Noah D Silverberg1, Grant L Iverson, Jeffrey R Brubacher, Elizabeth Holland, Lisa Casagrande Hoshino, Angela Aquino, Rael T Lange. 1. Division of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation (Dr Silverberg), Department of Psychiatry (Drs Iverson and Lange), and Department of Emergency Medicine (Dr Brubacher), Department of Psychiatry, University of British Columbia (Ms Aquino), Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada; Rehabilitation Research Program, GF Strong Rehab Centre, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada (Dr Silverberg); Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts (Dr Iverson); Red Sox Foundation and Massachusetts General Hospital Home Base Program, Boston (Dr Iverson); Department of Psychology, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada (Ms Hoshino); Defense and Veterans Brain Injury Center & National Intrepid Center of Excellence, Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, Bethesda, Maryland (Dr Lange). Ms Holland is in private practice at Victoria, British Columbia, Canada.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Patients with mild traumatic brain injury (MTBI) often underestimate their preinjury symptoms. This study aimed to clarify the mechanism underlying this recall bias and its contribution to MTBI outcome. SETTING: Level I trauma center. PARTICIPANTS: Patients with uncomplicated MTBI (N = 88) and orthopedic injury (N = 67). DESIGN: Prospective longitudinal. MAIN MEASURES: Current and retrospective ratings on the British Columbia Postconcussion Symptom Inventory, completed at 6 weeks and 1 year postinjury. RESULTS: Preinjury symptom reporting was comparable across groups, static across time, and associated with compensation-seeking. High preinjury symptom reporting was related to high postinjury symptom reporting in the orthopedic injury group but less so in the MTBI group, indicating a stronger positive recall bias in highly symptomatic MTBI patients. Low preinjury symptom reporting was not a risk factor for poor MTBI outcome. CONCLUSION: The recall bias was stronger and more likely clinically significant in MTBI patients with high postinjury symptoms. Multiple mechanisms appear to contribute to recall bias after MTBI, including the reattribution of preexisting symptoms to MTBI as well as processes that are not specific to MTBI (eg, related to compensation-seeking).
OBJECTIVE:Patients with mild traumatic brain injury (MTBI) often underestimate their preinjury symptoms. This study aimed to clarify the mechanism underlying this recall bias and its contribution to MTBI outcome. SETTING: Level I trauma center. PARTICIPANTS: Patients with uncomplicated MTBI (N = 88) and orthopedic injury (N = 67). DESIGN: Prospective longitudinal. MAIN MEASURES: Current and retrospective ratings on the British Columbia Postconcussion Symptom Inventory, completed at 6 weeks and 1 year postinjury. RESULTS: Preinjury symptom reporting was comparable across groups, static across time, and associated with compensation-seeking. High preinjury symptom reporting was related to high postinjury symptom reporting in the orthopedic injury group but less so in the MTBI group, indicating a stronger positive recall bias in highly symptomatic MTBI patients. Low preinjury symptom reporting was not a risk factor for poor MTBI outcome. CONCLUSION: The recall bias was stronger and more likely clinically significant in MTBI patients with high postinjury symptoms. Multiple mechanisms appear to contribute to recall bias after MTBI, including the reattribution of preexisting symptoms to MTBI as well as processes that are not specific to MTBI (eg, related to compensation-seeking).
Authors: Danielle C Hergert; Veronik Sicard; David D Stephenson; Sharvani Pabbathi Reddy; Cidney R Robertson-Benta; Andrew B Dodd; Edward J Bedrick; Gerard A Gioia; Timothy B Meier; Nicholas A Shaff; Davin K Quinn; Richard A Campbell; John P Phillips; Andrei A Vakhtin; Robert E Sapien; Andrew R Mayer Journal: J Int Neuropsychol Soc Date: 2021-08-11 Impact factor: 3.114
Authors: Edwina L Picon; Evgenia V Todorova; Daniela J Palombo; David L Perez; Andrew K Howard; Noah D Silverberg Journal: Arch Clin Neuropsychol Date: 2022-08-23 Impact factor: 3.448
Authors: Ashlyn M Bulas; Lihua Li; Raj G Kumar; Madhu Mazumdar; Andrea L Rosso; Ada O Youk; Kristen Dams-O'Connor Journal: J Head Trauma Rehabil Date: 2021-06-15 Impact factor: 3.117
Authors: Juanita A Haagsma; Inge Spronk; Mariska A C de Jongh; Gouke J Bonsel; Suzanne Polinder Journal: Health Qual Life Outcomes Date: 2020-05-27 Impact factor: 3.186