % ( | % ( | % ( | % ( | % ( | |||||
| Overall CAM use | 95.7 (88) | 86.2 (200) | 0.015 | 89.9 (179) | 88.3 (106) | 0.650* | ||||||
| Alternative medical systems | 68.5 (63) | 68.5 (159) | 0.992 | 64.3 (128) | 75.8 (91) | 0.032* | ||||||
| Homeopathy | 56.5 (52) | 53.0 (123) | 0.568 | 52.3 (23) | 59.8 (58) | 0.403* | 50.3 (100) | 60.0 (72) | 0.091* | 68.4 (54) | 42.4 (25) | 0.002* |
| Acupuncture | 48.9 (45) | 48.7 (113) | 0.973 | 33.3 (13) | 41.1 (39) | 0.405* | 46.2 (92) | 54.2 (65) | 0.170* | 49.3 (37) | 25.9 (15) | 0.006* |
| Ear acupuncture | 31.5 (29) | 33.2 (77) | 0.851 | 32.0 (8) | 41.7 (25) | 0.405* | 34.2 (68) | 30.8 (37) | 0.539* | 43.4 (23) | 29.0 (9) | 0.191* |
| Mind-body interventions | 14.1 (13) | 16.8 (39) | 0.553 | 15.1 (30) | 18.3 (22) | 0.445* | ||||||
| Thoughtfield therapy | 10.9 (10) | 12.5 (29) | 0.684 | 42.9 (3) | 36.0 (9) | 0.740* | 12.6 (25) | 11.7 (14) | 0.813* | 47.6 (10) | 18.2 (2) | 0.139** |
| Lightening process | 4.3 (4) | 5.2 (12) | 0.757 | 33.3 (1) | 50.0 (5) | 1.000** | 2.5 (5) | 9.2 (11) | 0.008* | 60.0 (3) | 37.5 (3) | 0.592** |
| Biologically-based systems. including herbalism | 90.2 (83) | 81.9 (190) | 0.064 | 86.9 (173) | 80.8 (97) | 0.143* | ||||||
| DSVMT | 72.8 (67) | 64.2 (149) | 0.139 | 74.2 (46) | 75.0 (93) | 0.905* | 68.8 (137) | 64.2 (77) | 0.389* | 80.7 (96) | 63.6 (42) | 0.011* |
| DSVMS | 71.7 (66) | 53.9 (125) |
| 66.1 (37) | 61.1 (55) | 0.546* | 60.3 (120) | 58.3 (70) | 0.729* | 72.2 (70) | 43.8 (21) | 0.001* |
| Special diet | 55.4 (51) | 44.4 (103) | 0.073 | 76.1 (35) | 73.5 (61) | 0.746* | 42.7 (85) | 56.7 (68) | 0.016* | 79.5 (58) | 67.3 (37) | 0.119* |
| Herbs | 35.9 (33) | 38.4 (89) | 0.676 | 63.0 (17) | 52.4 (33) | 0.355* | 35.7 (71) | 41.7 (50) | 0.286* | 58.8 (30) | 50.0 (19) | 0.408* |
| Biopathy | 10.9 (10) | 14.2 (33) | 0.422 | 50.0 (5) | 36.4 (8) | 0.699** | 10.1 (20) | 19.2 (23) | 0.021* | 35.7 (5) | 44.4 (8) | 0.618* |
| Manipulative and body-based methods | 60.9 (56) | 61.6 (143) | 0.898 | 59.3 (118) | 65.5 (79) | 0.245* | ||||||
| Reflexology | 41.3 (38) | 42.7 (99) | 0.822 | 41.9 (13) | 51.3 (39) | 0.378* | 40.2 (80) | 45.8 (55) | 0.324* | 51.6 (32) | 43.2 (19) | 0.392* |
| Massage | 33.7 (31) | 42.7 (99) | 0.137 | 58.3 (14) | 36.0 (27) | 0.053* | 38.7 (77) | 43.3 (52) | 0.413* | 46.3 (25) | 36.4 (16) | 0.321* |
| Kinesiology | 29.3 (27) | 29.3 (68) | 0.995 | 40.0 (8) | 44.7 (21) | 0.723* | 27.1 ((54) | 33.3 (40) | 0.240* | 40.6 (13) | 44.1 (15) | 0.774* |
| Naprapathy | 6.5 (6) | 15.9 (37) | 0.024 | 75.0 (3) | 41.7 (10) | 0.311** | 12.1 (24) | 14.2 (17) | 0.586* | 50.0 (8) | 40.0 (4) | 0.619** |
| Craniosacral therapy | 5.4 (5) | 9.9 (23) | 0.196 | 80.0 (4) | 31.3 (5) | 0.119** | 9.0 (18) | 8.3 (10) | 0.828* | 75.0 (9) | 0.0 (0) | 0.001** |
| Energy therapies | 40.2 (37) | 42.2 (98) | 0.739 | 40.7 (81) | 44.2 (53) | 0.544* | ||||||
| Healing | 35.9 (33) | 32.8 (76) | 0.593 | 37.5 (9) | 32.1 (17) | 0.641** | 29.1 (58) | 41.7 (50) | 0.022* | 47.2 (17) | 20.0 (8) | 0.012* |
| Magneticfield therapy | 14.1 (13) | 21.1 (49) | 0.149 | 36.4 (4) | 27.3 (9) | 0.706** | 22.6 (45) | 14.2 (17) | 0.065* | 38.7 (12) | 7.7 (1) | 0.068** |
| Rehabilitation in a CAM institution | 7.6 (7) | 9.9 (23) | 0.519 | 66.7 (4) | 84.2 (16) | 0.562** | 10.6 (21) | 7.5 (9) | 0.366* | 94.4 (17) | 42.9 (3) | 0.012** |
*Pearson Chi-Square test
**Fisher's Exact test