Selin Kocakaya1, Christoph Patrick Beier1, Dagmar Beier1. 1. Department of Neurology, RWTH Aachen, Aachen, Germany (S.K., C.P.B., D.B.); Department of Neurology, University Hospital Odense and Clinical Institute, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark (C.P.B., D.B.).
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Adult medulloblastoma is a potentially curable malignant entity with an incidence of 0.5-1 per million. Valid data on prognosis, treatment, and demographics are lacking, as most current knowledge stems from retrospective studies. Surgical resection followed by radiotherapy are accepted parts of treatment regimes; however, established prognostic factors and data clarifying the role of chemotherapy are missing. METHODS: We investigated 227 publications from 1969-2013, with 907 identifiable, individual patients being available for meta-analysis. Demographic data, risk stratification, and treatment of these patients were similar to previous cohorts. RESULTS: The median overall survival (mOS) was 65 months (95% CI: 54.6-75.3) , the 5-year overall survival was 50.9% with 16% of the patients dying more than 5 years after diagnosis. Incomplete resection, clinical and radiological signs for brainstem infiltration, and abstinence from radiotherapy were predictive of worse outcome. Metastatic disease at tumor recurrence was identified as a new prognostic factor, while neither metastasis at initial diagnosis nor desmoplastic/classic histology was correlated with survival. Patients receiving chemotherapy first-line survived significantly longer (mOS: 108 mo, 95% CI: 68.6-148.4) than patients treated with radiation alone (mOS: 57 mo, 95% CI: 39.6-74.4) or patients who received chemotherapy at tumor recurrence. This effect was not biased by tumor stage or decade of treatment. Importantly, (neo)adjuvant chemotherapy also significantly increased the chance for long-term survival (>5 y) compared with radiotherapy alone or chemotherapy at tumor recurrence. CONCLUSIONS: This meta-analysis clarifies relevant prognostic factors and suggests that chemotherapy as part of first-line therapy improves overall survival and increases the proportion of patients with long-term survival.
BACKGROUND: Adult medulloblastoma is a potentially curable malignant entity with an incidence of 0.5-1 per million. Valid data on prognosis, treatment, and demographics are lacking, as most current knowledge stems from retrospective studies. Surgical resection followed by radiotherapy are accepted parts of treatment regimes; however, established prognostic factors and data clarifying the role of chemotherapy are missing. METHODS: We investigated 227 publications from 1969-2013, with 907 identifiable, individual patients being available for meta-analysis. Demographic data, risk stratification, and treatment of these patients were similar to previous cohorts. RESULTS: The median overall survival (mOS) was 65 months (95% CI: 54.6-75.3) , the 5-year overall survival was 50.9% with 16% of the patients dying more than 5 years after diagnosis. Incomplete resection, clinical and radiological signs for brainstem infiltration, and abstinence from radiotherapy were predictive of worse outcome. Metastatic disease at tumor recurrence was identified as a new prognostic factor, while neither metastasis at initial diagnosis nor desmoplastic/classic histology was correlated with survival. Patients receiving chemotherapy first-line survived significantly longer (mOS: 108 mo, 95% CI: 68.6-148.4) than patients treated with radiation alone (mOS: 57 mo, 95% CI: 39.6-74.4) or patients who received chemotherapy at tumor recurrence. This effect was not biased by tumor stage or decade of treatment. Importantly, (neo)adjuvant chemotherapy also significantly increased the chance for long-term survival (>5 y) compared with radiotherapy alone or chemotherapy at tumor recurrence. CONCLUSIONS: This meta-analysis clarifies relevant prognostic factors and suggests that chemotherapy as part of first-line therapy improves overall survival and increases the proportion of patients with long-term survival.
Authors: H G Brown; J L Kepner; E J Perlman; H S Friedman; D R Strother; P K Duffner; L E Kun; P T Goldthwaite; P C Burger Journal: J Neuropathol Exp Neurol Date: 2000-10 Impact factor: 3.685
Authors: D Jenkin; M A Shabanah; E A Shail; A Gray; M Hassounah; Y Khafaga; A Kofide; M Mustafa; H Schultz Journal: Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys Date: 2000-06-01 Impact factor: 7.038
Authors: Charles G Eberhart; James L Kepner; Patricia T Goldthwaite; Larry E Kun; Patricia K Duffner; Henry S Friedman; Douglas R Strother; Peter C Burger Journal: Cancer Date: 2002-01-15 Impact factor: 6.860
Authors: A W Chan; N J Tarbell; P M Black; D N Louis; M P Frosch; M Ancukiewicz; P Chapman; J S Loeffler Journal: Neurosurgery Date: 2000-09 Impact factor: 4.654
Authors: C Carrie; C Lasset; C Alapetite; C Haie-Meder; S Hoffstetter; M C Demaille; C Kerr; J P Wagner; J L Lagrange; J P Maire Journal: Cancer Date: 1994-10-15 Impact factor: 6.860
Authors: Alba A Brandes; Mario Ermani; Pietro Amista; Umberto Basso; Francesca Vastola; Marina Gardiman; Paolo Iuzzolino; Sergio Turazzi; Antonino Rotilio; Lorenzo Volpin; Carlo Mazza; Laura Sainati; Franco Ammannati; Franco Berti Journal: Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys Date: 2003-11-01 Impact factor: 7.038
Authors: V C Keil; M Warmuth-Metz; C Reh; S J Enkirch; C Reinert; D Beier; D T W Jones; T Pietsch; H H Schild; E Hattingen; P Hau Journal: AJNR Am J Neuroradiol Date: 2017-08-10 Impact factor: 3.825
Authors: Marta Penas-Prado; Brett J Theeler; Brittany Cordeiro; Ira J Dunkel; Peter Hau; Anita Mahajan; Giles W Robinson; Nicole Willmarth; Orwa Aboud; Kenneth Aldape; John A Butman; Amar Gajjar; William Kelly; Ganesh Rao; Margarita Raygada; Christine Siegel; Carlos G Romo; Terri S Armstrong; Mark R Gilbert Journal: Neurooncol Adv Date: 2020-08-17
Authors: Paul A Northcott; Andrey Korshunov; Vijay Ramaswamy; Hallie Coltin; Lakshmikirupa Sundaresan; Kyle S Smith; Patryk Skowron; Luca Massimi; Charles G Eberhart; Karisa C Schreck; Nalin Gupta; William A Weiss; Daniela Tirapelli; Carlos Carlotti; Kay K W Li; Marina Ryzhova; Andrey Golanov; Olga Zheludkova; Oksana Absalyamova; Konstantin Okonechnikov; Damian Stichel; Andreas von Deimling; Caterina Giannini; Scott Raskin; Erwin G Van Meir; Jennifer A Chan; Daniel Fults; Lola B Chambless; Seung-Ki Kim; Alexandre Vasiljevic; Cecile Faure-Conter; Rajeev Vibhakar; Shin Jung; Sarah Leary; Jaume Mora; Roger E McLendon; Ian F Pollack; Peter Hauser; Wieslawa A Grajkowska; Joshua B Rubin; Marie-Lise C van Veelen; Pim J French; Johan M Kros; Linda M Liau; Stefan M Pfister; Marcel Kool; Noriyuki Kijima; Michael D Taylor; Roger J Packer Journal: Acta Neuropathol Date: 2021-08-18 Impact factor: 15.887
Authors: Dagmar Beier; Martin Proescholdt; Christiane Reinert; Torsten Pietsch; David T W Jones; Stefan M Pfister; Elke Hattingen; Clemens Seidel; Linda Dirven; Ralf Luerding; Jaap Reijneveld; Monika Warmuth-Metz; Matteo Bonsanto; Michael Bremer; Stephanie E Combs; Stefan Rieken; Ulrich Herrlinger; Holger Kuntze; Regine Mayer-Steinacker; Dag Moskopp; Thomas Schneider; Andreas Beringer; Uwe Schlegel; Walter Stummer; Helmut Welker; Astrid Weyerbrock; Frank Paulsen; Stefan Rutkowski; Michael Weller; Wolfgang Wick; Rolf-Dieter Kortmann; Ulrich Bogdahn; Peter Hau Journal: Neuro Oncol Date: 2018-02-19 Impact factor: 12.300