Sandra K Davidson1, Christopher F Dowrick2, Jane M Gunn3. 1. Department of General Practice Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry & Health Sciences University of Melbourne, Australia. Electronic address: sdav@unimelb.edu.au. 2. Institute of Psychology Health and Society University of Liverpool, United Kingdom. 3. Department of General Practice Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry & Health Sciences University of Melbourne, Australia.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: High rates of persistent depression highlight the need to identify the risk factors associated with poor depression outcomes and to provide targeted interventions to people at high risk. Although social relationships have been implicated in depression course, interventions targeting social relationships have been disappointing. Possibly, interventions have targeted the wrong elements of relationships. Alternatively, the statistical association between relationships and depression course is not causal, but due to shared variance with other factors. We investigated whether elements of social relationships predict major depressive episode (MDE) when multiple relevant variables are considered. METHOD: Data is from a longitudinal study of primary care patients with depressive symptoms. 494 participants completed questionnaires at baseline and a depression measure (PHQ-9) two years later. Baseline measures included functional (i.e. quality) and structural (i.e. quantity) social relationships, depression, neuroticism, chronic illness, alcohol abuse, childhood abuse, partner violence and sociodemographic characteristics. Logistic regression with generalised estimating equations was used to estimate the association between social relationships and MDE. RESULTS: Both functional and structural social relationships predicted MDE in univariate analysis. Only functional social relationships remained significant in multivariate analysis (OR: 0.87; 95%CI: 0.79-0.97; p=0.01). Other unique predictors of MDE were baseline depression severity, neuroticism, childhood sexual abuse and intimate partner violence. LIMITATIONS: We did not assess how a person's position in their depression trajectory influenced the association between social relationships and depression. CONCLUSIONS: Interventions targeting relationship quality may be part of a personalised treatment plan for people at high risk due of persistent depression due to poor social relationships.
BACKGROUND: High rates of persistent depression highlight the need to identify the risk factors associated with poor depression outcomes and to provide targeted interventions to people at high risk. Although social relationships have been implicated in depression course, interventions targeting social relationships have been disappointing. Possibly, interventions have targeted the wrong elements of relationships. Alternatively, the statistical association between relationships and depression course is not causal, but due to shared variance with other factors. We investigated whether elements of social relationships predict major depressive episode (MDE) when multiple relevant variables are considered. METHOD: Data is from a longitudinal study of primary care patients with depressive symptoms. 494 participants completed questionnaires at baseline and a depression measure (PHQ-9) two years later. Baseline measures included functional (i.e. quality) and structural (i.e. quantity) social relationships, depression, neuroticism, chronic illness, alcohol abuse, childhood abuse, partner violence and sociodemographic characteristics. Logistic regression with generalised estimating equations was used to estimate the association between social relationships and MDE. RESULTS: Both functional and structural social relationships predicted MDE in univariate analysis. Only functional social relationships remained significant in multivariate analysis (OR: 0.87; 95%CI: 0.79-0.97; p=0.01). Other unique predictors of MDE were baseline depression severity, neuroticism, childhood sexual abuse and intimate partner violence. LIMITATIONS: We did not assess how a person's position in their depression trajectory influenced the association between social relationships and depression. CONCLUSIONS: Interventions targeting relationship quality may be part of a personalised treatment plan for people at high risk due of persistent depression due to poor social relationships.
Authors: Zohre Ahmadabadi; Jackob M Najman; Gail M Williams; Alexandra M Clavarino; Peter d'Abbs; Nam Tran Journal: Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol Date: 2020-01-07 Impact factor: 4.328
Authors: Faith A Scanlon; Joy D Scheidell; Gary S Cuddeback; Darcy Samuelsohn; David A Wohl; Carl W Lejuez; William W Latimer; Maria R Khan Journal: J Correct Health Care Date: 2018-07-01
Authors: Laina Rosebrock; Sinéad Lambe; Sophie Mulhall; Ariane Petit; Bao S Loe; Simone Saidel; Maryam Pervez; Joanna Mitchell; Nisha Chauhan; Eloise Prouten; Cindy Chan; Charlotte Aynsworth; Elizabeth Murphy; Julia Jones; Rosie Powling; Kate Chapman; Robert Dudley; Anthony Morrison; Eileen O'Regan; David M Clark; Felicity Waite; Daniel Freeman Journal: Behav Cogn Psychother Date: 2022-02-15