| Literature DB >> 26689441 |
M A M Rogers1,2, J M Rohde1, N Blumberg3.
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: The recent establishment of the National Healthcare Safety Network Hemovigilance Module in the United States affords an opportunity to compare results with those of other developed nations.Entities:
Keywords: adverse reaction; haemovigilance; international; transfusion
Mesh:
Year: 2015 PMID: 26689441 PMCID: PMC7169273 DOI: 10.1111/vox.12367
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Vox Sang ISSN: 0042-9007 Impact factor: 2.144
Figure 1Rates of allergic reactions in haemovigilance reports, by Country.
Figure 2Rates of acute transfusion reactions in haemovigilance reports, by Country.
Figure 3Rates of haemolytic reactions in haemovigilance reports, by Country.
Figure 4Rates of respiratory transfusion reactions in haemovigilance reports, by Country.
Figure 5Rates of circulatory overload in haemovigilance reports, by Country.
Figure 6Rates of other transfusion reactions in haemovigilance reports, by Country.
Figure 7Rates of transfusion‐transmitted bacterial sepsis in haemovigilance reports, by Country.
Risk of transfusion‐transmitted viruses in haemovigilance reports, by Country
| Virus | Country | Years | Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cytomegalovirus | France | 2009 | 1 in 1·5 million |
| The Netherlands | 2012 | <1 in 620 000 | |
| Norway | 2004–2010 | 1 in 1·4 million | |
| Epstein–Barr Virus | The Netherlands | 2012 | <1 in 620 000 |
| Hepatitis A Virus | France | 2009 | <1 in 3 million |
| The Netherlands | 2012 | <1 in 620 000 | |
| Norway | 2004–2010 | 1 in 1·4 million | |
| Hepatitis B Virus | Australia | 2012–2013 | 1 in 720 000 |
| Canada | 2006–2009 | 1 in 1·7 million | |
| Denmark | 2009 | 1 in 270 000 | |
| Finland | 2007 | <1 in 450 000 | |
| France | 2009 | <1 in 3 million | |
| Germany | 2010 | 1 in 6·1 million | |
| Ireland | 2010–2011 | <1 in 190 000 | |
| Japan | 2012 | 1 in 880 000 | |
| The Netherlands | 2012 | <1 in 620 000 | |
| New Zealand | 2013 | 1 in 68 000 | |
| Spain | 2013 | 1 in 1·9 million | |
| Switzerland | 2013 | 1 in 400 000 | |
| UK | 2013 | 1 in 2·8 million | |
| USA | 2006–2008 | 1 in 300 000 | |
| Hepatitis C Virus | Australia | 2012–2013 | <1 in 1 million |
| Canada | 2006–2009 | 1 in 6·7 million | |
| Denmark | 2009 | <1 in 540 000 | |
| Finland | 2007 | <1 in 450 000 | |
| France | 2009 | <1 in 3 million | |
| Germany | 2010 | <1 in 6·1 million | |
| Ireland | 2010–2011 | <1 in 190 000 | |
| The Netherlands | 2012 | <1 in 620 000 | |
| Sweden | 2013 | <1 in 460 000 | |
| Switzerland | 2013 | 1 in 6·7 million | |
| UK | 2013 | <1 in 2·8 million | |
| USA | 2007–2008 | 1 in 1·1 million | |
| Hepatitis E Virus | France | 2009 | <1 in 3 million |
| Japan | 2012 | 1 in 1·3 million | |
| UK | 2013 | 1 in 2·8 million | |
| Human Immunodeficiency Virus | Australia | 2012–2013 | <1 in 1 million |
| Canada | 2006–2009 | 1 in 8 million | |
| Denmark | 2009 | <1 in 540 000 | |
| Finland | 2007 | <1 in 450 000 | |
| France | 2009 | <1 in 3 million | |
| Germany | 2010 | 1 in 6·1 million | |
| Ireland | 2010–2011 | <1 in 190 000 | |
| The Netherlands | 2012 | <1 in 620 000 | |
| New Zealand | 2013 | <1 in 140 000 | |
| Switzerland | 2013 | 1 in 4·1 million | |
| UK | 2013 | <1 in 2·8 million | |
| USA | 2007–2008 | 1 in 1·5 million | |
| Human T‐Lymphotropic Virus | Australia | 2012–2013 | <1 in 1 million |
| The Netherlands | 2012 | <1 in 620 000 | |
| USA | 2000–2001 | 1 in 2·1 million | |
| Parvovirus B19 | France | 2009 | 1 in 3 million |
| The Netherlands | 2012 | <1 in 620 000 | |
| Norway | 2004–2010 | 1 in 1·4 million | |
| Varicella Zoster Virus | Norway | 2004–2010 | 1 in 1·4 million |
Incidence of transfusion‐associated circulatory overload in the United States
| Author, year | Source | Type of study | Incidence | Incidence | Components | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frequency per patient | ||||||
| Popovsky | 5 Massachusetts hospitals, total hip or knee replacements | Retrospective cohort | 1·0% of patients | 1 in 95 patients | All | 1992–1993 |
| Bierbaum | 235 hospitals, total hip or knee arthroplasty | Prospective cohort | 8·0% of patients | 1 in 12 patients | All | 1996–1997 |
| Rana | Mayo Clinic, intensive care units | Prospective cohort | 1·85% of patients | 1 in 54 patients | All | 2003 |
| Li | Mayo Clinic, medical intensive care unit | Prospective cohort | 5·7% of patients | 1 in 18 patients | All | 2 years, before 2007 |
| Andrzejewski | Hospital in Massachusetts, all ages | Retrospective cohort | 0·6% of patients | 1 in 166 patients | RBCs | 2005–2008 |
| Clifford | Mayo Clinic, adults, non‐cardiac surgery | Retrospective cohort | 5·5% of patients | 1 in 18 patients | All | 2004 |
| 3·0% of patients | 1 in 33 patients | All | 2011 | |||
| Frequency per unit: | ||||||
| Rana | Mayo Clinic, intensive care units | Prospective cohort | 281/100 000 units | 1 in 356 units | All | 2003 |
| Andrzejewski | Hospital in Massachusetts, all ages | Retrospective cohort | 189/100 000 units | 1 in 530 units | RBCs | 2005–2008 |
| Harvey | National Healthcare Safety Network, 77 facilities | Voluntary haemovigilance | 9/100 000 units | 1 in 10942 units | All | 2010–2012 |
| Clifford | Mayo Clinic, adults, non‐cardiac surgery | Retrospective cohort | 4000/100 000 units | 1 in 25 units | RBCs | 2004 |
| 1087/100 000 units | 1 in 92 units | RBCs | 2011 | |||
| Frequency per hospital stay | ||||||
| Menis | Medicare administrative database | Retrospective | 0·06% of stays | 1 in 1602 stays | All | 2011 |
Incidence of febrile non‐haemolytic transfusion reaction in the United States
| Author, year | Source | Type of study | Incidence | Incidence | Components | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frequency per patient | ||||||
| Paglino | Yale‐New Haven Hospital, Connecticut, all ages | Retrospective cohort | 1·33% of patients | 1 in 75 patients | 25% leucoreduced RBCs | 1995–1998 |
| 0·79% of patients | 1 in 127 patients | 99% leucoreduced RBCs | 2000–2002 | |||
| Sanders | St. Jude Children's Research Hospital | Retrospective cohort | 4·94% of children | 1 in 20 children | All | 2002 |
| Kennedy | Wake Forest University, Comprehensive Cancer Center | Prospective active surveillance | 8·70% of patients | 1 in 11 patients | RBCs and PLTs, leucoreduced | 1993–1997 |
| Frequency per unit | ||||||
| Menitove | 33 Hospitals in South‐eastern Wisconsin, all ages | Retrospective cohort | 478/100 000 units | 1 in 209 units | RBCs and whole blood | 1980 |
| Dzieczkowski | Dana‐Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, Massachusetts | Prospective cohort | 2147/100 000 units | 1 in 47 units | RBCs, leucoreduced after storage | 1993 |
| Federowicz | Dana‐Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, Massachusetts | Prospective cohort | 1109/100 000 units | 1 in 90 units | RBCs, leucoreduced before storage | Before 1995 |
| Uhlman | Barnes‐Jewish Hospital, St. Louis, Missouri | Retrospective cohort | 124/100 000 units | 1 in 809 units | Non‐leucoreduced RBCs | 1999 |
| 81/100 000 units | 1 in 1238 units | Leucoreduced RBCs | 2000 | |||
| Domen | Cleveland Clinic, Ohio, all ages | Retrospective cohort | 30/100 000 units | 1 in 3293 units | RBCs | 1993–2001 |
| Paglino | Yale‐New Haven Hospital, Connecticut, all ages | Retrospective cohort | 340/100 000 units | 1 in 294 units | 25% leucoreduced RBCs | 1995–1998 |
| 180/100 000 units | 1 in 556 units | 99% leucoreduced RBCs | 2000–2002 | |||
| King | The Johns Hopkins Hospital, all ages | Retrospective cohort | 369/100 000 units | 1 in 271 units | 4% leucoreduced RBCs | 1994 |
| 186/100 000 units | 1 in 538 units | 99·5% leucoreduced RBCs | 2001 | |||
| Ezidiegwu | State University of New York, Syracuse, adults, nonsurgical | Retrospective cohort | 162/100 000 units | 1 in 619 units | RBCs | 1998–2000 |
| 79/100 000 units | 1 in 1259 units | Leucoreduced RBCs | 2001–2002 | |||
| Sanders | St. Jude Children's Research Hospital | Retrospective cohort | 360/100 000 units in children | 1 in 278 units in children | RBCs | 2002 |
| Kennedy | Wake Forest University, Comprehensive Cancer Center | Prospective active surveillance | 639/100 000 units | 1 in 156 units | RBCs and PLTs, leucoreduced | 1993–1997 |
| Harvey | National Healthcare Safety Network, 77 facilities | Voluntary haemovigilance | 106/100 000 units | 1 in 941 units | RBCs | 2010–2012 |
| Oakley | Vanderbilt University Medical Center, all ages | Retrospective cohort | 184/100 000 units in children | 1 in 545 units in children | Leucoreduced RBCs | 2011–2013 |
| 36/100 000 units in adults | 1 in 2775 units in adults | Leucoreduced RBCs | 2011–2013 | |||
| Frequency per hospital stay | ||||||
| Menis | Medicare administrative database | Retrospective | 0·07% of stays | 1 in 1419 stays | RBCs | 2011–2012 |