Andrea M Elliott1, Stewart C Alexander2, Craig A Mescher1, Deepika Mohan3, Amber E Barnato4. 1. Department of Medicine, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA. 2. Department of Consumer Sciences, College of Health and Human Science, Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, USA. 3. Department of Critical Care Medicine, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA. 4. Department of Medicine, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Center for Research on Health Care, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA. Electronic address: aeb2@pitt.edu.
Abstract
CONTEXT: Black patients are more likely than white patients to die in the intensive care unit with life-sustaining treatments. Differences in patient- and/or surrogate-provider communication may contribute to this phenomenon. OBJECTIVES: To test whether hospital-based physicians use different verbal and/or nonverbal communication with black and white simulated patients and their surrogates. METHODS: We conducted a randomized factorial trial of the relationship between patient race and physician communication using high-fidelity simulation. Using a combination of probabilistic and convenience sampling, we recruited 33 hospital-based physicians in western Pennsylvania who completed two encounters with prognostically similar, critically and terminally ill black and white elders with identical treatment preferences. We then conducted detailed content analysis of audio and video recordings of the encounters, coding verbal emotion-handling and shared decision-making behaviors, and nonverbal behaviors (time interacting with the patient and/or surrogate, with open vs. closed posture, and touching the patient and physical proximity). We used a paired t-test to compare each subjects' summed verbal and nonverbal communication scores with the black patient compared to the white patient. RESULTS: Subject physicians' verbal communication scores did not differ by patient race (black vs. white: 8.4 vs. 8.4, P-value = 0.958). However, their nonverbal communication scores were significantly lower with the black patient than with the white patient (black vs. white: 2.7 vs. 2.9, P-value 0.014). CONCLUSION: In this small regional sample, hospital-based physicians have similar verbal communication behaviors when discussing end-of-life care for otherwise similar black and white patients but exhibit significantly fewer positive, rapport-building nonverbal cues with black patients.
RCT Entities:
CONTEXT: Black patients are more likely than white patients to die in the intensive care unit with life-sustaining treatments. Differences in patient- and/or surrogate-provider communication may contribute to this phenomenon. OBJECTIVES: To test whether hospital-based physicians use different verbal and/or nonverbal communication with black and white simulated patients and their surrogates. METHODS: We conducted a randomized factorial trial of the relationship between patient race and physician communication using high-fidelity simulation. Using a combination of probabilistic and convenience sampling, we recruited 33 hospital-based physicians in western Pennsylvania who completed two encounters with prognostically similar, critically and terminally ill black and white elders with identical treatment preferences. We then conducted detailed content analysis of audio and video recordings of the encounters, coding verbal emotion-handling and shared decision-making behaviors, and nonverbal behaviors (time interacting with the patient and/or surrogate, with open vs. closed posture, and touching the patient and physical proximity). We used a paired t-test to compare each subjects' summed verbal and nonverbal communication scores with the black patient compared to the white patient. RESULTS: Subject physicians' verbal communication scores did not differ by patient race (black vs. white: 8.4 vs. 8.4, P-value = 0.958). However, their nonverbal communication scores were significantly lower with the black patient than with the white patient (black vs. white: 2.7 vs. 2.9, P-value 0.014). CONCLUSION: In this small regional sample, hospital-based physicians have similar verbal communication behaviors when discussing end-of-life care for otherwise similar black and white patients but exhibit significantly fewer positive, rapport-building nonverbal cues with black patients.
Authors: Sharon B Wyatt; David R Williams; Rosie Calvin; Frances C Henderson; Evelyn R Walker; Karen Winters Journal: Am J Med Sci Date: 2003-06 Impact factor: 2.378
Authors: Craig C Earle; Bridget A Neville; Mary Beth Landrum; John Z Ayanian; Susan D Block; Jane C Weeks Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2004-01-15 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Derek C Angus; Amber E Barnato; Walter T Linde-Zwirble; Lisa A Weissfeld; R Scott Watson; Tim Rickert; Gordon D Rubenfeld Journal: Crit Care Med Date: 2004-03 Impact factor: 7.598
Authors: Christie Masters; Dea Robinson; Sally Faulkner; Eltanya Patterson; Thomas McIlraith; Aziz Ansari Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2019-01-08 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Susan Eggly; Lauren M Hamel; Tanina S Foster; Terrance L Albrecht; Robert Chapman; Felicity W K Harper; Hayley Thompson; Jennifer J Griggs; Richard Gonzalez; Lisa Berry-Bobovski; Rifky Tkatch; Michael Simon; Anthony Shields; Shirish Gadgeel; Randa Loutfi; Haythem Ali; Ira Wollner; Louis A Penner Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2016-12-27
Authors: Christopher E Cox; Isaretta L Riley; Deepshikha C Ashana; Krista Haines; Maren K Olsen; Jessie Gu; Elias H Pratt; Mashael Al-Hegelan; Robert W Harrison; Colleen Naglee; Allie Frear; Hongqiu Yang; Kimberly S Johnson; Sharron L Docherty Journal: Contemp Clin Trials Date: 2021-02-13 Impact factor: 2.226
Authors: Elizabeth Chuang; Ryan J Fiter; Omar C Sanon; Ann Wang; Aluko A Hope; Clyde B Schechter; Michelle N Gong Journal: Am J Hosp Palliat Care Date: 2020-04-02 Impact factor: 2.500
Authors: Jaya Aysola; Justin T Clapp; Patricia Sullivan; Patrick J Brennan; Eve J Higginbotham; Matthew D Kearney; Chang Xu; Rosemary Thomas; Sarah Griggs; Mohamed Abdirisak; Alec Hilton; Toluwa Omole; Sean Foster; Mira Mamtani Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2021-08-02 Impact factor: 5.128