Emily Kroshus1,2,3, Christine M Baugh3,4,5, Daniel H Daneshvar6,7, Julie M Stamm6,8, R Mark Laursen9, S Bryn Austin1,10,11. 1. Department of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, MA. 2. Sport Science Institute, National Collegiate Athletic Association, Indianapolis, IN. 3. Edmond J. Safra Center for Ethics, Harvard University, Boston, MA. 4. Interfaculty Initiative in Health Policy, Harvard University, Boston, MA. 5. Division of Sports Medicine, Boston Children's Hospital, MA. 6. Center for the Study of Traumatic Encephalopathy, Boston University School of Medicine, MA. 7. Sports Legacy Institute, Boston, MA. 8. Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Boston University School of Medicine, MA. 9. Sargent College of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, Boston University, MA. 10. Division of Adolescent and Young Adult Medicine, Boston Children's Hospital, MA. 11. Department of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.
Abstract
CONTEXT: Anecdotal and qualitative evidence has suggested that some clinicians face pressure from coaches and other personnel in the athletic environment to prematurely return athletes to participation after a concussion. This type of pressure potentially can result in compromised patient care. OBJECTIVE: To quantify the extent to which clinicians in the collegiate sports medicine environment experience pressure when caring for concussed athletes and whether this pressure varies by the supervisory structure of the institution's sports medicine department, the clinician's sex, and other factors. DESIGN: Cross-sectional study. SETTING: Web-based survey of National College Athletic Association member institutions. PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS: A total of 789 athletic trainers and 111 team physicians from 530 institutions. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): We asked participants whether they had experienced pressure from 3 stakeholder populations (other clinicians, coaches, athletes) to prematurely return athletes to participation after a concussion. Modifying variables that we assessed were the position (athletic trainer, physician) and sex of the clinicians, the supervisory structure of their institutions' sports medicine departments, and the division of competition in which their institutions participate. RESULTS: We observed that 64.4% (n = 580) of responding clinicians reported having experienced pressure from athletes to prematurely clear them to return to participation after a concussion, and 53.7% (n = 483) reported having experienced this pressure from coaches. Only 6.6% (n = 59) reported having experienced pressure from other clinicians to prematurely clear an athlete to return to participation after a concussion. Clinicians reported greater pressure from coaches when their departments were under the supervisory purview of the athletic department rather than a medical institution. Female clinicians reported greater pressure from coaches than male clinicians did. CONCLUSIONS: Most clinicians reported experiencing pressure to prematurely return athletes to participation after a concussion. Identifying factors that are associated with variability in pressure on clinicians during concussion recovery can inform potential future strategies to reduce these pressures.
CONTEXT: Anecdotal and qualitative evidence has suggested that some clinicians face pressure from coaches and other personnel in the athletic environment to prematurely return athletes to participation after a concussion. This type of pressure potentially can result in compromised patient care. OBJECTIVE: To quantify the extent to which clinicians in the collegiate sports medicine environment experience pressure when caring for concussed athletes and whether this pressure varies by the supervisory structure of the institution's sports medicine department, the clinician's sex, and other factors. DESIGN: Cross-sectional study. SETTING: Web-based survey of National College Athletic Association member institutions. PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS: A total of 789 athletic trainers and 111 team physicians from 530 institutions. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): We asked participants whether they had experienced pressure from 3 stakeholder populations (other clinicians, coaches, athletes) to prematurely return athletes to participation after a concussion. Modifying variables that we assessed were the position (athletic trainer, physician) and sex of the clinicians, the supervisory structure of their institutions' sports medicine departments, and the division of competition in which their institutions participate. RESULTS: We observed that 64.4% (n = 580) of responding clinicians reported having experienced pressure from athletes to prematurely clear them to return to participation after a concussion, and 53.7% (n = 483) reported having experienced this pressure from coaches. Only 6.6% (n = 59) reported having experienced pressure from other clinicians to prematurely clear an athlete to return to participation after a concussion. Clinicians reported greater pressure from coaches when their departments were under the supervisory purview of the athletic department rather than a medical institution. Female clinicians reported greater pressure from coaches than male clinicians did. CONCLUSIONS: Most clinicians reported experiencing pressure to prematurely return athletes to participation after a concussion. Identifying factors that are associated with variability in pressure on clinicians during concussion recovery can inform potential future strategies to reduce these pressures.
Entities:
Keywords:
college; conflict of interest; organizational structure; sex
Authors: Ann C McKee; Brandon E Gavett; Robert A Stern; Christopher J Nowinski; Robert C Cantu; Neil W Kowall; Daniel P Perl; E Tessa Hedley-Whyte; Bruce Price; Chris Sullivan; Peter Morin; Hyo-Soon Lee; Caroline A Kubilus; Daniel H Daneshvar; Megan Wulff; Andrew E Budson Journal: J Neuropathol Exp Neurol Date: 2010-09 Impact factor: 3.685
Authors: Emily Kroshus; Daniel H Daneshvar; Christine M Baugh; Christopher J Nowinski; Robert C Cantu Journal: Br J Sports Med Date: 2013-08-16 Impact factor: 13.800
Authors: Ron Courson; Michael Goldenberg; Kevin G Adams; Scott A Anderson; Bob Colgate; Larry Cooper; Lori Dewald; R T Floyd; Douglas B Gregory; Peter A Indelicato; David Klossner; Rick O'Leary; Tracy Ray; Tim Selgo; Charlie Thompson; Gary Turbak Journal: J Athl Train Date: 2014 Jan-Feb Impact factor: 2.860
Authors: Johna K Register-Mihalik; Kevin M Guskiewicz; Tamara C Valovich McLeod; Laura A Linnan; Frederick O Mueller; Stephen W Marshall Journal: J Athl Train Date: 2013-07-12 Impact factor: 2.860
Authors: Thomas G Bowman; Stephanie Mazerolle Singe; Alicia M Pike Lacy; Johna K Register-Mihalik Journal: J Athl Train Date: 2020-01-27 Impact factor: 2.860
Authors: Christine M Baugh; Emily Kroshus; Bailey L Lanser; Tory R Lindley; William P Meehan Journal: J Athl Train Date: 2020-06-23 Impact factor: 2.860
Authors: R J Elbin; Alicia Sufrinko; Philip Schatz; Jon French; Luke Henry; Scott Burkhart; Michael W Collins; Anthony P Kontos Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2016-09 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Christine M Baugh; Zachary Y Kerr; Emily Kroshus; Bailey L Lanser; Tory R Lindley; William P Meehan Journal: J Athl Train Date: 2020-06-23 Impact factor: 2.860