Literature DB >> 26185482

Capturing complexity: Mixing methods in the analysis of a European tobacco control policy network.

Heide Weishaar1, Amanda Amos2, Jeff Collin1.   

Abstract

Social network analysis (SNA), a method which can be used to explore networks in various contexts, has received increasing attention. Drawing on the development of European smoke-free policy, this paper explores how a mixed method approach to SNA can be utilised to investigate a complex policy network. Textual data from public documents, consultation submissions and websites were extracted, converted and analysed using plagiarism detection software and quantitative network analysis, and qualitative data from public documents and 35 interviews were thematically analysed. While the quantitative analysis enabled understanding of the network's structure and components, the qualitative analysis provided in-depth information about specific actors' positions, relationships and interactions. The paper establishes that SNA is suited to empirically testing and analysing networks in EU policymaking. It contributes to methodological debates about the antagonism between qualitative and quantitative approaches and demonstrates that qualitative and quantitative network analysis can offer a powerful tool for policy analysis.

Entities:  

Keywords:  plagiarism detection software; policy analysis; policy network; social network analysis

Year:  2015        PMID: 26185482      PMCID: PMC4500196          DOI: 10.1080/13645579.2014.897851

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Int J Soc Res Methodol        ISSN: 1364-5579


  8 in total

Review 1.  Community structure in social and biological networks.

Authors:  M Girvan; M E J Newman
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2002-06-11       Impact factor: 11.205

2.  Seeing the forest and the trees: using network analysis to develop an organizational blueprint of state tobacco control systems.

Authors:  Jenine K Harris; Douglas A Luke; Ryan C Burke; Nancy B Mueller
Journal:  Soc Sci Med       Date:  2008-08-21       Impact factor: 4.634

3.  Revisiting the foundations of network analysis.

Authors:  Carter T Butts
Journal:  Science       Date:  2009-07-24       Impact factor: 47.728

4.  (Net)Working out: social capital in a private health club.

Authors:  Nick Crossley
Journal:  Br J Sociol       Date:  2008-09

5.  Manufacturing credibility: the National Energy Management Institute and the Tobacco Institute's strategy for indoor air quality.

Authors:  Richard B Campbell; Edith D Balbach
Journal:  Am J Public Health       Date:  2011-01-13       Impact factor: 9.308

6.  Global tobacco control diffusion: the case of the framework convention on tobacco control.

Authors:  Heather L Wipfli; Kayo Fujimoto; Thomas W Valente
Journal:  Am J Public Health       Date:  2010-05-13       Impact factor: 9.308

7.  Systems analysis of collaboration in 5 national tobacco control networks.

Authors:  Douglas A Luke; Jenine K Harris; Sarah Shelton; Peg Allen; Bobbi J Carothers; Nancy B Mueller
Journal:  Am J Public Health       Date:  2010-05-13       Impact factor: 9.308

Review 8.  Tobacco industry efforts to present ventilation as an alternative to smoke-free environments in North America.

Authors:  J Drope; S A Bialous; S A Glantz
Journal:  Tob Control       Date:  2004-03       Impact factor: 7.552

  8 in total
  8 in total

1.  Tobacco Control and Health Advocacy in the European Union: Understanding Effective Coalition-Building.

Authors:  Heide Weishaar; Jeff Collin; Amanda Amos
Journal:  Nicotine Tob Res       Date:  2015-01-29       Impact factor: 4.244

Review 2.  Systems science and systems thinking for public health: a systematic review of the field.

Authors:  Gemma Carey; Eleanor Malbon; Nicole Carey; Andrew Joyce; Brad Crammond; Alan Carey
Journal:  BMJ Open       Date:  2015-12-30       Impact factor: 2.692

3.  The revision of the 2014 European tobacco products directive: an analysis of the tobacco industry's attempts to 'break the health silo'.

Authors:  Silvy Peeters; Hélia Costa; David Stuckler; Martin McKee; Anna B Gilmore
Journal:  Tob Control       Date:  2015-02-24       Impact factor: 7.552

4.  Unpacking commercial sector opposition to European smoke-free policy: lack of unity, 'fear of association' and harm reduction debates.

Authors:  Heide Weishaar; Amanda Amos; Jeff Collin
Journal:  Tob Control       Date:  2015-06-08       Impact factor: 7.552

5.  The Development, Description and Appraisal of an Emergent Multimethod Research Design to Study Workforce Changes in Integrated Care Interventions.

Authors:  Loraine Busetto; Katrien Luijkx; Stefano Calciolari; Laura G González-Ortiz; Hubertus J M Vrijhoef
Journal:  Int J Integr Care       Date:  2017-03-08       Impact factor: 5.120

6.  The case for developing a cohesive systems approach to research across unhealthy commodity industries.

Authors:  Cécile Knai; Mark Petticrew; Simon Capewell; Rebecca Cassidy; Jeff Collin; Steven Cummins; Elizabeth Eastmure; Patrick Fafard; Niamh Fitzgerald; Anna B Gilmore; Ben Hawkins; Jørgen Dejgård Jensen; Srinivasa Vittal Katikireddi; Nason Maani; Nicholas Mays; Modi Mwatsama; Rima Nakkash; Jim F Orford; Harry Rutter; Natalie Savona; May C I van Schalkwyk; Heide Weishaar
Journal:  BMJ Glob Health       Date:  2021-02

Review 7.  Why media representations of corporations matter for public health policy: a scoping review.

Authors:  Heide Weishaar; Lori Dorfman; Nicholas Freudenberg; Benjamin Hawkins; Katherine Smith; Oliver Razum; Shona Hilton
Journal:  BMC Public Health       Date:  2016-08-30       Impact factor: 3.295

8.  Systems Thinking as a Framework for Analyzing Commercial Determinants of Health.

Authors:  Cécile Knai; Mark Petticrew; Nicholas Mays; Simon Capewell; Rebecca Cassidy; Steven Cummins; Elizabeth Eastmure; Patrick Fafard; Benjamin Hawkins; Jørgen Dejgård Jensen; Srinivasa Vittal Katikireddi; Modi Mwatsama; Jim Orford; Heide Weishaar
Journal:  Milbank Q       Date:  2018-09       Impact factor: 4.911

  8 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.