John M Stewart1, Alice F Tarantal2, Wayne J Hawthorne3,4, Evelyn J Salvaris5, Philip J O'Connell3,4, Mark B Nottle6, Anthony J F d'Apice5,7, Peter J Cowan5,7, Mary Kearns-Jonker1. 1. Department of Human Anatomy, Loma Linda University School of Medicine, Loma Linda, CA, USA. 2. Departments of Pediatrics and Cell Biology and Human Anatomy, and California National Primate Research Center, University of California, Davis, CA, USA. 3. Centre for Transplant and Renal Research, Westmead Millennium Institute, Westmead, NSW, Australia. 4. National Pancreas Transplant Unit, University of Sydney at Westmead Hospital, Westmead, NSW, Australia. 5. Immunology Research Centre, St. Vincent's Hospital Melbourne, Melbourne, Vic., Australia. 6. Discipline of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, Australia. 7. Department of Medicine, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Vic., Australia.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Survival of vascularized xenografts is dependent on pre-emptive inhibition of the xenoantibody response against galactosyltransferase knockout (GTKO) porcine organs. Our analysis in multiple GTKO pig-to-primate models of xenotransplantation has demonstrated that the anti-non-gal-α-1,3-gal (anti-non-Gal) xenoantibody response displays limited structural diversity. This allowed our group to identify an experimental compound which selectively inhibited induced anti-non-Gal IgM xenoantibodies. However, because this compound had an unknown safety profile, we extended this line of research to include screening small molecules with known safety profiles allowing rapid advancement to large animal models. METHODS: The NIH clinical collections of small molecules were screened by ELISA for their ability to inhibit xenoantibody binding to GTKO pig endothelial cells. Serum collected from non-immunosuppressed rhesus monkeys at day 14 post-injection with GTKO pig endothelial cells was utilized as a source of elicited xenoantibody for initial screening. Virtual small molecule screening based on xenoantibody structure was used to assess the likelihood that the identified small molecules bound xenoantibody directly. As a proxy for selectivity, ELISAs against tetanus toxoid and the natural antigens laminin, thyroglobulin, and single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) were utilized to assess the ability of the identified reagents to inhibit additional antibody responses. The identified inhibitory small molecules were further tested for their ability to inhibit xenoantibody elicited in multiple settings, including rhesus monkeys pre-treated with an anti-non-Gal selective anti-idiotypic antibody, non-immunosuppressed rhesus monkeys immunized with wild-type fetal pig isletlike cell clusters, and non-immunosuppressed baboons transplanted with GTKO multiple transgenic pig kidneys. RESULTS: Four clinically relevant small molecules inhibited anti-non-Gal IgM binding to GTKO pig endothelial cells in vitro. Three of these drugs displayed a limited region of structural similarity suggesting they may inhibit xenoantibody by a similar mechanism. One of these, the anti-hypertensive agent clonidine, displayed only minimal inhibition of antibodies elicited by vaccination against tetanus toxoid or pre-existing natural antibodies against laminin, thyroglobulin, or ssDNA. Furthermore, clonidine inhibited elicited anti-non-Gal IgM from all animals that demonstrated a xenoantibody response in each experimental setting. CONCLUSIONS: Clinically relevant small molecule drugs with known safety profiles can inhibit xenoantibody elicited against non-Gal antigens in diverse experimental xenotransplantation settings. These molecules are ready to be tested in large animal models. However, it will first be necessary to optimize the timing and dosing required to inhibit xenoantibodies in vivo.
BACKGROUND: Survival of vascularized xenografts is dependent on pre-emptive inhibition of the xenoantibody response against galactosyltransferase knockout (GTKO) porcine organs. Our analysis in multiple GTKO pig-to-primate models of xenotransplantation has demonstrated that the anti-non-gal-α-1,3-gal (anti-non-Gal) xenoantibody response displays limited structural diversity. This allowed our group to identify an experimental compound which selectively inhibited induced anti-non-GalIgM xenoantibodies. However, because this compound had an unknown safety profile, we extended this line of research to include screening small molecules with known safety profiles allowing rapid advancement to large animal models. METHODS: The NIH clinical collections of small molecules were screened by ELISA for their ability to inhibit xenoantibody binding to GTKO pig endothelial cells. Serum collected from non-immunosuppressed rhesus monkeys at day 14 post-injection with GTKO pig endothelial cells was utilized as a source of elicited xenoantibody for initial screening. Virtual small molecule screening based on xenoantibody structure was used to assess the likelihood that the identified small molecules bound xenoantibody directly. As a proxy for selectivity, ELISAs against tetanus toxoid and the natural antigens laminin, thyroglobulin, and single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) were utilized to assess the ability of the identified reagents to inhibit additional antibody responses. The identified inhibitory small molecules were further tested for their ability to inhibit xenoantibody elicited in multiple settings, including rhesus monkeys pre-treated with an anti-non-Gal selective anti-idiotypic antibody, non-immunosuppressed rhesus monkeys immunized with wild-type fetal pig isletlike cell clusters, and non-immunosuppressed baboons transplanted with GTKO multiple transgenic pig kidneys. RESULTS: Four clinically relevant small molecules inhibited anti-non-GalIgM binding to GTKO pig endothelial cells in vitro. Three of these drugs displayed a limited region of structural similarity suggesting they may inhibit xenoantibody by a similar mechanism. One of these, the anti-hypertensive agent clonidine, displayed only minimal inhibition of antibodies elicited by vaccination against tetanus toxoid or pre-existing natural antibodies against laminin, thyroglobulin, or ssDNA. Furthermore, clonidine inhibited elicited anti-non-GalIgM from all animals that demonstrated a xenoantibody response in each experimental setting. CONCLUSIONS: Clinically relevant small molecule drugs with known safety profiles can inhibit xenoantibody elicited against non-Gal antigens in diverse experimental xenotransplantation settings. These molecules are ready to be tested in large animal models. However, it will first be necessary to optimize the timing and dosing required to inhibit xenoantibodies in vivo.
Authors: M Boes; T Schmidt; K Linkemann; B C Beaudette; A Marshak-Rothstein; J Chen Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2000-02-01 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Jose L Estrada; Greg Martens; Ping Li; Andrew Adams; Kenneth A Newell; Mandy L Ford; James R Butler; Richard Sidner; Matt Tector; Joseph Tector Journal: Xenotransplantation Date: 2015-03-01 Impact factor: 3.907
Authors: P J Cowan; A Aminian; H Barlow; A A Brown; C G Chen; N Fisicaro; D M Francis; D J Goodman; W Han; M Kurek; M B Nottle; M J Pearse; E Salvaris; T A Shinkel; G V Stainsby; A B Stewart; A J d'Apice Journal: Transplantation Date: 2000-06-27 Impact factor: 4.939
Authors: David K C Cooper; Vikas Satyananda; Burcin Ekser; Dirk J van der Windt; Hidetaka Hara; Mohamed B Ezzelarab; Henk-Jan Schuurman Journal: Xenotransplantation Date: 2014-09-01 Impact factor: 3.907
Authors: Mary Kearns-Jonker; Jacqueline Fischer-Lougheed; Irina Shulkin; Annette Kleihauer; Noboru Mitsuhashi; Donald B Kohn; Kenneth Weinberg; Anthony J F D'Apice; Vaughn A Starnes; Donald V Cramer Journal: Transplantation Date: 2004-06-15 Impact factor: 4.939
Authors: Ian Carroll; Jennifer Hah; Sean Mackey; Einar Ottestad; Jiang Ti Kong; Sam Lahidji; Vivianne Tawfik; Jarred Younger; Catherine Curtin Journal: J Reconstr Microsurg Date: 2013-03-05 Impact factor: 2.873
Authors: Sergey Lyskov; Fang-Chieh Chou; Shane Ó Conchúir; Bryan S Der; Kevin Drew; Daisuke Kuroda; Jianqing Xu; Brian D Weitzner; P Douglas Renfrew; Parin Sripakdeevong; Benjamin Borgo; James J Havranek; Brian Kuhlman; Tanja Kortemme; Richard Bonneau; Jeffrey J Gray; Rhiju Das Journal: PLoS One Date: 2013-05-22 Impact factor: 3.240