Werner Krutsch1, J Zellner2, F Baumann2, C Pfeifer2, M Nerlich2, P Angele2,3. 1. Department of Trauma Surgery, University Medical Centre Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany. werner.krutsch@ukr.de. 2. Department of Trauma Surgery, University Medical Centre Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany. 3. Sporthopaedicum, Straubing/Regensburg, Germany.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) ruptures are often associated with primary meniscal and cartilage lesions. Late reconstruction of ACL-deficient knees may increase the risk of developing secondary meniscal and cartilage lesions; hence, the timing of ACL repair is of the utmost importance. Because meniscus outcome is also a potential predictor for osteoarthritis (OA), this study compared ACL repair within the first 6 months after injury to that of surgery conducted 7-12 months after injury with regard to the incidence of meniscal and cartilage lesions. METHODS: This prospective cross-sectional study included all complete isolated primary ACL ruptures treated in our institution within 1 year after trauma over a 12-month period. Exclusion criteria were revision ACL, complex ligament injuries, previous knee surgery, and missing injury data. Cartilage lesions were classified according to the score established by the International Cartilage Repair Society (ICRS score) and meniscal tears according to their treatment options. RESULTS: Two hundred and thirty-three of 730 patients (162 men, 71 women) with ACL repair met the inclusion criteria. 86.3 % of surgical interventions were conducted within 6 months and 13.7 % after 6 months of trauma. Severe cartilage lesions grade III-IV did not significantly differ between the different time points of ACL repair (<6 months 39.9 %; >6 months 31.3 %; p = n.s.). Medial meniscus lesions received significantly higher meniscal repair in early compared to delayed ACL repair. Significantly higher rate of meniscal repair of the medial meniscus was seen in cases of early ACL repair compared to delayed (<6 months 77.2 %, >6 months 46.7; p = 0.022). The rate of medial meniscal repair in early ACL repair was significantly higher for women (89.5-0 %; p = 0.002), however, not for men (73.3-53.8 %; p = n.s.). No differences were found for lateral meniscal lesions, with regard to neither the different time points (p = n.s.) nor the sex (p = n.s.). CONCLUSIONS: Because of the significantly higher rate of prognostically advantageous meniscal repair, the recommendation for an ACL reconstruction within 6 months after trauma was made to preserve the meniscus and reduce the risk of developing OA. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prospective cross-sectional cohort study, Level II.
PURPOSE: Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) ruptures are often associated with primary meniscal and cartilage lesions. Late reconstruction of ACL-deficient knees may increase the risk of developing secondary meniscal and cartilage lesions; hence, the timing of ACL repair is of the utmost importance. Because meniscus outcome is also a potential predictor for osteoarthritis (OA), this study compared ACL repair within the first 6 months after injury to that of surgery conducted 7-12 months after injury with regard to the incidence of meniscal and cartilage lesions. METHODS: This prospective cross-sectional study included all complete isolated primary ACL ruptures treated in our institution within 1 year after trauma over a 12-month period. Exclusion criteria were revision ACL, complex ligament injuries, previous knee surgery, and missing injury data. Cartilage lesions were classified according to the score established by the International Cartilage Repair Society (ICRS score) and meniscal tears according to their treatment options. RESULTS: Two hundred and thirty-three of 730 patients (162 men, 71 women) with ACL repair met the inclusion criteria. 86.3 % of surgical interventions were conducted within 6 months and 13.7 % after 6 months of trauma. Severe cartilage lesions grade III-IV did not significantly differ between the different time points of ACL repair (<6 months 39.9 %; >6 months 31.3 %; p = n.s.). Medial meniscus lesions received significantly higher meniscal repair in early compared to delayed ACL repair. Significantly higher rate of meniscal repair of the medial meniscus was seen in cases of early ACL repair compared to delayed (<6 months 77.2 %, >6 months 46.7; p = 0.022). The rate of medial meniscal repair in early ACL repair was significantly higher for women (89.5-0 %; p = 0.002), however, not for men (73.3-53.8 %; p = n.s.). No differences were found for lateral meniscal lesions, with regard to neither the different time points (p = n.s.) nor the sex (p = n.s.). CONCLUSIONS: Because of the significantly higher rate of prognostically advantageous meniscal repair, the recommendation for an ACL reconstruction within 6 months after trauma was made to preserve the meniscus and reduce the risk of developing OA. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prospective cross-sectional cohort study, Level II.
Authors: Robert H Brophy; Rick W Wright; Tal S David; Robert G McCormack; Jon K Sekiya; Steven J Svoboda; Laura J Huston; Amanda K Haas; Karen Steger-May Journal: Am J Sports Med Date: 2012-02-28 Impact factor: 6.202
Authors: Neil Ghodadra; Nathan A Mall; Vasili Karas; Robert C Grumet; Spencer Kirk; Allison G McNickle; Cecilia Pascual Garrido; Brian J Cole; Bernard R Bach Journal: J Knee Surg Date: 2012-11-06 Impact factor: 2.757
Authors: James R Slauterbeck; Petteri Kousa; Blake C Clifton; Shelly Naud; Timothy W Tourville; Robert J Johnson; Bruce D Beynnon Journal: J Bone Joint Surg Am Date: 2009-09 Impact factor: 5.284
Authors: Björn Barenius; Sari Ponzer; Adel Shalabi; Robert Bujak; Louise Norlén; Karl Eriksson Journal: Am J Sports Med Date: 2014-03-18 Impact factor: 6.202
Authors: Robert A Burnett; Robert Westermann; Kyle Duchman; Ned Amendola; Carolyn Hettrich; Brian Wolf; Natalie Glass; Matthew Bollier Journal: Iowa Orthop J Date: 2019
Authors: Muzammil Memon; Lydia Ginsberg; Darren de Sa; Andrew Nashed; Nicole Simunovic; Mark Phillips; Matthew Denkers; Rick Ogilvie; Devin Peterson; Olufemi R Ayeni Journal: J Exp Orthop Date: 2017-01-23